The stuff Hacker News actually recommends.

VR and AR headsets

Meta Quest 1 vs Meta Quest 2

Hacker News owners lean toward the Meta Quest 1.

Meta Quest 1Meta Quest 2
Owners with an opinion27443
Positive verdicts84% of 2550% of 351
Positive/negative since 20248/338/54
Happy after 3+ years11
Longest happy owner5 yrs5 yrs
Praised fordisplay and valueperformance and ease of use
Criticized forcomfort and ease of usecomfort and display
Newest comment

Updated

What owners wrote about both

Meta Quest 1: Doesn’t like itMeta Quest 2: Likes it
I’m on my third quest unit (my quest 1 died during the pandemic and I had to buy a new 1, and then the 2 came out). I still use it for around 3-4 hours a week and I’m thinking about upgrading to the quest 3. Just use one or two apps though (beat saber and fitxr), I never really got into actual gaming or social stuff on it. I wish a company would come around and seethe potential for fitness tech with VR, they could come up with better optimized solutions for it (and I don’t really count the mirror or stationary bike stuff). Fitness really fees like the killer app.
Meta Quest 1: Likes itMeta Quest 2: Doesn’t like it
> …I guess I’ve been an enthusiast since the Rift Kickstarter? The rift CV1 was really comfortable because there wasn't a whole lot in it. No processing, no battery, no cameras. It was pretty light. And the strap was not built down to a price and skimped on to upsell the elite straps. Even the much heavier quest 1 was way more comfortable than the quest 2 and 3. Way better standard strap. So good an elite one wasn't even needed.
Meta Quest 1: Likes itMeta Quest 2: Doesn’t like it
The Quest 2 uses speakers inside the strap mounting arm. They don't touch your ears at all (in fact this makes for not such amazing audio but anyway...). Though the Quest 1 did things in the same way and had much better audio. The Quest 2 was just really made down to a price point. Too much so. The Quest 1 was much better in terms of value for money - despite being 100$ more it fixed all the shortcomings of the Quest 2 (except the obvious improvements there like screen resolution and CPU).
Meta Quest 1: Likes itMeta Quest 2: Doesn’t like it
I don't know about your friends, but playing Alyx opened my eyes to the level of immersion VR can achieve. It's a kind of gameplay that can't be repeated with 2d screens. I really do think it could be revolutionary, based on playing that game alone. If you can get ahold of a headset and a powerful gaming PC - I recommend giving it a try. The problems right now are very fundamental. The quest 2 out of the box is supremely uncomfortable. Casual users will put it on and not want to use it due to VR nausea and the discomfort of the headset after wearing it for 20 minutes. The hardware is not powerful enough to create an experience like Alyx - all the headset games just have basic polygons and colors. Resolution is still poor, FOV is poor. We're still in the infancy of immersion/comfort/usability. I played Alyx on the Quest 1 which I actually think had better immersion due to the OLED screens. IMO the trick is going to be whether Meta can pull off a usable, immersive device in the next 5 years without their revenues completely tanking. The problems to overcome are really hard and still at "basic research" level which takes years to develop. The other issue is the killer game or app that gets people into VR en-masse. I guess my point is I think writing VR off completely is a mistake - like someone saying what is the point of a cell phone in the 1980s when they were giant bricks and cost a fortune. VR will get good enough at some point that it's like putting on a pair of glasses and…
Meta Quest 1: NeutralMeta Quest 2: Likes it
I have used a Rift CV1, a Quest 1 and now a Quest 2. What I like about the Q2 is that it's cheap and offers wifi capability so I can sit on the couch far from the PC. More relaxing that way. Sometimes I use real controllers and I got a USB extender cable for that.
Meta Quest 1: Likes itMeta Quest 2: Neutral
The Quest is a really curious piece of technology. I wouldn't recommend buying one, but see if you can find the opportunity to try one; the VR experience for $300-400 is pretty damn impressive. The differences between the first and second revisions are also quite interesting, especially since the Quest 2 was designed to sell at a lower price point, before inflation drove the price back up. Furthermore, the lens on the Quest 1 is a blisteringly bright 90hz OLED display, whereas the Quest uses a 120hz LCD panel. A really curious side-grade that still has people arguing over which version is better. The software experience is middling (pretty bad if you use any online services whatsoever), but the quality of the hardware for the price is nearly impeccable. Having tried both models, I think I still prefer the muted footprint of the Quest 1, and I'm holding out for a nice replacement OS someday so I can use it as a purely tethered headset.
Meta Quest 1: Likes itMeta Quest 2: Doesn’t like it
In my experience the Quest 2 was unusable out of the box due to not having enough space inside for glasses. It caused quite a bit of pain making it only possible to have it on for a few minutes at a time - this is different to the Quest 1 where my entire family (all of whom wear glasses) tried and enjoyed the headset. I bought prescription inserts for the Quest 2, and they work fabulously. But even though I love VR I would never, ever visit a VR arena that used Quest 2's as their main headset for this reason.
Meta Quest 1: Likes itMeta Quest 2: Doesn’t like it
I have the Quest I and Quest II. Thrill of the Fight is my main "workout" game, so now I use the Quest I exclusively for that (works just as well), because I do worry about the amount of sweat I get on it. I use the Quest II for the less physically punishing apps to maintain its longevity. The Quest II actually feels a little more uncomfortable to be for exercise anyway. It seems like the lenses are closer to the face and the unit gets a little warmer. So to you question, yes the face gasket and head strap can get quite sweaty, but not so much "inside" the device far as I can tell. To the last point, I've punched the headset with the controllers a few times (usually going for a short inside uppercut), but they seem pretty sturdy. (Or maybe my punches just have no power :-)
