The stuff Hacker News actually recommends.

Consoles and handhelds

Nintendo Switch vs Sony PlayStation PS4

Hacker News owners lean toward the Nintendo Switch.

Nintendo SwitchSony PlayStation PS4
Owners with an opinion30469
Positive verdicts61% of 24061% of 54
Positive/negative since 202463/429/10
Happy after 3+ years21
Longest happy owner8 yrs10 yrs
Praised forease of use and performancereliability and ease of use
Criticized forreliability and comfortsoftware
Newest comment

Updated

What owners wrote about both

Nintendo Switch: Likes itSony PlayStation PS4: Neutral
I caved and bought a Switch last week. It’s the best tech purchase I’ve made in years! The games on it are fun, the versatility of the Joycons is incredible, and the loading speed is a breath of fresh air. My main console is an original PS4. I upgraded to PS5 last year and returned it. It’s just more of the same. Huge game downloads, huge update downloads, a huge console, and long load times. And tbh, I didn’t see a lot of difference in terms of graphics. If you want to play super realistic games then Nintendo doesn’t seem to be the way to go, but if you want to have fun and don’t care about frame rate/whatever other performance metric people complain about, the Switch is amazing.
Nintendo Switch: Likes itSony PlayStation PS4: Doesn’t like it
>The Wii U and Virtual Boy aside, how do they do it? Nintendo's top-tier exclusives, and a constant focus on end-to-end user experience. The PS4/Xbone (and even, to an extent, the 360/PS3) have so much jank when it comes to playing a game on them. My experience with The Last of Us Part II basically consisted of inserting the game, waiting nearly 25 minutes for it to install, going through that entire process again, twice, because there was a smudge on the disc, then waiting another 20 mins to download a 10GB patch, only to load up the game and sit through hours upon hours of boring-as-fuck intro content before I saw a single zombie. With Super Mario Odyssey, I put the game in, downloaded some optional 50MB patch in about 20 seconds, then started jumping around collecting coins and throwing my hat at everything. They just "get it" in ways that Sony and Microsoft don't (or at least, haven't "got" since the original PS2/Xbox era).
Nintendo Switch: Likes itSony PlayStation PS4: Doesn’t like it
I'm not talking about the games themselves, I'm talking about the experience of using the console (I also thought Dread was a bit of a letdown, and don't get me started on the difference between 3D All Stars and the Crash/Spyro remaster). It's just that on the Switch, in almost all cases you just put the cartridge in the console you're in-game within seconds. For Xbone/PS4 (and I'm assuming this is worse on the new consoles), there's a whole arduous process to go through before you can play the game. As someone who no longer has the time/energy to pour into gaming like I used to, this hour long wait before playing a game just makes the whole experience not worth it.
Nintendo Switch: Likes itSony PlayStation PS4: Doesn’t like it
It's hard to understate how much "time to play" makes the switch enjoyable. I can return to a game I was playing, exactly where I was, in about 3 seconds. Even if I've not touched the switch in days or weeks! The system level pause/resume makes it so I can quickly jump into a game whenever I have time, even if it's just 10 minutes. Contrast that to my ps4 experience and it is a world away. Takes at least a minute to get to home screen, then there's usually gigabytes of updates to download. Sometimes it might be _hours_ before I can start the game I wanted to play. I'm not sure if the latest generation of xbox/ps have solved this. Combimed with the supply issues of the new generation consoles, I've not been too keen on getting one because my switch has sufficed
Nintendo Switch: Likes itSony PlayStation PS4: Likes it
The two pillars of what made console gaming so enticing for years were cost and convenience. I love my gaming PC, but there is nothing as seamless as sitting on my couch, pressing the middle button on my PlayStation or Xbox, and jumping right back into a game that was in a quick suspend state. Even my PS4 still sees action due to the convenience factor. Love my steam deck, but the dock/handheld experience isn’t as seamless as switch and flipping from desktop to gaming mode had a like 15% chance of freezing the device until maybe 18-24mo ago. There was also that update issue for years if you left your home network. Xbox/Switch/Playstation are incredibly reliable and turnkey (and until recently, a low upfront cost). It’s why people turned to them by the millions.
Nintendo Switch: Doesn’t like itSony PlayStation PS4: Doesn’t like it
Yeah, at least since Steam Deck launched & especially with Steam Machine now also being available consoles really don't make any sense. All the lazy complaints about "I want it to just work", "I don't want to build & maintain a PC" etc. really make no sense any more. And arguably the breaking point has been much sooner, with the PS4 & Switch both selling you back commodity hardware (x86 APU with FreeBSD for PS4 & ancient NVIDIA Tegra for Switch), just totally locked down, user hostile & with overpriced games.
Nintendo Switch: Likes itSony PlayStation PS4: Likes it
I just think that without the draw of the motion controllers, the Wii U screen just really wasn't good enough to make the console worth using. The Nintendo switch was brilliant, you just had to think like a 13 year old to understand why that was always going to sell like gangbusters. The games library was just too weak honestly, I think that was the main thing. The software problems were in large part caused by Nintendo under-speccing its machines catching up to it. Multiplatform's were particularly adversely affected. All in all you were better off buying a PS4 honestly.
Nintendo Switch: Likes itSony PlayStation PS4: Likes it
I agree with the sentiment, but in my experience that's just not true. [1] The PS4 and PS5 are nice and pain free. The Switch even more so, because the games will run right off the cartridge without needing updates. They have available updates, but the version shipped on the cartridge is 100% playable. [1] With the exception of the XBox because Microsoft can't get their shit together.
Nintendo Switch: Likes itSony PlayStation PS4: Likes it
as someone who travels a lot, i just keep my ps4 in a travel case. the whole gaming setup ends up being smaller than my laptop bag or work bag. ps5 looks less portable but ''''next gen'''' hardware like the switch & steam deck are both incredibly travel friendly. >people who cannot afford a console or PC used hardware tends to run incredibly cheap and i doubt someone who can't scratch up 150-300 dollars over the course of a few months has access to reliable high speed internet. the best use case i have found so far for game streaming is fishing in ff xiv while cooking dinner.