The stuff Hacker News actually recommends.

Phones

Pine64 PinePhone vs Purism Librem 5

No clear winner: owners rate them about the same.

Pine64 PinePhonePurism Librem 5
Owners with an opinion13728
Positive verdicts25% of 11236% of 25
Positive/negative since 202411/495/10
Happy after 3+ years12
Longest happy owner4 yrs6 yrs
Praised forease of use and repairabilitysoftware and ease of use
Criticized forperformance and reliabilityperformance and battery
Newest comment

Updated

What owners wrote about both

Pine64 PinePhone: Likes itPurism Librem 5: Doesn’t like it
I can't believe people still buy the Purism scam after all these years...I ordered a Librem 5 and a Pinephone back in the days of the other supply chain story(Covid). The Pinephone flew in from China in less than 2 months; the Librem 5 took more than 4 years to arrive. All Purism offered during that time were "opportunities" to invest and exhausting delay stories about failing supply chains, while keeping their customers completely in the dark about their order state. Instead of preying on the goodwill of FOSS enthousiasts, they now try to tap into a new market (nationalism) to sell the same useless overpriced brick to.
Pine64 PinePhone: Doesn’t like itPurism Librem 5: Doesn’t like it
I actually have one that does. But you're making my point for me: that's how bad they are as phones. A laptop with an iffy phone situation would at least be a highly useful laptop, if nothing else. A PinePhone or Librem 5 is just kind of meh-to-bad at almost everything.
Pine64 PinePhone: Recommends itPurism Librem 5: Recommends it
Alternatively you could use a GNU/Linux phone (Librem 5 or Pinephone), which allows to freely choose the OS and supports ordinary mobile use cases. It is small, but if you connect a screen and keyboard, you get the full PC.
Pine64 PinePhone: Likes itPurism Librem 5: Likes it
> (correct me if I'm wrong) the only companies that offer bootloader unlocking is Google Pixels, Motorola, Nothing, and OnePlus Pinephone and Librem 5 (my daily driver) do not have a locked bootloader in the first place. They are just little (GNU/)Linux computers.
Pine64 PinePhone: Likes itPurism Librem 5: Likes it
> It can barely handle basic web browsing I don't understand what you're talking about. SXMo ( https://sxmo.org/ ) is fast on Pinephone. Even Phosh is pretty usable. Firefox with NoScript is more than good enough to browse web sites with pictures. Also, Librem 5 is much faster than Pinephone, and I've been using it as a daily driver for quite some time already.
Pine64 PinePhone: Recommends itPurism Librem 5: Recommends it
> only 20 community supported devices You realize it's a result of reverse-engineering done by volunteers? To me it looks like a large number actually. The main hurdle for true "Linux Phone" is the lack of free drivers and specs, such that volunteers must spend tremendous efforts to make basic things work. > which Linux phone should I buy and how could I contribute to its success? To help Linux ecosystem on mobile, you could support vendors who intentionally provide free drivers or specs and help improve the software running on their devices. AFAIK only Pinephone and Librem 5 fit here. The former is in stock from time to time. Also many users of GNU/Linux phones run Phosh developed by Purism. Helping to improve it would help the whole community.
Pine64 PinePhone: Doesn’t like itPurism Librem 5: Doesn’t like it
> there were no VoLTE implementations in common use other than stuffs on Android What's wrong with the Android one - is it not permissively licensed? I think the biggest problem of Linux phones is the community's obsession with trying (and failing) to reimplement (multiple times, in parallel) things that Android does really well and can be used as-is. That's why the PinePhone or Librem 5 still can't even match the usability (at basic things like phone or camera or battery life) of a 2010-era Android phone, despite having similar hardware. You want a Linux phone that actually works? Start with an AOSP-based phone and provide manufacturer-approved root and escape hatch such as first-party terminal and Wayland/X server app to run Linux apps. Over time, you can slowly replace Android components with their Linux desktop counterparts when they're ready (or the other way around - the Android bits can just be the commonly-accepted solution to specific problems in Linux - even desktop - distros), but at least you're starting from a solid base.
Pine64 PinePhone: Doesn’t like itPurism Librem 5: Doesn’t like it
