The stuff Hacker News actually recommends.

Pens and paper

Pilot Metropolitan vs Platinum Preppy

Hacker News owners slightly favor the Platinum Preppy.

Pilot MetropolitanPlatinum Preppy
Owners with an opinion3213
Positive verdicts72% of 2985% of 13
Positive/negative since 20248/34/1
Happy after 3+ years30
Longest happy owner10 yrs2 yrs
Praised forvalue and ease of usevalue and performance
Criticized forreliability and performancecomfort and ergonomics
Newest comment

Updated

What owners wrote about both

Pilot Metropolitan: Doesn’t like itPlatinum Preppy: Likes it
A few years ago I bought a Pilot Metropolitan fountain pen. It's decent, but the ink evaporates really quickly. Last year I bought an inexpensive Platinum Preppy and it doesn't have this problem at all. No idea why the Pilot is so bad or if I can fix it, but it basically makes the pen useless to me because I do not write daily. Even if I did use it daily, the disappearing ink means I'd have more maintenance to deal with than I really want. The other thing many people don't think about is paper quality. Fountain pen ink really soaks through many types of paper. It took me a while, but I finally found a yellow legal pad brand that is great with a fountain pen. Mintra canary premium legal pads are inexpensive and nice to write on.
Pilot Metropolitan: Likes itPlatinum Preppy: Doesn’t like it
> Folks recommend the really cheap platinum preppy pens, but be warned they are super scratchy. The reason people recommend the platinum is that its cheap and its cap system is especially good for avoiding dry-out. To me, the platinum preppy feels like a rounded pencil. I think its a good pen, but my reservation is that the plastic is a bit brittle on the preppy. I'd personally probably go with the Pilot Kakuno, or the more expensive Platinum prefonte, or if you're really worried about costs, the interesting and fraught world of Chinese fountain pens > I would go a size up from what you normally prefer wrt to nib (if you are new, try M as F and EF are extremely scratchy IMHO). This is a feature of all the Japanese pens - they tend to have a finer grind. The European and other pens (e.g., Lamy) are about what you expect. > Finally, I don't love the metropolitan. Feels great in the hand but I always find myself reaching for the smooth writing I get from my Eco. The Metropolitan is a love-or-hate pen for some people, due to hand feel. I personally like it. If you can hold one, that'd be best. I think a couple of things make the Metro a better beginning pen than the Eco, if you like how it feels in your hand. It's cheaper; its got a metal body and cap (can be banged around), its got better QC (The first Eco I was given had the infamous 'barrel crack'. The second just flat didn't write. I'm a bit miffed at the brand), It can take cartridges or its included converter-sac, and it is…
Pilot Metropolitan: Recommends itPlatinum Preppy: Recommends it
I have been using fountain pens exclusively for the last two years. I don't identify as an addict or a collector. I can tell you that they are not overhyped. Fountain pens are totally worth it. I never went too high with the price. I have multiple Pilot Metropolitans (M and F nibs), multiple Platinum Preppies, one Lamy Safari. I also have several Indian Parkers. I can very highly recommend Pilot Metropolitan, Lamy Safari, and Platinum Preppy. You can't go wrong with them. They are also cheap enough. With ink, just go with plain Lamy ink, or Platinum/Pilot inks. I also use Noodler's.
Pilot Metropolitan: Recommends itPlatinum Preppy: Recommends it
As a fountain pen enthusiast who uses fountain pens exclusively, this list surprises me. What does this author want to cover? Good looking expensive stuff? Just buy a Pilot Metropolitan or a Lamy Safari. Or even a Platinum Preppy. These pens are extremely cheap. And beyond these pens, if you notice any improvement in smoothness and comfort of writing, I would throw that in the margin of error. People have their reasons to buy more expensive pens. But if smoothness, comfort are your goal, then you can buy what I said. Metal-body Lamys and Pilots are also generational wealth. You can hand over one to your daughter after you write 40 years with it. My favorite fountain pen so far is: Pilot Custom 823. That's a bit expensive. But I used Metropolitan, Preppy, and Safari for close to a decade. And I had only these pens. Nothing else.
Pilot Metropolitan: Doesn’t like itPlatinum Preppy: Doesn’t like it
I bought the TWISBI ECO on a lark. I was hesitant because I already had the GO and the ECO was just more expensive. Well boy-howdy is the ECO not only leagues better than the GO, but I much prefer to all my other pens. Folks recommend the really cheap platinum preppy pens, but be warned they are super scratchy. I would go a size up from what you normally prefer wrt to nib (if you are new, try M as F and EF are extremely scratchy IMHO). The opposite is true about the TWISBI in my experience. Go a size down. Their F nibs write quite fat. Then again, I mostly write on cheap paper so this advice def doesn't apply to e.g. Rhodia pads. Finally, I don't love the metropolitan. Feels great in the hand but I always find myself reaching for the smooth writing I get from my Eco.
Pilot Metropolitan: Recommends itPlatinum Preppy: Recommends it
- a jacket made of pure leather, custom-made, from a local artisanal, spent ~$120 (quite expensive for India), wearing it for 8 years, and it keeps getting better , zero sign of wear and tear - several fountain pens, especially Pilot Metropolitan F, Lamy Safari M; also the Platinum Preppy is really great, did not expect much from such a cheap pen; contemplated buying better fountain pens now and then, but these are so great; I write exclusively with fountain pens now - physical books that I buy, I buy because they are worth keeping, others I just borrow from library, friends, or buy ebooks - mechanical keyboard, a chinese-made rip-off of a famous brand, but really great, and just as same as the original - leather notebooks (refillable), gets better with the passing of time, can refill them with notebooks from market - as for software, I pay for/use stuff that are open, and easy to migrate from, has good support, etc. vim, ObsidianMD, git, etc. come to mind I am a person who always looks for durable products. Because I like the ease and comfort that comes from using stuff that you are using for years. I look for durable products when I am in the market for anything .