The stuff Hacker News actually recommends.

VR and AR headsets

Meta Quest 2 vs Valve Index

No clear winner: owners rate them about the same.

Meta Quest 2Valve Index
Owners with an opinion443128
Positive verdicts50% of 35156% of 102
Positive/negative since 202438/5424/13
Happy after 3+ years10
Longest happy owner5 yrs0.5 yrs
Praised forperformance and ease of useperformance and comfort
Criticized forcomfort and displayease of use and display
Newest comment

Updated

What owners wrote about both

Meta Quest 2: NeutralValve Index: Likes it
That's gonna be one expensive BeatSaber machine, but after having owned an Index (and really feeling how nice that headset was when I got my current Quest 2), there's no way I'm not gonna get one.
Meta Quest 2: Doesn’t like itValve Index: Likes it
As an owner of an HTC Vive and a Quest 2, I find the terrible specs of the Quest to be the biggest reason why it collects dust. The resolution is horrible, the cameras are horrible, and the apps it can run are crap. Exploring raytraced worlds on my 3090Ti in a high resolution Vive or Valve Index delivers a level of immersive experience that’s impossible to achieve on Quests hardware. The Quest 3 is still a bit of a potato but one day, quality and convenience will converge into a sweet spot that clicks for more people in a way that only enthusiasts get to experience nowadays. A portable Index would likely have the impact people tend to expect when they imagine futuristic VR.
Meta Quest 2: Likes itValve Index: Doesn’t like it
I was tooling around with VR development when I tried developing directly from within the headset. Shockingly, the Quest 2 was streets ahead of the Index when it came to usability. It wasn't bad; it just wasn't something I would want to replace my current setup. I'm sure once the headsets hit a certain resolution, this will become much more common.
Meta Quest 2: Likes itValve Index: Neutral
At typically more than 2x the cost. I've played Alyx on both, the Index is absolutely not a 2x better experience. I'm no fan of their corporate parent either, but the value proposition on Quest 2 for general purpose PC VR gaming (especially prior to this price increase) was remarkable given size of subsidy Meta were prepared to make on price.
Meta Quest 2: Doesn’t like itValve Index: Likes it
I bought two recently for my parents and they don’t use them. I tried to use them but there are no real VR games to play. All of the games are arcade-style mini games with 20 year-old graphics. They get boring after a couple minutes. Huge disappointment! Around 10 years ago I gave up on VR and decided to wait for the VR game market to grow. It was a huge bummer to learn that nothing has changed after all this time. I think it will take another decade or two for hardware power and costs to catch up to modern game engines. For me, the only VR experience worth experiencing right now is probably a $1000 Valve Index with Half-Life Alyx running on my $4000 PC.
Meta Quest 2: Doesn’t like itValve Index: Likes it
A lot of people have found motion sickness in VR is actually usually driven by refresh rate. They get sick because the screen doesn't update as fast as reality. If you have the chance to try a Valve Index, they have the ability (not default setting though) to go to 144hz, and you may experience way less sickness. The Quest and Quest2 can't go that high.
Meta Quest 2: Doesn’t like itValve Index: Likes it
You are ignoring that plenty of people, especially young people, already tolerate headsets enough to spend many hours wearing them. Making the headsets much much lighter, less hot, wireless, better optics, higher res, higher refresh rates, etc., will improve the experience massively. Look into what is already public: companies are exploring eye tracking, varifocal lenses (so your eyes are not always looking at the same focal plane), etc. You can even compare the Index versus the Quest 2 to see what a difference a better screen can make. People already deal with eye strain by staring at a bright screen from a fixed distance for most of their life. Neural link, sure, eventually. For now, if you don’t think ten years of progress won’t lead to hundreds of millions of devices sold, well, wait and see.
Meta Quest 2: Likes itValve Index: Doesn’t like it
If you already have an Oculus Quest you should try hooking it up to your PC using Airlink or the link cable first. This allows you to use it with Steam VR or the desktop Oculus apps. As long as your PC can handle VR, you'll get better graphics and access to more VR titles. If you use Airlink you'll still have a completely wireless headset, a trick to reducing latency and avoiding problems with traffic spikes on your network is to get a wifi card for your PC and set it up as a hotspot so you can connect your Quest directly to the PC without going through the router. Some good first time experiences for people are Space Pirate Trainer if they like shooters or I Expect You To Die if they're more of a puzzle game type and Beat Saber if they like rhythm games. These games don't involve thumbstick based movement so they probably won't make you feel sick. If you want something that's really chill and is just kind of pretty to look at and walk through then Walkabout Mini Golf is pretty good, it's not the most exciting game but it does have multiplayer and it's pretty relaxing to play a round and just admire the work they put into the courses. I've heard that setting up a fan so it's blowing on you while you're playing VR is a good way to prevent motion sickness. I don't really get very motion sick though so I haven't had to try it. Some very good games that will definitely make you motion sick are Pavlov and Bone Works. You will feel queasy after playing these for the first few times…
