The stuff Hacker News actually recommends.

GPUs and CPUs

Nvidia GeForce GTX vs NVIDIA GeForce RTX

Hacker News owners lean toward the NVIDIA GeForce RTX.

Nvidia GeForce GTXNVIDIA GeForce RTX
Owners with an opinion132617
Positive verdicts73% of 10076% of 416
Positive/negative since 202435/14214/71
Happy after 3+ years1510
Longest happy owner12 yrs6 yrs
Praised forperformance and reliabilityperformance and value
Criticized forsoftwarenoise
Newest comment

Updated

What owners wrote about both

Nvidia GeForce GTX: NeutralNVIDIA GeForce RTX: Likes it
As a hobbyist exploring LLMs since Summer 2022 (electrician by trade)... I've been as blown away by generative AI results/output as I've been left laughing at its hallucinations . My first forays were via CrAIyon & ThisWordDoesNotExist .com . Now, four years later: I've finally been able to purchase a 5070Ti (from a ~1080Ti~ – so, an upgrade ). The past few days have been overwhelming as I explore the rights/wrongs of bigger offline models (more parameters, even if They're [only] Made Out of Weights ). ---- My twin, an actual brilliant engineer (me: amateurhour), after playing with this new "toy" [discussing chessboard layout, electrical engineering concepts] deduced (accurately IMHO): "it's able to be wrong FASTER – don't let this be discouraging it's an incredible piece of hardware but I still cannot trust it for citing reference material." My general Qwen3:14b model was unable to troubleshoot a bespoke coding issue (as expected, it's not a code-er). I have minimal coding experience, but he is a professional hardware engineer; I've been self-tasked to play around with "any coding model that might solve a bug I'm having with a current piece of firmware" – so that should be an interesting conceptual experience for both me and twin. Anybody have a good coding model (it's whatever language Atmel Arduino uses, by default) that runs on a 5070Ti, best?
Nvidia GeForce GTX: Doesn’t like itNVIDIA GeForce RTX: Neutral
Well, before the 5060 Ti I have now, about 6 months ago I had an 1080 Ti and games absolutely didn't just work. In fact, the all thing was a very big mess because there isn't/wasn't proper support for 1000 series NVIDIA GPUs with Wayland and there was a big list of issues: VSync being an obvious one (but many others). I had to configure (the few distros that still support it) to use X11 and live with another set of issues.
Nvidia GeForce GTX: NeutralNVIDIA GeForce RTX: Likes it
I mean, I upgraded from a GTX 1080 Ti to a GTX 4080 last summer, and the difference in graphical quality I can get in games is pretty great. That was a multi-generation upgrade, but, when exactly do you think that GPU performance per dollar flat-lined?
Nvidia GeForce GTX: Doesn’t like itNVIDIA GeForce RTX: Neutral
I wrote something similar to this. Instead of requiring a shared network drive, dependent files are automatically detected and transferred over with HTTP, and as an advanced feature, it splits the video to chunks to allow 20x+ encode speeds, concurrently utilizing multiple machines to encode a single input file and utilizing NVENC. Video is then concatenated together and API for that mode is identical. Wrote it in C# and it runs both on Windows and Linux. The original need for this actually was to accelerate encodes a system I run on a cloud VM needs when I have either my desktop or laptop available, who then work as encode slaves and pick up jobs, run them and send the output files back. If no slaves are available, the system falls back to local CPU encode. Later I ended up using this using a local Windows server machine as the "client" the slaves also connect to to ask for jobs (actually the system runs inside a Unity project in that case because C# is awesome). Probably a bit of a rare problem I hit with this is that different NVENC generations generate different enough bitstreams that they can't be concatenated together. From my pool of machines I found out only my RTX 2070 and RTX 3080 Mobile are compatible. GTX 970 and Quadro P5000 that I had laying around both were incompatible with that pool and with each other. Interestingly I found no similar software to the chunked encoding in my system, but am chalking it up on me not searching hard enough or these being integrate…
