The stuff Hacker News actually recommends.

Phones

Apple iPhone 4S vs Apple iPhone 8

Owners are split: the signals below point different ways.

Apple iPhone 4SApple iPhone 8
Owners with an opinion49113
Positive verdicts59% of 3974% of 90
Positive/negative since 20247/1018/11
Happy after 3+ years615
Longest happy owner8 yrs7 yrs
Praised fordesign and durabilityreliability and durability
Criticized forperformance and softwarebattery and performance
Newest comment

Updated

What owners wrote about both

Apple iPhone 4S: Likes itApple iPhone 8: Doesn’t like it
Before the iPhone 6 and its rounded displays, I never used a case on my iPhone (including models 3g, 4s, and 5). I occasionally dropped it, but never had more than minor scratches or minor dents on the metal edging. Then I got an iPhone 6, and at some point dropped it & cracked the screen. Replaced the screen, and eventually cracked it again. Got an iPhone 8 and eventually cracked the screen. When I wanted to buy an iPhone X, my wife said, "Only if you get a case", and I didn't really have a good counter-argument. Which makes it kind of an irony: if you push too far in some direction, you end up going way back. Jony Ive pushed for the iPhone 6 form factor: thinner, rounder. Which made it prettier without a case; but by sacrificing too much sturdiness, it meant everyone needed to have a case -- so the iPhone form factor became "a very pretty, fragile phone in a bulky case" rather than "a nice-looking moderately robust phone without a case".
Apple iPhone 4S: Likes itApple iPhone 8: Doesn’t like it
I used iPhone 4S for 4 years and did not drop it once. I dropped iPhone 8 first day, I have no idea how to hold it, so I bought case immediately. Now it's bearable. Another reason for using a case is a terrible camera protruding from the phone.
Apple iPhone 4S: Likes itApple iPhone 8: Doesn’t like it
I hate screen cases. But I bought one for iPhone 8 because this thing is not made to be used without case. I dropped it first day, it's just not convenient to hold. I had 4S for 6 years before and never dropped it. iPhones went downwards as Jobs died.
Apple iPhone 4S: Likes itApple iPhone 8: Neutral
I recently bought iPhone 8 after using 4S for many years. That screen is too huge! I would switch it to SE if not for better tech inside (better fingerprint reader is the main selling point for me, but better CPU is nice too). I'm using iPhone 8 for almost a year now and I can't get accustomed to it. I loved when I could use phone with one hand. Also my hands are huge, so I have no idea how could one use it with one hand (without that gimmick with double-tapping home button). Now recent iPhone models are just not appealing to me at all. I don't want to use face recognition and they no longer use fingerprint readers. Honestly, give me tiny iPhone with 3'5" display, put latest tech inside and you'll have my $300 immediately.
Apple iPhone 4S: Likes itApple iPhone 8: Neutral
My first smartphone was iPhone 4S which I bought at 2012. Its WiFi started to work very bad exactly after 1 year of use, so warranty was not applicable. I found repair guy who replaced WiFi module for something like 10% of this phone initial cost. I used it for around 5 years and recently switched to iPhone 8. It still works now without any issues except degraded battery and software. Well, charging cables of course were broken after one or two years, that's problem for all Apple devices I've owned so far. Not a big problem, Chinese cables are cheap and of better quality anyway.
Apple iPhone 4S: NeutralApple iPhone 8: Neutral
Honestly I observe zero progress in the last 10 years. My first iPhone was 4S. My current iPhone is 8. My use-case is absolutely the same. Calls, SMS, Whatsapp, navigation, books, browser. The same with macs. I boot, open IDE, Terminal and that's about it. Yes, hardware's getting faster (which is compensated by software getting slower). But nothing changed dramatically. I think that the only thing that changed is adoption of fingerprint reader. Both in iPhone 8 and in mac. AI might be that thing that could tremendously change my usage pattern. But it should be as smart as human assistant. GPT4-level intelligence might have the necessary power for that.
Apple iPhone 4S: NeutralApple iPhone 8: Neutral
I got an iPhone 8 after rocking an iPhone 4s for about 8 years. And this point, all the phones are pretty damn fast and smart be it an android or iPhone ecosystem. I would be happy with either. What finalized my purchase was the fact that Costco was offering 300$ store credit plus a couple other things on a Black Friday sale. Seemed like a good deal at the time.