The stuff Hacker News actually recommends.

Phones

Samsung Galaxy Note vs Samsung Galaxy S

No clear winner: owners rate them about the same.

Samsung Galaxy NoteSamsung Galaxy S
Owners with an opinion88449
Positive verdicts72% of 7563% of 368
Positive/negative since 202414/9107/71
Happy after 3+ years942
Longest happy owner10 yrs12 yrs
Praised forperformance and ease of useperformance and reliability
Criticized forreliability and supportsoftware
Newest comment

Updated

What owners wrote about both

Samsung Galaxy Note: Likes itSamsung Galaxy S: Doesn’t like it
I dropped my flagship Samsung S24U one time. I was running and it slipped out of my back pocket. That 1 meter fall resulted in calls unable to be placed, USB charging and ABD does not work, and the microphone for the voice recorder does not work. All that indicates that the daughterboard cable was displaced. But the unworking rear camera indicates that there is a second fault in there as well. Not to mention the alarmingly large dent in the corner, that shattered the screen protector and likely would have resulted in the screen itself having shattered if no protector were on it. New phones are designed to break. Contrast with my Note 3 that I carried for 8 years without so much as cracking the screen once.
Samsung Galaxy Note: Likes itSamsung Galaxy S: Doesn’t like it
i have good memories of my Note 3. samsung was pretty cool back then. i bought some galaxy s 5 years ago for a lot of money, then it got splashed with water and died. stupid waste of money. i've had my current oppo for 3+ years and he's a trooper, and it was about half the price of a similar-spec samsung. samsung is overpriced shit.
Samsung Galaxy Note: Doesn’t like itSamsung Galaxy S: Likes it
My small army of old android devices are plugged into a USB 'charging station' (multiple USB charging ports off a single plastic device) which in plugged into a smart switch. The smart switch turns on for a couple of hours overnight, to keep the phones charged at least minimally. Most of the devices also have a custom ROM and are rooted, and using the ACCA app I restrict charging to a maximum of 80% battery capacity. I had a Samsung Note 5 (released in 2015) that only went spicy maybe 6 months ago. I have a Samsung S9 and a Nokia 6.1 that are both still going strong with fairly recent versions of LineageOS. Both are 2018 phones, so around 6.5 years old (old for phones, but shouldn't be 'electronically' old).
Samsung Galaxy Note: NeutralSamsung Galaxy S: Likes it
Curious how you're finding it so far? I mowed my Note20 Ultra in June of last year and replaced it with a 14 Pro Max then just last month went and swapped back to an S24 Ultra. I found Apple to be too restrictive. The OS level stuff was one thing but the app store lacking things like emulators or vape apps because "Apple said so" rubbed me the wrong way, whether I need them or not. Plus I like writing python on my phone.
Samsung Galaxy Note: Doesn’t like itSamsung Galaxy S: Likes it
> On the other, basic expected computational features such as night mode are missing. Oh, how fast is progress in the world of technology. I remember 6 years ago when google showed some prototypes of night photo from a smartphone using long expose. Meanwhile my Galaxy Note 4 made blurry unusable mess during the 14th of july nightly event I tried it at, while my gf DLSR were clear and great. Ah ah, smartphones will never be able to do that. How 4 years ago Night Sight blew me away with their demonstration and almost made me go pixel. How 3 years ago Samsung added a Night mode to my S9+ through a regular update and while the photo took a whole second to take the result was usually clean and crisp compared to the noisy mess on my previous Note 4, making it actually usable for static scene or portrait shot. How the night mode on my S21 Plus was genuinely great to the point it was just another mode as long as you avoid the usual night tricks like light sources. How my new S22 Ultra for the first time passed my "smartphone will never really be good for night event shots" by taking picture during the 14th of july fireworks the quality of which I would scientifically classify as "pretty fucking great". And now it's just a basic expected computational feature. Sometime we forget how much progress is being made due to how incremental they all are, but damn, and that's just one feature on a piece of glass and plastic that's insanely powerful and filled with features in my pocket. PS: th…
Samsung Galaxy Note: Doesn’t like itSamsung Galaxy S: Doesn’t like it
>That reminds me of my own Samsung Galaxy SII. Shipped out of the box with Android 2.3, Samsung supported it up until Android 4.1 Even that was amazing for Samsung's standards back then. For example my former Samsung Note II shipped with Android 4.1.1 Jellybean and they only supported it till 4.4.2 KitKat. Just let that sink in. I basically bought a flagship e-waste device. Custom ROMs didn't help much since you'd lose S-pen functionality if you went past 4.4.2 as modders couldn't port the needed firmware blobs past that kernel or something like that, OH, and also Knox efuses could brick your wifi, that is your the phone wouldn't brick itself due to the FW bug in Samsung's eMMC that would lock itself to read-only mode out of nowhere.
Samsung Galaxy Note: Likes itSamsung Galaxy S: Likes it
