The stuff Hacker News actually recommends.

VR and AR headsets

Meta Quest 2 vs Meta Quest Pro

Hacker News owners slightly favor the Meta Quest Pro.

Meta Quest 2Meta Quest Pro
Owners with an opinion44341
Positive verdicts50% of 35166% of 32
Positive/negative since 202438/542/3
Happy after 3+ years10
Longest happy owner5 yrs–
Praised forperformance and ease of usecomfort and performance
Criticized forcomfort and displaydisplay and software
Newest comment

Updated

What owners wrote about both

Meta Quest 2: Likes itMeta Quest Pro: Neutral
Nope. I own an HTC Vive, HTC Vive Pro, Oculus Quest 2, Oculus Quest Pro, Magic Leap 2; the Vision Pro is a completely different animal. Of those I think the quest 2 is the best product, fwiw. But the vision is a dev kit for a totally new platform, and I don’t believe any of the others is a fair comp.
Meta Quest 2: NeutralMeta Quest Pro: Likes it
Depends on whether this new device follows the Quest 2 design or the Quest Pro. I suspect it’ll be like the 2, judging by it having a full gasket. For the Quest 2: you can purchase premade lens kits with your prescription that snap on over the fresnel lenses. If you want to save a decent chunk of money, there’s DIY kits you can 3D print/Etsy. You also CAN use your glasses in a pinch, but it’s an unenjoyable experience imo (and can be impossible if you have really chonky frames). For the Quest Pro: it feels almost like the thing was made with glasses-users in mind - provided you don’t use the light gaskets (which I personally rarely do). I believe there’s also the same aftermarket lens adapters like on the Quest 2, but I’ve been quite fine using my glasses so I can’t confirm it.
Meta Quest 2: Likes itMeta Quest Pro: Doesn’t like it
I largely agree with what you’ve written. I love my Quest 2 even though I own other headsets, but I feel that the Quest Pro is largely a failure. How you market a headset with a PPD of only 22 as a headset for work? 35 PPD is the minimum if you want to read text. The only headset capable of that is the $1999 Varjo Aero. What’s even more puzzling is that there’s currently no good way of extending the Quest Pro’s battery life Whether Meta and the other manufacturers will admit it or not, they need Apple to make VR & AR acceptable to the masses and workplaces. Despite the name change, meta still cannot escape its past yet. The Quest 2 is a revolutionary consumer device that is largely ignored because of meta’s poor public image at least in developed countries
Meta Quest 2: Likes itMeta Quest Pro: Doesn’t like it
As much as I’m unhappy about the death of PCVR thanks to the Quest 2, I have to agree with Carmack that it was very close to being the Right Device for bringing VR to the masses - and the sales numbers mostly reflect this. But I can’t help but feel something dysfunctional happened internally since the Quest 2 launch. The Quest Pro should not have been launched at $1500 with its current feature set/SoC and no depth sensor. And I find it difficult to accept the “enterprise market” claim as anything more than a cope when I go into BestBuy and see it being demoed to consumers and displayed prominently in an endcap. Then you look at the software side. Horizon is a horrible pile of ugly jank that no one uses. I gave it another shot for the first time in ages last week after seeing an advertising campaign for a deep faked Notorious BIG concert in Horizon. Long story short, the “live metaverse concert” had fewer attendees than an average Wendy’s and the performance was low res 2d video on a screen. Embarrassing stuff. As far as gaming is concerned: Meta spent hundreds of millions acquiring some of the largest third party VR devs over the past couple years - and still not a single game has been announced. It sure smells like rotten bureaucratic infighting combined with Zuck doggedly chasing where he thinks the puck is going and Carmack’s resignation letter certainly doesn’t disabuse me of the notion.
Meta Quest 2: Likes itMeta Quest Pro: Doesn’t like it
I'm bullish on VR/AR but FB seems to have totally lost the plot. The metaverse is a joke, the Meta Quest 2 software is utter garbage (super buggy, unintuitive, extremely frustrating), and the Quest Pro was incredibly lackluster. I enjoy my Quest 2 overall once you get into a game but the OS is trash and FB's layer on top of Android is not well done. My friends and I spend way more time than we should just trying to get into a "Home" all together and launching a game from the OS is a crapshoot. The OS is completely full of papercuts from unresponsive UI to things like switching to passthrough kills party audio for a second or two. Staying in passthrough for more than a minute (sometimes less) will kick you from the game you are playing which is infuriating. Do they think that people don't need to step away to deal with kids/pets/drinks/bathroom/etc? I can't tell you how many gaming sessions have been ruined or screwed up because someone had to take a short break and the OS/Game just shit the bed. I was excited for the Quest Pro and was ready to buy one if it was compelling... it was not. The specs are a minor bump over the Q2, the color passthrough camera feels very "beta", and from videos I've watched of it in action I'm glad I didn't get one. The (literal) bending of "reality" when using passthrough looks terrible and feels like it would really break immersion. The controllers did look interesting and I haven't heard anything really bad about them, they do seem like a big st…
