The stuff Hacker News actually recommends.

Consoles and handhelds

Microsoft Xbox vs Sony PlayStation PS5

Owners are split: the signals below point different ways.

Microsoft XboxSony PlayStation PS5
Owners with an opinion251120
Positive verdicts59% of 20968% of 96
Positive/negative since 202444/4127/12
Happy after 3+ years70
Longest happy owner21 yrs2 yrs
Praised forease of use and reliabilityease of use and performance
Criticized forsoftwarevalue and software
Newest comment

Updated

What owners wrote about both

Microsoft Xbox: Likes itSony PlayStation PS5: Doesn’t like it
I want to agree but I don't see the greener grass at all. Please bear in mind that this is totally anecdotal. I own all three major consoles. My PS5 has been switched on about six times since I purchased it at the time the PSVR2 was released. Is it because I'm not into the funky and weird JRPG titles or am I just sold to the Xbox ecosystem? I play Xbox almost every single day. My PS5 is just using up space and for two titles which didn't fully grip me (Horizon and The Last of Us). What am I missing here? Is the answer PC/Steam?
Microsoft Xbox: Likes itSony PlayStation PS5: Doesn’t like it
Microsoft is much better about backwards compatibility and preservation than Sony, too. I have a library of Xbox and Xbox 360 discs I can just put in my Xbox Series X and still play, often with improvements. I can even still buy many titles from those generations digitally and play them on my Series X. Meanwhile, Sony's missing many landmark titles from two generations, and your only option for playing PS3 games on a PS5 is streaming.
Microsoft Xbox: Likes itSony PlayStation PS5: Doesn’t like it
A bit off topic, but I recently bought my first Xbox (series x) after owning every generation of PlayStation since launch. There were 3 reasons I opted for the Xbox: availability, aesthetics of the device itself (in my opinion the new PS5 is hideous), and most importantly Xbox Game Pass. I am amazed at the number of high quality games on there for a relatively small monthly fee. Buying one new game at full price is the equivalent of around 6 months of game pass. So for the same price I can either have 2 new games a year, or have access to hundreds of games. Subscription services like that make piracy completely redundant. Game pass is spotify for games, and I haven't bought or pirated music since I started using spotify
Microsoft Xbox: Doesn’t like itSony PlayStation PS5: Likes it
I agree with the sentiment, but in my experience that's just not true. [1] The PS4 and PS5 are nice and pain free. The Switch even more so, because the games will run right off the cartridge without needing updates. They have available updates, but the version shipped on the cartridge is 100% playable. [1] With the exception of the XBox because Microsoft can't get their shit together.
Microsoft Xbox: Likes itSony PlayStation PS5: Doesn’t like it
I have a PS5, but bought a Series S recently and since then the PS5 is gathering dust. Not because it's some superior console(it isn't) but because GamePass is just such a fantastic offering, and Sony's PS Plus Premium is just a joke in comparison. And the fact that nearly all games sync saves with their PC versions is just a cherry on top. I can play something on my gaming PC then move over to the living room and continue seamlessly - it's great. Can't do that with 99% of games on the PS5.
Microsoft Xbox: Likes itSony PlayStation PS5: Doesn’t like it
A family member recently purchased a PS5. I have an Xbox Series X. And I am amazed at how unnecessarily awkward and grotesque the PS5 case is. It doesn’t fit well with the decor of almost media rooms nor physically fit in existing cabinets. Also the plastic does not feel premium. Lifting and moving the device you can hear creaks. The bluray drive vibrates the device which can be heard while in use. The XSX player is much quieter. The PS5 has no rubberized feet. At the end of the day these are purpose-built computers to play games. They should blend into the entertainment center. The XSX is a box that quietly does it’s job. For a Microsoft product the XSX has the premium feel.
Microsoft Xbox: Likes itSony PlayStation PS5: Recommends it
Getting a PS5 consists of signing up for Telegram alerts and waiting for stock alerts. Within 1-3 weeks you’ll snag one. In my opinion it makes sense to be patient for 3 weeks and get a PS5, which will surely be relevant for 5-7 more years. Keep in mind, PS4s are also difficult to find right now. They are still selling at the full $300 retail price if you can even find one, and used on eBay they are $250. Why pay $250 for a console that will stop getting new games this year or next year? Now granted, OP seems to be in a different country so maybe these circumstances are different for them but in the US certainly it does not make sense to buy a PS4, for the same price you can buy an Xbox Series S.
Microsoft Xbox: Doesn’t like itSony PlayStation PS5: Doesn’t like it
It's not excessive at all, it's the only conscious way to cast a vote against losing control over the way your games are presented to you. > Playstation has some of the most immersive single player experiences available today, on any platform. Playstation is struggling hard, same as Xbox this generation. PS5 has like 3 exclusives, two of which are Fromsoftware RPGs you can emulate and the other one is probably some censored Senran Kagura rerelease (I genuinely forget what it is). Xbox doesn't fare much better, and both OEMs are scrambling to publish on PC after their own sales slump hard enough to justify laying off entire studios[0] or pulling games a week after release[1]. It's downright pathetic compared to the halcyon days of the PS3, and enough to make the PS4 and Xbox One years look at least... competitive. The two big console manufacturers are lame ducks doing their best to avoid each other, and fostering exactly the sort of lock-in they need to promote recurring service revenue and blatant advertising onto their users. It's just a harsh fact of the gaming industry, right now. Everyone wants to be Nintendo, but nobody has the money to invest in their studios that they bought up during the last generation. Now we get Concord and Starfield as next-gen consolation prizes, lucky us. If the trend of studio layoffs continues, the AAA games industry is going to go anemic. [0] https://www.pushsquare.com/news/2024/06/xbox-explains-why-it... [1] https://ftw.usatoday.c…
