The stuff Hacker News actually recommends.

Phones · Apple iPhone

Apple iPhone 8

52owners with an opinion
66%of verdicts positive
17/11positive/negative since 2024
6 yrslongest happy owner
4happy after 3+ years

Praised for reliability and performance; criticized for battery and software.

What owners wrote

Likes itOwned 6 yearsStill going
I do all the things Peter Easton, the original author, says not to - running my phone between 20 and 80%, with an occasional full charge, and it's usually charged off a 1A charger, despite being capable of charging at 3x that. It's a six year old iPhone 8, with the original factory battery, an estimated 76% of its original capacity, and its internal resistance is still low enough that it's running in 'peak performance' mode. Easton knows nothing about electronics or batteries and has a terminal case of Dunning-Kruger. "It's not 2005 anymore" really? Then why does the iPhone 15 offer the option to cap the max battery charge at 80%? https://support.apple.com/en-us/108055 Your phone is not going to explode in flames because of a malfunctioning power supply and it's beyond absurd to suggest it might. USB is a POWER SUPPLY to the phone's mainboard - it powers the charger, it isn't the battery charger itself and the two are not directly connected. If the USB plug supplies the wrong voltage or negotiation doesn't happen, the phone simply won't charge. Furthermore, many cell phone batteries have an internal BMS that will disconnect the battery if it goes overtemperature, overvoltage, or overcurrent - charge or discharge. I've changed the battery in several android phones and each had a small battery protection board on it. Charge rate absolutely impacts battery lifetime. If Easton opened a single datasheet from any lithium-ion battery manufacturer he could verify that himself. Manu…
Likes itOwned 4 years
> dont really need a screen, its cubersome when you are outside for long periods of time and battery life on Apple phones isn't very good > Need something, I don't care if its big, that will last for at least a week, can do 3g/4g (5g is too much) SMS globally and calling internationally That depends on if you feel that you need to keep everything that needs network running in the background all the time. I keep some things running in the background, but not everything. My aging iPhone 8 lasts me a week between charges, and it's got 4 years on its back and still using the original battery, now down to just under 80% maximum capacity. Really, the iPhones' battery life is fine.
Likes itOwned 3 years
My god, I'd heard that Android support over time was not great, but 3 years? That's really, really short. I'm a gadget nut, so for a long time I got a new phone every 18-24 months -- and for most of that time, the year over year gains on phones were sufficient to justify the upgrade, at least for some users. But we're in a more mature market now. YoY updates on phones are pretty incremental. I kept my iPhone 8 for about 3 years before handing it off to my wife (who, lest you think me a jerk, absolutely DID NOT WANT to spend the money on a new phone for her), who then used it for almost 2 more years. The phone I replaced it with is an 11Pro. I expect to get AT LEAST 3 years out of it. (What finally tempted me out of the 8 was the camera, which I assume is a common story no matter which kind of phone you like -- they got a LOT better between 2016 and 2019.) Pixels are high-end Android handsets, right? I would have assumed that they'd have similar useful lives; I don't blame Android folks for being up in arms, because sunsetting a 3 year old handset is just BANANAS.
Likes itOwned 3 yearsStill going
> " Most people use pre-paid phones until they either break down or get stolen. " Reference please. My personal impression is that most people buy subsidized phones, as part of the contract, every 2 years when the renewal is up. If you have better data than my anecdote, I'm all ears. The Android devices that I've had, and that my family has had, stopped receiving major updates, and even security patches, after only 1 year. So first of all, I don't care what other people do, I can't use devices that are no longer upgraded with security patches. Meanwhile iPhone 6s is getting upgraded to iOS 14. Also, low end Androids stop being usable after about 2 years, either because apps become too slow, or because the battery is affected. And even the high end phones have hardware issues much faster than my iPhones. I've had two Galaxy S phones in my household, after 2 years one had a damaged motherboard and the other had a battery dying on us. These devices are designed for obsolescence. And many people are actually spending more money on those lower end Androids than if they got a higher end iPhone and keep it for 6 years. My 3 year old iPhone 8 still has a battery that's in top shape BTW, with no performance issues.
NeutralOwned 1 year
