The stuff Hacker News actually recommends.

Phones · Google Nexus

Google Nexus 4

32owners with an opinion
52%of verdicts positive
3/10positive/negative since 2024
2 yrslongest happy owner
0happy after 3+ years

Praised for design and display; criticized for performance and reliability.

What owners wrote

Likes itOwned 2 years
You get a similar experience with the Nexus devices... I'm currently using a OnePlus One, which hasn't been bad, but considering switching to a Nexus 5X mainly so I can switch carriers to Verizon. I used my Nexus 4 for over 2 years and it received regular updates (5.x lagged a little though). Also, the Nexus devices are pretty well supported via CyanogenMod. Beyond that, the Motorola phones since Google bought and sold off mobility have been well received as well, the Pure line should see updates for at least 2 years. If you stay away from Samsung, LG, and other vendors trying to get you to upgrade every year and favor those not tethering to a specific carrier's upgrade model, you'll have better luck.
Likes itOwned 2 years
I agree, and that could be dangerous for Apple in the long run. But they still seem to be ahead, especially when it comes to laptops. I've used a Nexus 4 with great pleasure for about two years, and being back on an iPhone 5S, while slightly better (in my opinion), is only barely worth the higher cost. I hope that happens to laptops too, because I'd love to have alternatives and some more competition.
Doesn’t like itOwned 1 year
My Nexus 4's speaker failed just after a year. I replaced it with a Nexus 5, whose speaker and microphone failed after 7 months. I did a warranty exchange and the refurbished Nexus 5 now in my pocket's speaker and microphone just went out about a week ago. They share a flex cable that runs under the battery and seems to go bad somehow. I messed with the connection but it didn't fix it. I've preordered the 5x, but this time with the 2-year warranty.
Likes it
I think the Nexus 4 is still my favourite phone I've ever owned. Maybe it represents a period of techno-optimism I had, and how my relationship with phones have changed over the years. Now I despise my phone but am required to own it for my digital ID to pay taxes, receive work messages, etc. Sounds like I've been very lucky with my Pixel 4 and 7 that I haven't had any hardware issues while running GrapheneOS.
Likes it
> I continue to be surprised that so many developers and other tech nerds - the type who post on HN - chose and continue to choose the iPhone over Android when Apple dictates what apps they can install and locks third-party accessories out of certain features. I bought a Nexus One the day it became available, installed endless third party ROMs on it, tweaked it to my heart's desire. Got a Nexus 4, then 5. Today I have an iPhone. I just need something that works, just because I can tweak endlessly doesn't mean it's a good use of my time. Honestly one of the original biggest motivators was iMessage. A rock solid messaging system ought to be table stakes for a mobile OS but Google has reinvented the wheel so many times I've lost track. Also FaceTime for calling distant relatives. Sad to say, I don't find myself missing the relative openness of Android at all.
Doesn’t like it
They're both emphatically not fine from any erudite informed perspective of what has been better in the past. I've used small-form factor DOS luggable-bricks, miniature Windows7 7" diagonal laptops (Fuji B112, B2131) obsessively since the epoch, also exotics like Fakespace NDOF dataGloves, yada~ and my usual combination of trackball magicMouse and 3D connextion SpaceNavigator on my desktops. Now I've got an Android tablet and an iPhone which are decidedly not 50 years better. Neglecting the exotics, UX experience in DOS sometimes was better than, e.g. explicitly touching (yes DOS could do that) somewhere in the middle of a paragraph only to have the cursor leap to the beginning, end, select the entire paragraph (iOS18 or so..) or invoke some unintended 'gesture', and then require twenty more touches of adjustments to getthe selection right. Using external near-fullsize BT keyboards which actually make typing tolerable on my iPh and DroidTab, I'm constantly taken 'aback' (to memories of the past) by having to remove a finger from the keyboard to the screen to accomplish some cursor positioning that might just as well be done with less trouble with a keyboard touchpad or mouse. I do use a tiny tactile feedback BT keyboard with it's own tiny thumb-trackPad which works nominally better than on-screen keybooards when I'm crunched for space and can't use near fullsize kbs. Oh.. there's speech-to-text these days. Something about my present set of afflictions is holding me back…
Doesn’t like it
The Nexus 4 camera was rubbish and the GPS was rubbish. It could barely ever get a decent lock meaning navigating with it was a awful. I was so glad to replace that phone.
Doesn’t like it
The Nexus 4 was a nice phone but I thought the battery life was bad and it also ran hot. My Moto-X was truly next level. It was oled and could do always on display that didn't need to power the blacks pixels on the screen. It was the first phone to do this. It has voice recognition for unlocking (getting info that you couldn't when the phone was locked). First to do this too since I believe it uses dedicated hardware at the time. It also knew when I was driving to unlock the phone for voice commands also. It was small.
