The stuff Hacker News actually recommends.

Phones

Google Nexus 4 vs Google Pixel

Hacker News owners slightly favor the Google Pixel.

Google Nexus 4Google Pixel
Owners with an opinion621968
Positive verdicts51% of 5356% of 1602
Positive/negative since 20243/10503/387
Happy after 3+ years054
Longest happy owner2 yrs10 yrs
Praised forreliability and designreliability and performance
Criticized forbattery and performancesoftware and battery
Newest comment

Updated

What owners wrote about both

Google Nexus 4: Likes itGoogle Pixel: Neutral
Too little, too late for me... I hate to be the guy having those "hot takes" or whatever, but hear me out for a sec: I didn't get a cell phone until 2013. (Yes I used land lines until then.) It was a Nexus 4 (still love the grippy sides and sleek glass back). Every 2-3 years I traded up, all the way until Pixel 6. Tomorrow my first iPhone will be delivered. Why? A lot of reasons, but some are: - I can't just plug my Google phone into an external display to mirror it. Uh, hello?? DisplayPort out is explicitly disabled in the source code with no reason given: https://twitter.com/MishaalRahman/status/1189998588023234560 -- yet this works great in other phones. - I can't access my text messages from my Android phone (without a separate app like SMS Backup & Restore) -- go ahead, try it. Yeah, do an adb backup. Maybe rooting your phone would give you access, but it's impossible otherwise AFAIK. And I think rooting your phone deletes everything in the process. Did you know you can just plug in an iPhone into Windows or Macs and dump a backup to your computers? It's all right there, text messages, system settings, contacts, photos, databases, EVERYTHING (except maybe hardware-protected keys). It's amazing. - I can't access my phone backup. It's ONLY stored on Google's servers. The only way to even get close is to restore it to a phone. This is a physical device I bought and literally am holding in my hand but can't access all the stuff on it! - Do I even need to mention all the Go…
Google Nexus 4: Doesn’t like itGoogle Pixel: Likes it
My own experience in the Android land, after making that jump from Nokia N900 to Nexus 4, is that you can get a new $CURRENT_GEN-1 (or -2) device for much much less while still having most of the performance/features . As such, I have never bought a then-current flagship. I have always kept my mobile plans (yes, multiple) separate from devices - I prefer the flexibility. With my story being: (N900 [USB port fell off!] ->) Nexus 4 [battery died] -> Nexus 5X [dropped it] -> Pixel [battery died on warranty, sent in] -> Pixel 2 [got as warranty replacement!] _and_ Pixel 3A [bought it]... I'm still very fine with the 3A thank you very much. In fact the only reasonable argument I've read for replacing a perfectly functional Android device is "when Google stops doing sec patches". Anyone here has any other good arguments for "replace before it's not functional"? (P.S. For "fun" I later replaced the battery and antenna in Nexus 4 - it still works today! And I keep Pixel 2 in the drawer as a hot backup. And yes, for both phones I do periodically turn them on, update and charge the battery.)
Google Nexus 4: Likes itGoogle Pixel: Doesn’t like it
Mine doesn't crash (anymore, it did when v12 came out), but my cell/data goes offline randomly and I get worse service than my peers in many places. It also overheats when exposed to almost any sunlight at all no matter the ambient temperature (it's overheated in my car with the ac on and no case) or when charging and doing a video call at the same time. My Nexus 4 and Note 5 were solid phones, but every android phone I've had after that has been awful in one way or another. The final straw for me has been android auto on this phone. Completely unusable and unsafe. So many crashes and lockups and touching any cable causes it to disconnect (but my wifes iphone doesn't do this so it's not just the cables). At this point I'm looking at an iPhone for my next phone. Something like android would be nice, but I also want a premium phone that works. My Note 5 is actually still going strong and is smooth and responsive (except for lack of updates). The battery hasn't swelled or anything.
Google Nexus 4: Doesn’t like itGoogle Pixel: Likes it
Like many others have said this is not true. I've had a nexus 4 (2012-2017) which I had to change due to battery starting to swell, also had a custom rom which might have helped. I upgraded to a Pixel2 in 2017 which I still have. I'm even considering replacing the battery instead of the whole phone since it's still doing just fine otherwise. I really don't need a better camera so why bother with a new phone that doesn't offer much more than what I already have. Both of those phone are/were caseless too, just be careful with your stuff and you'll do just fine for a couple of years. In my opinion people choose to change their phone more than they have to change their phone.
Google Nexus 4: Likes itGoogle Pixel: Doesn’t like it
The definition of flagship is specious at best. Recent Pixels have been coming out with budget mid-range processors and less technological prowess as compared to their brethren from Samsung etc, and the camera is at a standstill since the Pixel 2. On the other hand, devices like the Nexus 4 had a big emphasis on powerful CPU and midrange price. Safe to say that Google's strategy is fluid, to put it charitably.
Google Nexus 4: Likes itGoogle Pixel: Likes it
I think the Nexus 4 is still my favourite phone I've ever owned. Maybe it represents a period of techno-optimism I had, and how my relationship with phones have changed over the years. Now I despise my phone but am required to own it for my digital ID to pay taxes, receive work messages, etc. Sounds like I've been very lucky with my Pixel 4 and 7 that I haven't had any hardware issues while running GrapheneOS.
Google Nexus 4: Doesn’t like itGoogle Pixel: Doesn’t like it