I recently bought iPhone 8 after using 4S for many years. That screen is too huge! I would switch it to SE if not for better tech inside (better fingerprint reader is the main selling point for me, but better CPU is nice too). I'm using iPhone 8 for almost a year now and I can't get accustomed to it. I loved when I could use phone with one hand. Also my hands are huge, so I have no idea how could one use it with one hand (without that gimmick with double-tapping home button). Now recent iPhone models are just not appealing to me at all. I don't want to use face recognition and they no longer use fingerprint readers. Honestly, give me tiny iPhone with 3'5" display, put latest tech inside and you'll have my $300 immediately.
Doesn’t like it
Yeah, I’m not a dedicated iPhone user and my personal phones are androids so my iOS experience has been iPod Touch 2G -> employer owned iPhone 8 -> employer owned iPhone XR -> iPad Air M3. Each of those big gaps have seen the UI shift and the keyboard decline.
Likes it
In my experience, iPhone 4 was better than iPhone 8 which is better than iPhone 17. Either I got lucky, went to more interesting places and composed better, or the technology is getting worse from an aesthetic point-of-view. I definitely had more keepers, more memorable photos of a higher subjective quality. I pretty much don't bother with iPhotography now. Similar story on Android but I won't bore with the model names and numbers. Older handsets gave better results. Pre-smartphone, king of the hill was the Sony K800, I loved the photos from that phone. No fancy software, just quality hardware and straightforward processing gave consistent results. That said, I should try Halide app. Bringing it back to basics with less computation might be the way forward for me.
Doesn’t like it
What really annoys me is Apple EOLed the iPhone 8 and then came out with a virtually identical SE version. Of course they soon discontinued the SE too… Maybe they updated the CPU slightly but screen and camera were identical. I would have kept my iPhone 8 if they kept updating the software. Yet somehow they can manage update the SE software despite looking the same as the iPhone 8… I know there is a cost and overhead toward supporting old platforms. But for the premium on these devices and the level of waste generated, manufacturers can still do better… I’d prefer no new features and only security updates… perhaps I’m weird.
Likes it
I'm also a touchID / iphone 8 size fan, but the nice cameras/zoom in flagship models are hard to give up. At least Face ID has improved significantly from the early days of iphone 10 -- it's faster and more reliable than it was on the older models if you tried it back then.
Doesn’t like it
My iPhone 8 just stopped working 2 months back (phone works but the microphone used in phone calls no longer works) so by chance my good friend gave me his pixel 8 that was only a couple few months old. It got a pink line down the screen that comes and goes which if you press in one spot can usually make it go away but he is a business owner and he can't risk the screen going from line to not working for a day as a missed communication could cost him thousands. So he said here take it and he got a new one. Seems like this pink line is common and a defect in some screens. Anyways I wanted to say I also have a pixel 8 but with stock OS and my battery typically lasts a full day with average usage. My iPhone 8 previously even with a replacement battery was lucky if it lasted more then 5 hours. I had to charge that thing multiple times a day.
Neutral
My previous phone was the iphone 8. It’s trully a world of difference in usability compared to the iPhone 13 I’m using now. I have big hands, so I can ise the latter one-handed, but a lot of people I’ve seen don’t.
Likes it
> Something can be said about unlocking deprecated devices, but it would only ever be used by a tiny percentage of people. Apple devices in particular last a very long time anyway, as you should expect from a premium brand. Used by a tiny percentage only because Apple has made it as difficult as possible to not upgrade, which is especially egregious precisely because their devices are long-lasting. (This comment brought to you via a perfectly functioning iPhone 8 running the latest possible iOS that supports it.)
Likes it
I prefer my old iPhone 8 to the new models, but without the updates it's no longer useful. I was waiting for 4th Gen SE but it never came, but in practice it's the same width and less than 2 centimetres taller. If I could have a shorter phone (like an iPhone 8 without the bezel) that would be amazing. I tried small Androids in the past, had a Sony Xperia compact (Z1?) and loved it until it very literally fell apart.
Doesn’t like it
I have an iPhone 8 still in service and compared to an equally old Android device, the Android (some kind of Motorola eX series low end phone) runs circles around the iPhone. Even playing background video or audio streamed from wifi and output over bluetooth with the screen off, the Android will burn 15% in an hour while the iPhone will burn over 60%. Both are the same age but the iPhone feels subjectively obselete while the low end Motorola feels like a mid-2010s computer. Even for it's age the Android will last two weeks in Airplane mode.
Doesn’t like it
I'm in the same boat. I need to update my Apple Watch but can't because I can't update my iPhone 8. I love Apple stuff but there's no ignoring the costs (beyond the purchase price).