My experience with my own pixel 7 pro and a pixel 5 has been that these devices are an order of magnitude lower in build quality than Samsung or iPhones. I really, really wanted to be happy with them but they've been a never ending source of frustration. My pixel 5 just stopped turning on one day about 2 years in, and my pixel 7 pro had the volume and power buttons fall out about 3 weeks in (not due to a drop, after googling it's apparently a very widely seen issue). The service with iFixit was unhelpful, they told me "We keep seeing this and Google says this is wear and tear. We can't submit it for a warranty repair, and if we try we end up eating the cost". After finally complaining on twitter I was contacted by some support person who said to give iFixit this email and they would fix it. They still refused, and after a few more rounds of interactions like that I eventually bought some replacement buttons on Amazon, popped them in, and put a case that covers them on it. I'm fully expecting this to randomly die some time before 2 years is up. Combine that with Google's extremely strong tendency to abandon everything, promises like these seem well, worthless. Meanwhile my daughter is using my wife's old iPhone from 8 years ago. My Samsung note 3 and my s8 still boot up and work just fine (though I cracked the screen on one about 5 years ago). It's just so obvious that these phones are very low priority to Google, while other companies base their business around their phones.
Samsung Galaxy Note: Doesn’t like itSamsung Galaxy S: Doesn’t like it
I think that Android has burned too many users in weird ways. For example, I recently convinced my father to switch to iPhone after 4 years of Android. Why? The first phone he got was a Galaxy S7 (Snapdragon). After just a year it was extremely slow, crashing all the time, overheating... which turned out to actually be a very, very common problem with the processor (Snapdragon 820). It was Qualcomm's first stab at a 64-bit processor and it showed. Well... try, try again. Galaxy Note 9. After a year, super slow at everything, even though all he does is browse internet and check emails. Even the Microsoft Outlook app would crash loading Inbox 25% of the time with no other apps open. Battery replacement and factory reset didn't help at all. A few months after that, it started dropping Verizon phone calls at random. Turns out that was another flaw widely reported on their forums, specifically on Verizon, with a botched software update installation for the modem, that if you were unfortunate enough to install, could not be removed or repaired or factory reset. And, of course, Samsung wasn't pushing any updates to fix it. Kind of a really big deal when you are a small business owner. So iPhone 13 he went. A year and a half later and it doesn't drop calls.
Samsung Galaxy Note: Likes itSamsung Galaxy S: Likes it
I've used LineageOS to revive a Samsung Galaxy S4 and a Note 3, they work pretty well. The installation is easy. That said, you might encounter bugs on your particular device which may or may not be a big deal for you. I have had some issues with GPS accuracy and Bluetooth connections from the S4 to a certain device occasionally dropping out, but I haven't done careful before/after tests so these may be hardware problems. I would recommend giving the LineageOS a try, at least before replacing the phone, if that's the path you want to take.
Samsung Galaxy Note: Likes itSamsung Galaxy S: Likes it
It was perfect for the time. It's definitely lacking in features today, which is by definition true of any phone from that era. I still have them both with me and in active use - mostly as remote controls, kids games, etc. Perhaps more pertinently, my daily driver is a Galaxy Note 8, which also has a 3.5mm jack and MicroSD card. There's really nothing that my 4-generations newer, work-mandated iPhone has, in terms of functionality and definitely battery life, that Note 8 does not. iPhones are about sexy impracticality, and that's clearly where market has gone (Unlike S2 & S5, Note 8 also cannot be held without a case) - I'm just a old grouch who misses the olden days :).
Samsung Galaxy Note: Doesn’t like itSamsung Galaxy S: Doesn’t like it
I'd love a small Android phone, with one caveat: A built-in stylus. I'm stuck with the huge Samsung Note series, or the Samsung S22 which is no smaller. I've used external stylii and my fingers too, but absolutely nothing comes close to the experience of just sliding out the stylus which is always there and using it.
Samsung Galaxy Note: Doesn’t like itSamsung Galaxy S: Doesn’t like it
> My Samsung Galaxy Note 2 and S2 are still working. My Galaxy S4 and Note 4 were working quite fine ~18 months later, but only technically. They were aggravatingly slow and I was factory-resetting them each every 3 months, also rooted them and de-bloated them quite thoroughly. This rejuvenated them for a while but then some mere 1-2 months later they were back to a crawl. We can throw anecdotal evidence around until the end of time but to say older Samsung are working only applies in very strict dictionary terms and not what an average user would find acceptable (f.ex. various functions were routinely taking 2-3 seconds before the device responded). Several acquaintances had the same experiences.
Samsung Galaxy Note: Likes itSamsung Galaxy S: Likes it
Nexus were never premium. It was cheap-ish high-end SoC best demonstration of Android OS. However, Pixels are definitely meant to be flagships, and IMO they are still not worth that name. Anecdata: my Samsung Galaxy Note 2 fell quite literally hundred times more than my Pixel 5 (I was very clumsy/drunk by then, and got better), and is still perfectly alive , while my Pixel 5's display broke very easily (it's not even the glass that is broken, it's some internal circuitry). Maybe phones were to be tougher back then? Well, I also have a Samsung Galaxy S10e, it survived many falls just fine (well it does seem a tad worse than my Galaxy Note 2, because paint goes off where it fell).
Samsung Galaxy Note: Likes itSamsung Galaxy S: Likes it
I agree with the premise of the article, that software becomes more important than hardware at some point in the future. The only two phones I have owned are a Galaxy S3 and a Note 4: Samsung makes great hardware, but disabling bloat and waiting for Android updates is not good. I am almost two years past my trade up date, but the Note 4 keeps satisfying. I had intended to try an iPhone next, since I like my iPad and MacBook, but the S8 definitely has me tempted to stay with Samsung. The screen, with almost no bezel, is the selling point for me.