The stuff Hacker News actually recommends.

VR and AR headsets

Apple Vision Pro vs Meta Quest 2

Hacker News owners slightly favor the Apple Vision Pro.

Apple Vision ProMeta Quest 2
Owners with an opinion346443
Positive verdicts62% of 30550% of 351
Positive/negative since 2024183/11438/54
Happy after 3+ years01
Longest happy owner2 yrs5 yrs
Praised fordisplay and performanceperformance and ease of use
Criticized forcomfort and valuecomfort and display
Newest comment

Updated

What owners wrote about both

Apple Vision Pro: Likes itMeta Quest 2: Recommends it
There are dozens of us! I clarified a bit in a longer post. I do actually like the Vision Pro... but even though I own one I barely use it. It's a good device but it's just too many hoops for what I do. I find a much affordable Quest, even older generations, with adb and a proper WebXR support (including with AR support, which Apple refuses to implement) fits better my need. I have 0 problem popping a Quest 2 in my backpack without even thinking about it, only protection being a literally piece of cardboard on the lenses. I can work with it anywhere and give demos to total stranger with no worries about them dropping it or heck even running away with it. FWIW I'm also not in the Apple ecosystem so all the wall garden hoops just tire me. I want the device I own to let me do my work. I find that, probably counter-intuitively, super high resolution and refresh rate matter... but only up to a point. As I mentioned in the longer post if you are "just" looking for a monitor with another form factor, sure, maybe it's OK-ish, but to me it's very uninteresting and not worth all the challenges, including social, of having an HMD strapped to your face. Only when it's properly immersive does it shine, and then resolution and refresh rate don't have to be that high to be usable.
Apple Vision Pro: Likes itMeta Quest 2: Neutral
This isn't true. It's more that the Vision Pro deliberately prioritized certain things that Meta or Vive or Valve or Sony have not: geometrically stable pass through, wide library of popular 3D movies via AppleTV and Disney+, high resolution immersive environments, seamless keyboard/mouse/trackpad migration between PC and native apps, strong iOS/iPadOS ecosystem integration, high fps / low latency wireless ultra-wide virtual displays for the Mac, etc. In some ways it focuses on what the Oculus Go was trying to do but was underpowered to really do it. It's meant to replace other iOS devices for general productivity and entertainment, and to complement a Mac. It's not focused on VR gaming though it can do that. I have a Oculus Rift dev kit, Ovulus Go, Quest , Quest 2, Valve Index, PSVR2. The AVP is much better of an experience on almost every level but three: too much motion blur when moving your head (this isn't bad when watching high fps video), lack of controller support, not so great hand tracking (which the Quest had to do well due to lack of eye tracking). The controller support should be fixed with the Sony PSVR2 partnership. Motion blur and hand tracking I suspect will be software fixed as they evolve to prioritize active fitness with the AVP.
Apple Vision Pro: Doesn’t like itMeta Quest 2: Likes it
It could have worked for a more physical experience, but the Vision Pro does less for me than even an Oculus Quest 2. No controllers, no haptics, I just get that it wasn't aimed at me but I'm scratching my head about what they were going for. Even Meta isn't to keen on the experiences I value in VR (basically fitness), and even though they support it, I get the feeling that they would much rather be doing social experiences...I hope someone enters the VR space in the fitness area with more enthusiasm.
Apple Vision Pro: Doesn’t like itMeta Quest 2: Neutral
> i've never had a VR/AR experience anywhere close What VR experiences have you had? I was not impressed at all. Have had a Rift since they launched. Rift-S, Quest 2, Quest 3, PSVR, PSVR2. Nothing about the Vision Pro did anything for me. The "try to hold your eyes still to point" is the worst possible UX interaction I've ever used. Super un-natural and un-intuitive. That's not how my eyes work. I knew that the first time I tried "stare to point" on PSVR2. It was awful there and it's awful on Vision Pro It also felt horrible. I'm not saying any of the other HMD are great but Vision Pro's weight was awful. It's either too tight to stay on or resting on my nose. Someday that will be fixed (glasses?) but in the context of shipping devices, the devices that put the weight on the forehead are way more comfortable. I think PSVR(1) was the first to do that. Rift-S copied. Quest is a step back unless you get a 3rd party accessory The "you get one screen from your mac" was also disappointing. I've had 6 screens in VR from my PC since Rift shipped. It's built into the Rift/Link OS. Yes, it's got issues but 1 screen is still a step back of many years, not forward.
Apple Vision Pro: Recommends itMeta Quest 2: Likes it
