The stuff Hacker News actually recommends.

Laptops

Apple MacBook Pro Retina vs Lenovo ThinkPad

No clear winner: owners rate them about the same.

Apple MacBook Pro RetinaLenovo ThinkPad
Owners with an opinion1302732
Positive verdicts84% of 11175% of 2366
Positive/negative since 202411/2686/273
Happy after 3+ years22281
Longest happy owner10 yrs25 yrs
Praised forreliability and displayreliability and performance
Criticized forsoftware and performancebattery
Newest comment

Updated

What owners wrote about both

Apple MacBook Pro Retina: Likes itLenovo ThinkPad: Doesn’t like it
The 2012 "Retina" MacBook Pro design was great. The 2016 redesign stumbled with the terrible "butterfly" keyboard, the unpopular touchbar (which removed a physical esc key), etc., but it also had 4 thunderbolt ports and could drive an external 5K monitor (same panel as 27" "Retina" iMac), and it was significantly thinner than its successor design, the M1 MacBook Pro. Although the ARM models run very cool, the x86 models still had good thermals, better than ThinkPads I am familiar with.
Apple MacBook Pro Retina: Likes itLenovo ThinkPad: Neutral
Hmm. I'm not even sure anymore... - Main machine is a 2018 Mac Mini with an extravagant 64 GB of RAM. - Home server is an i7-4790K running Gentoo. This is for things like seeding Linux distros, serving media throughout the house, a secondary NAS (when I went with bigger drives in my other NAS the old disks went here), IRC client, MOO client, Wireguard... servery things. - NAS is an old Synology DS1515, not even plus. - Laptop is an M1 Macbook Air. - Raspberry Pi 3 is running PiHole. - A second or third generation i5 behind my desk running Windows 10 for when I need to do Windowsey things. - Thinkpad X200 Tablet for running older Windowsey things on period-accurate hardware. - Thinkpad T500 that I use for making ISOs from old backup CDs or generally any time accessing an optical disc is required. - 2012 Retina Macbook Pro that my nieces and nephews use when they come over. (Monterey works great!) - Asus Transformer Something Or Other sits on my desk running Creatures Docking Station in tablet mode. This is for decoration. I like to watch the Norns livin' like Norns while my mind wanders. And then of course the not-quite-computers-to-me things: - iPhone 13 Pro - Apple TV 4K - iPad Mini (whatever the last one is) - Apple Watch (im a sheep) - iPad Air 2 - iPad Air 1 (I use this as a cookbook in the kitchen. It's filthy.) - Kobo Libra H2O That's probably it! Nothing else springs to mind at least.
Apple MacBook Pro Retina: Doesn’t like itLenovo ThinkPad: Recommends it
You should definitely give it a try in a shop. My partner was for many years using MacBooks, but when he compared the new rMBP keyboard to the latest X1C, the difference is so clear for the ThinkPad that now we have again one Windows computer in the house. I think the modern ThinkPad keyboards are nice, but when I got myself the T25 I have to say it has the pinnacle of laptop keyboards. I really wish they'd release a laptop with the classic keyboard every couple of years; it'll be very hard for me to replace this. The feel of the keys is nice and soft, there's lots of key travel, it's very hard to write typos and the PgUp/PgDwn keys are in a perfect location.
Apple MacBook Pro Retina: Likes itLenovo ThinkPad: Recommends it
Depending on how far your budget will stretch, a refurbished ThinkPad from the last three or four years is an excellent option under $400. If you were after something a bit more powerful with some extra features, a 13" or 15" retina MacBook Pro from 2013-14 can be had for under $1000, I'm currently using a 2013 retina 15" with a 512GB SSD that I got for $1100. I got mine as a display unit from a major electronics retailer and then spent another $120 replacing the batteries through Apple.
Apple MacBook Pro Retina: NeutralLenovo ThinkPad: Likes it
* maxed out Thinkpad T460p, i7 with four cores, 32 GB RAM, 512 GB SSD, Ubuntu - its a Workstation at 14" and I use it for software engineering (JVM stuff, Node), but non-company stuff * 2016 MBP 15" Retina with i7, 16 GB RAM, 256 GB SSD for software engineering for the company I work for
Apple MacBook Pro Retina: Recommends itLenovo ThinkPad: Neutral
Life is too short not to buy a Mac. I have an rMBP 15" and its awesome. After years of using Macs, I got a ThinkPad T450s because of the keyboard. It's now sitting on a shelf while I set it up for my dad. It's okay . The screen is okay, pretty bad backlight bleed.[1] It's got a weird memory configuration--you can run dual channel only up to 8GB. The keyboard is fantastic, but the touchpad is awful. [2] Apple's touchpad is unmatched, and induces less cramping than the trackpoint. Windows is getting better. I think Windows 10 is pretty good. But its not better than OS X, and Visual Studio is the only Windows app I miss. Even Office 2016 is just as good on the Mac (unless you have particular Excel-related needs). Retina support is still far better in OS X, and its 2015 and a non-retina screen isn't acceptable any more. [1] I got the AUO screen, I hear the LG is better, but that's one thing you risk on the PC side--everyone has less tight sourcing tolerances than Apple. [2] The touchpad on my work-issued T430 is better. That's another fact of PC-life: Its pretty much a crapshot whether the next iteration of any given model will have major regressions in trackpad quality or battery life or screen quality. PC manufacturers just don't care--they'll source whatever part is cheapest.
