The stuff Hacker News actually recommends.

Networking

MikroTik Routers vs Ubiquiti EdgeRouter

Hacker News owners lean toward the MikroTik Routers.

MikroTik RoutersUbiquiti EdgeRouter
Owners with an opinion230102
Positive verdicts78% of 18659% of 71
Positive/negative since 202472/247/13
Happy after 3+ years134
Longest happy owner17 yrs10 yrs
Praised forreliability and valuereliability and performance
Criticized forease of use and performancesupport
Newest comment

Updated

What owners wrote about both

MikroTik Routers: Recommends itUbiquiti EdgeRouter: Doesn’t like it
Mikrotik. Past experiences include Cisco (bad incentives, they make a lot of money from certifications and licenses), TP-Link (broke the case physically when pressing a button, was left without updates after some time), Ubiquiti (could not handle the load of my home network. I had the edgerouter-x though which is weak)
MikroTik Routers: Likes itUbiquiti EdgeRouter: Doesn’t like it
> Have look at Mikrotik CCR2004-1G-12S+2XS (1G-12S+2XS means 1x1Gbps RJ45, 12xSFP+, 2xSFP28) or CCR2116-12G-4S+ Both of these look fantastic. The second one, with the four SFP+ ports, looks like an almost drop-in replacement for the Infinity, particularly with its 16GB of RAM. (We use soft-reconfiguration inbound which bloats the amount of RAM needed for the tables.) > However, neither of them will route 80 Gbps full duplex. That's actually fine, at least for our needs. We only have 50Gbps of connectivity between peer, IXP, and transit links and today's 30Gbps is high because of end-of-month activities. We got the Infinity largely because it was the only EdgeRouter that could do what we needed. Like the gap between EdgeRouter Infinity and "every other router that can do what it does," there's a rather large gap in Ubiquiti's EdgeRouter line. The next one down in the list is the EdgeRouter-12 that is a small fraction of the capability of the Infinity. > another thing on Mikrotik naming conventions: CRS = switches; CCR = routers That's good to know. I hadn't started down the Mikrotik path yet but I'll give it a look. We have a leaf router at a small office where we experiment and maybe I can put one in there to start. Thanks for all of the information!
MikroTik Routers: Likes itUbiquiti EdgeRouter: Neutral
Mikrotik HAP AC2 as router and wifi, with HAP AC providing extra access point. Fiddly to set up, but solid and trouble-free since. Used to use Ubiquiti Edgerouter, until it failed. The Smart QOS feature was pretty good. Used to use Unifi for wifi, but always struggled with clients getting stuck communicating with the most distant access point. (Edit: In case it's relevant for some, I should also list: a Draytek 130 to adapt perculiar UK PPPoA broadband to PPPoE.)
MikroTik Routers: NeutralUbiquiti EdgeRouter: Likes it
I've recently updated my setup a bit. FTTH -> MediaConvertor -> Ubuquiti EdgeRouter 4 (ER-4) -> Mix of TP-Link TL-SG2008P Switches, Netgear GS208E/GS205E Switches, all multi-VLAN -> Older HP Workstation with XEON procs running as VMware server (hoping to replace with something smaller and less power hungry eventually) -> OC200 Controller -> 2x EAP245v3 WAPs (Obviously not exactly in a chain order like that...) I have a TP-Link TL-ER7206 that I may replace the ER-4 with (ER-4 is stable, and working well) (Would love to know if anyone is successfully running the TL-ER7206 with the Bell Canada provided SFP directly installed.) (Had to go with the MediaConvertor because the SFP in the ER-4 has a bug and resets every 20 minutes or so) Previously I had: Cable Modem -> ALIX running pfSense -> Netgear GS208E/GS205E Switches multi-VLAN -> Older HP Workstation with XEON procs running as VMware server (hoping to replace with something smaller and less power hungry eventually) -> 2x MikroTik HAP AC as WAPs I liked the setup, but the Cable Internet was slow by today's standards, and the ALIX only had 100M LAN ports, which limited my inter-VLAN communication speeds. (I couldn't justify the expense of new hardware required to run the newer pfSense/OpnSense) I liked the MikroTiks, but noticed that the wireless performance was slow once I moved to the Gigabit Fibre Internet. The MikroTiks had replaced some TP-Link Archer C7 I was using as WAPs that were running OpenWRT. They were okay, but th…
Switched from the Ubiquiti EdgeRouter to the MikroTik RoutersMikroTik Routers: Recommends it
I've been using a Mikrotik for about 2 years now, switched from an Ubiquiti EdgeRouter X when I upgraded to 1gig at home. It works great and has been rock solid since setting it up. I even have 4 port bonding setup to my main switch because neither has SFP+. However, it was kind of a bear to get all setup. In terms of setup difficulty it goes Mikrotik -> EdgeRouter - any consumer focused router. I've been putting off setting up VLANs for about a year and a half because I just know I'm going to break everything.
MikroTik Routers: Likes itUbiquiti EdgeRouter: Likes it
Probably the most painful home Internet experience you can have is a consumer router fail. Suddenly you really need all those basic sysamin features a business system provides. I used OpenWRT on Linksys back in the day, but later had an early PCEngines APU running PfSense. Those worked well enough until my ISP increased our bandwidth. Made the jump to a little Mikrotik RB2011 on the top floor and added an extra AP (actuall a RB 900 series router) on the first. That did the job up until we got 1 Gb fiber. Not willing to use the ISP's router+mesh, I got a Ubiquiti EdgrRouter and a couple of Netgear APs (by then all our switches were ProSafe managed). The ER has been great. After mastering RouterOS, Vyatta was no big deal. I regret now not getting UI APs, Netgear changes its crappy prosumer interface with every model it seems, and they're painful to manage without paying for the cloud service. The switches are OK, but the once again the UX annoyingly varies by model. Of course, Ubiquiti has its own issues mostly in how the company itself is run. If I have to, I'm ready to go back to Mikrotik (whose web ui the Vault 7 goons could only crack during an interlude between firmwares: as if anyone leaves that UI enabled). In all the years I ran it, Mikrotik never caused me a problem with a RouterOS update (neither has EdgeOS).