The stuff Hacker News actually recommends.

Consoles and handhelds

Nintendo Switch vs Nintendo Wii

Hacker News owners slightly favor the Nintendo Wii.

Nintendo SwitchNintendo Wii
Owners with an opinion30420
Positive verdicts61% of 24087% of 15
Positive/negative since 202463/423/1
Happy after 3+ years20
Longest happy owner8 yrs–
Praised forease of use and performanceperformance and ease of use
Criticized forreliability and comfortreliability
Newest comment

Updated

What owners wrote about both

Nintendo Switch: Doesn’t like itNintendo Wii: Doesn’t like it
My kids play the N64 more than the Wii because the Wii is quite frustrating to set up and maintain batteries and controller connections. The Switch is even more awful, but they’ll play it handheld. The PS5 is complex but generally straightforward. It helps that the controllers are big and we have a nice, clean charging dock for them. The Switch charging dock is finicky and annoying with the tiny controllers. I think my immediate feedback is that the game cards could be a lot bigger. Anyone out there want to make a ridiculously beefy SD card adapter and corresponding slot? Or maybe even one that interfaces like a puck/block with some keying and locking. But overall this is 100% on target for my 6 and 8 year olds. They want to play games, not operate a console. We take them to a Retro Gaming night every few months and I’ve noticed that the X-in-1 consoles (even the brand names) are rarely touched, and all have laminated cards desperately attempting to tell kids how to get into a game. The console UX is paramount.
Nintendo Switch: NeutralNintendo Wii: Neutral
I don't suffer from that particular nostalgia, not having had a Nintendo console (C64/Amiga diehard here), but I bought Wii and Switch, and a couple of first-party games for each. I considered, and passed on, the other consoles. Nintendo is playing a different game than other console/game makers (excuse the pun), IMHO.
Nintendo Switch: Likes itNintendo Wii: Likes it
The reason I explicitly noted Nintendo and Apple is because they are not "rando companies". They are companies with explicit track records of not focus grouping every product to death. You say the Wii was "mixed", but that's just wrong. It outsold the PS3 and XBox 360. The Wii U was a misstep, but the Switch is essentially a Wii U/Game Boy hybrid. Because Nintendo saw what was off with the Switch and made the changes. As for Apple, they were lambasted for removing the Home button, removing the audio jack, making their own chips. But those have all been not the major missteps people thought they were.
Nintendo Switch: Doesn’t like itNintendo Wii: Doesn’t like it
Nintendo always does something that's JUST slightly off with their consoles that make them annoying as hell to use. With the switch it's the screwed up USB-C implementation and the fact that you can't use bluetooth headphones (it has BT support, but only for the controllers) With the DS, the wifi only supported WEP, not WPA, even though WPA2 had been released by the time the DS came out The Wii famously didn't support HD output.
Nintendo Switch: Likes itNintendo Wii: Likes it
The past 20 years for Nintendo have been pretty interesting, to say the least. They started with the Gamecube, a console that sold weak numbers and faced stuff competition despite it's library of modern classics. They followed that up with the iPhone of game consoles, the Wii, and moved hundreds of millions of units like it was no big deal. Seeking to capitalize on that same success, they made the Wii U, which seemingly forgot all of the things that made the Wii great in the first place. Then they fixed it with the Switch, identifying the disappointment that people felt with the Wii U and streamlining the product to really dig in to consumer trends. It's a lot of ups and downs, and that's without even touching on their software and handheld history. It's got me wondering what's up at Nintendo. Their mainstay studios like HAL Laboratories and MercurySteam haven't changed all that much over the years, and their presentation quality and infatuation with design has yet to waver. Overall, I'm starting to think their hardware and management teams are the weakest links: their least successful and least appreciated ventures have been when they wandered outside of their walled garden to make a quick buck (Super Mario Run or Mario Kart Grand Prix, anyone?), second only to their questionable hardware designs over the previous 2 decades. I have nothing but respect for the way Nintendo's developers and engineers deliver a polished product for all kinds of consumers, but I struggle to imag…
Nintendo Switch: NeutralNintendo Wii: Neutral
PC / xbox+playstation / switch are almost completely separate markets. It has never entered my mind that "I should buy an xbox/playstation", not once. I have had NES, (original) game boy, SNES, gamecube, wii, and now a switch. It's not about the switch being cheaper than current-gen high-end consoles, it's that the games that are exclusives for those consoles just don't appeal to me.
Nintendo Switch: Likes itNintendo Wii: Likes it
The Wii continues to outplay the Switch in my house. It's great how solid the Switch's hardware is, but the games are a bit meh -- though I'll admit that's probably a product of the times and competition, might as well just repackage old games. But I can't imagine there will ever be a console as revolutionary (no pun intended for those who remember) as the Wii. To take such a huge gamble on motion gaming and have it work so well is so applause-worthy. To compare, imagine Zuckerberg announces a headset today, and it's actually good? See how wild that sounds?
Nintendo Switch: Likes itNintendo Wii: Likes it
To rally in defence of the Wii, I'm a PC gamer through and through. I could never get on with consoles, particularly for first person shooters, although I had good times playing some casual games on friend's machines back in the day. The Wii was fantastic though, I loved playing shooters on it, and the fun factor of things like tennis, golf and such made it a regular feature of family evenings. That's over with the Switch. We occasionally play Mario Kart together but that's it. My eldest got addicted to CotW, Stardew Valley and Animal Crossing but now she's into LoL on her laptop the Switch is dead to her as well. I'm not saying it's a bad console or machine, far from it, it's fantastic. But it's a fantastic console, whereas the Wii was something special. I wonder how many people bought Switch due to a halo effect from Wii. We certainly did. If they brought out Wii game controllers and games for it I'd be all over it.