Meta Quest 2: Recommends itValve Index: Doesn’t like it
The Quest 2 is the best bang for the buck by far. Unfortunately made by facebook, but designed by John Carmack while he was still working there, and if I'm not mistaken sold at a loss. For the money it's the clear choice. Another option if you don't mind over paying is the valve index. You'll get higher resolution and finger tracking. It's also said to be quite comfortable. At $1000 it's more like a sports car. By that I mean it breaks down all the time. When it's working it's great but if you use it a lot there are problems with the controllers. Lots of RMA stories. Many people turn to dissembling them and fixing things themselves. I've turned to that with my Vive. The soon to be released PSVR 2 on PS5 is also worth an honorable mention but leaves out some of the experimental VR stuff you can hack around at on PC VR. Edit: I should note as well with the Quest 2. There isn't even a tradeoff between PCVR and standalone mode. You can get the link cable and use it as a PCVR headset to play steam games etc.
Meta Quest 2: NeutralValve Index: Likes it
Not really, "Facebook Horizons" is like a cheaper knock-off version of Rec Room. Laggier, buggier and feels very very corporate. You walk around and feel stalked by these "Community Leader" facebook employees and it just feels ick. Hard to explain. I recommend you try out Rec Room. Infinitely better. I own both the index and the quest 2. The quest 2 is less powerful objectively but it's ergonomics are on point. It's so much easier to pick up and play. Yet every time I put it on I lament how it's owned and created by Facebook. What a travesty. I hope Valve makes an Index 2 and pushes VR forward again.
Meta Quest 2: Likes itValve Index: Doesn’t like it
Because the Valve index is very expensive and needs to be tethered to an also expresive gaming PC via cumbersome cables plus the need to install the IR lighthouses in your living-room, and require maintenance of drivers and VR compatible SW(I was a PC gamer, I know). All this expense, physical installation work and general friction is a non-starter for most consumers and that's why yours sits on the shelf unused. The Quest(2) is not tethered but has the "gaming PC" built inside of it, no need to bolt lighthouses to your living room walls, and has the frictionless ecosystem polish of the PS/X-box. So it sits charging on my couch, always updating itself and the games in the background, and when I have 10 minutes of boredom during WFH, I can slip it on my head and will instantly resume the last game state I was on, no cables, no PC, no maintaining or curating drivers and SW, none of that stuff. Zero friction. And I can also put it in my backpack and take it to a friend's place instead of having the whole setup bolted to my living room. I also had work colleagues with gaming PCs buy the Index and return it in the 30 day window after getting bored of the nuisance of cables and SW, then buy a Quest 2 and keep it. The Quest absolutely killed the Index for the mainstream VR market and got Valve to move in the same direction.
Meta Quest 2: NeutralValve Index: Neutral
This isn't true. It's more that the Vision Pro deliberately prioritized certain things that Meta or Vive or Valve or Sony have not: geometrically stable pass through, wide library of popular 3D movies via AppleTV and Disney+, high resolution immersive environments, seamless keyboard/mouse/trackpad migration between PC and native apps, strong iOS/iPadOS ecosystem integration, high fps / low latency wireless ultra-wide virtual displays for the Mac, etc. In some ways it focuses on what the Oculus Go was trying to do but was underpowered to really do it. It's meant to replace other iOS devices for general productivity and entertainment, and to complement a Mac. It's not focused on VR gaming though it can do that. I have a Oculus Rift dev kit, Ovulus Go, Quest , Quest 2, Valve Index, PSVR2. The AVP is much better of an experience on almost every level but three: too much motion blur when moving your head (this isn't bad when watching high fps video), lack of controller support, not so great hand tracking (which the Quest had to do well due to lack of eye tracking). The controller support should be fixed with the Sony PSVR2 partnership. Motion blur and hand tracking I suspect will be software fixed as they evolve to prioritize active fitness with the AVP.
Meta Quest 2: Likes itValve Index: Likes it
I've had a HTC Vive, Quest 2, and the Valve Index. It's much higher fidelity than any of them by a very large margin. The virtual desktop feature is pretty similar experiences. The hand tracking controls are classic apple (it just works). The eye tracking can use some more work. I do feel that this could be the future. It's a huge step forward in certain areas, and I think the rest will be fixed. In a generation or two, this is going to be really compelling. I never felt that way about any of the other headsets I own.
Meta Quest 2: Doesn’t like itValve Index: Doesn’t like it
I own a Quest 2 and it's far from glorious. The resolution makes everything a blurry mess, and the lenses make anything off-center even more blurry. It DOES get sweaty, hot, and it leaves pressure marks on your face. My 65" 4k OLED TV and shelf speakers absolutely destroy the Quest 2. I have also owned an HTC Vive and a Valve Index. I would rather do nothing than use any of them for media consumption.