The stuff Hacker News actually recommends.

Consoles and handhelds

Sony PlayStation PS4 vs Sony PlayStation PS5

Hacker News owners lean toward the Sony PlayStation PS5.

Sony PlayStation PS4Sony PlayStation PS5
Owners with an opinion69120
Positive verdicts61% of 5468% of 96
Positive/negative since 20249/1027/12
Happy after 3+ years10
Longest happy owner10 yrs2 yrs
Praised forreliability and ease of useease of use and performance
Criticized forsoftwarevalue and software
Newest comment

Updated

What owners wrote about both

Sony PlayStation PS4: NeutralSony PlayStation PS5: Likes it
One data point: there was no chip shortage at the PS4 launch, but I still waited more than a year to get one because there was little to play on it. While with the PS5 I got one as soon as I could (that still took more than a year since launch, but for chip shortage reasons) because I knew I could simply replace the PS4 with it under the TV and carry on.
Sony PlayStation PS4: Likes itSony PlayStation PS5: Doesn’t like it
> No more fears of developing carpal tunnel for me. Unfortunately, I developed major RSI in my right hand from playing Horizon Forbidden West, to the point that I had to stop playing console games for several months. And I don’t typically have that problem on any other console, including previous PS consoles. There’s something about the shape of the controller in combination with the controls for that game, which requires frequent usage of both R triggers, sometimes in combination with other buttons. Also could be related to the force feedback of the triggers that’s new on PS5 (though it doesn’t seem frequent/strong enough to matter). I never had this same problem with Horizon Zero Dawn on the PS4, even though the controls are mostly the same. I’m not sure I’ll be able to finish Forbidden West.
Sony PlayStation PS4: Doesn’t like itSony PlayStation PS5: Likes it
Back in the PS4 era when I had FIOS gigabit it was incredibly frustrating to have that internet speed with a console which would download things at 10-15Mbit. There were some tweaks which would double it plus or minus a bit, but, it was fundamentally incapable of using anything close to line rate. PS5 is incredibly faster. Sony is using Akamai CDN now (they didn't when I checked in the PS4 era) and I consistently max out the PS5s gigabit port (I have 10G symmetric at home).
Sony PlayStation PS4: NeutralSony PlayStation PS5: Doesn’t like it
I caved and bought a Switch last week. It’s the best tech purchase I’ve made in years! The games on it are fun, the versatility of the Joycons is incredible, and the loading speed is a breath of fresh air. My main console is an original PS4. I upgraded to PS5 last year and returned it. It’s just more of the same. Huge game downloads, huge update downloads, a huge console, and long load times. And tbh, I didn’t see a lot of difference in terms of graphics. If you want to play super realistic games then Nintendo doesn’t seem to be the way to go, but if you want to have fun and don’t care about frame rate/whatever other performance metric people complain about, the Switch is amazing.
Sony PlayStation PS4: NeutralSony PlayStation PS5: Likes it
- For work MacBook Pro, 2020 Intel...I wish this was an M1 but I won't get an upgrade for four years :( - My personal MacBook Pro M1 (love this laptop) - My gaming computer (I mostly use it to play MTGO but I mostly play PS5 nowadays) - My wife's MacBook Air - A tiny Linux box I play around with occasionally. - A Raspberry Pi 400 I've done nothing with. "Sort of computers": Wife and I each have an iPhone 11. Gave her my iPad Pro b/c she plays iPad games a lot and I took her very old iPad b/c I mostly just read books. We share an iPod touch for "just music" (like working out or cooking). Gaming consoles: PS5 + external 5TB HDD, PS4 (mostly a FromSoftware machine for Bloodborne & Sekiro), Switch
Sony PlayStation PS4: Doesn’t like itSony PlayStation PS5: Recommends it
Getting a PS5 consists of signing up for Telegram alerts and waiting for stock alerts. Within 1-3 weeks you’ll snag one. In my opinion it makes sense to be patient for 3 weeks and get a PS5, which will surely be relevant for 5-7 more years. Keep in mind, PS4s are also difficult to find right now. They are still selling at the full $300 retail price if you can even find one, and used on eBay they are $250. Why pay $250 for a console that will stop getting new games this year or next year? Now granted, OP seems to be in a different country so maybe these circumstances are different for them but in the US certainly it does not make sense to buy a PS4, for the same price you can buy an Xbox Series S.
Sony PlayStation PS4: Doesn’t like itSony PlayStation PS5: Doesn’t like it
Something I'd like them to clarify is what happens when Playstation 6 comes out. Will users be able to use their PS5 controllers, including the accessibility controllers, or will they be forced to buy it all over again? Their track record is horrible in that sense. You can use PS4 controllers on PS5 but not for PS5 games, so they don't even have the "technical reasons" excuse.
Sony PlayStation PS4: Likes itSony PlayStation PS5: Likes it
I agree with the sentiment, but in my experience that's just not true. [1] The PS4 and PS5 are nice and pain free. The Switch even more so, because the games will run right off the cartridge without needing updates. They have available updates, but the version shipped on the cartridge is 100% playable. [1] With the exception of the XBox because Microsoft can't get their shit together.