The stuff Hacker News actually recommends.

Networking

Ubiquiti EdgeRouter vs Ubiquiti UniFi

Hacker News owners lean toward the Ubiquiti UniFi.

Ubiquiti EdgeRouterUbiquiti UniFi
Owners with an opinion102583
Positive verdicts59% of 7165% of 498
Positive/negative since 20247/13182/93
Happy after 3+ years419
Longest happy owner10 yrs20 yrs
Praised forreliability and performancereliability and ease of use
Criticized forsupportsoftware and performance
Newest comment

Updated

What owners wrote about both

Ubiquiti EdgeRouter: Doesn’t like itUbiquiti UniFi: Likes it
It really depends on what you need from it; a cheap L2 switch will do the job, but frankly, you can get a Ubiquti Flex Mini with 5x1Gb ports for £35, I have a bunch of them around the house, and they're semi-managed so I can do VLANs on them and power them over PoE; since I'm already running Unifi, don't see the point cheaping out on switches. I also have a bunch of EdgeMAX because I use the L3 features, they were more expensive, and that range is sadly now discontinued, but the Unifi equipment have all been workhorses, and the only think I've ever had fail in the past decade was an EdgeRouter Lite, the power circuitry failed after some dodgy mains voltage issues in my previous home.
Ubiquiti EdgeRouter: NeutralUbiquiti UniFi: Likes it
I'm slowly in the process of migrating from an EdgeRouter and Edgeswitches (including the 16XG for my SAN backplane) to Unifi. Am comfortable at the command line (and actually just had Claude help me build a bunch of configs and an IaC harness for my whole infrastructure) but the SPOG will be nice - that and Ubiquiti has basically abandoned the Edge* line. This was prompted by not wanting to by having persistent problems with the Cat 6 STP termination and the length of the run between my office and the rack in my garage, and my Mac Studio and Edgeswitch would generally only negotiate at 5gbps and even then be error prone, so I got a Unifi switch with 8 ports and 2 SFP+ and ran fiber to the garage for the uplink, and just a short 10' run between the switch and my studio gave me rock solid 10gig (I just run the controller, for now, on a small VM, with my 2 WAPs, but will go all in when I pull the trigger, though, oof, $2,500 for everything I need).
Ubiquiti EdgeRouter: NeutralUbiquiti UniFi: Likes it
I sympathize with the poster, as deploying my own stack should've been an easier migration from their EdgeRouter kit than it turned out to be - though wisely, I had budgeted a six hour window for a process that ultimately took ~2hrs. Ubiquiti's niche really is the "I want Enterprise features but I also don't want to be my own CCIE to run this shit," and in that sense it overachieves nicely. Does it have idiosyncrasies? You betcha, and OP found this out first hand. Would I trust this for blind/hands-off remote site deployment? Hell naw, that's what Meraki is for. Would I build a data center around these? Maybe , depending on the data center's function? Honestly, my wishlist for the product suite is a stronger focus on self-hosting, removing the Bluetooth app requirement for initial setup of hardware, improving zero touch provisioning, and letting me use Identity without having to tie it to their servers (e.g., local LDAP or SAML/SSO integration). That'd make me a happy dinosaur.
Ubiquiti EdgeRouter: Likes itUbiquiti UniFi: Doesn’t like it
The catch is figuring out what's going to stick around and what won't. I have a Ubiquiti EdgeRouter Lite that's a little over ten years old. At the time, it was revolutionary in its ability to pump a whole lot of data over a cheap device with a lot of features - but a lot of those features weren't available in the GUI at all; you had to go CLI and learn Vyatta (of which it was a fork) to do them. It's been updated over the years and is now much easier to use as the web interface exposes a lot more functionality, but it's not part of Unifi (and never will be). Early on, I looked at and even tried one of their AP's. 100 Mbps wired uplinks for N wireless? No thanks. Even the one that I got to test with had absolutely abysmal range. Say what you will about TP-LINK generally, but their Omada unified control system had AP's that actually