The stuff Hacker News actually recommends.

Consoles and handhelds

Nintendo Switch vs Sony PlayStation PS5

No clear winner: owners rate them about the same.

Nintendo SwitchSony PlayStation PS5
Owners with an opinion304120
Positive verdicts61% of 24068% of 96
Positive/negative since 202463/4227/12
Happy after 3+ years20
Longest happy owner8 yrs2 yrs
Praised forease of use and performanceease of use and performance
Criticized forreliability and comfortvalue and software
Newest comment

Updated

What owners wrote about both

Nintendo Switch: Doesn’t like itSony PlayStation PS5: Likes it
My kids play the N64 more than the Wii because the Wii is quite frustrating to set up and maintain batteries and controller connections. The Switch is even more awful, but they’ll play it handheld. The PS5 is complex but generally straightforward. It helps that the controllers are big and we have a nice, clean charging dock for them. The Switch charging dock is finicky and annoying with the tiny controllers. I think my immediate feedback is that the game cards could be a lot bigger. Anyone out there want to make a ridiculously beefy SD card adapter and corresponding slot? Or maybe even one that interfaces like a puck/block with some keying and locking. But overall this is 100% on target for my 6 and 8 year olds. They want to play games, not operate a console. We take them to a Retro Gaming night every few months and I’ve noticed that the X-in-1 consoles (even the brand names) are rarely touched, and all have laminated cards desperately attempting to tell kids how to get into a game. The console UX is paramount.
Nintendo Switch: Likes itSony PlayStation PS5: Neutral
We already have a good sense of what SoC Nintendo will likely be going with for the Switch 2. Being so dismissive of the Switch shows the disconnect between what most gamers care about, and what some tech enthusiasts think gamers care about. The Switch 1 used a crappy mobile chip, sure, but it was able to run tons of games that no other Tegra device could have dreamed of running, due to the power of having a stable target for optimization, with sufficiently powerful APIs available, and a huge target market. The Switch 1 can do 90% of what a Steam Deck can, while using a fraction of the power, thickness, and cooling. With the Switch 2 almost certainly gaining DLSS, I fully expect the Switch 2 to run circles around the Steam Deck, even without a “high end chip”. It will be weaker on paper, but that won’t matter. I say this as someone who owns a PS5, a Switch OLED, an ROG Ally, and a fairly decent gaming PC. I briefly had an original Steam Deck, but the screen was atrocious. Most people I see talking about Steam Deck’s awesomeness seem to either have very little experience with a Switch, or just have a lot of disdain for Nintendo. Yes, having access to Steam games is cool… but hauling around a massive device with short battery life is not cool to most gamers, and neither is spending forever tweaking settings just to get something that’s marginally better than the Switch 1 can do out of the box. The Switch 1 is at the end of its life right now, but Nintendo is certainly prepari…
Nintendo Switch: Doesn’t like itSony PlayStation PS5: Likes it
I used to share a lot of screenshots from PS5 to Twitter. It was one of the easiest ways to get pictures off the platform. Now I use the Playstation App on my phone which works OK but is a bit clumsy. The Switch has a really wacky way of getting pictures off it; it runs an HTTP server on an ad hoc WiFi network when you ask it to! Every week I miss something else that we lost when Twitter got ruined.
Nintendo Switch: Likes itSony PlayStation PS5: Doesn’t like it
I caved and bought a Switch last week. It’s the best tech purchase I’ve made in years! The games on it are fun, the versatility of the Joycons is incredible, and the loading speed is a breath of fresh air. My main console is an original PS4. I upgraded to PS5 last year and returned it. It’s just more of the same. Huge game downloads, huge update downloads, a huge console, and long load times. And tbh, I didn’t see a lot of difference in terms of graphics. If you want to play super realistic games then Nintendo doesn’t seem to be the way to go, but if you want to have fun and don’t care about frame rate/whatever other performance metric people complain about, the Switch is amazing.
Nintendo Switch: Doesn’t like itSony PlayStation PS5: Likes it
Same for me, load times on PS5 are actually pretty impressive. I can't remember being bothered by load times since I have it. In comparison I recently started my Switch again to play Dead Cells and load times really break the die & retry experience. So yeah, praising the Switch performance over PS5 is... weird? Possibly dishonest?
