The stuff Hacker News actually recommends.

Keyboards

ZSA ErgoDox vs ZSA Moonlander

Hacker News owners slightly favor the ZSA Moonlander.

ZSA ErgoDoxZSA Moonlander
Owners with an opinion221194
Positive verdicts76% of 18879% of 158
Positive/negative since 202435/2159/24
Happy after 3+ years184
Longest happy owner10 yrs6 yrs
Praised forergonomics and comfortergonomics and ease of use
Criticized forease of useportability
Newest comment

Updated

What owners wrote about both

ZSA ErgoDox: NeutralZSA Moonlander: Doesn’t like it
I've had a Moonlander for a couple years, and an ErgoDox Ez for 3-4 years before that, and, honestly, I'm looking to move to something else. My biggest issue seems to be that I'm switching between a Macbook and the Moonlander all the time, and the Moonlander I just find myself making too many dumb typos on. In particular, I think the ortholinear layout isn't doing me any favors, and the missing extra keys on the right (particularly the missing "+" key) I really struggle with. I do love the thumb clusters, but as the article above says, the red button I never use. The real star of the show is the programmable firmware. I have a lot of custom mappings on my main layer that I really love, with dual use keys being a big one (z and / are control if held for example). The Framework 16 keyboard with QMK firmware sounds really, really good to me. Unfortunately, my next keyboard doesn't seem to exist: Low profile mechanical switches, QMK or similar firmware, split, thumb clusters, staggered layout, enough keys to have []\ on the right. The low profile seems to be the killer there.
ZSA ErgoDox: NeutralZSA Moonlander: Doesn’t like it
On the other hand, I've tried many keyboards, including the ErgoDox and Kinesis Advantage, with the latter being the most comfortable for me. While the Moonlander boasts impressive customizability, I found its untypical angle of the thumb cluster to be a drawback for my personal typing experience. Given its premium price point and the extended delivery time from Taiwan (mine took almost a month to come to the UK), I'd strongly recommend trying it out before making a purchase to ensure it meets your ergonomic needs and avoids potential disappointment.
ZSA ErgoDox: Likes itZSA Moonlander: Doesn’t like it
I love my ergodox ez. I got the moon lander, and it looks cool but I do not like it. Niether does my friend. The tenting tilts the thumb away which makes it uncomfortable. I wish I just got another ergodox ez (eventually I did).
ZSA ErgoDox: NeutralZSA Moonlander: Likes it
ZSA configurator so much better than QMK configuration, it's not even a remote comparison. I happily pay money to companies who provide a lot of additional value on top of open source offering. I have moonlander, zsa platform, ergodox ez. When ZSA (inevitably, as for me) will release concave moonlander, I'm going to buy it too...
ZSA ErgoDox: Likes itZSA Moonlander: Neutral
> I notice very significant latency with my Moonlander Mk1, but that is most likely caused by the software and fancy layered kemaps I have created. I'm not noticing all that much latency with my Ergodox EZ, but I'm also running QMK master[1] (rather than ZSA's fork via Oryx). It would be useful to note the firmware + revision in these tests. 40ms sounds like a lot of latency for twitchy games like StarCraft II (for which I've extensively customized my layout[2]); while I'm definitely enjoying the improved ergonomics in the game, I'm starting to wonder how much it's actually impacting my performance. [1]: forked to https://github.com/rollcat/qmk_firmware [2]: https://gist.github.com/rollcat/8b8dcd36c0abccf430b4160ad899...
ZSA ErgoDox: Doesn’t like itZSA Moonlander: Likes it
That was my experience. I went from an ergodox to a dactyl manuform and at first I found it great. But that went to good to decent. I did not jive with something about the curvature + layout, even though I could touch type at a good speed. I ended up switching to a moonlander and find it is more enjoyable. I also found it an improvement over the ergodox, because the clusters are more thought out and the tenting has less degrees of freedom so is easier to get just right.
ZSA ErgoDox: Doesn’t like itZSA Moonlander: Likes it
Never seen these issue on an EZ but they are common issues on Ergodox in general and I have had to resolder the mini-usb connectors a number of times on DIY units as they just do not have a lot of structural support. You do have to baby the connector a bit but everything else takes considerable abuse. I have no doubt this is why they went with a recessed USB type C on the Moonlander which would take significant force to break.
ZSA ErgoDox: Recommends itZSA Moonlander: Likes it
This is a great entry point to split ortholinear keyboards. Build quality is great, its well supported, and its very easy to set up and get using it. The moonlander they sell is also pretty good. I like the ergodox style thumb cluster better, but the moonlander is super portable, so that helps if you are moving around a lot. When I converted to split ortholinear it took me about a month to get back to the same proficiency that I had with a standard keyboard, so if your looking to make the plunge make sure you set aside time to practice the new layout. I would set up two keyboards so I could switch back after a few hours and still be productive for the day while I was getting used to the new layout.
ZSA ErgoDox: Likes itZSA Moonlander: Neutral
