The stuff Hacker News actually recommends.

Consoles and handhelds

Valve Steam Controller vs Valve Steam Deck

Hacker News owners slightly favor the Valve Steam Deck.

Valve Steam ControllerValve Steam Deck
Owners with an opinion49700
Positive verdicts73% of 4183% of 623
Positive/negative since 202419/6271/67
Happy after 3+ years02
Longest happy owner–25 yrs
Praised forease of use and performanceperformance and ease of use
Criticized forsoftwarereliability
Newest comment

Updated

What owners wrote about both

Valve Steam Controller: Likes itValve Steam Deck: Neutral
Weird, I have used the steam controller a lot and bizarrely my kids even picked them up. I find the right track pad on the steam deck smaller than I'd like and I wish they hadn't relocated the buttons. But I really wanted a d-pad on the steam controller so I could use it for emulation more seamlessly so I was glad to see that on the deck.
Valve Steam Controller: Recommends itValve Steam Deck: Likes it
My next PC will almost certainly be a Steam Deck. Already been using Linux for decades now, but that portable form factor is just the perfect size for my own needs/wants. Been wanting something inbetween a smartphone/tablet and a laptop for a long time now, but netbooks were still a shade too large (and underpowered). Steam Deck fills that wish perfectly. Now we just gotta hope Valve don't "kick it to the curb" like they did the Steam Controller (best game controller I've ever owned).
Switched from the Valve Steam Controller to the Valve Steam DeckValve Steam Deck: Doesn’t like it
I have one. I wanted to like it, but it just lacked. The feedback on the large directional buttons is limited, the controller isn't terribly comfortable to hold, and the ABXY buttons are at quite an awkward position. The trackpad to play PC games was an interesting idea, but it just didn't work for me because it lacked precision or range. My biggest issue is that the touchpad lack precision that a normal joystick would provide, and you need quite some force to push the directional buttons underneath the DPAD. It wasn't a complete design failure. I do miss the button on the end of the triggers, that was a smart choice. I find the Deck paddles a lot harder to press than the ones on the Steam controller. The deck took everything the Steam controller tried to do and just did it better. The trackpads is still there, including the force feedback, but it's no longer used in place of usual controls. With these lessons learned, I think Valve will be able to design an awesome controller!
Valve Steam Controller: Likes itValve Steam Deck: Likes it
Valve makes it very very easy to be a PC gamer, and, importantly, slightly harder to be a PC gamer who buys games in places other than Steam. Yes you can buy games on GoG or Epic and play them on a steam deck or a steam machine. But it's juuuuust enough faff to be annoying enough, that you'd rather just get them on steam. I know people (and am a person) who have rebought games they already own so they are on steam, to make playing between steam deck and desktop more reliable. It's the same with the steam controller. You _can_ use it with games outside of steam, but it's enough of a faff that you find yourself avoiding it. It's incredibly effective, and why they are an effective monopoly in PC gaming.
Valve Steam Controller: Likes itValve Steam Deck: Likes it
Steam Controller was significantly better than Xbox controllers for some kinds of games, but it was much clunkier for others. Steam Deck's controller is an improvement over either of them, and this new Steam Controller appears to be pretty much Deck's controller without the Deck, with some tiny extras added.
Valve Steam Controller: Doesn’t like itValve Steam Deck: Doesn’t like it
It looks way too chunky, just like the original Steam Controller, Steam Deck or original duke Xbox controller. Not everybody has Jack Reacher hands. Microsoft really did it right with the XSX controller. They took the old X360 / Xone design (perfect for large and medium hands) shrunk it slightly and then added cut-outs and and angled button surfaces (perfect for medium and small hands). The Elite is similarly good, with the back buttons being elongated and thin, meaning everyone can reach them comfortably without them getting in the way.
Valve Steam Controller: Likes itValve Steam Deck: Likes it
Yes, that is exactly it. Nintendo Switch and Valve Stream deck (and even the old steam controllers) have this functionality. In the case of the Steamdeck, there are sensors in the joysticks to know if your finger is present to then allow mapping to enable/disable gyro aiming as well. Making it easier to reset the devices position in space without also aiming.
Valve Steam Controller: Likes itValve Steam Deck: Likes it
At this point, Valve has yet to disappoint me. Even their failures, like the Steam Controller, were amazing pieces of tech. The Steam Deck is no exception. It's exactly what I've been wanting: a SFFPC that doubles as a portable gaming console with Linux natively installed. Bravo Steam!