Meta Quest 1: Likes itMeta Quest 2: Likes it
Weird. Maybe I've always been given a Quest that was already setup or rooted. I've never bought one myself. I only ran into this issue recently with a Quest 3. Every Quest 1 and 2 I've used I could enable developer mode and do what I wanted. adb just worked after enabling developer mode.
Meta Quest 1: Doesn’t like itMeta Quest 2: Doesn’t like it
I had Rift, Quest 1, and Quest 2. The problem with these is 1. They’re really high friction to turn on so I don’t usually bother 2. The displays are too low rez so I don’t want to read text/do work or watch non-3D movies in them (though 3D ones are spectacular, but too hard to set up and no streaming service support means even more friction “acquiring” them), and 3. There aren’t enough AAA blockbuster narrative games (Half Life Alyx made my entire Rift purchase worth it, but nothing single handedly justified the Quest 2). The UI is also really annoying to navigate without controllers. Idk why they didn’t instantly adopt the Apple look-and-pinch model (even without eye tracking a crosshair with snapping would probably be fine).
Meta Quest 1: Likes itMeta Quest 2: Likes it
I agree with your SoC assessment, and while I love my Apple gear, I am skeptical of Apple's VR/AR success for the consumer market. For the Pro market? I don't know. I think of my Oculus (I have versions 1 and 2) as the 'perfect toy.' Both versions were cheap, and I have spent about $100 on a few programs, and it is something that I play with for about 10 minutes almost every day. So very much worth the money.
Meta Quest 1: NeutralMeta Quest 2: Neutral
>I'm curious how you concluded this? In my experience it's unfortunately all too common for people to try low end products like Google Cardboard and write off spatial mediums like AR/VR altogether Let's set aside AR because I do think there is potential there, and I never had any issues with AR. Granted, I also haven't experience an actually good AR app. For VR, I've tried a bunch headsets, from the original Oculus, to the crappy Google Cardboard, to the Meta Quest 1/2 headsets, to the PS VR2, and some newish versions of VIVE. To be fair, none of them extensively, but here's what I found: - if the VR app has you merely looking around, while standing still or allows 'natural' motion (where I physically walk around a space), after about an hour, I'll get a low-level nausea that will make me feel like crap for the next few hours. It's manageable to use VR every once in a while in this way, but I would never use it day-in/day-out because of the after-effects. - if the VR app requires motion via controller - forget it. I'm not even sure I could handle 10 minutes of that. Obviously, I haven't done an exhaustive study on headsets and VR apps, so maybe the new high-end headsets mitigate the nausea issues to the extent where it would not cause discomfort - but so far that hasn't been the case.
Meta Quest 1: Doesn’t like itMeta Quest 2: Doesn’t like it
The main problem with the Quest 1's (and Quest 2's) weight is that it's all in the front, making you feel top-heavy; you can actually make it feel "lighter" by adding weights to the back (commonly, external battery packs, but I literally strapped a ziplock bag of sand to the back and even that was an improvement) The Quest Pro is a major improvement in this regard; despite being heavier on paper, it feels much lighter because of the weight distribution. That said, I wouldn't be surprised if the waist-mounted battery pack is purely for auxiliary power for extended use, which makes sense.
Meta Quest 1: Likes itMeta Quest 2: Likes it
> All that being said, I desperately want one of these to try out as essentially a 'replacement' for my monitor at home. I’m very much in the same situation. I have a Quest 1 and 2. And they were great during lock down to have something for my kids to do to be active indoors. I had a few meetings that way too and liked Immersed the few times I used it. But, this has me excited. (But not for meetings) I’m very interested to see how this new headset will work as a monitor replacement. Especially if I can take my “work” environment home with me, or when I’m working in the car while waiting for my kid’s $SPORT practice.
Meta Quest 1: Likes itMeta Quest 2: Likes it
I bought the Quest 1 for $500, and I thought it was a good buy even then. $400 for the Quest 2 is still a steal, honestly. And I have a PC that can handle VR games (and you can use the Quest 1 or 2 as basically a PC VR headset if you want). But it’s just so much less hassle to use the native Quest. The main use of the Quest is still to play beatsaber tho LOL.
Meta Quest 1: Likes itMeta Quest 2: Likes it
I used my Quest 1 a lot, and had to buy another one when it stopped working (during COVID, sigh) because it was so much a part of my daily lifestyle. The Quest 2 is even better, and I got custom prescription lenses just for my VR system that solves the problem of comfort with glasses. But I only use my VR system for fitness, and only a few fitness oriented or active apps. It is the killer but only VR app for me. I don't think the Go was a very good product. Facebook was right to double/triple down on the Quest, but that does leave early adopters a bit in a mess with outdated hardware (although I'm on my third quest system already).
Meta Quest 1: Likes itMeta Quest 2: Likes it
I have no problem using the desktop display mode on my Oculus Quest 1, it's sharp enough that I can comfortably browse the web or use other apps. It's not as clear as my main physical display so I don't use it exclusively. The displays on the Quest 2 are better and many people use Virtual Desktop with their Quest. I'm expecting Cambria to be yet another notch above that and if it's good enough and if they've really nailed the comfort and weight I'm going to ditch my monitor and switch over to Cambria + Airlink to my desktop. My point is, we're already there and companies like Meta are already targeting these devices as display killers and the next iteration of productivity platforms.