Meta Quest 2: Likes itMeta Quest Pro: Doesn’t like it
Carmack's vision culminated in Quest 2, which is the only hardware Meta has produced that any significant number of people care about. Instead of Macintosh, I might point at Commodore. Affordable hardware with success in some niches like video production, but poor broader acceptance beyond gaming markets. Weirdly out of touch management with a yearning to be accepted by stuffy business types, but completely misjudging wants and needs. With Quest Pro I get vibes of the Commodore 128, a game machine trying and failing to be a Serious Business Device.
Meta Quest 2: NeutralMeta Quest Pro: Doesn’t like it
I’d be disappointed in my Quest Pro even at $800. Compared to my Quest 2 with an aftermarket halo strap, the Pro is a device filled with tradeoffs and oddities even on aspects that you’d think are obvious upgrades. Eg: the screen is remarkably clear in the periphery - but in dark environments it exhibits a very obvious yellow light bleed reminiscent of IPS glow. Supposedly this is an artifact of local dimming not yet being enabled - but it remains unknown as to whether Meta will be able to fix this universally since it’s apparently computationally expensive and the XR2 SoC is very obviously struggling. Like the reviewer, I’m most impressed by the Touch Pro controllers. The Quest 2 is getting a firmware update this month that adds support for the Touch Pro so I may actually end up going back to the older headset and picking up a pair of the new controllers.
Meta Quest 2: NeutralMeta Quest Pro: Recommends it
> You're pretty much describing the Quest Pro. Speaking as a user of a heavily comfort-modded Quest 2 and recent Pro owner: the Pro is surprisingly comfortable (especially with the below lifehack) and mostly on par with a Quest 2 with a modded Bobo halo strap. Craziest thing about the Quest Pro is that you can (carefully) pop off the back cushion and flip it. I highly recommend anyone with a Pro try it out since it’s significantly more comfortable and brings a very noticeable increase in FoV. There’s a thread about this on one of the Quest subreddits - and there’s not a single comment from anyone who prefers the stock placement. It does make aligning the charging dock a bit finicky but otherwise it’s kind of strange that Meta chose the other cushion direction as the default.
Meta Quest 2: Doesn’t like itMeta Quest Pro: Likes it
> A better head strap, ideally one with an adjustment knob at the back to easily loosen and tighten the headset. Also one with an extra battery that both gives you longer unplugged time but more importantly balances the headset front to back. You're pretty much describing the Quest Pro. This part also matches the Quest 2 with Elite Battery Strap for what it's worth, but the Quest Pro also matches your next criteria, whereas the Quest 2 didn't. > And a better headset/face interface. You can get one that is much softer and thicker, which puts less pressure on the face and moves the screens a few extra mm away. They also have vented interfaces, which help cut down on the problem of getting hot face. The Quest Pro only attaches at the top on the forehead, is open air by default and further away from the face, and for example I can comfortably fit it over my glasses, which I couldn't do on the Quest 2. It's a huge step up in comfort for long sessions, although you'd still want to attach a USB-C power cable for anything beyond a couple of hours. Disclaimer: I work at Meta but not on anything VR related, this is based on my own experience as a personal user of VR headsets.
Meta Quest 2: Doesn’t like itMeta Quest Pro: Likes it
The Quest Pro has a better design than the Quest 2 (as well as many other benefits), but in terms of pixel density it only offers 10% higher PPD than the Quest 2 (which was already pretty low).[1] (Disclaimer: I'm affiliated with Simula). [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28691358
Meta Quest 2: Doesn’t like itMeta Quest Pro: Likes it
> it only offers 10% higher PPD than the Quest 2 My understanding is that the optics are what destroys readability on the Quest 2, and in that regard the Quest Pro is in a completely different league with the pancake lenses.
Meta Quest 2: Doesn’t like itMeta Quest Pro: Likes it
The Quest Pro is a great headset in many ways, but it only offers 10% higher pixel density than the Quest 2 (which was already pretty low). For comparison: it offers 22.69 PPD. The human eye can distinguish up to 60 PPD.