Neutral
Up until 2011 I was still using one of those Samsung phones with the slide out keyboard, maybe an Intensity II or something. My first smartphone was a Windows phone, an HTC Titan. I really liked the phone and the OS - I thought it was very well done. The only problem: the app store was complete shit. There were barely any apps and the ones that were there were trash barely discernible from malware. After about a year I bought a Nexus 4 instead.
Doesn’t like it
I have some seriously bad luck with spicy pillows. I had a nexus 4 and 5 that had their battery swollen. Also an iPhone 6 and a Poco X3 pro. Also, a ZTE z959 and moto E4. I don't want a spicy pillow. I'd rather the phone turn itself off before the battery swells up but ideally it should automatically disconnect the battery and keep running off of the wall unless it is too hot, in which case, it should shut itself off.
Doesn’t like it
Back in the day when cameras still took better photos than phones, I've always wanted to backup vacation photos without bringing a computer. I still remember getting so close with the Google Nexus 4 to being able to connect an SD card reader. It supported OTG, but did not have the required charge pump to supply 5V of VBUS. (Supposedly you could hack together something using a 9V battery, some resistors, and a kernel patch, but that was a bit more than I was willing to risk for the convenience.) Finally, the Nexus 7 and Nexus 5 supported it out of the box, and while Android didn't offer a FAT32 implementation back then, there was (is?) a USB host API which let apps supply that instead, and I think somebody actually ended up implementing FAT32 in userspace to make it all work!
Likes it
When I first had got my nexus 4, my first upgrade over another Android phone that I can't remember, I was astonished by the improved fidelity of the pictures. Then after I got my next phone I looked back and saw that the pictures had terrible artifacts that weren't hard to find. Now I'm on a Pixel N after having a handful of earlier Pixels and I can see the shortcomings of the photos it takes (and all its predecessors have taken) without much difficulty. Just zoom into the picture a little. There's something to be said for analog.
Doesn’t like it
I've owned several Nexus and Pixel phones and they universally sucked. Nexus S, Galaxy Nexus, Nexus 4, Pixel 2. I think that's all of them. I sent the last one to be fixed under warranty and they basically ignored me for six months (which I spent with no phone) until I threatened to get consumer protection from my country involved. Yeah yeah, why did I keep buying them? I have no idea. I guess I assumed the rest of Android phones sucked more.
Likes it
So far my smartphone history has been: HTC Desire (approx. Nexus1) -> Galaxy Nexus -> Nexus 4 -> Nexus 5 -> Nexus 5X -> Pixel 1 -> Pixel 2 -> Pixel 3 -> ? My favourites where the N4 and P2. The P2 fixed the shitty cameras, and now it looks like finally the P5 will fix the shitty battery life. Can anyone with a P5 comment on how it compares. I'm glad they finally realized the 4 was a mistake. And from the reviews/specs/features the 5 seems perfect - but I'm worried I'm missing something. I don't want to keep changing phones, it just happens because there is always one deal breaker built in.
Likes it
> The point stands. People who have a choice (have enough money) choose iPhone rather than allow crapware. Not all people, I could easily afford an iPhone yet I stick with my Nexus 4 (which is currently Android 5.1.1 and noticeably quicker than 4 was on the same phone), it does everything I want from a smartphone and was a third the price of the equivalent iPhone at the time.
Neutral
I'm of a similar mind, but everyone is different. Personally, I do see the extra value in the $430 difference, so I bought an iPhone. I won't get into it here, but it's worth it to me. However, I also own a Nexus 4 as a backup, and it has come in handy. My wife broke her iPhone and I gave her mine and switched to the Nexus 4 until I could get a replacement iPhone. Same thing when my old Windows Phone stopped working before I got my first iPhone, I moved to the Nexus until I could get a new phone. It's great that for $200 you can get a phone that is nice with few compromises and not really be bummed if it breaks. The camera was god-awful on the Nexus 4, but for $200 I didn't mind much.
Doesn’t like it
Your next sentence wasn't particularly useful, as there aren't any other choices. If I want what I consider a reasonably-sized phone (~4.2"), I have to settle for something with crap specs. I use a few apps that poorly implement the top-left button such that left-swiping doesn't do anything. Sigh. Yeah, just playing with mine, and noting how I readjust my grip to do various things. I just always feel like I'm about to drop my phone when I have to do that. And I just realized: I've never dropped and broken the screen on a phone until I got my Nexus 4 (which I've broken 3 times). My Nexus One and Nexus S lived happily break-free (well, ok, my S broke because someone [accidentally] violently elbowed it out of my hand, but that's hardly due to the size of the phone). We'll see if the market "fixes" this. I'm skeptical, as phones have been larger than my preference for at least 2 years now, and they're still growing.