I'll be the outlier here: if the AVP were $1500, I'd buy it in a heartbeat and use it for most of the day at work. The "work on a big screen floating in front of you" experience is excellent, and I say that comparing it to working on a big screen in Quest 2, which I've done for hours at a time. In addition, media is super compelling in AVP. I'd watch movies in it, facetime with it, etc. etc. If the "cheaper model" is $1500 and all they lose is, say, the external screens, I'd grab it up.
Apple Vision Pro: Doesn’t like itMeta Quest 2: Likes it
We have a Quest 2 and it's decent enough. Games look good, things look "good enough" for the most part. I did an in-store demo of the Vision Pro the other day and things look great for the most part. It's impressive, and everything it does is really interesting. Two things stood out to me. First, it's HEAVY. The demo was 3 or 4 minutes long and I was already feeling it. Second, I have no idea why I'd want to use a real computer like this. It looks like they're trying to sell it as a real work computer and entertainment device. But to me at least, it looks like a less good laptop/desktop and way overkill to replace a phone. It would be interesting to try at home if it was more like $1000, but I saw no reason at all to consider it for purchase at the current price. I could see no problem it solved, or as a replacement for anything I already own. I'm not sure how that gets rescued by any changes other than making it cheap.
Apple Vision Pro: Likes itMeta Quest 2: Neutral
A conversation with my dad on this post (before he eventually convinced me to post my thoughts here) went a little like this: --- Here's my take on it. The Apple Vision Pro was built for being a computer that encompasses space. Not meant to be a “headset”, and not approaching the problem as a “headset”, but more-so an immersive head-mounted computer. So all the preconceptions people’ve had about “headset” in the past are kinda thrown out the window. Sure, the Quest 3 is similar in that it’s got a focus on AR instead of VR, but it’s still built for gaming first - we can see by the app library and what the Quest store pushes for its apps - it’s gaming. Similar story with other headsets - primary focus is gaming. Be it immersive experiences in gaming (KayakVR, etc.), competitive gaming (Breachers, Pavlov, etc.), or social (VRChat, Resonite, Rec Room, Bigscreen, etc.), it’s still gaming. The Apple Vision Pro is built on a completely different foundation and philosophy from other headsets. That’s why, and how, I use mine. Otherwise, it would just kinda be in the corner as a “really high resolution, really good eye and hand tracked, but otherwise very uncomfortable and heavy headset with too many compromises” sorta deal. My Quest 2 for example, I bought that simply to tear it apart and have fun with it. I did just that, and now it’s non-functional (I have to fix it up at some point). My Pico 4 Enterprise, I bought with the express intent of getting eye and face tracking working wit…
Apple Vision Pro: Likes itMeta Quest 2: Neutral
> Vision Pro is a meticulously over-engineered “devkit” that is far too heavy to have product-market fit but good enough to seed curiosity into the world That's exactly what I think. And that's exactly why I bought it. I have: * Oculus Rift 1 * HTC Vive * Quest 2 None of those made me want to write apps for them. They have nice games and I spent quality time with them, but just playing. I tried watching videos and it was ok, but it was still better to do that on my TV. I tried actually working with them, and the resolution was not enough. The Vision Pro? It's the opposite. Games, such as they are, are underwhelming. It doesn't even have many '3d' experiences, windows are mostly flat (for now). And guess what? It excel at all the tasks the others fail at, because it's an iPad with a different form factor. If you can work from an iPad, you can work from the Vision Pro. Even watching videos is a better experience due to the passthrough, as you can still interact with people around you(if you so choose) – you can passthrough with the Quest, but you have to choose between your content and the world. So now I'm spending my time learning how to work with it. It has incredible potential. It is not the mass market device yet, but the next one should be transformative.
Apple Vision Pro: Doesn’t like itMeta Quest 2: Likes it
OP here. I own a Quest 2 as well. It's a toy compared to the AVP, but it is more comfortable. I agree with your impression - these things will get addressed, but not within the return window, and a $5K gamble that it'll become useful is too rich for my taste.
Apple Vision Pro: Likes itMeta Quest 2: Doesn’t like it
Drank a can of beer while wearing AVP this past weekend. No issues whatsoever, the device profile isn’t obtrusive enough to interfere. I was struggling to do that with Meta Quest 2 before tho, as the shape of it on my face ends up hitting the top of the can sometimes, and it is just straight up not the best experience. For that case, yeah, a straw would help.
Apple Vision Pro: Doesn’t like itMeta Quest 2: Neutral
