The stuff Hacker News actually recommends.

Phones

Pine64 PinePhone vs Purism Librem

No clear winner: owners rate them about the same.

Pine64 PinePhonePurism Librem
Owners with an opinion13739
Positive verdicts25% of 11229% of 28
Positive/negative since 202411/492/9
Happy after 3+ years11
Longest happy owner4 yrs4 yrs
Praised forease of use and repairabilityreliability and software
Criticized forperformance and reliabilityperformance and ease of use
Newest comment

Updated

What owners wrote about both

Pine64 PinePhone: Likes itPurism Librem: Doesn’t like it
The real reason I liked the pinephone so much was not the price tag, but the replacement parts [1]. I didn't go for the librem cause it's an overexpensive bet with no sight of any repair parts. Before that I only bought android phones where I knew that I can find either scrapped parts or replacement parts on ebay. [1] https://pine64.com/product-category/smartphone-spare-parts/
Pine64 PinePhone: Recommends itPurism Librem: Recommends it
>So many things that used to work without a smartphone don’t anymore and people don’t realize it. Have you considered using a GNU/Linux phone (Librem 5 or Pinephone)? There is no dependence on a megacorp and QR codes work fine. Some services might redirect you to a web app if you show them such phone.
Pine64 PinePhone: Doesn’t like itPurism Librem: Doesn’t like it
Those have a ridiculously low performance. While this phone still does not have an Armv9-A CPU, but only a quadruple Cortex-A78, that is nonetheless like 4 to 10 times faster than the phones mentioned by you and faster than a light notebook of a decade ago. The other Linux phones are barely competitive with a laptop of 25 years ago and they are not really usable as a personal computer today, unless you like waiting for your computer.
Pine64 PinePhone: Doesn’t like itPurism Librem: Doesn’t like it
All the open/pro-privacy/pro-consumer cell phones I've seen (pinephone, Fairphone, Librem) never go far enough (non-open cellular modems/wireless chipsets) while also being either insanely priced, unobtainable, barely functional, scammy, broken, or some combination of those things. I really want a product like that to succeed, but I'm just not seeing anything reasonable being produced.
Pine64 PinePhone: Doesn’t like itPurism Librem: Doesn’t like it
I mean there has been a new entrant in the past few years, the fairphone, which arrived with a vision and an ethics, and is slowly getting market share, and better products, that are repairable, or new entrant like frame.work, which arrived with a vision, ethics too, and is slowly improving and getting market share. I am not sure why as a society we need to accomodate small vendors who arrive without a plan or anything selling shit shipped from China that is going to last 30 days and just become e-waste, like PinePhone or Librem comes to mind, I am not sure why society needs to accomodate any cowboy who wants to become a manufacturer to sell low effort china phones
Pine64 PinePhone: Doesn’t like itPurism Librem: Doesn’t like it
Banks in many countries require an Android phone for online banking. Even if they offer an online-banking website that you can access with any browser, you may still need the Android app for 2FA. This is one of a number of reasons why the PinePhone or Librem is unfortunately not a daily driver. Also, things like paying for parking or interacting with public services are moving to Android apps in some places.
Pine64 PinePhone: NeutralPurism Librem: Neutral
I've been using Linux on my Thinkpads for a while now. As well as many other machines. It does have some issues, primarily when it comes time to integrate with my smartphone, which is the primary issue here. And before someone chimes in, yes I have used both the PinePhone and Purism platforms. They are promising, but not a suitable replacement yet.
Pine64 PinePhone: Likes itPurism Librem: Likes it
> With all that information, I think it's reasonable to say that iPhones are far from private. But, as the alternatives are even worse Android smartphones are indeed worse, but it's not the only alternative. Consider GNU/Linux phones if you care about privacy and want to support it: https://puri.sm/products/librem-5 and https://pine64.org/pinephone . There are also things like /e/OS (Edit: and GrapheneOS), but they are installed on Android phones and must obey their planned obsolescence due to the proprietary drivers (tied to an old Linux kernel).
Pine64 PinePhone: Doesn’t like itPurism Librem: Doesn’t like it
I care about open smartphones, but not to the extent that I care about other things. A de-Googled Android or iOS device with a judicious selection of apps is good enough to fulfill 80% of the "geek device" use case segment (though not at the same time - de-Googled Android is better at running arbitrary software, whereas iOS seems to be better at painless privacy). I'm just not invested enough in open smartphones to fight PinePhone's software immaturity, or to spend crazy amounts of cash on a Librem. On the other hand, I was an adopter of the Pinebook, and will be for (affordable) productivity VR as soon as I get the chance. For both of these form factors, I'm more than happy to write 80% of the UI I use if it gives me what I want otherwise.
Pine64 PinePhone: Likes itPurism Librem: Likes it
Fellow humans, there are alternatives to being tracked via cell phone! Your neck need not be under anyone's boot! You don't even need to give up any functionality: Data service: The simplest thing is to buy a prepaid SIM and top it off with cash. The lovely people over at /r/nocontract maintain a big spreadsheet so you can filter by various properties of the available contracts. Another way to go is to pay for a postpaid plan with a virtual credit card (e.g., privacy.com). It won't be linked to your name at the telco, but of course privacy.com knows who you are. Yet a third way to go, which is nascent, is buy an eSIM with crypto. All these methods make you /pseudo/nymous, but obviously you're still identifiable by subscriber number and possibly IMEI, to put aside correlational things like your traffic profile. You can help this problem by routing everything through a VPN. Then you're pseudonymous but the cell carrier knows nothing about you other than that you use a VPN. Pay for the VPN with crypto. Of course now the VPN provider knows your traffic, but you're much more anonymous to them than you are to a telco. You make your choices. Defense in depth. Etc. OS: CalyxOS: https://calyxos.org/ Privacy-respecting Android distribution that replaces Google spyware with MicroG, so you can have your cake and eat it too. Most everything will work as you're used to, but it does still talk to Google to make that happen. GrapheneOS: https://grapheneos.org/ Very much like Calyx, but e…