The stuff Hacker News actually recommends.

VR and AR headsets

Oculus Rift vs Valve Index

Owners are split: the signals below point different ways.

Oculus RiftValve Index
Owners with an opinion87128
Positive verdicts44% of 6856% of 102
Positive/negative since 20248/1124/13
Happy after 3+ years20
Longest happy owner10 yrs0.5 yrs
Praised forcomfort and performanceperformance and comfort
Criticized fordisplay and ease of useease of use and display
Newest comment

Updated

What owners wrote about both

Oculus Rift: NeutralValve Index: Doesn’t like it
Red Alert VR! I too thought RTS would be awesome in VR. But alas, making games was beaten out of me by the sentiment that game development isn’t professionally viable without major crunch time. Failing of my own, but I hope someone tries! I had Oculus Rift in my living room, then upgraded to Index. The difference in lighthouse placement basically reduced my usage of Index vs Rift by 75%. It’s impossible to get out and use casually.
Oculus Rift: Likes itValve Index: Neutral
The ELI5 version is that if the motion your eyes see doesn't match what the movement/balance sensors in your inner ear feel, your brain thinks the mismatch is because you ate something you shouldn't and begins inducing vomiting. Motion sickness. The result is that games where your real world movement matches the game world movement, such as games like Beat Saber, MOST people feel fine. But in a game where the movements don't match, such as any racing or flying game, and any game where you move by holding a button or stick, motion sickness sets in VERY quickly for most people. Lag between moving your head and moving the image creates motion sickness because it creates the mismatch. Getting head tracking latency down to zero frames was a real innovation on the Oculus Rift and is an absolute requirement for any VR headset. Secondly, the frame rate needs to be high. The original Rift was 90 fps. Valve Index is up to 144 fps. Quest 2 I THINK is designed for 80 fps IIRC. In some games, like MS Flight Simulator, it's not really possible to achieve the 144 fps my Index supports without turning the graphics wayyyy down. In this case, the software performs dynamic reprojection when I move my head. Essentially, it just moves the last frame rendered frame around the display to mimic what its movement should be. Of course, it has the side effect that the edges of vision are just black if there's no rendered data, but it's enough to prevent motion sickness when looking around the…
Oculus Rift: Likes itValve Index: Neutral
I'm still disappointed that Facebook bought Oculus. I was a big Oculus Rift user, but I switched to a Valve Index when Facebook got involved. I don't want Facebook monetizing my data and my gaming life. It sucks because the Valve software just isn't anywhere close to being as good. And they haven't shown any meaningful signs of improvement in the last two years. I don't think they are ever going to get it like Oculus used to. I think they'll eventually decide VR is not worth it because of a lack of user engagement, when in reality the problem is that no one wants to constantly fight with Valve's obstinate software just to play VR games.
Oculus Rift: NeutralValve Index: Neutral
This isn't true. It's more that the Vision Pro deliberately prioritized certain things that Meta or Vive or Valve or Sony have not: geometrically stable pass through, wide library of popular 3D movies via AppleTV and Disney+, high resolution immersive environments, seamless keyboard/mouse/trackpad migration between PC and native apps, strong iOS/iPadOS ecosystem integration, high fps / low latency wireless ultra-wide virtual displays for the Mac, etc. In some ways it focuses on what the Oculus Go was trying to do but was underpowered to really do it. It's meant to replace other iOS devices for general productivity and entertainment, and to complement a Mac. It's not focused on VR gaming though it can do that. I have a Oculus Rift dev kit, Ovulus Go, Quest , Quest 2, Valve Index, PSVR2. The AVP is much better of an experience on almost every level but three: too much motion blur when moving your head (this isn't bad when watching high fps video), lack of controller support, not so great hand tracking (which the Quest had to do well due to lack of eye tracking). The controller support should be fixed with the Sony PSVR2 partnership. Motion blur and hand tracking I suspect will be software fixed as they evolve to prioritize active fitness with the AVP.
Oculus Rift: Doesn’t like itValve Index: Doesn’t like it
I was very excited about VR, owned rift dk2 and cv1, my roommate has valve index which I've played with. still very strongly meh. I get sick very easily, even with traditional screens in some FPS games. VR people seem to live in a bubble and plug their ears every time somebody says VR sucks. sorry, it mainly sucks. headsets are heavy, wires tangle, graphics cards are expensive, cameras or projectors are tedious, resolution isn't good enough, rooms are never big enough or clean enough, a guest broke our window by accident, god I could go on with all the drawbacks.
Oculus Rift: NeutralValve Index: Neutral
As a person who wanted VR monitors, I backed the original Oculus Dev Kit 1 a decade ago, and it was terrible for that purpose. So I got the DK2, and the Vive, and the Index afterwards, trying each. The Index pretty much has it -- it's doable. I can read comfortably in there, or watch a youtube video and not feel like I'm getting some grainy, crappy version, but it's just barely there. It's very heavy and hot, though, so I almost never choose to use it. The claimed resolution of the Vision Pro is unbelievably larger than the Index. I forget what the numbers were exactly, but they claimed to be able to virtualize "multiple 4k monitors" or something, and the per-eye resolutions _actually supported that_. The next thing is: it's gotta be reasonably light, balanced, and cool, so I can wear it for an hour and not get intense neck pain or nausea. I'm skeptical but, hey, we gotta keep trying. If it hits those points: it'll be a great virtual monitor and a lot more.
Oculus Rift: Doesn’t like itValve Index: Doesn’t like it
Everyone can see the value of a Holodeck, or a magical lightweight high-resolution display that barely weighs on your head, doesn't cause eye-strain and doesn't mess up your hair. But that hasn't yet been technically achieved. What the comments are saying is: "I can't see how current state-of-the-art wearable displays can offer any value, given their current limitations " And I agree. With none of the headsets I've tried (Rift, Rift-S, Valve Index, HoloLens, HoloLens 2), I could imagine working 8 hours per day. They're heavy, scratchy and are annoying to put-on & take off. The Nreal Airs, mentioned by a sibling comment, have a promising form-factor, but only feature a 1080p display. At our current technological advancement, I doubt that Apple will overcome these limitations next week.
Oculus Rift: Likes itValve Index: Likes it
> "Allow". Trust me, these things are not at all designed to be worn over glasses. It is uncomfortable as fuck and getting everything aligned properly so you can actually see is a pain too. I don't need to trust you, I've owned three headsets so far, an Oculus Rift DK2, a HTC Vive and a Valve Index. I have a fairly large head (to the extent that many glasses don't fit me) and yet have never had an issue with glasses in any of the headsets. I also have -6.5 in each eye so can't use the headsets without vision correction. It's not as convenient as not wearing glasses for sure, I had to guide the glasses into place in the headset, but I've played hundreds of hours of games in each headset, including many multi-hour stints in Fallout 4 VR which requires a lot of movement and Elite: Dangerous, and wearing glasses just wasn't an issue. > Buying prescription inserts is basically a requirement if you can't manage without your glasses. My experience would suggest it's not a requirement at all.