The stuff Hacker News actually recommends.

Boards and maker kit

Raspberry Pi 3 vs Raspberry Pi 4

No clear winner: owners rate them about the same.

Raspberry Pi 3Raspberry Pi 4
Owners with an opinion71206
Positive verdicts75% of 5573% of 156
Positive/negative since 202414/547/22
Happy after 3+ years24
Longest happy owner9 yrs4 yrs
Praised forperformance and reliabilityreliability and performance
Criticized forease of useease of use
Newest comment

Updated

What owners wrote about both

Raspberry Pi 3: Likes itRaspberry Pi 4: Neutral
I have a 4 with a huge ass passive heatsink on at home. It's my minecraft server when I feel like it. The heatsink is uncomfortable to touch (it's not in a case). Pretty sure it would downclock if i removed it. So it works without a fan, but not without a heatsink (I bet the keyboards have a heatsink for the Pis built in.). A 3 would have worked fine without any heatsink at all. At least at normal room temperature.
Raspberry Pi 3: NeutralRaspberry Pi 4: Likes it
I am running a hypervisor ( https://blogs.vmware.com/arm/2023/12/15/esxi-arm-fling-1-15-... ) on my Raspberry Pi 4. Rock solid. Currently running virtual machines: * Home Assistant ( https://home-assistant.io/ ) - with USB passthrough of USB stick to read out my digital electricity/gas meters, Zigbee and Z-Wave * Homebridge (to allow my Eufy video doorbell to work with Homekit) * Pihole All are running from iSCSI storage served by my Synology NAS. I am running an older Pi (3) on demand in my garden as a client for my media server to play music on garden speakers.
Raspberry Pi 3: Doesn’t like itRaspberry Pi 4: Likes it
I did have a disconnect issue with CAN bus on a Pi 3 though. Swapping out the Pi 3 for a Pi 4 fixed it using the same install/SD card. I even swapped back to test and it disconnected an hour into a print again. A 30$ Le Potato is still more than the 25$ Raspberry Pi 3A+. Which I like for it's smaller size. A single USB port isn't too big a deal if you get a CSI Pi Camera for monitoring instead of USB.
Raspberry Pi 3: Doesn’t like itRaspberry Pi 4: Neutral
As the Pi got more powerful it moved into more areas. Some unassociated commercially based solutions now have "..or run on a pi if you have one" where you're really paying for some service fee or s/w costs (plex for instance) -they target other devices too of course. If the Pi CM4 came with more motherboards which did PCIx4 (Taco from RADXA, the rockpi people) then you'd see it being used as the foundation for NAS builds and the like. Right now, Aside from the taco, I don't know what I can buy which exposes the PCI bus in a way I can buy semi-random cards to do eg SATA and work them reliably. Or some PCIx4 function which might suit another role. I've found myself looking at breakout daughtercards for the M.2 slots (or whatever it is, which maps PCI into that format) -most of them seem to come with consequences: its not as fast as the single bus speed suggests if you multiplex anything behind them. And, booting off devices which live on the M.2 slot sometimes seems painful from the write-ups: you have to fenagle the /Pi boot state to respect that device as a boot device. Same with the CM4, there's a lot of "be brave and know how to do things with uboot" about driving that in any way more than the simple. Pi "Clones" now mean they do uBoot and they have the GPIO grid. pretty much everything else is not necessarily very much like a Pi. Really? I think it's become "ARM core as a service" combined with some industry standard/semi-standard IO choices. I'm running one Pi4 as a NAS,…
Raspberry Pi 3: Likes itRaspberry Pi 4: Doesn’t like it
While a Pi can be used to browse the internet a bit and write some text, i would not want to endure the low performance for anything even slightly more heavy weight. I absolutely hate to wait for slow compile times, long startup times, slow disk writes and laggy browsers. All of which you will get on a Pi. The sad truth is that for no reason a lot of modern software is super bloated and eats resources like crazy. And you can not avoid those in work related environments. Things like elastic search, a bunch of docker containers, an IDE, multiple browsers, Thunderbird, Slack and so on... must run in parallel without any hiccup. And my case it has to drive at least 2 monitors, without any complaints, all while video conferencing is running. My base memory usage is around at 10-15 gb all the time (i am using ubuntu with awesome wm) good luck cramming that in the 8gb of the Pi and a swap on a SD card (hope you got an SSD). Modern computers are super silent anyway so who cares if the Pi is quieter than the AC or the cars outside the window. As it stands Pi are ridiculously expensive nowadays so there is really no reason to put up with a subpar solution. Just get a cheap (used) workstation or mini PC which costs the same and is multiple times as powerful. If it is too loud replace the fans with silent ones those are cheap too... My Pi3 is now driving my 3d Printer which is a more appropriate use case. And my Pi4 collects dust behind the TV because it is a bit too slow to serve as a…