Things like the PinePhone and the Librem 5 are cool on paper but if you can’t use it reliably as a phone, it can’t reliably work in standby, the camera sucks, the battery life is anemic, notifications suck, you can’t stream music from it, and the best thing you can say is “I can ssh into it,” which is cool for sure but I can do that (albeit with limitations) using iSH on iOS and is possible to enable on a number of Android distros. And I fully understand that that isn’t the point. The point is the hard work that has gone into this and the selective-amounts of “freedom” (if we convince ourselves that the modems and firmware in these things being absolutely not free software or open doesn’t to a certain extent obviate the entire thought experiment) you get versus another platform. I get it. I’m glad people are working on this stuff and having fun. And at $200, the Pine Phone is at least cheap enough to try out as a toy if you’re into that kind of thing (I think I’d rather jailbreak an older iPhone or use a modified Android device running an alt-OS, but that’s me). The Librem 5 is either $1000 or $2000 depending on what option you get, and that is to me, only for people who either enjoy setting their money on fire or who have been brainwashed by the marketing that it can do what it cannot do for 99.99999% of the population. I dunno. I don’t like being a hater but I don’t see the real point of having a mobile phone that isn’t a usable phone and that is really only usable if plugg…
Pine64 PinePhone: Doesn’t like itPurism Librem 5: Doesn’t like it
There should be videos demoing the p-boot-demo image on YouTube, I included some in my Weekly Updates [0] on the topic. At this point, it makes no sense to try the image - it's simply to old, and projects have progressed too much. Regarding the battery life: This is a thing on the PinePhone, even more on the PinePhone Pro and (to a lesser degree) the Librem 5. These days I carry a Librem 5 (PureOS) and a OnePlus 6 (postmarketOS), the battery angst does not really apply to the One Plus 6, it easily lasts a day unless something goes terribly wrong. The main reason to do so is that I like to listen to way more podcasts than current (and likely also future) Librem 5 battery life allows. [0]: https://linmob.net/categories/weekly-update/ ,
Pine64 PinePhone: Doesn’t like itPurism Librem 5: Doesn’t like it
I got mine a month ago; ordered oktober 2019. Since than tried the Pinephone and PPP as a daily driver. The Librem5...it's slower and clunkier than the Pinephone pro. Both last less than 24 hours on a charge(suspend and calls seem to be a difficult problem tot fix). In the end, these may be nice tinkering devices, but nowhere near anything that you can reliably use as a phone. I now use a Fairphone 4 + Calyxos, and am quite happy with it. Spotify instead of Ncspot, Bluetooth that works, calls that work, no more buggy mobile Firefox config, reliable maps, messaging clients that work in the background. Most importantly; a battery that last at least 2 days, with reliable fast-charging. Purism, Pine and the Opensource community around it are just too small; either they run out of cash and/or people burn out trying to make it happen. A whole different case, but Valve's steamdeck is IMO a good example that Linux-based products with a good value proposition are possible, under the right circumstances.
Pine64 PinePhone: Doesn’t like itPurism Librem 5: Doesn’t like it
>We won, but also we lost big. This is why the Steam Deck is important. It's a reminder that computers work for us and that games are supposed to be fun. It's a shame that the mobile equivalents (Pine Phone, Librem 5) aren't competitive yet.
Pine64 PinePhone: Likes itPurism Librem 5: Likes it
> More developers are familiar with Android than the desktop Linux software stack. More work goes into it. Far more apps are written for it, and that includes a very active open source app ecosystem. The problem is that the Android app ecosystem has a very large number of apps which are based on collecting users' personal information and violating people's privacy, and it is hard for a normal user to avoid all the spyware and malware in Android. In my experience using CyanogenMod/LineageOS and the F-Droid repo since 2015, I inevitably fall back to installing some proprietary apps when using AOSP-derivatives, whereas my PinePhone and Librem 5 USA only have FOSS apps and drivers installed on them. If the goal is to use FOSS as much as possible, you are better off buying a Linux phone in my opinion. By the way, one of the apps that I helped develop is on F-Droid ( https://f-droid.org/en/packages/com.ketanolab.nusimi/ ) and I have given workshops on how to install LineageOS on phones, so I speak as someone who tries to promote the use of FOSS on Android phones, but the phone industry does put up a lot of barriers to make it difficult to install AOSP-derivatives. > GrapheneOS only supports devices with proper security support for all the firmware, drivers, etc. and again there are no closed source kernel drivers. We can support pretty much any mobile device with alternate OS support since any serious one will have AOSP support. Most devices have lackluster security and don't meet