worked in my house. So the early Unifi stuff wasn't anything special, and based on how they had dropped the ball on so much of their early hardware (the EdgeRouter Lite had its software on an internal USB drive that, out of warranty, failed in a way that I was only able to diagnose with a serial console cable - at least it had a port so I could monitor it during boot, and searching for the error messages found a way to replace the thumbdrive and reload the software) I had no reason to go with them. If I were setting someone up today, with all new gear, I might go Unifi, but I have no reason to spend any time at all replacing a system that works jus…
Ubiquiti EdgeRouter: NeutralUbiquiti UniFi: Doesn’t like it
I've been slowly accumulating Unifi gear and I'm happy with it, though my experience is mixed - the prices are relatively good for a unified ecosystem, IMO. OTOH I've had two pieces of equipment die: an outdoor camera that shorted PoE pins because it really wasn't an outdoor camera, and the original doorbell that died after about three years of use (cause of death unknown, but I suspect a heavy rainstorm). Technically I had a third 48-port, 1st gen EdgeRouter Pro (750W model) that I saved from e-waste that died, but that already had quite a few years under its belt. I still lean towards liking them. I have a set of 5 in-wall APs that have been functioning for 5? 6? years straight and still get updates and work with the unifi console. My Dream Machine Pro works pretty well for its purpose. I don't like that it doesn't offer more PoE+2.5G port options, and that only two ports are true PoE++, but from an effort perspective it's been so nice to manage. All this being said, I think that their strength is in APs that are a good balance of tech + cost, and cameras which lean slightly more expensive but are trivially easy to manage locally and remotely. Going forward I'd probably skip unifi cameras and try to integrate OTS ONVIF cameras which will be a better value. I'd avoid any of the large switching gear. I don't think that stuff is well-priced, and it lags a bit behind what you can find from Mikrotik and other manufacturers. It's not that important to have that stuff included in…
Ubiquiti EdgeRouter: Doesn’t like itUbiquiti UniFi: Likes it
I still use their access points because it's hard to get anything else as good for the same kind of price, but they burned me killing the development on EdgeRouter. So I've gone elsewhere for cameras, switching and routing. This release is a nice point in their favour though but I can't see myself going back all in on Ubiquiti.
Ubiquiti EdgeRouter: Doesn’t like itUbiquiti UniFi: Recommends it
Yes, I've had one on the top of my shelves in my office for years. Only recommendation is use a shielded cable between the PoE injector and the unit -- keeps it safe during t-storms. I also have an ER4 the old UI a bit kludgey but they did revamp it a few years ago. I rarely connect to it and instead use UNMS to manage/monitor it (along with some other sites/devices). These days, I just go with the UDM-Pro SE's and if I need more than 8 PoE ports, I add on a Unifi switch via SFP. You can do pretty much everything these days in Unifi, no need for EdgeMax (well, VLANs is about as exotic as my installs get).
Ubiquiti EdgeRouter: NeutralUbiquiti UniFi: Doesn’t like it
I love ubiquiti. My entire home network runs on their gear, with self-hosted management. I have infra deployed across the country in a remote office that runs their gear, with a cloud key. It's solid stuff all around. Don’t use any of their unifi routers tho, can’t speak to that. I have an ER-4 at home and the remote office has a pfsense 1U.
Ubiquiti EdgeRouter: Likes itUbiquiti UniFi: Doesn’t like it
I found building rules around a dynamic prefix to be simple enough on my old EdgeRouter once I found the poorly documented magic incantation to do so. It isn’t possible on the UniFi system that replaced it. Who needs basic core functionality anyway.
Ubiquiti EdgeRouter: Likes itUbiquiti UniFi: Doesn’t like it