Raspberry Pi 3: Likes itRaspberry Pi 4: Likes it
Raspberry Compute Module (basically a normal raspberry without built-in I/O) is widely used in the industry at large. What they are not meant to be is the lowest cost per CPU/GPU flops so they are mostly used in high-value-add / low-volume / gen-1 products. https://www.raspberrypi.com/products/compute-module-5/?varia... I personally worked on a system with raspberry compute modules 3 and 4, the total system cost was in the ~million dollar range. This was definitely a commercial product with dozens of engineers doing R&D, not a hobby project. We were looking into smaller systems with lower profit margins (~20k USD) and for those we were considering moving away from raspberry CMs because of cost. The main advantage of the raspberry CM ecosystem is just how widely popular it is and how cheap and available "dev boards" are (just grab a non-CM raspberry and it is almost the same thing). Most of these types of systems don't really have the I/O that makes testing and developing a lot easier. Being popular is quite important because firmware issues are notoriously expensive to troubleshoot and fix often requiring the manufacturer help. Said manufacturer does not give a damn if you are a low-volume customer. More popular systems have more information available online and are less likely to have bugs (or at least the bugs are known). I remember one of our other systems bluetooth module had a weird edgecase bug that caused the module to shutdown after several days of it being powered…
Raspberry Pi 3: Likes itRaspberry Pi 4: Likes it
I've used them for mostly dedicated tasks, at least the Rpi3 and older. I've used the Rpi3 as a CUPS server in a couple of sites, for a few printers. Been running for many years now 24/7 with no issues. As I could buy those SBCs for the original low price and the installation was a total no-brainer, I would never consider using any kind of mini PC for that. I have a couple of RPI4 with 8GB and 4GB RAM respectively, these I have been using as kind-of general computers (they're running off SSDs instead of SD cards). I've had no reason so far to replace them with anything Intel/AMD.
Raspberry Pi 3: NeutralRaspberry Pi 4: Neutral
I have used OpenBSD on first a Raspberry Pi 3 and then 4. I liked it, until one day the system stopped responding on either SSH and the serial port, so I had to cut the power to reboot. That's fine, these things happen, but I lost several system files in the process and I couldn't figure out which ones. I only noticed because some things no longer worked and there were some files in /usr's lost+found. OpenBSD's file system does not have journalling. Their closest equivalent, soft updates, was removed some versions ago, so that they can add journalling later. Until that happens, I will install OpenBSD anywhere again. That's a shame because apart from that, it really is a good operating system. The documentation is excellent and there are some great services in base. I much prefer OpenSMTPD over Postfix, for example, because it's just a lot simpler and I don't feel unsure if I've missed some option that I really needed to change for the system to be secure.
Raspberry Pi 3: Doesn’t like itRaspberry Pi 4: Doesn’t like it
Just a note to anyone interested in trying out Home Assistant: It's amazing _but_ do NOT use a raspberry pi to run it. Save yourself a ton of headaches and buy a mini pc (there was a list of used mini pcs posted here yesterday from ebay). Also I recommend using HAOS (or whatever the "we install and run the whole OS" option is called) so that you can use things like plugins without messing around with docker. I love docker but trust me, life is easier on HAOS. I liked HA but felt like it wasn't really "stable". I used a Pi 3 for a while, then a Pi 4 decked out (highest ram, NVME storage, super nice case, etc) and still felt like it was unstable. I chalked this up to HA but then rolled the dice on a Beelink mini pc and it has been rock solid ever since. Also don't be misled by the lower price of the Pi, I paid more for my Pi 4 setup than the Beelink (or about the same). I blamed everything from the Zigbee/Z-wave dongles, to HAOS, to HA itself, etc but in the end it was RPi. The 4 was the last Pi I'll ever buy. EDIT: I was in a hurry and didn't add my normal disclaimer when I talk about the RPi's: Yes I know some of you have a Pi 1 that been running you entire life since it first came out and you think I'm full of crap. I've owned every Pi 1-4 and never been truly happy with them. I bought them "raw" and sourced all the parts myself, I bought high-end (at least in price) kits with everything included, I bought all official accessories (like power), they always were just that lit…
Raspberry Pi 3: Doesn’t like itRaspberry Pi 4: Doesn’t like it
