The stuff Hacker News actually recommends.

Networking

MikroTik Routers vs Ubiquiti UniFi

Hacker News owners slightly favor the MikroTik Routers.

MikroTik RoutersUbiquiti UniFi
Owners with an opinion230583
Positive verdicts78% of 18665% of 498
Positive/negative since 202472/24182/93
Happy after 3+ years1319
Longest happy owner17 yrs20 yrs
Praised forreliability and valuereliability and ease of use
Criticized forease of use and performancesoftware and performance
Newest comment

Updated

What owners wrote about both

MikroTik Routers: Doesn’t like itUbiquiti UniFi: Likes it
> They run linux and offer ssh but with a custom shell That feels like DOS with short character limits etc. It's attrocious. > Ubiquiti sucks nowadays Actually the general consensus is that they are amazing. You're in the minority
MikroTik Routers: Recommends itUbiquiti UniFi: Doesn’t like it
Ubiquiti unifi has struggled to integrate routing as reliably and as well as the wireless and switching piece. Mikrotik router and unifi everything else has kind of been my go-to for at least 10 or 12y now.
MikroTik Routers: Doesn’t like itUbiquiti UniFi: Neutral
I've been a MikroTik fan since the beginning of my career some 15 years ago now. I have used the MikroTik router and Ubiquiti AP combination ever since. With that said, I can absolutely agree that their UX is terrible for anyone who doesn't specifically know how to configure a MikroTik router. The fact that you have to configure FQ-CoDel yourself and some bufferbloat protection isn't just a built-in option is absurd for anyone using it as a home router.
MikroTik Routers: Doesn’t like itUbiquiti UniFi: Likes it
>Mikrotik make all sorts of equipment, including home routers. The hAP ax3 is shown on their homepage. It runs Router OS 7. See >Even the devices that are homeish in capability are mostly deployed into apartment buildings as NTD's and managed via API/Ansible not by the occupant. >The cheaper routerboards, like the 2000 series, are almost entirely eaten by Wisps. I can see that you might get confused by the form factor, but I guarantee you can find these running entire branches of a wisp network. >It's not insane to ask for sane defaults or UIs which hide progressive complexity. Ubiquiti manage it far better. Teltonika manage it far better. Unifi is explicitly targeting prosumers. When they do snap out of that and target the ISP space you get things like their faulty dual UI POE switches (Make a change in the old UI? Welp thats going to wipe your comments from the new one!) or the poor slobs custom building rifle scopes for AF60 LR. >Perhaps Mikrotik don't have the resources to do that - fair enough, that's a business decision. But it's not insane to desire a UI which encapsulates domain knowledge in a way which guides the user. That's just good UI. The issue is that is the current situation. It does guide the user, the average one who will purchase their product. What they don't have is a big warning for people stumbling in from elsewhere. >The problem with UIs like Mikrotiks, which are effectively just a graphical overlay on a config file, is that they make it very easy to m…
MikroTik Routers: Doesn’t like itUbiquiti UniFi: Recommends it
I redid the backbone of my home in 10Gb fiber, and "cheap" is not the term I would use. Especially when you can get perfectly cromulent 1GbE switches for like $10 these days. The Mikrotik switches [1] work technically speaking but they are quite difficult to configure. You have to pull them from your network, connect physically to a specific port, force your machine onto a specific IP, connect to a specific IP. I could not get this to work in macOS nor Ubuntu despite hours of futzing with it. They both kept infuriatingly overriding my changes to the IP. I was only able to get this to work on an old Windows 10 laptop. Once you do get their web UI up, you pray the password on the sticker on the bottom works. Neither of mine did and I had to firmware reset both and find the default password online. The web UI itself holds no hands. It's straight out of 1995, largely unstyled HTML. While using both of my devices the backend the UI talked to would crash and log me out about every five minutes. Not every five minutes after log in. Every 5 minutes wall time! The Mikrotik switches are also fanless, and 10GBE SFP+ adapters throw off a lot of heat. If you use more than one they overheat. You can just about get away with two if you put them on opposite sides but I would not recommend it. I've also had very mixed luck with SFP+ module compatibility with this thing. I had a number of modules that refused to run at higher than one GB, hence my fighting to get into the UI. Despite a ton…
MikroTik Routers: Likes itUbiquiti UniFi: Doesn’t like it
