The stuff Hacker News actually recommends.

Laptops · Apple MacBook Air

Apple MacBook Air M3

52owners with an opinion
77%of verdicts positive
33/10positive/negative since 2024
1.5 yrslongest happy owner
0happy after 3+ years

Praised for performance and portability; criticized for display and value.

What owners wrote

Likes itOwned 1.5 years
I'm a year and a half in and everything is running smooth. I still get a full workday out of the battery - and that's using Linux. That's plenty for me. It opens smooth. The keyboard is good - no deck flex. The screen is fine - even at only 300nits I don't need it brighter as I don't work in bright areas. I really really don't see how this won't last another 2 and half years or even more.
Likes it
Apple is not what it used to be… We see it in the hardware AND the software. It used to be: think different It used to be: It just works… Now we got “apple intelligence” and subscriptions all over the place and also the lock-in feels stronger over time. Don’t even get me started that one can’t easily replace the battery oneself. They gradually convinced us that reduced repairability is fine. I got my first MacBook Pro in 2006… things were quite different back then. Anyway, I’ve decided I wanted to get away from BigTech a while ago. Apple is the hardest part for me. They used to have this annoyance-free usability that I loved so much. iPhone Duo, Touchscreen on the Mac, liquid glass, visionPro, etc. are all valid things to go after and I don’t think these are bad things per se. But it is not what I care about. And clearly the focus has shifted away from the values I used to share with this company about what constitutes a good product. I took the hit on the ownership/control side because their products were so ‘seamless’. Now I hope the Framework and Fairphone (with eOS) have matured enough to not regret when I am getting off the Apple-train. I don’t expect a frictionless experience - it just has to be sufficiently annoyance-free. I’ll happily take some rough edges in exchange for greater control and ownership. “Unfortunately” their products are really sturdy and it will take a while until my M3 MacBookAir and iPhone 14 need to be replaced ^^
Doesn’t like it
> I run both Windows and MacOS and have done so for decades. I cannot remember the last time I had a hard freeze like I get on Fedora. I've gotten plenty of freezes and even more slowdowns on my MacBook Air M3 when using lots of RAM. But I'm using a lot more than 15 tabs in Firefox, and quiet a few VS Code instances, too. I agree that we should be improving Linux instead of making excuses.
Likes it
I got an M1 Max studio w/ 64gb when they first came out and I love it. Price was obviously a lot more reasonable at the time. I’m fortunate to have dedicated office space, and there is definitely a nice psychological effect to having a desktop in a specific spot and “going to the office”. I’ve since purchased an m3 MacBook Air as my thin client and for lightweight travel use, and when my wife needs to take a call in the office or whatever I pop out to the living room and either hop on Remote Desktop or SSH into my Studio. Highly recommend this setup. If you’re primarily doing thin client on a local network, a neo should be fine for that (and to use as a media player/communicator around the house). That said, I have been eyeballing Omarchy…
Likes it
While not quite what you are saying here, I have found that I like usbc charging on my 15in m3 MacBook Air way more than its magsafe. The magsafe is always falling out as soon as I move the computer on and off my lap and is another cable that I can only use for one purpose. Nowhere near as good as it was back in the early 2010s macbook days...
Doesn’t like it
I don't like MacOS. Everytime I talk about setting up a custom PC, people say - buy Mac Mini. No. I don't want MacOS. It's soooo slow workflow wise. I was literally behind my manager for 2 whole years to get him to move me from Macbook Air 11 inch to a linux laptop. He was ready to give me Macbook Pro 2016. But not a Linux laptop, in an org which had them. And I went over his head to get a Linux laptop there. The slow workflow MacOS had. My goodness. But people always argued that I used a subpar Mac device as slow as Macbook Air 11. So you didn't have the full experience. blah blah blah. Guess what? I use a M3 Macbook Air with 24GB now. It is still is as bad as it was back then. And after the glass update, I has become abysmal. So no. I'll just get another Linux computer. Not a Mac. The only time I will voluntarily choose MacOs is if I had to choose between Windows and Mac. Then I will choose Mac 100% of the time. Or if I had to ever develop for Apple ecosystem as well.
