The stuff Hacker News actually recommends.

Phones · Apple iPhone

Apple iPhone 4S

30owners with an opinion
54%of verdicts positive
7/10positive/negative since 2024
8 yrslongest happy owner
5happy after 3+ years

Praised for design and build quality; criticized for performance and reliability.

What owners wrote

Likes itOwned 6 years
I hate screen cases. But I bought one for iPhone 8 because this thing is not made to be used without case. I dropped it first day, it's just not convenient to hold. I had 4S for 6 years before and never dropped it. iPhones went downwards as Jobs died.
Likes itOwned 6 yearsStill going
I'm still using an iPhone 4S 64GB from 2011, which my dad bought for me as a graduation present. Partly because I'm too poor to upgrade, and partly because it still meets most of my needs. The biggest problem I face is software rot in iOS 6. That would be the same regardless of OS. I can't use WhatsApp any more, or Kakaotalk. Facebook used to forward my messages to email, but now they demand that I use a Messenger app. Instead, I just check Facebook's website using the browser. There haven't been any really significant apps that I needed that have been released in the last 5 years. I've made a list in case I ever update my OS. I don't need BBM or Pokémon Go. The messenger apps are the worst for forcing software updates, but I hope that people will eventually move back to email and SMS, which just work.
Likes itOwned 5 years
My first smartphone was iPhone 4S which I bought at 2012. Its WiFi started to work very bad exactly after 1 year of use, so warranty was not applicable. I found repair guy who replaced WiFi module for something like 10% of this phone initial cost. I used it for around 5 years and recently switched to iPhone 8. It still works now without any issues except degraded battery and software. Well, charging cables of course were broken after one or two years, that's problem for all Apple devices I've owned so far. Not a big problem, Chinese cables are cheap and of better quality anyway.
NeutralOwned 5 yearsStill going
I had a 1st gen iPhone for 5 years, and currently have a 4s that I've been using for 5-6 years (I only replace my phones when my current one stops working). There's longevity in the devices, but not as much longevity in the software. Each update gets slower than the last and then you stop getting updates at all.
Recommends itOwned 5 yearsStill going
If this will be your first iPhone, you've picked a good one to get started with. My first and only iPhone, after nearly 5 years, is the iPhone 4S which is seemingly an identical body as this SE. And it is a rock-solid, perfect little machine. I've dropped it countless times on brick and cement and it has no scratches on it after all this time -- never even put a case on it. These larger, thin phones that have come since have been a lot more fragile.
Likes itOwned 4 years
I used iPhone 4S for 4 years and did not drop it once. I dropped iPhone 8 first day, I have no idea how to hold it, so I bought case immediately. Now it's bearable. Another reason for using a case is a terrible camera protruding from the phone.
Likes itOwned 2 yearsStill going
When a new iphone comes out, owners of old iphones could feel that their phones are inadequate, and are searching for "is the iphone [n-1] slow?". Also, with each iphone generally comes a new ios version, which is more or less written for the specs of the newest phone. That being said, this post is being typed from an iphone 4s I've owned for two years. I've never had any complaints about performance. Never noticed a slowdown.
Likes it
I think we're fighting against the modern world here. My 4S did and still does take the last great iPhone photos, before the processing pipeline ruined it for me, with over-sharpening, smeared noise-reduction and color flattening. Thankfully we have access to raw DNGs in phones after the 4S, so we can create our own image processing pipeline. But for "out of the camera" JPGs, the 4S is still supreme.
Likes it
All day every day my iPhone makes me feel like an idiot. I need to correct every other word I type (or at least what my iPhone thinks I typed). While correcting, autocorrect introduces new and even more baffling misspellings. Sometimes it gets to “fever dream where you’re suddenly unable to successfully perform everyday tasks” levels of insanity. And the worst part is: it used to be fine. I’d type more or less on full keyboard levels of speed and accuracy on my iPhone 4S.
Doesn’t like it
Autobrightness only works for screens which are against a wall. Your eyes care about what is behind the screen, not in front of it, and that’s one thing autobrightness never took into account. I used to jailbreak my iPhone 4s to get some dark mode.
Likes it
I just got old iPhone 4s with iOS 9 from drawer, and hour later managed to downgrade to iOS 6, uhh, shapes and colors on these icons is something and it's got 3d dock at the bottom that looks just like dock from OSX 10.7, what a blast from the past. links for those interested in downgrading: https://github.com/LukeZGD/Legacy-iOS-Kit/wiki/How-to-Use https://github.com/LukeZGD/Legacy-iOS-Kit/wiki/Restore-32-bi... https://github.com/LukeZGD/EverPwnage https://sideloadly.io
Likes it
> with old iPhones My first iPhone was a 4S and i was astonished how correctly i'm typing. At least in English. I even managed to bully the spell checker into reasonably accepting both English and Romanian, back when they didn't have multiple languages at the same time on the keyboard. I'm not sure when it started to go downhill, but I was using an XS and it was at at least one more version after whatever XS shipped with.
Doesn’t like it