I find shifting extremely comfortable, but not quite to the extent as the author of this post. Like the author, I use thumb keys on the opposite hand to make the other hand start typing symbols. For example, I press the key below V with my left hand, and then home row on the right hand "jkl;" becomes "( {})". (Actually, the whole side becomes symbols. I use the characters below the numbers to type the shifted symbol there, so qwer is !@#$, though on the other side, I don't duplicate the parentheses and instead have `~ below 9 and 0.) Overall, I find that this is ridiculously comfortable to use. I suffered from mild wrist pain when typing on standard keyboards, mostly because my pinky had to do so much work for programming (and pressing backspace, kill the default position of that key with fire), and the Ergodox helped me a lot. One thing I'll note, when I moved from Ergodox to Moonlander, I lost the 1.5U key next to the h/n keys (heh). I used to use that as backspace, but moved it to my left thumb. When you're backspacing an entire word (not something I do in Emacs, but something you have to do in the web browser), the up/down/up/down/up/down motion isn't as fast with your thumb as it is with your pointer finger. OS X users probably don't have this problem, as C-w isn't "close window" there like it is on Windows.
ZSA ErgoDox: Recommends itZSA Moonlander: Likes it
Um, yes? It's one of their marketed features: https://ergodox-ez.com/#dualfunctionkeys Much of the point of the Ergodox is that it's completely reprogrammable, and ZSA's Oryx makes that very easy for the Ergodox EZ and Moonlander (which I've just gotten). For other keyboards running QMK the QMK Configurator makes it relatively easy too, except for macros (I also have a Hotdox Ergodox). I use the keys my thumbs sit on as space on the left and enter on the right, and holding space as shift and holding enter as control. I use the two little finger home keys (A and I in the Workman layout) as letters when tapped and layer switchers when held. Left gets me symbols and numbers, and right gets me movement, editing, and more symbols. You can also make keys act like modifiers are held down, e.g. a single key that does shift-enter for Jupyter notebooks, or ctrl-C, ctrl-V, etc. You could probably set up a whole Emacs layer or two like that. I also use autoshift, so a long tap on a letter key gives you the capital letter (this makes held letters as modifiers a bit less convenient). With these keyboards I never move my right little finger to the right, as doing that on normal keyboards is really damaging my right wrist (hence spending hundreds of dollars on programmable keyboards with lots of thumb keys). I've been trying similar things in software for a while with AutoHotKey and sxhkd, but concluded I needed to do it at a lower level. UInput is an option for that on Linux, but
ZSA ErgoDox: Doesn’t like itZSA Moonlander: Likes it
I like that the thumb cluster on the Moonlander has an adjustable angle - the fixed angle on the Ergodox EZ wasn't the most comfortable fit for me. As well, if you are going to be carrying the keyboard around with you, the Moonlander folds down flat and comes stock with a neoprene carrying case and the hex wrench to readjust it, so it's fairly trivial. I've also had no debounce issues across two of them.
ZSA ErgoDox: Recommends itZSA Moonlander: Likes it
Been using my ErgodoxEZ for the last 6 years. Fantastic keyboard, great ergonomics, rock solid build quality. Pricy but very worth imo. If I were buying today, I'd buy a Moonlander, the newer version of the Ergodox.
Switched from the ZSA ErgoDox to the ZSA MoonlanderZSA Moonlander: Likes it
I backed ergodox-ez on indiegogo in 2016. I moved to the moonlander mostly for the built in wrist pads. support has been amazing. I just got a replacement for a cracked piece of plastic that I can repair myself. https://www.zsa.io/moonlander/teardown The thing I like most is the split and I have customized the layout to my working style. I really should learn to use layers or try some of the "hacks" https://www.zsa.io/moonlander/printables .
ZSA ErgoDox: Likes itZSA Moonlander: Likes it
Daily driver is a Svalboard. Before that, there was a Rolio, Corne-ish Zen, Moonlander, Ergodox EZ. All were great. I tried to make the MoErgo Glove 80 and a Characorder Master Forge work, but without sufficient success. For 'thinking not typing' Svalboard takes the biscuit. I use tap-dance, with 1 extra momentary layer for macros. Layout-wise, I went with Workman. Makes Helix interesting, but it's muscle-memory now. What is unplayable now... minecraft lol.
ZSA ErgoDox: Doesn’t like itZSA Moonlander: Doesn’t like it
I have an Ergodox EZ I built as well as a Moonlander, but I ultimately decided split/tilt wasn't right for my wrists. I switched to an Arisu layout ergo single-frame keyboard and that is what I rely on to this day. The biggest win was going to a vertical mouse. I'm also a lover of the Model M and Model F, but these are not properly ergonomic in 2026 (and at 40+ years old). Shoutout to the IV Works AV3/AV4 and the Evoluent vertical mouse for helping stave off surgery for another 6 years (and counting).
ZSA ErgoDox: NeutralZSA Moonlander: Neutral
Went also through ErgoDox EZ and MoonLander but down-sized to a Corne-ish Zen. Happier since. Less keys (3x6) and lower profile is even nicer for ergonomics, for me at least, but does require a bit more of mental gymnastics for layers. well worth it IMHO.
ZSA ErgoDox: Doesn’t like itZSA Moonlander: Doesn’t like it
The only ergo keyboard I've ever enjoyed is the ZSA Voyager. I tried the Kinesis, the Ergodox, and the Moonlander, but something about them didn't quite suit me. I think they all had similarly oversized thumb clusters, which I found very uncomfortable. My current setup is the Voyager with homerow mods, which is super comfortable and I manage to mostly avoid typos. edit: I should also say I'm an avid Emacs user.