You don't need this. Strictly speaking, we don't need much. But a travel router can be nice to have. I bring some tech with me when I travel. Obviously a phone, but also a decent-sounding smart speaker with long battery life so I can hear some music of my choosing in decent fidelity without using Bluetooth [bonus: battery-backed alarm clock!], a laptop for computing, a streaming box for plugging into the TV, maybe some manner of SBC to futz with if I'm bored and can't sleep during downtime. All of this stuff really wants to have a [wifi] connection to a local area network, like it has when I'm at home. A travel router (this one, or something from any other vendor mentioned in these threads, or just about anything that can run openwrt well) solves that problem. All I have to do is get the router connected to the Internet however I do that (maybe there's ethernet, decent wifi, or maybe my phone hotspot or USB tethering is the order of the day), and then everything else Just Works as soon as it is unpacked and switched on. And it all works togetherly, on my own wireless LAN -- just as those things also work at home. Bonus nachos: With some manner of VPN like Tailscale configured in the router, or the automagic stuff this UBNT device is claimed to be able to do, a person can bring their home LAN with them, too -- without individual devices being configured to do that. I think travel routers are pretty great, myself. (But using Ubiquiti gear makes me feel filthy for reasons th…
MikroTik Routers: Likes itUbiquiti UniFi: Neutral
I would put mikrotik ahead of ubiquiti in terms of giving control to do stuff. But.... more of a learning curve. I use both mikrotik and ubiquiti at home. The mikrotik is necessary for a few things the ubiquiti can't do, but mostly it's a wash. Incidentally mikrotik tends to be behind ubiquiti for rolling out new wifi stuff
MikroTik Routers: Likes itUbiquiti UniFi: Doesn’t like it
Mikrotik is pretty lacking in aspects that relate to the newest hotness of wifi standards. 802.11ax ("wifi 6") is as good as it gets, with [eg] their wAP AX. They get a lot of stuff right, though. They run RouterOS, which is a custom userland for Linux that is intensely flexible. Approximately any routing-esque function a person can dream up that can work with a Linux kernel can be made to work within RouterOS. The form factor of the wAP AC/AX boxes is really very nice -- they can blend well in on a wall (inside or outside), attached to a pipe, or whatever. I've got a wAP AC on the wall of my living room, for instance. I use another one when "camping" off-grid, zip-tied to the leg of an easy-up awning. It's ostensibly just an access point, but it doesn't have to be. I mean, like: There's two ethernet ports, but they exist without a preconceived function. Want to use it as a router, with hardware WAN and LAN ports? How about with VLANs and a managed switch instead, so it works with just one cable? Eleventy-five different SSIDs? Bridging networks with wifi? Using station mode to leech bandwidth from the cafe across the street, and perform firewalling and NAT and VPN, so you can use it in your apartment -- with only one box? Sure, no problem. Whatever it is, it works. Power is flexible. All of the bits to use passive POE are included; or it can just plug in with the included DC connector; or it can use proper 802.3af PoE. I don't know how it compares to something…
MikroTik Routers: Likes itUbiquiti UniFi: Doesn’t like it
Yeah, setting up my router with VLANs/Firewall/NAT etc was so damn frustrating with Ubiquiti compared to the Mikrotik router I had before. While I could just export my config file with Mikrotik and ask ChatGPT to make whatever changes I wanted in seconds ("here's my config, make a vlan 20 with all my iot devices") and get a fully working config back, with Ubiquiti you just get a bunch of inaccurate "click here and there" instructions back instead since the UI changes slightly all the time. The switchover was still worth it, as the Ubiquity UI is nicer in daily use (and Mikrotik wifi sucks ass, so I had to use other APs). However, every time I want to change something I wish I had an easily ediable config file to edit, and get LLM help with, instead of a confusing UI to click around in.
MikroTik Routers: Doesn’t like itUbiquiti UniFi: Likes it
Yep. I actually had to do that to get the Ubiqiti one to work. It just did not work when I tried that with the Mikrotik adapter.
MikroTik Routers: Doesn’t like itUbiquiti UniFi: Neutral
Early this year I started redoing the backbone of my home network with 10 gb. Some of it's fiber, some of it's 10 gb copper Ethernet. It's been genuinely frustrating the weird incompatibilities between switches and SFP+ modules. All my switches are MikroTik. My SFP+ modules are MikroTik, Ubiquiti, and some 3rd party ones from before I knew better. I've had modules that will only run at gigabit in one switch but will give me the full 10 gb in another. I've had modules that refuse to work in one MikroTik switch but will happily work in a different MikroTik switch. I've just had a world of pain. I've got everything basically working after months of fiddling and I'm inclined to just not… touch… anything.
MikroTik Routers: Doesn’t like itUbiquiti UniFi: Likes it
