The stuff Hacker News actually recommends.

Phones

OnePlus vs Samsung Galaxy

Hacker News owners lean toward the OnePlus.

OnePlusSamsung Galaxy
Owners with an opinion301255
Positive verdicts73% of 25550% of 215
Positive/negative since 2024104/3234/35
Happy after 3+ years2511
Longest happy owner11 yrs15 yrs
Praised forperformance and reliabilityreliability and performance
Criticized forsoftwaresoftware
Newest comment

Updated

What owners wrote about both

OnePlus: Likes itSamsung Galaxy: Doesn’t like it
As a Pixel / Galaxy / OnePlus user... My app and photo quality preference are OnePlus > Pixel > > > ... > Samsung. shrug Really it could be a toss up between OnePlus and Google depending on generation. My partner's Pixel 7 takes nearly as nice photos as my OnePlus 12. My Galaxy photos were... very watercolor paint. I could not stand them.
OnePlus: Likes itSamsung Galaxy: Neutral
FWIW I've owned two OnePlus phones, both bought secondhand - a 7 Pro and a 9 Pro. The 7 Pro was one of my all time favorite phones, and I am using the 9 Pro now. I really like it. I owned a Samsung Galaxy S21 Ultra in between, and it was decent but the photos always felt weird to me. Overall I much prefer the 9 Pro to the S21 Ultra. I do agree that OxygenOS 11 was really rough on the 7 Pro, and I held onto OxygenOS 10.3.8 until 12 came out! That transitional period was rough for them. My 9 Pro has OxygenOS 13.1 and it's been rock solid.
OnePlus: Doesn’t like itSamsung Galaxy: Neutral
I had a pixel 7 pro, that after a half a year developed a battery problem. I got my money back and could get another pixel but was afraid of battery problems again, and picked a one plus 10 pro. I regret it. Pixel has the best Android expirence on the market. I'm not buying iPhones probably ever. I tried iphone 14 pro max a little bit and it's not worth 400 EUR over the Pixel for me. I also had Samsungs, they are ok, but pixel is better.
Switched from the Samsung Galaxy to the OnePlusOnePlus: Recommends it
I switched from Samsung Galaxy (first S, then S3) to OnePlus years back, and I've been a happy camper. I currently have an OnePlus 9, I've heard no so good (compared to previous) reviews of their newer models, but I'll cross that bridge when I get there. My current phone has been running great for multiple years, minimal bloatware, would recommend.
OnePlus: Likes itSamsung Galaxy: Likes it
By the way, inferior goods are not necessarily poor-quality products, though there is a meaningful correlation, and I based my original comment on it. Still, a OnePlus Android phone is considered an inferior good; an iPhone (or a Samsung Galaxy Android phone) is considered superior. Both are of excellent quality and better than one another in key areas. It's more about how wealth, brand perception, and overall market sentiment affect their demand. OnePlus phones will be in more demand during recessions, and demand for iPhones and Samsung Galaxys will decrease. No objection to your use/non-use of the Market for Lemons label. Just wanted to clarify a possible misconception. P.S. Apologies for editing this comment late. I thought the original version wasn't very concise.
OnePlus: Likes itSamsung Galaxy: Likes it
Like several other comments suggest, the author is actually spending way more than $250 on each phone. I have been buying 1-2 generation older but still brand new phones last few years- such as OnePlus 7T, OnePlus 8 and Galaxy S10e. All of them were fantastic, capable phones and cost less than $300.
OnePlus: Likes itSamsung Galaxy: Likes it
> 3-4yr old androids have been, in my very anecdotal experience, completely unusable (software bugs that’ll never be fixed, battery drain from OS updates released after manufacture year). What sort of Android device? Flagships usually have a much longer life than cheap ones. I had a Mi Mix 2S for 3 years (2.5 of it with literally a hole in the bottom left corner with a circuit bord visible after i dropped a heavy and sharp object on it) and it was as snappy and fast when it died due to water damage, and was still getting updates. I know people with OnePlus 6 or Samsung Galaxy S7 which work just fine ( there are no updates though). The updates part sucks but is getting better across providers, so hopefully will be better in the future.