The stuff Hacker News actually recommends.

Phones

Apple iPhone 4 vs Apple iPhone 5

No clear winner: owners rate them about the same.

Apple iPhone 4Apple iPhone 5
Owners with an opinion11058
Positive verdicts72% of 9771% of 51
Positive/negative since 202422/1210/2
Happy after 3+ years61
Longest happy owner10 yrs3 yrs
Praised fordesign and performanceease of use and design
Criticized forreliability and batterybattery and reliability
Newest comment

Updated

What owners wrote about both

Apple iPhone 4: NeutralApple iPhone 5: Neutral
> Same thing with my phones. I went from an iphone 4, to a 5, to a 6 to an 11. And there I have stayed. There are a few features that would be nice to have, but not enough for me to fork over the cash. And my old one still does everything fine. My iPhone 7 (Plus? whatever the called the big one) still seems a totally serviceable phone from my limited use, although substantially slower than my 12. It's not been supported for some years now, but I still boot it occasionally and it's far from useless and probably more performant than a low/mid tier Android phone from 3-4 years ago.
Apple iPhone 4: Likes itApple iPhone 5: Likes it
I broke iPhone 4, 5, 5s and 1 st. Gen. SE. All of them are quite small, and all also the 4th are light as well. I use cases, but those light ones, so they don’t add weight and add some protection. Mostly from scratches. In my case, all of them fell from some surface onto the floor. Usually it’s a metre distance. I think I never dropped a phone from my ear height, so not even 2 m.
Apple iPhone 4: Doesn’t like itApple iPhone 5: Doesn’t like it
There's some degree of active involvement with this. I've long suspected Apple to do this for example. The best version of iOS for any iDevice is usually the one just before the one that they use as the hard cutoff point. Granted, my big example of this is quite old (the iPhone 4 would run iOS 6 really well, while on iOS 7 it was a glitchy, slow, battery-draining mess) but it does seem to be a common trend (my last Apple phone, the iPhone 5 ran quite well on iOS 9 but would just have a complete breakdown if you installed iOS 10). They were IIRC also caught red-handed a couple times deliberately releasing updates to older iDevices that would just wreck their battery life and have a few lawsuits pending about that.
Apple iPhone 4: Likes itApple iPhone 5: Likes it
Ipad 1 running IOS 5.1. It is on the wall near of the front door showing the gate entrance of my house. Software used: IP Cam viewer. Ipad 2 running IOS 7.4. It is on the wall in the kitchen used for show recipes online and/or in ebooks. Software used: Safari and DVR Reader Iphone 4 running IOS 7.1.2. Pluged on a speakers system connected to a NAS by wifi. Software used: FileXplorer Iphone 5 running IOS 7.4. Used as GPS in a bike. Software used: TOMTOM maps updated to 2021/Q1
Apple iPhone 4: Likes itApple iPhone 5: Likes it
"You think you do, but you don't." I LOVED my iPhone 4 & iPhone 5 back in the day. I thought they were just perfect. I could reach all the keys, they fit in any pants, and they were just my favorite era of phones ever. Metal edges, glass front and back, no stupid camera bump -- perfection. For the time they existed, there was nothing to improve on those phones. But I pretty much hate my iPhone Mini. And it has almost nothing to do with the phone -- it's basically an improved version of the iPhone 4, except now it's got a stupid camera bump. And I would still love the form factor, but like... so many things just don't fit right. Apps just haven't been tested to work on it, especially if you tweak your default font sizes at all, and it's just a sub-optimal experience in almost every way. My fingers fit, but now websites are built with bigger fonts and need bigger screens. I passionately hate "viewport wobble" and you see it all the freakin' time on the iPhone Mini. Book an Uber? The buttons are off screen, or weird places. Sure that's the app's fault -- and frankly a lot of apps need to do better for responsive design in order to better improve accessibility (especially for elderly users!) but that's a bigger fight than I want to get into when I pick up a phone and just want it to work. So I don't know, like if I had a magic wand and could just zap every website, every app into compliance with the slightly smaller screen... sure it'd be great. But I don't, and that makes for a…