The common sentiment is that Mikrotik is the gold standard for reliability and, not talking about the terrible UI, you're considered an Adult in networking if you choose to manually configure individual interfaces to do basic things, and it 'just works' Except when it doesn't, and you have to stop your day job to troubleshoot your home network because an interface literally vanishes overnight, when you hadn't touched the router in months. Then there's the wifi radio settings and the terrible CAPman, where I had to Google radio frequency settings and channel configuration (why?). In any case what's this power good for? what's a use case that you want to give up ease of use and central management for configuration power? I'm moving to all Ubiquiti stuff, and so far I love the management tooling that already alerts me and shows me latency stats and packet drops on my network in a status page, including a log. I love that I can use the app to connect my phone to an IPSEC tunnel at home, that I can quickly connect sites. Mikrotik's winbox and web configuration UI seem like they were written by lone developers in basements who never interacted with humans.
MikroTik Routers: Doesn’t like itUbiquiti UniFi: Likes it
I have a bit of a soft spot for Mikrotik, but I can't help feel like their hardware only exists to sell training. For our house I tried a Mikrotik, a TP Link and a Ubiquiti AP. The only one that really works in our case is the Ubiquiti. Also for a home that's mostly Apple hardware, you kinda need a manage wifi solution, because Apples WIFI stack have issues switching between APs and needs a controller to kick you off (I don't know if that's still the case). Ubiquiti have one of the only routers that will force Apple hardware to switch APs. Mikrotiks CAPsMAN isn't even really a WIFI/AP controller, it's just provisioning. For all it's flaws, I still really want to just run 100% Mikrotik gear.
MikroTik Routers: Likes itUbiquiti UniFi: Recommends it
I love Mikrotik too and the price point, but it's for people who know network engineering or need a particularly rare type of gear (like a small inexpensive 10G SFP switch). I tell people to jump into Ubiquiti's (ui.com) ecosystem which is much more accessible for power users who occasionally wrestle with concepts like wireless, VLANs, subnets, and traffic rules.
MikroTik Routers: Doesn’t like itUbiquiti UniFi: Neutral
Juniper for routing. The neat trick with wisps with broken networks is to just drop a big juniper device in their core and edge, and replace 10 mikrotiks and suddenly a large tranche of angry customers just stop calling. The big questions come at the tower. Juniper doesn't have a massive POE tower switch. The options there can be all bad. Its this huge mess. AC or DC, backup or no backup etc etc. And there are always drawbacks. I had a customer purchase a massive cambium tower switch with all the bells and whistles only for it to occasionally lock up and forward on all ports like a hub. Netonix can be good, however their failure rate is higher than I would like, and the support always tries to blame your grounding on returns. But the interface is easy to teach to junior techs, and other than some weird issues with linux partition size and their vlan implementation they just go. The ubiquiti tower switches are a lot of fun. I dont know if its still the case but for a few firmware versions they had half the config only available in a legacy interface. But once you made a change in the legacy interface, all the labels you set in the new interface are lost. RF last mile for residentials, Ubiquiti/Cambium. They both work well in some respects and suck in others. NEC for backhaul if you can get it. Otherwise there are some decent ubnt/cambo options also. ubnt has come a long way in 60GHz.
MikroTik Routers: Likes itUbiquiti UniFi: Doesn’t like it
Ubiquiti’s hardware is limited in some respects whereby with Mikrotik you can implement anything, its just a matter of how and the performance. Ubiquiti for core, especially when deploying CGNAT, is a bad idea.
MikroTik Routers: Likes itUbiquiti UniFi: Doesn’t like it
Barely can break 350mbps with IDs and IPS enabled and starts getting buffer overload. I'm pretty sure Mikrotik had a faster router a few years before the usg4 hit the market for about the same price. what unifi sold people on was cloud managed easy config and it just started working somewhat in the last version for me. Really feels like they need to triple down on the software front and beef the midrange hardware. I just looked the other day - as I'm getting symmetric 2gb fiber in a few months and unifi has some wild high end router but it seems like it needs more on the CPU and ram front still, too. OpenSense here I come?
MikroTik Routers: Likes itUbiquiti UniFi: Doesn’t like it
While I can't speak for a less technical user, I'm throwing away a nearly brand-new Ubiquiti access point on the basis that it took me like five times as long to set up client isolation as it did to manually set up PPPoE and VLAN tagging for my fiber connection on the Mikrotik I bought at the same time. Also the Mikrotik didn't install an nginx server on my laptop. I'm replacing the Ubiquiti with another Mikrotik box even though they're apparently not that great for wifi purely on the basis of the UX.