The stuff Hacker News actually recommends.

Consoles and handhelds

Sony PlayStation 5 vs Valve Steam Deck

Hacker News owners lean toward the Valve Steam Deck.

Sony PlayStation 5Valve Steam Deck
Owners with an opinion54700
Positive verdicts57% of 4283% of 623
Positive/negative since 202420/12271/67
Happy after 3+ years02
Longest happy owner–25 yrs
Praised forease of use and performanceperformance and ease of use
Criticized forreliability and valuereliability
Newest comment

Updated

What owners wrote about both

Sony PlayStation 5: Doesn’t like itValve Steam Deck: Likes it
I agree with your point re people not even noticing. There are so many titles with jaw-dropping visuals on PS5 and it's hard to complain. But the numbers are numbers - PS5 isn't suited for 4k native gaming and it's not even close. Perhaps with the new upscaling? I don't know. I've RTX 4090 that is leagues ahead of PS5 and there are games that reach its limits in 4k (see Alan Wake 2 - a great game btw, or Black Myth Wukong). It also boils down to the software part - sadly a lot of games are badly optimized due to laziness. UE5 is getting popular and games made with it have already demonstrated that PS5 may struggle with them. I believe over time PS5 Pro will become the baseline for optimization, leading to more frustrated PS5 owners wanting to upgrade. Speaking of handhelds, Steamdeck is also mind-blowing good.
Sony PlayStation 5: NeutralValve Steam Deck: Likes it
In my experience, the Steam offline mode only works if your computer is actually offline (without any network connection); if you're connected to the local network but the Internet connection from your router is down, it still tries to connect to the authentication servers while starting up.
Sony PlayStation 5: Doesn’t like itValve Steam Deck: Likes it
I’m on the other side. Almost bought a PS5. Or to be more accurate, wanted to buy a PS5, but they were insanely behind with shipping and the little stocks there were got bought up by resellers. Then once Sony managed to get stocks up somewhat, they jacked up the prices (something I don’t recall any other console manufacturer ever doing). I bought a steam deck instead and I’ve been playing basically all I would’ve been playing on the PS5 I wanted to get, plus it’s a nice emulation machine and I’m also catching up on my PC backlog. Compatibility is great in my experience, sleep mode is incredibly convenient, and the only real complaint I have is battery life is basically awful for modern games. You’ll be recharging after any modest length session.
Sony PlayStation 5: Doesn’t like itValve Steam Deck: Likes it
I've been blown away by my Steam Deck. It arrived about 5 days before my long sought after PS5 and basically the PS5 has sat collecting dust. I pre-ordered the Deck thinking I'd sell or trade it for the PS5, that was basically my interest in the device. But after a few days it was clear this was something special. Why? For me it's my 'forever console'. Access to my full Steam Library was one thing, but having basically every retro console at my disposal is unreal. Just last night I played a game of M.U.L.E. and StarRaiders on my Atari800 emulator. That was after a couple of rounds of MarioKart on SNES, then Pilot Wings on 64 and then some Resident Evil 4 on GameCube. I also love that so many older PC games just work on it. I recently replayed the entire Mass Effect Trilogy on it (absolutely the best experience playing that game, something about the controls, the screen and it on my lap was just too fun). Ditto on Dark Souls 1 and 2 which I also just replayed (and yes Eldin Ring runs unreal on it, somehow). The only real surprise is that Dead Space doesn't run on it, I have a hutch they'll get it sorted out (sorta like they did working with FromSoftware on Eldin Ring). Lastly, the other major advantage for me is the ability to return games. This is an unheralded Steam feature that's a really great. I buy games I wouldn't even consider on PS-whatever/Xbox because you're screwed if you don't like it. Hell my 2 year old son managed to buy the new COD on PS5 by mashing the…
Switched from the Sony PlayStation 5 to the Valve Steam DeckValve Steam Deck: Likes it
It's honestly my favourite gaming device, even though I still think it's way too big and that the screen is...not great(quality wise, not resolution). But the price beats everything else and the software is top notch, it allowed me to play more games and enjoy them more than my very fancy gaming PC, PS5 and Xbox combined. I'm definitely preordering Deck 2 the second it's announced.
Switched from the Sony PlayStation 5 to the Valve Steam DeckValve Steam Deck: Doesn’t like it
I'm the exact opposite. I got the deck, had a honeymoon period of maybe five days, then I went back to the PS5. The deck is heavier than the Switch, louder than the Switch (which makes no sound at all), gets hotter than the Switch (which doesn't get hot at all), has a screen that is inferior to the new one on the OLED Switch, and has the buttons in such an awkward position that I get cramps in my hand after half an hour of playing. BUT YOU CAN PLAY ELDEN RING, you would say now. Yeah nah. All those AAA titles run like ass and/or look like ass on the deck. It's just not a feasible device for anything. For high-end titles, the PS5 wins out always. For indie titles, the Switch wins out, always. I guess it's a really cool device for hackers who just want to mess around, though.
Sony PlayStation 5: Doesn’t like itValve Steam Deck: Doesn’t like it
So I randomly ended up buying a lot of computer gear last year because I killed a perfectly fine 4 year old PC and couldn't decide what I wanted to replace it. I thought at the time "this is an expensive mistake" but you look at the prices I paid for parts a year ago and it's mind-blowing eg: - 4TB Samsung Pro 990 SSD for $150 (now $940) - 64GB DDR kit for a laptop $180 (now $700) - 64GB DDR5 CL30 kit for a desktop $200 (now $950) - 9800X3D/5070Ti PC $1800 - 2TB Samsung Pro 990 $95 I think? I honestly don't even remember why I bought this It's really depressing now. Normally at this point in the NViida product cycle we'd be expected a 50x0 Super series. I think it's all but confirmed we won't see those until next year. I think the 50x0 series will last a lot longer than the 40x0 series. So it's going to be interesting to see what happens when this hits phone makers who also need RAM. There certainly won't be a RAM increase this year and there'll likely be a price bump. Apple may be able to absorb this to some degree because of anyone I expect them to have long term contracts. Still, Apple has temporarily delisted the base 16GB Mac Mini and removed the 512GB Mac Studio so they aren't unaffected. But I think this SSD/RAM price hike has basically killed the Steam Machine, which is sad. Valve obviously didn't lock in long-term contracts before announcing it. Woops. The Steam Deck is also a hard find as a result. We've seen an almost unprecedented price hike on the PS5, which is a…