Nvidia GeForce GTX: Doesn’t like itNVIDIA GeForce RTX: Likes it
My current PC is using an old 4th gen i7 with an RTX 3060Ti and it keeps trucking along just fine, even with my 144Hz display. It used to have a GTX 960 but its 2GB of VRAM were anemic for some ML stuff I wanted to run + the newer Nvenc is a massive upgrade in quality. I don't see any reason to upgrade anything else.
Nvidia GeForce GTX: Likes itNVIDIA GeForce RTX: Doesn’t like it
Yup. This is my take. I build a new machine about once every 4 years for gaming/development, and I just don't really see all that much difference between the capabilities of the machine I built two generations ago (now ~9 years old) and the one I specced out last year. I can still load up modern AAA titles on the 9 year old machine and they run just fine at 1080p 60fps with some minor tweaks to the graphics. Turns out the GTX 970 from 2014 is still more than capable. Basically - these top end cards are a complete waste of cash for the average consumer. Hard to even claim you're future-proofing the machine with it - you're just plain wasting money.
Nvidia GeForce GTX: Likes itNVIDIA GeForce RTX: Doesn’t like it
Just to echo the other children of this comment; I'm pretty lost as to the reasoning here. I game at 1440p on a GTX 1080 from launch day in 2016. Cost is essentially no object for me, as gaming is my primary hobby and I can easily spend 60hrs/week playing video games, so the return would be more than justified in my mind. But I haven't upgraded in 6 years because there has been no reason to. I'm running my favorite games at 144fps, and the newer super-high fidelity stuff I can run at 60fps, which is more than reasonable. I will say that I was excited for the 40XX lineup, but at these prices I'm more inclined to hunt for a cheaper 2080 or 3080 solely for RTX functionality, but that's an enthusiast feature even for someone like me who spends a huge amount of time gaming. I couldn't imagine giving up my access to old titles, console emulators, mods, itch.io experiments, and low-budget indie games on Steam to save a few hundred bucks in the short-term to buy a console. YMMV if you're not paid well in a HCOL area, or if your location offers alternatives such as PC cafes.
Nvidia GeForce GTX: Likes itNVIDIA GeForce RTX: Neutral
I started out using my old GTX 1080 on Thursday, could generate 512x512 just fine. That's in 8G of VRAM. It worked well on the hlky branch using webui (built using gradio). Seeing that training etc. is much more memory intensive, and wanting to get faster results, I bought an RTX 3090, which has 24G of VRAM. However it maxes out at about 1024x512, only twice as many pixels. Observing the card with GPUZ, it never actually allocates more than 13.9G. Using the lstein branch, I can't get above 896x512. Similarly, GPUZ shows allocated VRAM never reaches 14G. The interface isn't as good as the webui on hlky either - never mind the web interface, a bigger problem is it doesn't save all the parameters alongside generated images. This is all running using Miniconda on Windows. On Linux it may be a different story, but my gaming PC is not dual-boot (yet).
Nvidia GeForce GTX: Likes itNVIDIA GeForce RTX: Doesn’t like it
For over a month the local microcenter has had hundreds of RTX 3xxx series GPUs, and that's just from the public numbers, which are capped at quantity 25. Nobody is buying these cards. One, inflation. Two, everyone who really wanted them already bought. Three, people have realized that they can just be careful about graphics quality settings and save themselves hundreds of dollars. The newer cards are a shitty deal, frankly, at the low end. A new 3060 retail costs twice as much as a used 1070 ti that will perform nearly identically, even have nearly the same power draw (you really have to hand it to NVIDIA to have nearly the same performance per watt with a half decade spread.) Is DLSS nice? Yeah. Is RTX pretty? Yeah. Is it twice the cost nice/pretty? Nope? NVIDIA is going to have to trickle the 4000 series cards out so slowly if they want to have any hope of not severely boning their resellers. My guess is that we'll see 4080's first to get the whales, then 4090's to get the whales again...and then the lower cards announced but released from storage in very, very small quantities.
