The stuff Hacker News actually recommends.

Networking

TP-Link Omada vs Ubiquiti UniFi

Hacker News owners lean toward the TP-Link Omada.

TP-Link OmadaUbiquiti UniFi
Owners with an opinion46583
Positive verdicts86% of 4465% of 498
Positive/negative since 202414/5182/93
Happy after 3+ years219
Longest happy owner4.5 yrs20 yrs
Praised forreliability and performancereliability and ease of use
Criticized forsoftware and ease of usesoftware and performance
Newest comment

Updated

What owners wrote about both

TP-Link Omada: Doesn’t like itUbiquiti UniFi: Likes it
TP Link's support is the worst, too. I bought an Omada, thinking I was getting a quality product. It died in the first 2 weeks. Support accused me of not using a surge protector (it was plugged into a UPS) and grudgingly sent me a replacement. Even at home, I can't risk having to replace my router every 2 weeks, so I just stuffed it in a box. I did use it again later, but wasn't happy with it, and ended up with a Ubiquiti Unifi UCG-Ultra. It's better than the TP-Link Deco and Omada, Eero Pro, Google Wifi, and Asus routers I've had, though I'll admit some of the Asus were pretty decent.
TP-Link Omada: Likes itUbiquiti UniFi: Doesn’t like it
The catch is figuring out what's going to stick around and what won't. I have a Ubiquiti EdgeRouter Lite that's a little over ten years old. At the time, it was revolutionary in its ability to pump a whole lot of data over a cheap device with a lot of features - but a lot of those features weren't available in the GUI at all; you had to go CLI and learn Vyatta (of which it was a fork) to do them. It's been updated over the years and is now much easier to use as the web interface exposes a lot more functionality, but it's not part of Unifi (and never will be). Early on, I looked at and even tried one of their AP's. 100 Mbps wired uplinks for N wireless? No thanks. Even the one that I got to test with had absolutely abysmal range. Say what you will about TP-LINK generally, but their Omada unified control system had AP's that actually worked in my house. So the early Unifi stuff wasn't anything special, and based on how they had dropped the ball on so much of their early hardware (the EdgeRouter Lite had its software on an internal USB drive that, out of warranty, failed in a way that I was only able to diagnose with a serial console cable - at least it had a port so I could monitor it during boot, and searching for the error messages found a way to replace the thumbdrive and reload the software) I had no reason to go with them. If I were setting someone up today, with all new gear, I might go Unifi, but I have no reason to spend any time at all replacing a system that works jus…
TP-Link Omada: Likes itUbiquiti UniFi: Doesn’t like it
Based on having migrated multiple clients from UniFi to Omada but still has UniFi deployed across a few sites too, I'll give you a different take from the replies you've gotten so far. TP-Link's Omada is a newer, direct competitor to UniFi, and when it came out Ubiquiti was an absolute fucking dumpster fire in terms of, well, everything. Their software, hardware, and even the forums (which they killed in favor of the current mess). Their gateway/routing/network service story sucked, they were missing key features, their firmware was rotting in basic ways (like ssh being so old it literally included only insecure ciphers and you couldn't even connect to it anymore without + options), and finally were also starting to make more and more concerning and ugly choices that pointed towards serious organization issues (constant UI bike shedding churn in favor of ancient features and bugs they'd agreed were important) and enshitification (tying software applications to required hardware). However, they were also the only player doing that sort of fully self-hostable unified configuration networking. I migrated all the gateway/routing/simple service stuff to OPNsense, but then was stuck. TP-Link stepped in and have been working hard on Omada being a direct competitor. It's clearly inspired liberally from UniFi but that's A-OK by me, it's healthy for both to be going head to head. In my experience it had somewhat fewer features, particularly initially, and they definitely don't cover th…
TP-Link Omada: NeutralUbiquiti UniFi: Likes it
I've used both and was super interested to use Omada because of its price and performance. Honestly, Ubiquiti is just so much easier. The whole controller model for Omada tries to be way more "enterprisey" at the cost of a SOHO ease of use.
TP-Link Omada: Doesn’t like itUbiquiti UniFi: Likes it
I made the same conclusions but got burned with Omada. Cheaper, yes, but fewer features and buggier than Unifi (and that’s a pretty low bar). I migrated back to Unifi.
TP-Link Omada: Likes itUbiquiti UniFi: Doesn’t like it
I was on unifi for a long time but I found it somewhat unreliable with a lot of issues. I switched over to TP-Link's Omada and now I never touch my network. I believe that TP-Link isn't as flashy, but they are rock solid. I prefer rock solid.
TP-Link Omada: Likes itUbiquiti UniFi: Doesn’t like it
Similar to you, I tried everything, powerline, moca, and wifi. The key is using prosumer stuff. I have a multi story house and a single EAP670 is enough to cover the whole house at 450 mbps+ on wifi 6. It has wifi 6E but only my work laptop has it so I keep it off to save power. I had a U6-pro before that but it would degrade to 200 mbps four floors away. I learned so much I probably can be a network engineer at this point. But I think the lowest friction is to go for Firewalla + a prosumer AP like the two mentioned before. For what it’s worth, I run OPNsense.
TP-Link Omada: Likes itUbiquiti UniFi: Doesn’t like it