Doesn’t like it
I used the wireless charging on my Nokia Lumia for two years, every night. Loved it. Problem is, it's dog slow compared to how fast my iPhone 5s charges. And when I tried to charge my Nexus 4 on the same charger as the Nokia (they use the same technology, why not?) it would go haywire and never actually charge. Apple may be behind their competitors in some way, but they have a way of not pushing out technology until they're sure it's going to work the way the mass market expects it to (which is how the general public lets them get away with calling everything "magic". To a non-technical audience, it might as well be). My Nokia is full of cool features that don't work. If the battery dies, it takes half an hour before you can turn the phone on again. My Nexus 4 has a big screen but the camera is shit and it can't hold a charge through the day. My iPhone doesn't have a single "wow" feature to me, but then again there are no features that make me think "this would be so cool if only it worked". The last non-iPhone I didn't truly hate was my Palm Pre+.
Likes it
Nexus 4 here. It's been an excellent phone, and I've really enjoyed Android. Only criticism would be the camera (mainly with regards to the shutter lag) and the battery-life (although this only gets me occasionally). I've been building up quite an app library on my iPad, so if there is a larger screen iPhone released (4.7" hopefully) - I'll be tempted to have a go with that
Likes it
>> "What would it take for this guy to actually admit that Apple no longer makes the best phones?" Personally I think they still make the best overall phone. There are better phones out there for certain people but the iPhone is the best all rounder. However: iPhones have been my only smartphones. Every time I tried an alternative I didn't like it. I recently got a Nexus 4 and was impressed but the iPhone 5 still beat it in a few key areas for me (camera, microphone - I use voice memos a lot -, and screen). A few days ago I upgraded to the iPhone 5S. I'm not impressed. Touch ID is nice but I could live with out it. Slow motion camera for me is a gimmick. Speed improvements aren't really noticeable. The only real innovation is the M7. Overall there was very little reason to upgrade. It certainly wasn't worth the cost. It got me thinking that next time round, if Apple continues at it's current pace, I'll probably be purchasing an Android device. As a full time iOS developer, a Mac user, and someone deeply ingrained in the Apple ecosystem that's a pretty big statement I think.
Likes it
1) Lag is mostly a thing of the past now, but depends a lot on the hardware. My Nexus 4 rarely lags, whereas my Nexus 7 (2012) lags all the time. Some poorly made apps can also cause lag (Facebook used to be pretty bad). 2) It works fine with Exchange, but is lacking in features. It has, however, received a major overhaul in KitKat, so perhaps it's better now (haven't tried it yet).
Doesn’t like it
I'm actually saddened by the fact that we consider 8 hours of battery life satisfactory, and 14 hours nothing short of astronomical . Anything less than a full day work for a mobile device should be unacceptable. Smartphones are particularly bad at it. If anyone remembers Palm devices, they could last for more than a week (!) on one charge. With my Nexus 4, even with light usage, I've come to a habit to plug it in whenever possible, it goes that fast. We all love feature-rich devices, but I think, currently, the promoted features and hardware are way ahead of the battery capabilities. And it's not OK.
Neutral
I just bought a Nexus 4 as my second smartphone (the first being a Palm Pre 2). Android is nice in the sense that it's more open and you (I assume, at least, having never owned an iPhone) have more choices to use open-source software. There are other bits and pieces that I also like, like the the modular nature of the software (you can use a different launcher, etc.). But I disagree with a lot of the pluses in this article. I find the back button eminently confusing. I can never reliably predict what will happen when I go back. Sometimes if I go back from within Firefox, it'll go to the last app I used and close Firefox. Other times it'll go to the last page, or to the home screen. Sometimes in my now-playing screen of PowerAmp back will go to the album list, other times to the home screen. I can never reliably predict where back will go. The UI theme is also shockingly utilitarian. I've got one of the nicest screens ever produced, 320 ppi, in my hand, and I'm using it to render a #000000 background, #ffffff text, and the occasional solid blue line? Really? Maybe I just don't like the whole "flat UI" paradigm that's becoming the new hotness. Things also get more difficult when you try to leave the Google ecosystem. There's no CalDAV or CardDAV sync built in (though it's available with flaky and inconsistent addons), and removing all of the Google branding (like the search box at top) doesn't seem to be possible. The Google apps, while functional for the most