Nintendo Switch: Doesn’t like itSony PlayStation PS5: Likes it
At this point, I'm not really interested in buying one, but I'm pretty excited for the Steam Deck from the perspective of mobile computing and repairability. Nintendo has made repairing the Switch a pain and is very anti-consumer in giving you access to your save data without forking over more money. In a similar vein, I think it's cool to see Sony take a more repair friendly approach with the PS5. Taking the sides off for cleaning or replacement is super easy and as a bonus creates an extra revenue stream for new accessories. The amount of really cool stuff hacker types are going to get out of the Deck is one area to look forward to. Heck, this could be the mobile workstation tons on this site have been asking for since the iPad debuted. When demand for the Deck dies down, I think I'll buy one if only to show Valve that I support the product and their respect for consumers.
Nintendo Switch: Doesn’t like itSony PlayStation PS5: Likes it
its actually better on newer consoles. (ps5 in particular is much better than xbox). The consoles themselves are quick to wake up, and if you're playing single player games there's no need to update. > in almost all cases you just put the cartridge in the console you're in-game within seconds. This is true for some games on switch, however my experience is that many games suffer from extremely long loading times even compared to PS4/Xbox one. The ps5s loading times for games are orders of magnitude quicker; power on to in game in Spiderman miles Morales is less than 30 seconds. I've spent more time than that staring at single loading screens in Smash Bros, Metroid Dread and breath of the wild. > this hour long wait before playing a game just makes the whole experience not worth it. The hour long wait does happen occasionally, but it's not like you actually need to do anything during that time. You can do that and come back that night, and a month later the game will still be playable without updating.
Nintendo Switch: Likes itSony PlayStation PS5: Doesn’t like it
I've got one and my family still has a blast playing it. Aesthetics are obviously personal. I won't say it's the nicest looking fixture in my living room, but I also think the PS5 looks ridiculous. Its name was probably Nintendo's biggest misstep. That said, my point was that the Switch's success isn't due to the library alone. Due to Nintendo's decision to port most of its Wii U exclusives to the Switch, we have the rare ability to compare the sales performance of the two.
Nintendo Switch: Doesn’t like itSony PlayStation PS5: Likes it
The situation is better but not perfect (i would argue switch has some major issues on that front mostly related to slow in game load times). Ps5 games in my experience are turn on console to in game in under a minute. The OS standby is much better and quick resume features in games are excellent (Online games aside)
Nintendo Switch: Likes itSony PlayStation PS5: Likes it
This system won't run FIFA, GTA Online, Battlefield, Valorant or CoD, it's a nonstarter for many. Sure you don't need to subscribe to PS+, but that's somewhat easier to swallow since PS+ gives you games with the subscription. I'm still interested in this for playing older games but I have a Steam Deck and it still isn't remotely as seamless as my Switch or PS5.
Nintendo Switch: Likes itSony PlayStation PS5: Likes it
Nintendo is getting it right (maybe): focus on first-party exclusive games and, uh, a pile of indies and ports from the PS3 and PS4 eras. Come to think of it, Sony is also stuck in the PS4 era since PS5 pro is basically a PS4 pro that plays most of the same games but at 4K/60. (Though it does add a fast SSD and nice haptics on the DualSense controller.) But it's really about the games, and we haven't seen a lot of system seller exclusives on the PS5 that aren't on PS4, PC, or other consoles. (Though I'm partial to Astro-bot and also enjoyed timed exclusives like FF16 and FF7 Rebirth.) PS5 and Switch 2 are still great gaming consoles - PS5 is cheaper than many GPU cards, while Switch 2 competes favorably with Steam Deck as a handheld and hybrid game system.
Nintendo Switch: Likes itSony PlayStation PS5: Likes it
Gamepass is good, but PS Plus is also good. Arguably the main thing you get with Gamepass is more AAA games, but honestly, both iclude more games than you can reasonably play. > exclusives (this generation, there aint a huge difference) The difference doesn't need to be huge, it just needs to be there. For me personally, the backcatalog of From Software games (including 2020 Demon's Souls) and Returnal were enough to push me towards PS5. > the majority of people probably have a switch because nintendo I do also own a switch. It's nice and all, but for me competes in a different niche: portable indie game machine. Anecdotally, I also don't know anyone where a Switch displaces PC/PS/Xbox, so the non-overlapping group logic doesn't really apply.