This is immensely frustrating to me. I was an iPhone user from 2009 to 2019. In 2019, when the iTunes backup from my failed iPhone 4S wouldn't restore to an iPhone SE (it made the phone boot loop) I got frustrated and went Android. I decided to "sideload" all non-stock software on my Android phone. I never have setup a Google Play account. I kept all the APKs for the software I loaded over the years that I used that phone. I just got a new Android phone a couple of weeks ago. I was able to just load all the software I use day-to-day from APKs (except for a few that are, apparently, processor-specific). I imported my SMS, contacts, and call logs using a nice FOSS app[0]. It felt remarkably like moving to a new PC does. It was nice. I am really sad Google is ending this moving forward. Jackasses. [0] https://github.com/tmo1/sms-ie
Neutral
Of phones I owned 10+ years ago: iPhone 6S: 138.3/67.1/7.1 = 65.9 cc the mini is just barely smaller. iPhone 4S: 115.2/58.6/9.3 = 62.8 cc smaller than the mini. Treo 650: 113/59/23 = 153 cc which is about the same volume as a Galaxy Z Fold 3... the displacement was so uncomfortable, people often used hip holsters for the former.
Doesn’t like it
It was not a bug. I have similar story with my iPhone 4S became unusable with iOS 7. It was never fixed. One day I managed to jailbreak it, rolling back to iOS 6 and was astonished how fast and smooth it is. They just implemented iOS 7 with much more compute requirements, so only newer phones were able to run it smoothly. The progress of mobile CPUs these old days was crazy, so I don't really complain about it, it was inevitable.
Likes it
> ...what happens 40 years in the future, when our phones don't run the app anymore... 40 years? How about, like, 3 to 5 years? Remember when Apple decided to kill all 32-bit iOS apps for new hardware? I have an old iPod and iPhone 4S with "landlocked" software I enjoy using but can't anymore because Apple. Phone manufacturers have shown they don't give a damn about allowing old software to function. Physical devices tied to software is a terrible idea.
Doesn’t like it
That fair. Im referring to the general trend of adoption of smartphones being a certain way with Apple. Like others, I’ve spent time back and forth between iPhone and Android while using Macs more. Android dialled in was pretty comfortable for me, iPhone was a lot more taps and swipes for the same, but the vertical integration is harder to ignore.
Doesn’t like it
I went though a similar problem about 10 years ago. In my case, the phone (iPhone 4S) wasn't lost, but it's clock was perpetually off. The WiFi radio had failed and the Stratum 1 time server on my mobile network seemed to be sending it the wrong time. This resulted in all of the MFA TOTPs getting rejected and me not being able to access Gmail for a year. Despite the clock issue, many things still worked, presumably because this was still back when much of the internet used either weak or zero TLS/SSL.
Likes it
I'm a long-term Linux user and started buying Apple products long ago. I still keep my iPhone 4S around because I think it's a piece of art. I think the hardware and physical design of Apple products is really great. When I heard about this new EU regulation, I started to consider retiring my iPhone. I developed my own iOS app, but I'm unable to run it permanently because I need to get it approved by Apple to install it on my own device. PWAs are an alternative I was considering, and I'm also using some from others. If this is true. I'll switch to Android. The only device I'd keep using actively is the M1 MacBook because it's running Asahi Linux and I haven't booted into MacOS for months now.
Doesn’t like it
I still have my iPhone 4S keyboard that I used stubbornly for months (along with the 4s itself). Every now and then I charge it and connect it to my PC via bluetooth, but even in landscape mode it was just too small for my sausage fingers. I don't understand how a portrait mode keyboard will be any better, but I hope to be wrong.
Likes it
I'm in a similar position and I can answer for my situation. I bought iPad 3 back in 2012 I think. I liked it a lot and I bought iPhone 4S which I liked even more (until they released iOS 7 but that's theme for another rant). After that I understood that I love Apple approach and decided to buy a Macbook as I wanted to write some apps and also needed new laptop at that time. I bought Retina Macbook Pro 15" mid 2012. Well, it was worst laptop I ever saw. Software was good, I still love it. SSD broke in the second month, so I took it to repair and it was in repair for another month until replacement SSD arrived. Thankfully it was covered by warranty and that's the only good thing about this situation. I used it for 2 years and then it just started to tear apart. Charger cable failed. I bought new at aliexpress, tried to replace it and almost caused a fire, so I had to buy a new charger which costs like a cheap laptop LoL. Keyboard failed. Right now half of keys just do not work, another half of keys work if pressed hard enough. And I did not spill anything there, they just don't register presses. I'm using USB keyboard to work on it. Audio port failed. There's some switch there to detect optical cable or something like that. That switch is stuck, so red laser always lighting out of there and macOS thinks that I inserted a headphones, so speakers do not work. And headphones do not work either. I'm using USB headphones if I need sound. It sometimes panics. I think that something'
Likes it
I recently bought iPhone 8 after using 4S for many years. That screen is too huge! I would switch it to SE if not for better tech inside (better fingerprint reader is the main selling point for me, but better CPU is nice too). I'm using iPhone 8 for almost a year now and I can't get accustomed to it. I loved when I could use phone with one hand. Also my hands are huge, so I have no idea how could one use it with one hand (without that gimmick with double-tapping home button). Now recent iPhone models are just not appealing to me at all. I don't want to use face recognition and they no longer use fingerprint readers. Honestly, give me tiny iPhone with 3'5" display, put latest tech inside and you'll have my $300 immediately.