The stuff Hacker News actually recommends.

Laptops

Apple MacBook Air vs Apple MacBook Pro Retina

No clear winner: owners rate them about the same.

Apple MacBook AirApple MacBook Pro Retina
Owners with an opinion1931130
Positive verdicts79% of 165384% of 111
Positive/negative since 2024657/19011/2
Happy after 3+ years15122
Longest happy owner14 yrs10 yrs
Praised forperformance and batteryreliability and display
Criticized forreliabilitysoftware and performance
Newest comment

Updated

What owners wrote about both

Apple MacBook Air: Recommends itApple MacBook Pro Retina: Neutral
I am currently using the MacBook Pro (Retina, 13-inch, Early 2015) with 16gb ram and a 250gb ssd. I have had to have the screen replaced for the lamination unsticking, and the fan replaced since it was starting to sound like a trash compactor. Apart from that these are decent laptops, I'd recommend the macbook air though which is what I had before, the screen is about the same for normal use (excluding photo editing) and it is much cheaper. Use either of these with a good 4kp60 monitor/mouse/kb and you're set. Get a desktop box with a couple 1080ti if you need to do number crunching and set it up in the corner..
Apple MacBook Air: Recommends itApple MacBook Pro Retina: Neutral
Probably the MacBook Air, and when you're at a desk, another monitor for it. I got the Macbook Pro Retina and I'm not sure if it was worth the extra dollars and the very small amount of extra weight. I think I would be fine with an Air. In fact, if I did it over, I'd get the Air and then spend a little bit more along with the difference in price to create a nicer desktop machine.
Apple MacBook Air: Likes itApple MacBook Pro Retina: Likes it
The keyboard and touchpad experience are nearly identical between the two... not nearly as good as old IBM Thinkpads used to be, but that's a trade with IMO the much better touchpad experience on Mac. That said, I just don't think I can keep buying Apple hardware, just not a fan of the company... I only begrudgingly use Android as there isn't a reasonable, more open option. I'll probably stick with my M1 air for personal use a couple more years then pass it on. My daughter is still using my now 13yo rMBP with 16gb/512gb. I wish the ram and storage upgrades on mac weren't so overpriced.
Apple MacBook Air: Likes itApple MacBook Pro Retina: Likes it
Now we're getting into a different topic. They were really well-rounded machines—I just upgraded to 14" from an M1 Air myself, and only for compile + transcode times—but I wouldn't rank them higher than most others I've had: - Core 2 Duo Pros proved to me you can have a laptop as your main computer for real dev + video work - First-gen Retina 15" saved me from daily tension headaches - Second-gen 12" MacBook, after only having a maxed out 15", changed the way I structure my days and where I consider going to work I briefly had a Touch Bar supplied by a job; initially it was cool, but after the first month my only use for it was volume and brightness. I thought I wouldn't like going back to function keys but when I got the M1 Air I realized I prefer them
Apple MacBook Air: NeutralApple MacBook Pro Retina: Neutral
~5 yr old MacBook Air at home (I bought it because at that time it was the cheapest lightweight laptop with a great battery life). MacBook Pro (Retina, 15-inch, Mid 2015) at work (I could have gotten any laptop and any OS and many people actually go for those but I just went ahead with the standard issue). I am fine with both and I was fine with my Dell Linux work laptop before this workplace and a Windows work desktop before that. For me there is no "one true" machine or gadget or as some people say it "X is the only real Y". What I do, Android development earlier - and now front-end development which I hate and that's why I will be leaving this workplace soon, any of these machines are good enough (well, to be honest my 5 year old Air is not so enough anymore). Another reason I don't do much professional hobbyist thing once I am out of my workplace (not proud of it as such but no regrets so far either) - I use the time after work to read fiction, play badminton, travel/trek, sketch, films etc. If I have to buy another laptop (which will be for personal use if at all) I would like something like LiteBook ( https://litebook.store ). 13-inchish, lightweight, good battery life - decent power (not really sure how LiteBook fares here) to browse, films, music and some development here and there. Or, MacBook Air if hopefully Apple doesn't kill the line miraculously or doesn't increase the price. But if I must buy one at home, for development, it will be a custom build PC. Yes, desk
Apple MacBook Air: Likes itApple MacBook Pro Retina: Likes it
FWIW: I used to use 3 screens (main one in the middle, and an extra desktop to the right and left)... and could have never envisioned going without at least one external monitor. Then I went fully remote for a few years, and switched entirely to to a Macbook (first the Air, then the Pro Retina). I never looked back. Instead of many screens I just make generous use of OSX's multiple-desktops feature (which they call "spaces" http://support.apple.com/kb/PH14155 ). Instead of turning my head to look at the screen to my right, I 3-finger-swipe to the right. Instead of looking to my left, I 3-finger-swipe to the left. Etc. It's not exactly the same of course, but it works well. Surprisingly well actually. I say that all to say, you might want to give minimal a try at first. You can always add on more gear later. But who knows, you might like it! Oh, and I use a Tmobile hotspot, but they're all good.