The stuff Hacker News actually recommends.

Boards and maker kit

Raspberry Pi 4 vs Raspberry Pi 5

Hacker News owners lean toward the Raspberry Pi 4.

Raspberry Pi 4Raspberry Pi 5
Owners with an opinion20670
Positive verdicts73% of 15662% of 58
Positive/negative since 202447/2231/22
Happy after 3+ years40
Longest happy owner4 yrs1 yrs
Praised forreliability and performanceperformance and value
Criticized forease of usereliability
Newest comment

Updated

What owners wrote about both

Raspberry Pi 4: NeutralRaspberry Pi 5: Doesn’t like it
I've used it with the Coral EdgeTPU and Hailo. These have worked very well. What hasn't worked the greatest is the video transcoding, but that's mostly my fault. The first mistake was thinking that the Raspberri Pi would be suitable for this. The Raspberry Pi 5 seems like a good choice, but unfortunately, it lacks video encoding. The Raspberry Pi 4 has both encoding and decoding, but no PCIe interface for the EdgeTPU and Hailo. It is possible to use the USB EdgeTPU, but anything more than a few camera streams will not go well with the Raspberry Pi. My results with an Intel N100 have been much better, but I also made another mistake. I had issues where some videos were not recorded, and I think this has to do with me not using small video sizes for monitoring vs. larger ones for recording. Everything was large, and that's probably why the N100 couldn't keep up with 5 cameras. I can't confirm it because that system's disk died and it hasn't yet been restored. I'm interested to try Frigate with OpenVINO on the Intel Arc GPU. I have a Minisform MS-01 that should be able to transcode more camera streams. It will be interesting to see how the stronger iGPU fares vs. the Coral EdgeTPU.
Raspberry Pi 4: Likes itRaspberry Pi 5: Doesn’t like it
I think the RPi 4 is still competitive. At ~40$, Orange Pi's boards are Allwinner H618 and Rockchip RK3566 based boards. I do have an Orange Pi 3B in use because it has an nvme port, but the RPi 4 is generally faster. The Raspberry Pi 5 and Orange Pi 5 are just too expensive. I do have some of the Pi 5s from both these companies, but have replaced them with Intel N100 mini-PCs instead. But I'll still use RPi 4's for my 3d printers and other lower-end uses. And RPi's software support is just better: I've got an Orange Pi 4. Orange Pi hasn't updated their OS for it in years. Last time I tried to get it working in Armbian, HDMI output was (is?) broken: https://forum.armbian.com/topic/26818-opi-4-lts-no-hdmi-outp...
Raspberry Pi 4: Likes itRaspberry Pi 5: Doesn’t like it
Over at AliExpress there are tons of options, like this[1] or this[2] fun 4x M.2 box. Yes they're about twice the price of a bare Pi5, but they come with metal cases and power supplies, can fit an M.2 NVME without add-ons, and like the first example also includes some RAM and storage. While likely not the best quality RAM and storage, what I got in mine has held up to light use for several months so far without issues, so better than nothing. YMMV. I bought a few 2GB RPi4's when they were $35. At that price point they were great. I don't get the RPi5, especially 4GB+ variants. [1]: https://www.aliexpress.com/item/1005007511663921.html [2]: https://www.aliexpress.com/item/1005007900081466.html
Raspberry Pi 4: Likes itRaspberry Pi 5: Doesn’t like it
You completely missed my point. We already had the RPi4, and it was sold for $35 for the 2GB model. It was perfect at that. I had enough grunt, and 2GB was enough for a lot of use-cases. I still use mine for a lot of various tasks. One is my GPS-driven NTP server for example. Don't need lots of RAM for that, but do need the GPIOs. What I said was, I don't get the RPi5 value proposition. It's fairly expensive so not just something you throw at simple tasks like an NTP server without consideration. If you need grunt and RAM, well, why not just pay a bit more and get tons more of that? You get more PCIe, you get way more RAM, CPU and GPU, in a form factor that's not that much larger. And it's x86 so you're not facing the kernel support issues like OrangePi and friends. In my experience, there's very little overlap between "need hardware GPIO pins" and "need 8+GB of RAM and/or lots of compute".
Raspberry Pi 4: Doesn’t like itRaspberry Pi 5: Likes it
The Pi4 1GB is $35. The Pi4 4GB is $55, and Pi5 4GB is $60 It is only the Pi5 8GB that is $80. The Pi Zero is even cheaper, $15 for Pi Zero W. The advantage of the Raspberry Pi is the software. Raspbian just works and will continue to work. Other SBC might not work with their software and who knows if it will ever be updated. My understanding is that there are stable OSes for other boards, but then have to find boards that work. I recently got Pi5 to use as computer, and microPC is probably better for that. But the Pi can be repurposed for other uses. I'm pretty sure I can pull the microSD card from Pi4 and put in Pi5 and it will just work. The Pi4, which is an awful computer, will do some thing that microPC can't possibly do.
Raspberry Pi 4: Likes itRaspberry Pi 5: Doesn’t like it
I enjoy using the R.Pi 4 and R.Pi 400 and from the start I've been a supporter of this class of relatively inexpensive Linux-first device. But the R.Pi 4x series is peak R.Pi for me. In the last couple of years, NUC -class SFF devices with Intel-based chipsets have appeared [1] and they offer a much better performance profile (speed, power consumption) than the R.Pi 5. Some of these devices offer dual gigabit Ethernet. [1] Liliputing is one site that I follow for related information.
Raspberry Pi 4: Doesn’t like itRaspberry Pi 5: Doesn’t like it
100% with you on the IO. I've never even wanted two display output ports with any raspberry pi. You know what I do want though? An actual damn HDMI port! HDMI cables are everywhere, wherever I am I have unlimited options to connect an HDMI device to some kind of screen. But micro HDMI? The literal only thing in my life that uses it is the Raspberry Pi 4 and 5. There have been plenty of times where I've reached for a Pi 3b instead of a 4 or 5 just because I didn't have a micro HDMI cable. I do not understand what has gone through their head. How could anyone look at the use case for a Raspberry Pi and decide that two micro HDMI ports is a better choice than one HDMI port? I don't understand it. Like you, my experience with the Pi is that they mostly just sit there, headless, so the only reason I need display output is that it's useful during setup (because they don't have a proper serial console port). I can't set up a Pi 4 or 5 without going hunting for that micro HDMI cable I bought specifically for that purpose and never use for anything else. I can set up a Pi 3b anywhere, at any time.
Raspberry Pi 4: Likes itRaspberry Pi 5: Likes it
Sounds interesting (but a bit above my pay grade). AWS uses a streaming tech called NICE DCV which runs in a browser (chromium) on my raspberry pi. I was using a RP 4 before, but the performance is noticeably better with the RP 5.