Ha, I was downvoted and told "why do we need controllers, the iphone and macbook dont come with controllers" yesterday when I said this is stupid without controllers. I have a vive, q2 and q3. Look at him trying to type on that keyboard. I have hand gestures on my q3. They're nice for a few certain things, but thankfully I can forget they exist for 99% of what I do, that isn't flinging windows/screens left and right and expanding them in front of me. Or turning wifi on and off, etc.. And.. you can't do multiple screens and it has less resolution than my real life monitor when connecting to a mbp.. hm. I thought that was a super cool feature when I thought you could just add monitors wherever. I hadn't even thought of it before they showed it in the demo.
Apple Vision Pro: Doesn’t like itMeta Quest 2: Likes it
A Meta Quest 2 is just as "general purpose" as Vision Pro. It's basically the Android equivalent to Apple's iOS based Vision Pro. Apple has a bigger problem with the fact that they don't have any sort of VR controllers similar to the Quest's or PSVR2.
Apple Vision Pro: Doesn’t like itMeta Quest 2: Likes it
> Meta, today, has roughly the right price and is working forward to the right device: Apple has started with the right device and will work back to the right price. I like this analysis, though I think it still misses some fundamentals. To me, if you go back to root cause analysis on "why has VR/AR not succeeded yet" you have to come to some basic conclusions: 1. The value proposition isn't there. It just isn't valuable enough to have a giant screen or bring a virtual object into your space that you will pay for it and wear a special device. Apple did not solve this. They presented the same things you can do for 10 years, claiming that better quality will make it worth it. But I call BS on that - quality on the Quest 2 is easily good enough that consumers would do it for the use cases Apple presented (photos, movies etc) if the value was there. 2. Form factor. People simply DO NOT LIKE having a giant thing on their face. Apple failed comprehensively at this. The Vision Pro is just as bulky as other headsets - eg: Quest Pro. They also HATE being attached or wired to things and Apple has put a giant wire coming out of your head. The fact that Apple hasn't addressed the fundamentals leads me to the conclusion this device will at best be a dev kit for whatever eventually makes it to mass market. Perhaps 2 years from now it will indeed be Apple with a glasses like form factor. I'm a strong believer in the future of this type of device but I really do think Apple has basically j…
Apple Vision Pro: Doesn’t like itMeta Quest 2: Doesn’t like it
Of course the AVP is much nicer than the Quest 2. For more than 10 times the price it had better be. It doesn't really describe the companies' different abilities but the design goals. The quest 2 was clearly 'make it as cheap as possible so lots of people can buy it' and the AVP's was 'make it as good as it can be, price is not a factor' Still though, both products eventually get stuck at the same point: a killer usecase. Neither has a compelling reason to actually want to put it on. There's very few things that are better in VR and the ones that are are really niche. I personally love VR gaming and stimulations. I love VR for it and I use it a ton. But those are pretty niche. But socialising in VR is not really a great user experience despite most of meta's focus going there. And Apple? They don't really have any usecase that shines. Maybe watching movies but even that works better on an actual TV as you can share the experience with others.
Apple Vision Pro: NeutralMeta Quest 2: Neutral
On the other hand, the weakness of the onboard compute significantly restricts the Quests’ potential, as does their inability to take a DisplayPort input from a PC (the tether can only serve crappy compressed video). I own a Quest 2 and AVP and while the Quest is alright for what it does and regularly gets used (for PC-tethered Beat Saber mainly), I’m on the lookout for a quality dedicated PCVR-oriented replacement that doesn’t break the bank. I don’t see myself buying another Quest in the future unless they add back DisplayPort input or the onboard compute both becomes more powerful and gains the capability to run Steam so I don’t have to buy games from Facebook to play untethered.
Apple Vision Pro: Doesn’t like itMeta Quest 2: Doesn’t like it
I was surprised Apple didn't have this. My Meta Quest 2 had a super crappy version I tried for all of 2 minutes. The AVP passthrough and rendering content behind your hand (cut out?) both leave some to be desired. The little indicator that floats over your keyboard is cool, touch bar coming back from the grave. But I felt like I couldn't dial in the environment past the point where I could still see my keyboard/hands because of the "keyboard disappearing" issue.
Apple Vision Pro: Doesn’t like itMeta Quest 2: Doesn’t like it
It's better than anything else I've tried by a long shot, which admittedly is only the Quest 2, but still not good enough to work in all day. It wasn't the weight/comfort for me, just it was too blurry. I fully expect to be using one eventually as an external monitor replacement but it's got a little ways to go. Probably needs another generation or 2 of screen/camera improvements. It's _good_ but not worth keeping unless you already use mostly iPad apps for work.