Switched from the Nvidia GeForce GTX to the NVIDIA GeForce RTXNVIDIA GeForce RTX: Doesn’t like it
>A lot of people are undervolting their RTX GPU's because for an only about a ~3% performance loss you get about 10C less temp which translates to far less fan noise Bah, this is brilliant. I just upgraded a 1070 to a 3070 and am flabbergasted at how much heat it dumps into my room. One of the reasons I did not go with the 3080 was the ~100 watt lower draw. Do you know of any good tooling to assess the impact of undervolting or is it a manual guess-and-check process?
Switched from the Nvidia GeForce GTX to the NVIDIA GeForce RTXNVIDIA GeForce RTX: Likes it
Wow. I read your comment, went to Best Buy's website, and after a few minutes of waiting in a virtual "line" I bought a RTX 3070 for MSRP ($500). Finally I can upgrade my 6 year old GTX 1070.
Nvidia GeForce GTX: Likes itNVIDIA GeForce RTX: Likes it
> As for GPU, AMD hasn't raised prices by as much; and honestly my 3060 12GB from many, many years ago plays absolutely every single game I want to play at 1440p; with nice visuals. I also have DDR4 and an ancient 1080 8GB, both perform well at 1440p. I built the box months before cryptotokens went exponential in 2017 and it has carried me ever since.
Nvidia GeForce GTX: Likes itNVIDIA GeForce RTX: Likes it
As opposed to loading it up in RAM + VRAM? Pretty much always better to split it up to multiple GPUs. My priorities are load up all available VRAM, then offload MoE experts to RAM (if possible), then offload other layers. I use an RTX 3090 (24GB) and a GTX 1080ti (11GB). Just the 3090 for 3.8 I get maybe 60tg/s (UD-Q4 quant), for both I get around 40tg/s (UD-Q6). Not apples to apples though considering it's different quants. Here's my config: https://gitea.va.reichard.io/evan/nix/src/branch/master/modu...
Nvidia GeForce GTX: Likes itNVIDIA GeForce RTX: Likes it
I used an AMD Radeon 7770 for years, then I upgraded to a GTX 1060, the 7770 became my younger sister's GPU for her PC. It has only recently gave out, after some 14 years of service. Likewise for the 1060, its still going strong. I upgraded to a 3060 round about the time my younger brother decided he wanted a PC so he is now using it without any issues. About 10 years use out of it, plenty more to go. GPUs are pretty damn resilient if you aren't pissing around with them.
Nvidia GeForce GTX: NeutralNVIDIA GeForce RTX: Neutral
I'm laughing because I clicked your link thinking I agreed and had posted similar things and it's my comment. Still on k3s, still love it. My cluster is currently hosting 94 pods across 55 deployments. Using 500m cpu (half a core) average, spiking to 3cores under moderate load, and 25gb ram. Biggest ram hog is Jellyfin (which appears to have a slow leak, and gets restarted when it hits 16gb, although it's currently streaming to 5 family members). The cluster is exclusively recycled old hardware (4 machines), mostly old gaming machines. The most recent is 5 years old, the oldest is nearing 15 years old. The nodes are bare Arch linux installs - which are wonderfully slim, easy to configure, and light on resources. It burns 450Watts on average, which is higher than I'd like, but mostly because I have jellyfin and whisper/willow (self hosted home automation via voice control) as GPU accelerated loads - so I'm running an old nvidia 1060 and 2080. Everything is plain old yaml, I explicitly avoid absolutely anything more complicated (including things like helm and kustomize - with very few exceptions) and it's... wonderful. It's by far the least amount of "dev-ops" I've had to do for self hosting. Things work, it's simple, spinning up new service is a new folder and 3 new yaml files (0-namespace.yaml, 1-deployment.yaml, 2-ingress.yaml) which are just copied and edited each time. Any three machines can go down and the cluster stays up (metalLB is really, really cool - ARP/NDP ann…
Nvidia GeForce GTX: Likes itNVIDIA GeForce RTX: Likes it
