The stuff Hacker News actually recommends.

Laptops

Apple MacBook Air M3 vs Apple MacBook Pro

No clear winner: owners rate them about the same.

Apple MacBook Air M3Apple MacBook Pro
Owners with an opinion523902
Positive verdicts77% of 4362% of 3276
Positive/negative since 202433/10945/592
Happy after 3+ years0355
Longest happy owner1.5 yrs16 yrs
Praised forperformance and portabilityperformance and reliability
Criticized fordisplay and valuebattery
Newest comment

Updated

What owners wrote about both

Apple MacBook Air M3: Likes itApple MacBook Pro: Likes it
If you place 1mm thermal pads between the sinks and the case, the CPUs/GPUs won't throttle as readily. At least for my M3 MBA (check your actual clearance). I replaced a MacPro5,1 with an M2Pro — which uses soooooo much less energy performing similarly mundane tasks (~15x+). Idle is ~25W v. 160W
Apple MacBook Air M3: Likes itApple MacBook Pro: Likes it
>I ditched MSFT stock a few years ago in favor of AMD I bought equal amounts of MSFT and AMD, about four years ago. Haven't touched any of the AMD, yet... and was thinking maybe I should sell it all (also don't like AI-integrated things, fellow Old Man)... but now that GPUs are so expensive I haven't pulled the trigger, yet. Until a few months ago, AMD had been break-even for my then-three-years of holding. >I am ditching is a 2006 Xeon dual core Mine is a 2009, and honestly was held together with patches/glue (not literally). Also very stable after boot-up, but boots were becoming 50/50. I migrated off of Xeons (as my main machine) Jan 2023, when Apple released their M2Pro "Silicon" models. I also got a 15" M3 Macbook Air. Both machines make great internet browsers. I hate modern macOS, but it is usable when you block apple/icloud (entirely), at the host level. No update nags, no cloud storage BS, no problems. All my serious writing/paperwork happens offline, on quite antiquated equipment (oldest being my Smith Corona c~1946). Very happily awaiting the return of in-person meetups, as generative AI video begins requiring such social connection.
Apple MacBook Air M3: Likes itApple MacBook Pro: Likes it
I'm still typing this from an M1 MAX MBP w/ 64 gig of ram. I ended up needing more memory so, I swapped to this machine instead of my M1 air w/ 16gig. Both machines are completely capable for most tasks I deal with as a developer. Do I like my work m3? Sure. I wish I had the old m3 air I had to give back. But I'm happy with my machines. It's funny that my ipad has a more current CPU than my two laptops.
Apple MacBook Air M3: Likes itApple MacBook Pro: Likes it
I'm a web dev with both a M2 Max (in a Pro) and a M3 (Air). Never heard the fan come on a single time with either machine while developing. Heat has never been an issue. Battery life is superb on both. Pro has better screen but is way heavier. Air is much nicer to bring to a cafe. The only time I've ever heard the fan come on is when playing 3d games, especially non-native Apple Silicon games. If I were getting one only for development, I'd get an Air. If it were meant to be a desktop replacement workstation for work and gaming and movies and such, then the Pro. Both are easily more than fast enough for web dev. Not sure about other stacks (especially with heavy compiles or virtualization). I have a few services in Docker and that's fine (on both machines). It's just so so much better than the shitty old Wintel days that I don't even worry about it anymore. Lightyears ahead of any ThinkPad or Latitude, etc.
Apple MacBook Air M3: Likes itApple MacBook Pro: Likes it
Completely agree that Apple does the exact same stuff with account management and iCloud notifications, but I don’t understand where these arguments keep coming from that Apple is more costly. The 13.5 sLaptop 6 for Business is, i5/8gb/256gb is $1200 Compare that the 14” MBP (M3/8gb/512gb) for $1600. The diff in SSD storage offsets some of the cost, but not the whole $400 However, the 13” MacBook Air with the same specs (although a much better CPU) - M3/8gb/256gb is actually $100 cheaper. Until someone builds an actual M3 competitor, Apple’s making better laptops for cheaper. I have an M1 16” MBP that’s still running laps around any other laptop I’ve ever owned, including the 15” sBook 2 with a 1060. The Windows Arm laptop I have sucks compared to the M-series. Anyway, totally agree that Apple does the same cross-sell garbage as Microsoft, just think it’s way off to argue that their hardware is more expensive, at least meaningfully so when you compare the performance, longevity, and battery life.
Apple MacBook Air M3: Likes itApple MacBook Pro: Likes it
Precisely. But if you don't spend even $200 more on the Macbook Pro to get 16GB, you are leaving a bit of the M3's performance on the table due to swapping. So, $1799. Or step up to the M3 Pro with 18GB at $1999. And on the Air you could drop that same improvement in. So, $1,299. Which says to me that from $1000 to $2000 there are a variety of ways to get satisfactory performance out of a long-battery M3 Macbook. A corollary is that there is no way to get everything (unlimited multitasking, unthrottled renders, no swapping, no IO constraints) you could want out of a $999 Macbook Air M2/8GB/256GB.
Apple MacBook Air M3: Likes itApple MacBook Pro: Likes it
Well, what PC people do is they hyper-focus on one specific spec like number of displays supported or price per GB of RAM but can’t see the forest for the trees beyond that. If I just do the same thing with Macs I can win arguments just as easily. Find me a laptop with the kind of performance per watt specs as the M3 systems. Find another laptop of the same size/weight/power draw that can match the M3 Max’s performance at anything close to the same battery life. Find me a completely fanless Intel/AMD PC that performs as well as the MacBook Air and gets the same or better battery life. Find me a PC laptop where you can feed a RTX 40X0 mobile GPU with over 100GB of RAM. Find me another laptop that uses TSMC’s most advanced chip lithography. PC spec monkeys will basically say it’s not a real laptop because it can’t support 800 external monitors and there’s no print screen key and it doesn’t have a parallel port etc etc. These are all specs that don’t matter to 99% of users. Hell, if you’re the kind of person who has a triple or quad external monitor setup, that means you’ve spent around $1000 on just displays. That probably means you can afford $3,000 for a MacBook Pro with a Max chip or maybe pay $2,000 for a used one. And if you didn’t spend $1000+ on those displays, that means those four displays are probably so bad that you’re better off looking at one 4K display or two decent quality ultrawide displays.