You need a switch that can handle LAGG but I don’t think you need a particularly expensive or fancy switch. I run a TP-Link jetstream switch that supports LACP and was only $110 (same price as a 8 port lite ubiquti switch). It has 8 port PoE+ AND 2 port SFP. You have to run a omada controller (similar to a unifi controller) but you can buy a box (OC200) or just run a Docker image which is what I do. I find tbe TP-link APs much better performing at a reasonable price too. Ubiquti with their no free shipping and price increases has gone completely out of hand since the pandemic. Made me switch out all their hardware because of it. Ubiquti hardware was simply not worth their price and OPNsense + omada had blown my Ubiquti setup out of the water.
TP-Link Omada: Likes itUbiquiti UniFi: Neutral
Depending on what network gear you're using (I'm now switching to Omada, previously/still on some site son UniFi, but lots of even 'prosumer' stuff does this) there are specific mitigations available. All of this falls under the heading of "managing broadcast traffic", which is very important even for smaller networks. The three major categories of traffic on a network are unicast, broadcast, and multicast. Unicast is the normal case of one device talking to a single address. Broadcast involves sending a packet to every single possible recipient in the entire broadcast domain (almost always the subnet). ARP fits in here. Multicast is essentially in between, more efficient then broadcast, can still talk to multiple devices that have signed up to hear it. Obviously an actual broadcast storm can take down an entire network, but excessive broadcast traffic on WiFi specifically can also suck up a huge amount of airtime for little bandwidth. Every single device has to go to the slowest speed and stop what they're doing to listen and make sure no one is left out. Using STP/RSTP with proper values set and LACP for aggregated interfaces can help prevent inadvertent network loops. Many switches also support some kind of port isolation and explicit per port storm control restricting max numbers of packets/second for unicast/broadcast/multicast traffic. WiFi APs can use proxy ARP to cut it in their domain too. The WAP already of course knows the MACs of every device connected to it by de…
TP-Link Omada: Likes itUbiquiti UniFi: Neutral
I've only used both in home and small office settings, but I found TP-Link's Omada line of APs to be equivalent to Ubiquiti APs. Same type of hardware, same type of controller software you can run on your own machine. I don't know enough about APs to say whether the performance matches.
Switched from the Ubiquiti UniFi to the TP-Link OmadaTP-Link Omada: Likes it
All the complaints about Ubiquiti in this thread from a few months ago dissuaded me from investing in their gear: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44746603 I ended up going with TP-Link Omada and have been happy so far (a managed switch and wifi 6 WAPs). I am a bit concerned about their security track record given how bad their soho products are, so I ended up sticking with my opnsense router at the perimeter as the first line of defense. I’m curious to hear what you think you’re missing out on with Omada.
Switched from the Ubiquiti UniFi to the TP-Link OmadaTP-Link Omada: Recommends it
I use TP link Omada gear and its a been very good replacement to unifi. I use it both personally & manage a side gig venue’s network. I have lots of vlans & even run dante & ndi with no issues. Replaced a Unifi system it was so buggy. DHCP reserve IPs failed, spotty issues with artists phones & the mixer board to mix their in-ears etc. I’ve setup IPSec tunnel to AWS VPC even pretty easy. Using a pi4 for last 4 years on poe running their management docker container. So solid! I’d recommend the pi over buying their hardware device mamager, its way slower.
Switched from the TP-Link Omada to the Ubiquiti UniFiUbiquiti UniFi: Doesn’t like it
So I started seriously using UniFi I think in 2016-ish after using some of their PtP/PtMP stuff for longer. I never ran anything massive peaking at under 200 devices total across various sites, but we did put it pretty hard, and I did enjoy it and find the value proposition excellent. And having said that I'd sound a real note of caution, which is why I've eliminated most of them in favor the same-niche positioned Omada. Ubiquiti turned into a real development dumpster fire, every bad tech trope right from the textbook. They have a long history of introducing constant new hardware that, particular for routing/firewall/gateway services then languishes even as it gets sold new without a single update for ages. Various touted efforts that then got unceremoniously wiped. Really basic core functionality neglected for constant UX churn, let alone useful important new features. "Dumpster fire" has not been an unreasonable descriptor. They've also added a concerning trend towards proprietary lock-in and pushing of cloud, even though to their great credit full local control remains a key selling point. Omada isn't perfect either, and the hardware design is worse, though it's been more reliable and with a lot of basics better locked down for me. I'd be delighted to have two strong competitors there, and there have been a few promising glimmers on UniFi, like PPSK getting some initial attention (4 years late is better than nothing). And certainly the basic switching and WiFi mostly work…
Switched from the Ubiquiti UniFi to the TP-Link OmadaTP-Link Omada: Likes it
From reports online the UDM-SE won’t actually NAT close to 10 Gbps and the manufacturer doesn’t provide any NAT performance numbers…so it becomes a bottle neck if you have 10 Gbps internet which is widely available and not that expensive my part of the world. (Hong Kong). The only reasonably priced router I could find about 6 months ago that would NAT at line speed was the TP-LINK Onada ER8411. I ended up going with an all Oanda network which seems to work fine but ubiquiti had originally been my first choice.