Apple MacBook Pro Retina: Likes itLenovo ThinkPad: Doesn’t like it
Yes, I mostly run Win8.1 on a rMBP via bootcamp, and have no problems with it (took me a few hours to setup, you'll need a 16GB USB stick and a non-upgrade Windows 8 key to do it). The trackpad support is not as good as in OS X, but still infinitely better than any trackpad I've used on a pure Windows machine. It is definitely better than my previous Carbon X1. High res is beautiful (though there are many Windows options for that these days).
Apple MacBook Pro Retina: NeutralLenovo ThinkPad: Likes it
Retina MacBook Pro 15" 16GB/512GB SSD. Which I like mainly for the screen, use it at the simulated 1920x1200 res. It sucks that it can barely play flash or do other cpu intensive things without it getting fucking hot and loud. Its a shame because the GPU is pretty fast. Wish Apple could make a fucking decent thermal design. Thinkpad X220 16GB/256GB SSD, Win7 Pro. I love it for its small size, long battery life, and ruggedness. Although I should warn you the plastic doesn't get on well with mosquito repellant, I learned that in Costa Rica last year. Also the trackpoint, 3 mouse buttons, and keyboard. It actually has a bigger keyboard than the rMBP despite being classified as a 12" laptop. Oh and a 3-year warranty where a guy comes to your house to fix whatever is wrong that only cost $100 or so. The screen is painfully tiny at 1366x768 though. I guess I couldn't decide on one laptop, there are both good for different things. At home I sometimes plug into a 24" Dell 1920x1200 LCD and use a Kinesys Freestyle Pro keyboard and Logitech Anywhere MX mouse. That is nice for extended computer work. My phone is a HTC First. Yeah the Facebook phone. Its a reasonable size, looks nice, you can uninstall all the facebook junk, and the battery lasts me 3 days. And I only paid $170 for it because no one wants them. Oh and the GPS and 3G work unlike my previous Galaxy Nexus. Software-wise, I mainly use Debian under VMWare for work. And Firefox for browsing natively. The builtin sync feature i
Apple MacBook Pro Retina: Likes itLenovo ThinkPad: Likes it
I did that with my previous MBP (2015 15" retina). The lid cost a lot more but was quite easy to replace. Also I've replaced many many bits on thinkpads before for myself and other people.
Apple MacBook Pro Retina: Likes itLenovo ThinkPad: Likes it
If you want something that runs linux well (I currently have Cent OS running on mine, and it comes pre-loaded with Ubuntu), I'd say System 76 is a pretty good choice. Their 15.6" version is pretty beefy ($1400 base), but even their 14" model looks good right now ($800 base). The model I use is a few years old, and is holding up really well. They have native drivers for pretty much everything, even the hardware switches are supported through the BIOS if I remember correctly, so when I loaded up other distros, nothing was a problem. Windows pretty much runs on everything, but my work computer is a Lenovo/ThinkPad T540P. It's base is $800, but the version I'm running is optioned out to about $1500-1800 I think (Core i7 (4 core), 8GB RAM, 256GB SSD). Great computer, I've had about 14 vm's running in VirtualBox running on it at once before memory started becoming a problem (again, with the optioned out specs). (also, I run Windows 7 Enterprise on this, so may be YMMV with Windows 10). both of those are superb, though I guess neither really competes build-quality wise with my 15" Macbook Pro Retina. I end up using that for almost anything that I don't need the GNU C/C++ toolchain for, which ends up being most stuff anyway.
Apple MacBook Pro Retina: Likes itLenovo ThinkPad: Likes it
I gave up on new Thinkpads and went to a 13" Macbook Pro Retina. I had a hard requirement to go with something with a smallish form factor and 16GB of memory. I almost decided to go with a Thinkpad X230 - I have used a X200 running Xubuntu for almost 6 years happily. The X200 just started to fall apart and I was bumping up against the 4GB memory in it frequently enough in the last year to make a change. The X230 would have been way cheaper and supported the 16GB of memory I was after. But work was paying, I try to maximize laptop ROI by not upgrading every year, and the screen on the retina is quite lovely. The trackpad, not as much. I miss the thinkpad red nub. But, debian Jessie installed very easily and so far, I really like the experience. I'm using XMonad, with very little customization, and in general it seems to be a solid machine. Check back with me in four years. If I'm still using this machine, the switch will have been worth it. I'm quite sad about how Thinkpads seem to be transitioning from serious, hacker-friendly tools to somewhat generic consumer-grade gear.