Nintendo Switch: Likes itSony PlayStation PS5: Likes it
I have an 18 core i9 overclocked to a stable 5GHz and 128GB of RAM. Without fail, every single time I press the Windows key and start typing, the first few letters are dropped. Without fail, every single time I launch a new Explorer window, the file path has a slow ass green progress bar, my drives (of which I only have 4, and only one is a spinner) are place-holder icons and the available storage icons aren’t there. After very literally 10 seconds or so, Explorer finally looks right. Meanwhile, Everything search remains blissfully instant, Explorer alternatives such as OneCommander are blazing fast, and even tools like PowerToys search (the one that looks exactly like macOS’s Spotlight search) are fast as hell. I find that one surprising because I’d assume it’s just an alternative GUI for Windows search, but I guess not? Anyways, the point is, Windows itself isn’t even necessarily the problem (though, yes, it is a mess that I grow less and less able to tolerate). Even Windows’ first party foundational apps are completely broken. At this point I’ve all but washed my hands of Windows. I just can’t stand it anymore. Life for me from here on out is primarily Apple hardware, as many FOSS apps and services that I can find, and Linux VMs for development. Im planning on switching my Windows PC over to a NixOS bare metal install, and will run Windows via KVM for the rare moments when I want or need Windows. But even for gaming, which I do far less of nowadays (pretty much Souls games…
Nintendo Switch: Doesn’t like itSony PlayStation PS5: Doesn’t like it
Homebrew development has been a thing for as long as video game consoles have been around. I don't think it'd be reasonable to require Sony/Nintendo/Microsoft to provide the development toolchains/SDKs/software they've developed for free. However, it would be good if they were required to allow third-party software installations with software written using third party toolchains (like the homebrew ones). Consoles like the PS5/Xbox really aren't all that different from PCs nowadays, even from the software library side. Most games are cross-platform, and even Sony has been bringing their exclusives to PC. So really, a PS5/Xbox/Switch is just a gaming PC with arbitrary anti-consumer, anti-competitive restrictions. Even if these restrictions actually subsidize the price of the hardware, it's still harmful to consumers since they end up spending a lot more money on software over the lifetime of the console. Plus, that hardware is extremely locked down, so it's not like consumers are really benefiting from those supposed subsidies. They're just paying slightly less up front for a machine designed to take a lot of money from them.
Nintendo Switch: Likes itSony PlayStation PS5: Likes it
I agree with the sentiment, but in my experience that's just not true. [1] The PS4 and PS5 are nice and pain free. The Switch even more so, because the games will run right off the cartridge without needing updates. They have available updates, but the version shipped on the cartridge is 100% playable. [1] With the exception of the XBox because Microsoft can't get their shit together.
Nintendo Switch: NeutralSony PlayStation PS5: Neutral
I bought one, and of course it hasn’t arrived yet (though I think it will in Q3). The best parts for me are the following: 1. It’s indie. 2. It’s accessible. 3. It’s got a completely different engagement model. I have a 7yo who I bought it for (really) and with the web drag-and-draw IDE, I can’t think of a better way to get him involved in the exploration of technology. Maybe it can be fun and provide an outlet for deep exploration. I sure as hell am not going to sit down with him and explain the principles of enterprise architecture. For engagement models / indie-ism, we have a Switch and just got a PS5. They’re neat. I guess. But they’re also kinda stale and boring (outside a few winner games). Kinda like watching Disney these days with the Avengers series. Diminishing returns on every title and no real way to engage beyond consumption. I’m really hoping this is good for him (and good for me as a reset against my day to day as an engineer indoctrinated in the Bay Area ways of growth). To that end, the other comments I’m seeing don’t seem to understand the appeal that has attracted me.
Nintendo Switch: Doesn’t like itSony PlayStation PS5: Doesn’t like it
My PS5 will randomly steal the input from my LG TV's internal smart apps. My Nintendo Switch does whatever it feels like doing at random. Frankly I find the technology to be a total mess, and there's no way to debug it.