The stuff Hacker News actually recommends.

VR and AR headsets

Meta Quest 2 vs Meta Quest 3

Hacker News owners lean toward the Meta Quest 3.

Meta Quest 2Meta Quest 3
Owners with an opinion443208
Positive verdicts50% of 35166% of 179
Positive/negative since 202438/54109/53
Happy after 3+ years10
Longest happy owner5 yrs0.67 yrs
Praised forperformance and ease of useperformance and display
Criticized forcomfort and displaycomfort
Newest comment

Updated

What owners wrote about both

Meta Quest 2: NeutralMeta Quest 3: Doesn’t like it
I know everyone is singing the praises of the Steam Frame's wireless capabilities but honestly, I just want my wired VR experience back. I had a Rift 2, Reverb G2, then Quest 2 and eventually Quest 3. Despite the Quest 3 having a resolution similar to the G2, it looked more like the Rift 2 than the awe inspiring G2. Wireless gaming never looked as sharp and streaming over USB was also a very poor experience, with input latency and artifacting. Wireless headsets also _suck_ for simulators and productivity - where a battery only adds weights and a wire is not noticable. Personally, I would love to see a wired headset that resembles the bigscreen beyond but with inside out tracking and a universal face gasket. For wireless experiences, I'd love to be able to plug my phone in, put it in my back pocket and use it that way. That sort of "head mounted display"-first approach would make it practical to use the device for productivity / screen replacement while gaming would be dependant on your phone or computer.
Meta Quest 2: Doesn’t like itMeta Quest 3: Likes it
I have both a quest 2 and quest 3 and you are right, the quest 2 is laughable. The quest 3 is WAY better, and is way closer to making it feel like you are just looking through glass (not quite, but on the way). Eh, I don't use it for augmented reality a TON, but there are some fun apps that my kids and I like to use that use the passthrough for augmented reality... one is a virtual aquarium thing where you can draw 'windows' on your wall that become a window to the ocean, with things swimming around. It is pretty cool. I mostly use it, though, for short term moving around things, like to pick up something in the real world or to figure out where I am. I guess that can work in monotone, but it really feels cool in full color.
Meta Quest 2: Doesn’t like itMeta Quest 3: Likes it
Well the Meta Quest 2 starts $500 so I'm not sure if you were using a MQ2 or MQ3S (which has essentially the screens of the MQ2 from what I understand). I have tried the MQ2 (I own one) and I have tried the MQ3. The 3 is better but the resolution is still not great, the AVP was much better than either. I did like the color passthrough on the MQ3 (vs grayscale on the 2) but I wouldn't say any of it looked "GOOD", it was adequate but still too blurry. I think I'll end up getting a MQ3 eventually or maybe the next version at launch but I'm just not really drawn to VR. After the first few months of my MQ2 I lost interest and it's just collecting dust.
Meta Quest 2: NeutralMeta Quest 3: Doesn’t like it
I'm not using any hard definition, but by "entry level" laptops I meant low RAM, average-to-low CPU power, low-resolution screen (do you remember 768p screens? I've used that for more years than is acceptable to human dignity [1]), and if an external monitor was given, it was 1080p at best . And this was for development. As for the Oculus, I own an Oculus 2 and recently tried an Oculus 3, and while I don't know if calling them "entry level" is fair, I definitely wouldn't want to do any serious work with them, or spend a long time wearing them. For (some) gaming? Sure. Though I get dizzy easily. I do enjoy Beat Saber though! -- [1] for some reason, hardware procurement at most jobs I've worked (until relatively recently) had it backwards . They thought higher screen resolutions were for "watching movies and playing videogames", while lower resolutions were for "serious work". In fact, it's the opposite: 720p is more than enough to watch movies on a tiny laptop screen, while productivity requires more screen real estate! And as for videogames -- average GPUs at the time I was having these work discussions struggled with anything more hi-res than 720p, so thinking that higher resolutions were "for gaming" was a total logical disconnect. Oh well, I cannot complain now; since the advent of the MacBook for Serious Work (tm) all of these problems seem to have gone away.
Meta Quest 2: Doesn’t like itMeta Quest 3: Likes it
The Quest is pretty limited in hardware. The article mentions they use both Quest 2 and Quest 3; the Quest 2 is a $250 device that runs on a 5 year old mobile chip (about the same as the one in the Galaxy S20 Plus). The Quest 3 is much better (about on the level of a $500 phone), but they might just use the same games on both. And in VR/AR low latency and high framerate are much more important than visual fidelity. Your brain just kind of accepts those low fidelity representations, but reacts very badly to latency spikes or frame drops.
Meta Quest 2: Doesn’t like itMeta Quest 3: Likes it
I have worked for hours in Immersed in both the quest 2 and 3. The 3 is considerably more comfortable on the head and eyes. I constantly had to take the quest 2 off for a breather