I've owned several Nexus and Pixel phones and they universally sucked. Nexus S, Galaxy Nexus, Nexus 4, Pixel 2. I think that's all of them. I sent the last one to be fixed under warranty and they basically ignored me for six months (which I spent with no phone) until I threatened to get consumer protection from my country involved. Yeah yeah, why did I keep buying them? I have no idea. I guess I assumed the rest of Android phones sucked more.
Google Nexus 4: Doesn’t like itGoogle Pixel: Doesn’t like it
Watch a jogger jogging, and try to take a photo each time their foot hits the ground (so about 1.5 Hz). Within 10 seconds you'll find the camera crashes and/or starts throwing away photos you already took. Try it on battery saver mode or while playing music for even more bugginess. Tested this on: Nexus 4, Nexus 5, Nexus 6P, Pixel 1, Pixel 5, Pixel 7.
Google Nexus 4: Likes itGoogle Pixel: Likes it
Another anecdotal example here: Nexus 4, Pixel 2 XL, Pixel 4 XL, Pixel 6 Pro – never had any issues whatsoever, all phones still alive and kicking at my grandparents' places. Yes, most of them tied to the wall now... but hey, they're fine for showing some photos and displaying current time or setting alarms. Interestingly, I also used Samsung's Note 9 and 10+, iPhone 12, iPhone 14 Pro Max – daily, also with no issues... other than disliking Samsung's software. (I was/am doing a lot of mobile work so I test a lot of phones) After years of doing this kind of testing, it's hard for me to believe that the entire batches of phones are so fundamentally broken... I'd rather bet on software issues, but who knows.
Google Nexus 4: Doesn’t like itGoogle Pixel: Doesn’t like it
My thought when I read it as well. I've owned Nexus 4, 5, 6, Pixel 1, 2, 3, 4 and finally gave up. Half of these phones were purchased because the previous model crapped out. I am not a heavy phone user either. I think I stuck with them because there was always some integration with Google and iPhone that didn't make me happy, but whatever it is must have been solved by the time I got an iPhone because I'm on three years with mine. Probably won't replace it for another three years.
Google Nexus 4: Likes itGoogle Pixel: Likes it
My Nexus 7 became unusable because of the storage issue. You must have a 2013. I did love it though. I got an iPad thinking I would chase that feeling but it’s too big and heavy. The display on the pixel 7 was just great at the time, the rubbery back was nice to play with while reading, it was light and fit in jeans pockets. I guess one could get a big phone and the size is almost there, but then you have to lug that around all day. I miss my nexus 7 + nexus 4 combo.
Google Nexus 4: Doesn’t like itGoogle Pixel: Doesn’t like it
I wouldn't be surprised if the people doing product reviews managed to not hit this scenario often enough for it to show up in a review. The average reviewer may not be running special software to figure out what their signal level and mode are when outdoors. Could also be specific to the type of modem being used or specific frequency band for the article author (who is in France, I think?) vs reviewers who might be in the US or UK or etc. Personally I've had very bad experiences with quality control on Google phone handsets. Every single one I've owned had various problems that wouldn't make it past QC at other manufacturers - like a broken proximity sensor on the Pixel 4 I got for work, improper cooling on the nexus 5X I bought while working at google (constantly thermal throttled), and a nexus 4 I bought that had a bad internal flash drive that failed a week after I set it up (RIP my 2fa codes).
Google Nexus 4: Likes itGoogle Pixel: Likes it
They just are too expensive, Apple has the premium segment locked down and I don’t really understand why folks pay that much for android phones. A lot of this has to do with Google abandoning its product half way though. All the good google products are now over a decade old When I was poorer I Used android because the nexus 4 was really great price to product ratio. Same with the pixel 3a but the premium android phones don’t offer enough value or ecosystem lock-in to consider.
Google Nexus 4: Doesn’t like itGoogle Pixel: Doesn’t like it
Google mobile hardware has a long history of shoddiness. It absolutely shines in the components useful to marketing and completely falls down in the ones which aren't. The Nexus 4 had screen tint issues and a defective speaker that emitted a high pitched buzzing noise. The Nexus 5 overheated often and sometimes the camera just stopped connecting. The Nexus 5X had boot loop issues so bad there was a class action lawsuit. The Nexus 6P had the same boot loop issues as well as faulty battery sensors and poorly-designed frame that bent and snapped in the middle. Pixel 1 had faulty microphones that Google knew about and still sold, resulting in another class action lawsuit. The Pixel 2 emitted weird clicking and scratching noises from its speaker at all times. The Pixel 2 XL had a godawful POLED display with colors so uneven it looked like someone stomped on the panels before installing them. Oh and both their USB-C ports would spontaneously break and prevent charging the phone. Pixel 3XL included two wildly disparate speakers with no way to balance them, so the audio always feels like it's coming from one side. Trust me, some wild-ass Pixel 6 hardware fault will emerge in the next twelve months.
Google Nexus 4: Likes itGoogle Pixel: Likes it
So far my smartphone history has been: HTC Desire (approx. Nexus1) -> Galaxy Nexus -> Nexus 4 -> Nexus 5 -> Nexus 5X -> Pixel 1 -> Pixel 2 -> Pixel 3 -> ? My favourites where the N4 and P2. The P2 fixed the shitty cameras, and now it looks like finally the P5 will fix the shitty battery life. Can anyone with a P5 comment on how it compares. I'm glad they finally realized the 4 was a mistake. And from the reviews/specs/features the 5 seems perfect - but I'm worried I'm missing something. I don't want to keep changing phones, it just happens because there is always one deal breaker built in.