Doesn’t like it
I made the mistake of buying an 8 GB macbook air m3 a while ago, thinking it would be enough. I wasn't accounting for docker or vscode. It REALLY lags. The vim mode plugin will regularly lag on nearly every keystroke, until I kill everything and restart. On the topic of vim, the built-in vim mode in zed is really good. The helix mode is great too!!
Doesn’t like it
> closing the window, quits the app I've always hated this about macOS. And my main laptop is a macBook Air M3 15. The majority of my friends that use macOS have no idea how to quit an app. Nearly all think closing all the windows quits it. A lot of issues with a lot of apps can be fixed by quitting them and opening them up again. I help a ton of theater techs at a local improv theater. I finally gave up with most of them and told them to just reboot as a first step to fixing issues before continuing other troubleshooting steps.
Neutral
I picked up a 15" Macbook Air (M3) for $849 — clearance @costco early 2025. This model only has 8gb of RAM — which is fine for streaming videos/typing — it absolutely could not be my daily driver, but makes for good casual usage. Machines probably should ship with more than that (or a lighter operating system?), particularly when the RAM isn't upgradeable. I'll recon Apple supports at least two more macOS on these 8GB configurations. My favorite machine only has 4GB of RAM (Core2Duo Max, Win7Pro) and works good, albeit nothing modern.
Likes it
I love my MacBook Air 15" M3 so much. It is large fast and light. While I really appreciate the improved M5, my main ask is actually a brighter screen. The current 500 nits is a bit low if you are ever not in a dark room. Anyhow, because the differences between my M3 and the new M5 are just the CPU/GPU and I am not actually hurt much by the current CPU speed, I won't be upgrading.
Likes it
I skipped the touchbar/buttery era, but before that the GPU/ballgate disaster plagued the MacBookPro lineup — pushed me away from Apple hardware for over decade! My vision has since gotten bad enough that I can't really use laptops/phones well , anymore — but recently got a 15" MacBookAir, M3 pre-Tahoe (for bedtime youtubies). The hardware is exceptional, battery life even more so ... and I'll never update the operating system.
Likes it
If you place 1mm thermal pads between the sinks and the case, the CPUs/GPUs won't throttle as readily. At least for my M3 MBA (check your actual clearance). I replaced a MacPro5,1 with an M2Pro — which uses soooooo much less energy performing similarly mundane tasks (~15x+). Idle is ~25W v. 160W
Doesn’t like it
I've tried it, but it's very slow on a not too complex codebase with my M3 Macbook Air. -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Language Files Lines Blank Comment Code -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Typescript JSX 121 18724 1699 1051 15974 TypeScript 61 5389 629 550 4210 CSS 5 1039 50 22 967 Markdown 3 657 173 0 484 -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- It was like 5-10FPS at best, not really usable unfortunately because I like these tools. I'm using another similar one which is buttery smooth, Code Canvas.
Likes it
>I ditched MSFT stock a few years ago in favor of AMD I bought equal amounts of MSFT and AMD, about four years ago. Haven't touched any of the AMD, yet... and was thinking maybe I should sell it all (also don't like AI-integrated things, fellow Old Man)... but now that GPUs are so expensive I haven't pulled the trigger, yet. Until a few months ago, AMD had been break-even for my then-three-years of holding. >I am ditching is a 2006 Xeon dual core Mine is a 2009, and honestly was held together with patches/glue (not literally). Also very stable after boot-up, but boots were becoming 50/50. I migrated off of Xeons (as my main machine) Jan 2023, when Apple released their M2Pro "Silicon" models. I also got a 15" M3 Macbook Air. Both machines make great internet browsers. I hate modern macOS, but it is usable when you block apple/icloud (entirely), at the host level. No update nags, no cloud storage BS, no problems. All my serious writing/paperwork happens offline, on quite antiquated equipment (oldest being my Smith Corona c~1946). Very happily awaiting the return of in-person meetups, as generative AI video begins requiring such social connection.
Doesn’t like it
No Nano-Texture Option. I actually returned an M3 Macbook Air I got for xmas because I find it too reflective, waiting and hoping for a non-reflective Macbook Air. If Apple had made it clear they weren't gonna release a non-reflective screen for the Macbook air, I might've just kept the M3 or perhaps gotten the heavy Pro. Now I don't feel like getting any of these.