The stuff Hacker News actually recommends.

Phones

OnePlus vs Samsung Galaxy S

Hacker News owners lean toward the OnePlus.

OnePlusSamsung Galaxy S
Owners with an opinion301449
Positive verdicts73% of 25563% of 368
Positive/negative since 2024104/32107/71
Happy after 3+ years2542
Longest happy owner11 yrs12 yrs
Praised forperformance and reliabilityperformance and reliability
Criticized forsoftwaresoftware
Newest comment

Updated

What owners wrote about both

OnePlus: Likes itSamsung Galaxy S: Neutral
The OnePlus One was exciting because I think it genuinely was an Android-flagship-competitor at a much lower price. Prices crept up though, and the last OnePlus I owned was the 5 which was still pretty excellent! After a brief, very annoying stint using the Fairphone 4 (underpowered & expensive, though I did actually replace both the battery and the usb c port myself and it was exactly as easy as promised), I'm now finally on a Samsung S25+, though I did really really consider the newest OnePlus. Sad to know that it won't even be an alternative for my next phone, though hopefully by then, memory/silicon prices will have settled and Nothing will have their own flagship alternatives.
OnePlus: Likes itSamsung Galaxy S: Doesn’t like it
I have noticed with two 7 year old Snapdragon 835 devices that RAM and running a recent Android version makes a huge difference. I daily drive a OnePlus 5 running Android 14 through LineageOS and the user experience for non-gaming tasks is perfectly adequate. This phone has 6GB of ram, so it's still on par with most mid-range phones nowadays. My only gripe is that I had to replace the battery and disassembling phones is a pain. Meanwhile a Galaxy S8 with the same SoC, 4GB of memory and stock Android 9 with Samsung's modifications chugs like there's no tomorrow. I can understand that having two more gigabytes of memory can make a difference but there is a night and day difference between the phones. Perhaps Android 14 has way better memory management than Android 9? Or Samsung's slow and bloated software is hampering this device? Either way it's irritating to see that many companies don't test on old/low-end devices. Most people in the world aren't running modern flagships, especially if they target a world-wide audience.
OnePlus: Likes itSamsung Galaxy S: Doesn’t like it
It felt like there was an arc, where the hardware was getting better as they shrank components and managed to do decent things with the small lenses. Light computational touches were fine! But then things seemed to get weird. I had a Samsung S21 Ultra, and while it did some neat party tricks, I tended to dislike most of the photos, especially if you get anywhere near 100% view. Just so much automatic editing that maybe looks OK for a compressed web photo, but is not a high quality photo. I'm on a OnePlus 9 Pro and I am back to loving taking photos with it. They aren't as "impressive" as the 10x zoom photos, but they look good and do not look massively overworked. But it makes me nervous for when I need a replacement and have to come forward on this arc.
OnePlus: Likes itSamsung Galaxy S: Doesn’t like it
The SD845 phone has a larger screen. Galaxy S21+ and Oneplus 6. Notebookcheck's wi-fi browsing battery runtime tests set the brightness at 150 nits. Oneplus 6 gets 12hr42min, S21+ gets 10hr51min. At minimum brightness they get 30:06 and 29:40, respectively. All this despite the fact the Oneplus 6 has a 3300mAh battery and a 115.4cm^2 screen and the S21+ has a 4800mAh battery and a 108.4cm^2 screen. It's pathetic.
OnePlus: Likes itSamsung Galaxy S: Neutral
Interesting - I recently got myself an S9 and my wife a OnePlus 6T, and the OnePlus gets much better battery life (with fewer apps and overall lighter usage) - but now I'm not so impressed if that's how it's achieved. It's a fairly divisive issue - I can understand developers getting frustrated if their app's functionality is broken, but I do think this should be more in the user's control. A permissions-based model for backgrounding would be better, but there's too much permission prompting as well on Android (and this is something you can't back up - so on any restore, you're left 'allowing' permissions in every app you use in a new way - yes, when I select the camera mode in an app, I want to allow use of the camera - gets tedious across a bunch of different apps). My S9 (or maybe it's just Android) also puts a notification up if an app continues to run when I click 'back' out of it (or some other heuristic - it's not for every app, but it does a good job of identifying which are running) - which I think is a better compromise. It makes it much more visible which apps are consuming resources, and tapping the notification takes me to the App Info page with the 'Force Stop' button at the top. It's a bit noisy (it appears even for the stock music player, where obviously I want that to continue running), but it serves well as forcing visibility of battery hogs (whether it's through incompetence or nefarious background data collection), and reassuring to see it there for the
OnePlus: Doesn’t like itSamsung Galaxy S: Doesn’t like it
Most underdisplay fingerprint scanners are between mediocre to garbage. Optical scanners are slightly better but considered less secure, ultrasonic ones are a flaming PoS. Both on Samsung S-line, A-line and several Chinese Oneplus phones I've used personally, for years at a time. Usually they require a very specific state of the fingers, not too clean (don't work after washing and drying hands usually) and not too dirty, not too damaged, not too oily etc. Winter zero degree weather causing invisible condensation or wetness on a screen? Nope. Rain or drizzle? Nada. Also Samsung specifically on their S-line has some obvious software glitches I've confirmed on my phone. For example - in normal conditions, inside apartment, with reasonably clean hands, try to unlock and fail 5 times in a row, input password, then immediately lock the phone and try scanner once again and it will work realiably. It seems that having phone initially in "sleep/hibernation" causes its scaner brains to freeze and glitch, and only fully operational OS causes it to start working properly. I can totally see why Apple would opt for a better user experience, even if it's not as hyped or flashy on a shop display.
OnePlus: Doesn’t like itSamsung Galaxy S: Doesn’t like it
The cameras on the Pro versions used to be so good, then starting around one-plus 9 they really went downhill. I have photos in my archive from my OP8 Pro that look much better than those taken with the OP13. Coinciding with Samsung nerfing the Ultra (aside from the bloatware) - it's not looking like a great landscape for Android Phones.
OnePlus: Doesn’t like itSamsung Galaxy S: Doesn’t like it
I have also seen this in Androids (I tested this on multiple devices - S23U, OnePlus 6,8) , whenever I completely turned off the swap , the phone after a day or two of heavy usage would sometimes hang! It felt unintuitive since these devices had lot of RAM, and they shouldn't need swap . But turning off swap has always degraded performance for me.
OnePlus: Doesn’t like itSamsung Galaxy S: Doesn’t like it
There is another reason, there were way more brands of android phones in the past. I'm looking to buy a new phone, a flagship and my choices are basically Samsung, oneplus and xiaomi, each with its own issues. Samsung s22 in Europe reviews show that its a failure. Oneplus software took the wrong direction the last few models and xiaomi is just xiaomi with ads all over the place.
OnePlus: Likes itSamsung Galaxy S: Likes it
Its not just Google. All the network providers in America are pushing forced consumption down consumer throats by giving a deadline for upgrading their phones - beyond which it would stop working. I have two perfectly working (though a little older) phones - OnePlus 3 and a Galaxy S6 Edge. From February both these phones will not work with my phone carrier. I am aware that these are older phones and don't receive security patches etc, however I was perfectly fine using them and didn't have any issues with it. Too concerned about the consumerist lifestyle that is forced by this capitalist economy instead of providing updates/upgrades to their user till the phone's full life.