> 4-6 years ago things still looked quite promising This is very true. However if you bypass the Dream Machine and just use some other router or an EdgeRouter it’s ridiculously reliable in the home setting. There are a heap of nice features in the UDM line, but wow does it need polish and stability. My wifi is the best I’ve every used by a million miles, but the UDMP crashes and has weird behaviour that requires heroics to repair.
Ubiquiti EdgeRouter: Likes itUbiquiti UniFi: Neutral
> (Vyos is great but CLI based) The best firewalls/routers i've ever used have been Vyos (or Vyatta) based. Point & Click has it's charms, but its a crutch. With Vyos you can "replay" you entire configuration over a serial port, as well as make changes to it in a regular text editor. It does have a learning curve though :) I'm also on the UniFi line of things for now, but i really wish somebody would make a decent Vyos based appliance (low powered ARM device) like the Ubiquiti Edgerouters of old.
Ubiquiti EdgeRouter: NeutralUbiquiti UniFi: Doesn’t like it
Mikrotik HAP AC2 as router and wifi, with HAP AC providing extra access point. Fiddly to set up, but solid and trouble-free since. Used to use Ubiquiti Edgerouter, until it failed. The Smart QOS feature was pretty good. Used to use Unifi for wifi, but always struggled with clients getting stuck communicating with the most distant access point. (Edit: In case it's relevant for some, I should also list: a Draytek 130 to adapt perculiar UK PPPoA broadband to PPPoE.)
Ubiquiti EdgeRouter: Recommends itUbiquiti UniFi: Likes it
I'm currently using a Ubiquiti Edgerouter X (previously an ERLite) for routing/NAT and a UAP-AC-LR for WiFi (along with an OnHub in bridge mode, for AB testing). Previously, I used a UAP-LR reflashed with "normal" OpenWRT as I hated their controller/config software, but now there's Android and iOS apps for basic AP configuration. EdgeOS (a Vyatta fork) isn't as user friendly as other "consumer" routers, but every tech friend who owns one has fallen in love with the price/performance and feature set.
Switched from the Ubiquiti UniFi to the Ubiquiti EdgeRouterUbiquiti EdgeRouter: Likes it
My EdgeRouter finally bit the dust after over a decade of service, and I decided to "upgraded" to a Dream Machine. I was hesitant due to the security breaches and now I really regret my decision.
Ubiquiti EdgeRouter: Likes itUbiquiti UniFi: Likes it
As in the others that I _won't_ buy (which is what I meant)? I wouldn't buy Netgear, Asus, D-Link again. My ISP gave me Eero and I've never connected it, far too much Amazon crap going on there (but I have to keep it if I want the ISP to provide support). Gl.iNet has been OK for the price but re-flash it with vanilla OpenWRT because their OS has some dubious phone home stuff (or did last time I looked at it). Honestly, in terms of routers, I'm never likely to use something off-the-shelf again a decent box with Intel NICs that can run OPNSense and preferably run Coreboot (or similar). If I did go with something COTS (Commercial Off The Shelf), I'd look at Mikrotik. I'm not a massive fan of Ubiquiti but I have their APs and I've had a bunch of their EdgeMAX switches (sadly discontinued when some of their best devs left), and their APs have been solid for me for the best part of a decade. The advantage of using dedicated components is that each can be chosen according to your requirements.
Ubiquiti EdgeRouter: Doesn’t like itUbiquiti UniFi: Doesn’t like it
I used to think the same way, and I loved UBNT. Sadly, after 2 different more advanced configs I had caused wild stability issues - affecting APs, a USG and the controller itself to the point of making them less reliable than a random TP-Link router, plus an ERL randomly dying on me without warning and never booting again - I decided to pull UBNT from anything and anywhere. I now exclusively use open-source projects with a strong history and community - or used high-end enterprise gear that I pick up when it reaches EOL so it's dirt cheap. Stability has been so much better, even with the most advanced configs I ever created.
Ubiquiti EdgeRouter: Likes itUbiquiti UniFi: Likes it
Thanks for sharing! I've been running an EdgeMax router and U6 router for some time without issues, but hope to upgrade to a DreamMachine some day. The information you shared will definitely help when that day comes.