Yes. Although I suspect my definition of "moderate hardware" doesn't really match yours. I can run 2b-14b models just fine on the CPU on my laptop (framework 13 with 32gb ram). They aren't super fast, and the 14b models have limited context length unless I run a quantized version, but they run. If you just want generation and it doesn't need to be fast... drop the $200 for 128gb of system ram, and you can run the vast majority of the available models (up to ~70b quantized). Note - it won't be quick (expect 1-2 tokens/second, sometimes less). If you want something faster in the "low end" range still - look at picking up a pair of Nvidia p40s (~$400) which will give you 16gb of ram and be faster for 2b to 7b models. If you want to hit my level for "moderate", I use 2x3090 (I bought refurbed for ~$1600 a couple years ago) and they do quite a bit of work. Ex - I get ~15t/s generation for 70b 4 quant models, and 50-100t/s for 7b models. That's plenty usable for basically everything I want to run at home. They're faster than the m2 pro I was issued for work, and a good chunk cheaper (the m2 was in the 3k range). That said - the m1/m2 macs are generally pretty zippy here, I was quite surprised at how well they perform. Some folks claim to have success with the k80s, but I haven't tried and while 24g vram for under $100 seems nice (even if it's slow), the linux compatibility issues make me inclined to just go for the p40s right now. I run some tasks on much older hardware (ex -…
Nvidia GeForce GTX: Doesn’t like itNVIDIA GeForce RTX: Doesn’t like it
I’m actually shocked you got it to play games like that. I have several nvidia laptops that I use ranging from a 750M, to gtx 1650, to a rtx 4050. Every couple of months I’ll switch back to the dedicated GPU to run a sanity check for features, and do a 180 in an hour. I understand making compromises on shadowplay, GeForce streaming, the control centre, and the nvidia app as a whole. But I always notice microstuttering that shouldn’t be there and draw the line at having to manually set up VDPAU/VAAPI and keeping up with the trends of what this year’s optimal way to install games is (which DE on which back end, playonlinux vs lutris vs winetricks vs proton, etc). I’m glad you got your 3050 to do basic things and hope you get more use out of it as software improves. NB: IMO the best Linux nvidia laptops are the Lenovo legions. They have a bios switch to force the use of the nvidia chip and mask the iGPU. Half the issues are gone then.
Nvidia GeForce GTX: Doesn’t like itNVIDIA GeForce RTX: Doesn’t like it
3700X's 8-cores is a generational leap above the 7700k's quad core for modern games. They aren't comparable at all. I ran a GTX 1080 and then an RTX 3080. The performance was not very good in modern games designed for current gen consoles like pretty much any BR game for example. Some games got high FPS at times but with low minimum FPS.
Nvidia GeForce GTX: Likes itNVIDIA GeForce RTX: Likes it
Same, but R9 380X back in college. Bang per buck it seemed better than NVidia. But despite my distaste for NVidia back then, after that experience, I resolved to never get an AMD GPU again unless things drastically change. Drivers would constantly break something, some games would run poorly and I would have to fiddle with driver versions to address this (often involving annoying version rollbacks), it would randomly start overheating for no reason, sometimes it would just crash the system, etc. Upgraded to 480 later, and the exact same story repeated. You know what happened once I got an NVidia GPU years later (1080Ti)? I never had to think about the GPU ever again. I install a driver update occasionally, it “just werks”, and I would go on my merry way. Upgraded to a 3080 about half a year after it got released, and had the same story - it just works, and I never have to think or worry about it ever. I would love to support AMD GPUs, but I cannot, in good conscience, buy their GPU again and waste time troubleshooting it and stress over every driver update. On the flip side, AMD CPUs are amazing. Been with them since the original Ryzen release, upgraded once (from 1700 to 3900x), no issues whatsoever and am very happy with those. My next build will be an AMD Ryzen CPU as well, but it will have an NVidia GPU.