When the first Raspberry Pis came out I was in love. It was incredible, a full (headless) computer that was small and cheap. I played with it for a while but never had a great long-term use case for it. I bought pretty much every Pi up to the 4, always trying to find a place it could occupy in my life but never really managed to find a good use. I ran Home Assistant on a 3 then later on 4 (with a super nice case, NVME hat+stick, etc) but HA was not super stable. I, wrongly, blamed it on the HA software for a long time then I bought a Beelink mini computer and moved HA to it and I have literally not thought about HA since, it's worked flawlessly. Maybe I had bad luck, maybe I happened to get 6 (I had multiple of certain Pis) defective boards but they always felt "unstable" to me. They might run fine for months then randomly need to be rebooted. I'm sure some of you will say "I've had a Raspberry Pi 1 running constantly since I bought it and it's rock solid", good for you, that was not my experience. During COVID (maybe before as well) it came out that the company was prioritizing bulk sales over sales to individuals (or rather sales to companies that resold to individuals) which soured me. This news just further confirms my belief that the company and product I loved is dead and probably has been for some time. It was nice while it lasted.
Raspberry Pi 3: Doesn’t like itRaspberry Pi 4: Doesn’t like it
I have a couple of home automation projects that use Raspberry Pi boards and rely on BLE. One thing I’ve found is the onboard Bluetooth is pretty awful on the Pi 3 and not very good on the Pi 4. Switching to use a Bluetooth dongle made a huge difference with stability and reliability. I no longer had to continually run scripts to try to reset kernel drivers or the entire Bluetooth stack when things got cranky (which seemed to happen many times a day). As a bonus I got a Class 1 adapter that would let me tweak the power output.
Raspberry Pi 3: Doesn’t like itRaspberry Pi 4: Doesn’t like it
The Raspberry Pi 4 has separate USB hubs: one for WiFi and ethernet (an internal hub), and another for external USB ports. The USB port service loop will run with higher priority, so there doesn't seem to be any serious adverse affect. The same isn't true for SD card access, which does cause dropouts. I've seen a video that suggests that disabling power management for the SD card hardware will correct the problem -- specifically that changing power state causes a 3ms delay. But I'm not quite sure how to go about disabling that on a Raspberry Pi OS. . WiFi doesn't seem to affect audio latency. That's not true for Raspberry Pi 3, where WiFi and USB ports do run on the same USB hub.
Raspberry Pi 3: Doesn’t like itRaspberry Pi 4: Doesn’t like it
This is almost exactly where I'm at. Amazon has quite a few ridiculously cheap refurbished units of Dell OptiPlex Micro, Lenovo M series, and Intel Nuc products. The Raspberry Pis I have (3 and 4) are impossible to use as a desktop, and they are actually ill-suited for embedded cases due to their power draw.
Raspberry Pi 3: Likes itRaspberry Pi 4: Likes it
I had trouble with that on the original models, even with a good (or at least official) power supply (many reported the issue was worse with cheaper USB power sources). Never had trouble with the 3 that was a Kodi box and latterly has been used for some electronics experiments, the 4 that is my current Kodi box, or the 400 that has been playing as router+firewall+VPN since early this year (at the time getting a 3 or 4 for the job would have been either expensive or near impossible, and I didn't want to try a potentially less well supported option, but I spotted a nice offer on a 400).
Raspberry Pi 3: NeutralRaspberry Pi 4: Neutral
My goal is with self-hosted is to simplify some tooling, but not necessarily replace Google/MS/etc. More of a quick way to switch things if I have to. At home: - Miniflux - rss, much nicer than ttrss, less complicated - FoundryVTT - Tabletop RPG system to play remote games with some friends around the country - Seafile - mostly use it for an imgur/filesharing solution, but can also double as a dropbox alternative. I dont like nextcloud. - Portiner - manage my docker stuff easily - Caddy - simple reverse proxy - Syncthing - Mostly for sycnthing my local code worksapces, and MMO configs/settings between my computers at home. - HomeAssistant - handle mostly Zigbee stuff, and some motion sensor lights over the baby changing table at night. Rigged a ESP32 board with ESPHome and it connected it to a string of faerie lights. Turns on when you walk in with the baby in the middle of the night without blinding you. And some other odds and ends. Still use Google Home and Google Nest devices for most things. - Authentik - Oauth2, OIDC, SAML provider for my domain. Third party: - ImprovMX - This hosts my email domain/smtp, which allows me to do mx forwarding for my emails to any provider. I still use Gmail under the hood, but lets me skip out on the Google workplace nonsense (used to have a grandfathered free account, then paid for a while), while still keeping my email nimble. I can switch to any email provider in mins with no downtime if caught fast enough. - Tailscale - I like the wire…