Microsoft Xbox: Doesn’t like itSony PlayStation PS5: Doesn’t like it
The idea that Sony is already going to launch a mid-cycle “Pro” refresh of the PS5 seems like madness. Do they really want to further divide their customer base? There are so few exclusive games to play on a PS5 it’s hardly worth it. I say this as somebody that owns “everything.” My Xbox and PS5 collect dust most of the year. Likely going to stop buying consoles after doing so for 30 years. The PC and portable space is far more interesting and has better priced software.
Microsoft Xbox: Doesn’t like itSony PlayStation PS5: Doesn’t like it
Homebrew development has been a thing for as long as video game consoles have been around. I don't think it'd be reasonable to require Sony/Nintendo/Microsoft to provide the development toolchains/SDKs/software they've developed for free. However, it would be good if they were required to allow third-party software installations with software written using third party toolchains (like the homebrew ones). Consoles like the PS5/Xbox really aren't all that different from PCs nowadays, even from the software library side. Most games are cross-platform, and even Sony has been bringing their exclusives to PC. So really, a PS5/Xbox/Switch is just a gaming PC with arbitrary anti-consumer, anti-competitive restrictions. Even if these restrictions actually subsidize the price of the hardware, it's still harmful to consumers since they end up spending a lot more money on software over the lifetime of the console. Plus, that hardware is extremely locked down, so it's not like consumers are really benefiting from those supposed subsidies. They're just paying slightly less up front for a machine designed to take a lot of money from them.
Microsoft Xbox: Likes itSony PlayStation PS5: Likes it
The hidden cost of a gaming pc is the time you inevitably spend keeping it working. The older I get the more I get annoyed by things that waste what time I have left. I game exclusively on my PS5 and XBox Series X and have no regrets about doing so. Every time I spend a few bucks more than I would on pc I just think about how much time I'm not wasting getting it to work at all. YMMV.
Microsoft Xbox: Likes itSony PlayStation PS5: Likes it
> Using WiFi will probably add ~30-50ms of latency to your setup, which is bad, but also consider that both the PS5 and Xbox Series X have over 100ms of input lag alone. This is absolute nonsense. Average end-to-end input-to-rendered-frame latency is half that at 60fps and more like a third of that in 120hz mode in Gears 5 on the Series X https://www.neogaf.com/threads/xbox-series-x-input-latency-r... Lots of similar results abound. Here’s Multiverse on the PS5 averaging 31ms end-to-end latency at 60fps: https://twitter.com/noodalls/status/1552942081014132738 “100ms of input lag alone” (before the engine even has the input? c’mon mate) is a preposterous idea.
Microsoft Xbox: Likes itSony PlayStation PS5: Likes it
I disagree. Low power is currently the lead design principle in modern hardware, anywhere from consumer hardware to enterprise data centers. The least common denominator of a powerful personal computer - the modern gaming console (Xbox Series X or PS5) is already silent and you can't hear the fan. I can't imagine them going fanless in the next couple generations, but who knows what'll happen after that.
Microsoft Xbox: Likes itSony PlayStation PS5: Likes it
never, ever give a TV an internet connection, wifi password or dhcp lease. I realize there are ads on the homescreen of an xbox series x, ps4 pro, ps5, etc but I would much rather deal with those than whatever shoddy operating system TV manufacturers put on their thing. I have a thousand times more confidence that microsoft and sony will keep their OSes patched and up to date (they have a strong financial/self-interest incentive to do so, for anti piracy reasons) than the junk running on a TV.
Microsoft Xbox: Likes itSony PlayStation PS5: Likes it
A PS5 or XSX costs noticeably less than a mid-high GPU and offers effectively the same performance for most people. And is almost literally plug and play - whereas troubleshooting driver versions and weird developer implementation details (e.g. shader recompilation stutters in dx12 games) is still a problem these days! The flexibility and customizability and open nature of PCs is a double edged sword.
Microsoft Xbox: Doesn’t like itSony PlayStation PS5: Doesn’t like it
>Alternate character interpretation: these companies understand that this is a reasonably sustainable price for their customer base, It's not sustainable. It's being sold for too low relative to demand, so they would all just be sold out at that price. The scalpers don't change the supply. >that moving away from those "bad pricing decisions" will alienate their customers, and that The customers can choose to be irrationally angry about whatever they want. >scalpers should be put in trash skips and rolled down steep hills. What is all this anger for? We're not talking about scalping food and water here. These are skinner's boxes. Time wasting machines. It's all just a locked-down waste of silicon that will not be reused and in another ten years everyone will be throwing their PS5s out for a newer console that does the exact same thing. You want a PS5? You want an Xbox? Buy a PC with integrated graphics. it's the same damn thing, except it will actually be useful for something after you're done playing games on it. >Not every profit need be maximized immediately and without hesitation and scalpers need not exist. More than one thing is allowed to be true. It doesn't matter what your opinion of scalpers is. So long as people misvalue things on the open market, there will be traders ready to make a quick buck off of their ignorance.