Meta Quest 2: Doesn’t like itMeta Quest 3: Likes it
Yes Quest 3 is a completely different ball game to Quest 2 as far as this goes. Quest 2 resolution and lenses were completely unusable for me and Quest 3 is usable. But there are people that will say Quest 3 is unusable so you have to really try it. One thing it convinces me is that the resolution in Vision Pro is completely unnecessary for me. I need about 20% more resolution and I am done, after that other things are more important.
Meta Quest 2: Doesn’t like itMeta Quest 3: Likes it
I had the original Oculus Rift (tethered to a PC), the Oculus Go, the Quest 2 (paid for by my former employer) and now the Quest 3 (employer discount, I work for Meta but on WhatsApp, not Quest), and it’s a huge improvement over the Quest Pro or Quest 2, which is why I got it. My main use case is watching the 360º spherical panoramas I take with my Ricoh Theta Z1 camera, and possibly some light gaming, although Call of Duty Above and Beyond’s dogged insistence on realistic weapons handling is more of a drag than fun. I’m still working on getting a WebXR-enabled photo gallery generator using Three.js to be able to share those immersive panoramas with friends & family.
Meta Quest 2: NeutralMeta Quest 3: Likes it
Ha, I was downvoted and told "why do we need controllers, the iphone and macbook dont come with controllers" yesterday when I said this is stupid without controllers. I have a vive, q2 and q3. Look at him trying to type on that keyboard. I have hand gestures on my q3. They're nice for a few certain things, but thankfully I can forget they exist for 99% of what I do, that isn't flinging windows/screens left and right and expanding them in front of me. Or turning wifi on and off, etc.. And.. you can't do multiple screens and it has less resolution than my real life monitor when connecting to a mbp.. hm. I thought that was a super cool feature when I thought you could just add monitors wherever. I hadn't even thought of it before they showed it in the demo.
Meta Quest 2: Doesn’t like itMeta Quest 3: Likes it
Weight distribution is just as important as weight. The Meta Quest 3 is significantly more comfortable than the Quest 2 despite being slightly heavier, because the weight is much closer to your face. A fairly lightweight motorcycle helmet weighs about 1400 grams, but you really don't notice that weight unless it's poorly fitted. Given that the Vision Pro is exclusively available with a custom-fitted facial interface and headstrap, I'm quite confident that the comfort will be - at worst - on a par with most other VR headsets.
Meta Quest 2: Doesn’t like itMeta Quest 3: Likes it
So far Meta has published a whole bunch of spatial APIs including scene detection, spatial anchors, plane detection etc. [0] They are far ahead of Apple in many of these respects, but what they haven't had is a device that made this attractive to actually develop for in any meaningful way. Quest Pro lacks a depth sensor and has too small a market presence to attract a lot of developers, while Quest 2 has ugly, black and white low resolution pass through. So Quest 3 will be the first spatial computing device the world has ever had access to that is available at mass market price ( https://developer.oculus.com/documentation/unity/unity-spati...
Meta Quest 2: Doesn’t like itMeta Quest 3: Doesn’t like it
I bought my Quest 2 when it first came out, and I played it for a while, about 2-3 hours a week, peaking at about an hour a day when I found that Blade and Sorcery is a really good game for "exercise". I bought the Quest 3 as an upgrade because I had noticed my Quest 2 started having intermittent input lag issues. I never pinpointed what was causing it, but my Golf clubs would fly out of my hand and I'd have to wait a few seconds for them to eventually find their way back to me. My controllers would drift out of view when navigating menus. I uninstalled everything, reinstalled it again. When that didn't work, I upgraded. The issues persisted in the new version as well. So for about the last 20-ish months, I've averaged under an hour a month, most months I don't even pick it up. I might do some homemade PC VR "experiments" (still have access to mouse and keyboard for the game, and not the controllers) on some random claude code experiments. I have a "cyberpunk" mobius strip space station walking sim I've been working on, that will eventually hook into a treadmill.
Meta Quest 2: Likes itMeta Quest 3: Likes it
Yeah I had a Quest 2 and now have a Quest 3 for gaming - while the Q3 got a very modest resolution bump, the optics changes where night and day better - pancake lenses where worth upgrading alone over fresnels, reduction in glare and the sweetspot been massive by comparison.
Meta Quest 2: NeutralMeta Quest 3: Neutral
Parent comment says "aggressively cutting unsuccessful bets" and Oculus is nothing like that. Oculus Quest are decent products, but a complete flop compared to their investment and Zuck's vision of the metaverse. Remember they even renamed the company? You could say they're on betting on the long run, but I just don't see that happening in 5 or even 10 years. As an owner of Quest 2 and 3, I'd love to be proven wrong though. I just don't see any evidence of this would change any time soon.