Meta Quest 2: Doesn’t like itMeta Quest Pro: Likes it
Depends on the headset or glasses. Quest Pro designed for glasses. Quest 2 can work but you need spacers if you use it a lot otherwise they get scratched. Anyway I would consider Quest Pro or Pico 4 or something new rather than Quest 2.
Meta Quest 2: NeutralMeta Quest Pro: Doesn’t like it
That sounds more like issues with IPD adjustment rather than resolution issues. I feel that resolution is already good enough for gaming especially if you pair the Quest 2 with a VR ready PC. The resolution only isn't good enough for work. Reading a lot of text on a Quest 2 is nausea inducing. Since the Quest Pro's resolution isn't much better than Quest 2, I don't have high hopes for it when work involves a lot of reading and writing, but Quest 2 is already great for design collaboration.
Meta Quest 2: NeutralMeta Quest Pro: Doesn’t like it
Yeah I definitely do not want a VR winter. Meta uncoupling Facebook from the VR devices was a good move. IMO Oculus should have stayed Oculus under Meta's umbrella and have done its thing. When it went blatantly under Meta and proudly displayed its branding, it pushed VR / AR skeptics further away. Oculus had a fantastic origin story / brand and they stupidly killed it just like that. With the tech's current iteration though, it is not there for social / business. They are far too uncomfortable for such use. Make it almost as inconvenient as my glasses and people won't be able to live without it, a transformation just like smartphones did in our lives. I need to be able to comfortably put it on and get going. People will be using AR everyday through always on spectacles one day. VR for gaming and experiences is AMAZING. But very expensive. When I went from standalone Quest 2 experiences to PCVR experiences, the gap was HUGE. I can't go back to mobile graphics / experiences. Anyways, I doubt people putting on bulky VR glasses (even the new Quest Pro is way too bulky and uncomfortable, not even close) to work / be social will not be a reality anytime soon. VR gaming is still kind of niche and is not a big enough market to justify that amount of R&D costs. So something has to give. Would be very bummed about a VR winter.
Meta Quest 2: Likes itMeta Quest Pro: Doesn’t like it
I was extremely bullish on Meta’s VR effort. The Quest 2 is extremely impressive and you really feel like peering into the future of computing. I’m starting to realize that it may be the far future. The $1500 Quest Pro was just released to scathing reviews. The AR color passthrough feature sounds like a low quality joke. The headset is heavier and the battery lasts a hour or 2. The screen fidelity is still too low for productivity computing. The eye and face tracking result in extremely underwhelming animation that I can’t imagine adds any value to the social proposition. The primary Meta dream of all your social interactions in VR with friends, family and coworkers around the world is starting to seem more than a decade away. And on top of all that, Apple looks like it may have a serious entrant into this market and might easily beat Meta to the finish line to the next computing platform.
Meta Quest 2: Doesn’t like itMeta Quest Pro: Likes it
Quest Pro actually addresses those concerns. The head mount style is miles easier than the Quest 2 strap; it looks much more like PSVR if you've tried that. Putting on PSVR feels more like putting on a hat. It rests more on top of your head and doesn't smash your face. In fact, unlike other VR headsets it looks like Quest Pro doesn't contact your face at all, and leaves plenty of room for glasses. There's no charging cable to plug/unplug, no external tracker, and you don't need the controllers for meetings, so the headset is entirely self-contained. It could literally be as simple as five seconds to pick the headset up off your desk and put it on like a hat and it turns on automatically and you're in. Of course the ultimate idea is you'll be doing your regular work on virtual screens in VR, so you won't even need to don/doff the headset. But I think comfort and battery life and screen resolution will need to improve further for that to be realistic for most people. As for flexibility, Workrooms supports standard video calling just fine. You can join from your laptop or phone and still participate. To the VR participants you appear on a large projection screen, and you see the VR participants using a virtual meeting room camera. So you lose nothing in terms of flexibility.
Meta Quest 2: Likes itMeta Quest Pro: Doesn’t like it
I don’t really know if the specs are good for bang for your buck. All I know is that the Quest 2 specs run the existing library pretty well. Paying 5x the price, I would expect a jump from WiiU to PS5, but is there any software that comes close? The 4x resolution sounds great, but the Quest 2 resolution was already pretty solid. It’s still a great movie watching experience. I’m sure it’s even better with the Pro, but not $1500-for-a-niche-device better