The stuff Hacker News actually recommends.

Consoles and handhelds

Microsoft Xbox vs Sony PlayStation PS4

Hacker News owners slightly favor the Sony PlayStation PS4.

Microsoft XboxSony PlayStation PS4
Owners with an opinion25169
Positive verdicts59% of 20961% of 54
Positive/negative since 202444/419/10
Happy after 3+ years71
Longest happy owner21 yrs10 yrs
Praised forease of use and reliabilityreliability and ease of use
Criticized forsoftwaresoftware
Newest comment

Updated

What owners wrote about both

Microsoft Xbox: Doesn’t like itSony PlayStation PS4: Likes it
Remember that at launch it was $100 cheaper and more powerful. Multi-plats on PS4 outperformed Xbox One almost always. Usually the PS4 version was 1080p native, Xbox One 900p. Plus storage could be easily upgraded with a screwdriver. And you got the exclusives too. All of the Xbox One's benefits mainly came later when they added backwards compatibility, 4K Blu-ray support, Game Pass etc.
Microsoft Xbox: Doesn’t like itSony PlayStation PS4: Likes it
PS4 is a gaming device with similar hardware, the "killer app" is going to be a game. It seemed to me that Sony invested a lot more than Microsoft in making games during the PS4 era. Microsoft seemed to think Gears of War and Halo were "good enough" while Sony was producing a lot more exclusives. Microsoft must have realized they were getting slaughtered due to lack of games since they started buying gaming studios towards the end of this era.
Microsoft Xbox: Likes itSony PlayStation PS4: Doesn’t like it
I stuck to XB1 for backwards compatibility and Gears of War, but on the other hand I failed to see an obvious advantage to the PS4. What's the "killer app" of the PS4? Apart from exclusives, both seem similar. Both seem to be considerably worse as a media box compared to the good old 360 with it's magnificent built-in DLNA compatibility and CD-ripping.
Microsoft Xbox: Doesn’t like itSony PlayStation PS4: Likes it
I agree with the sentiment, but in my experience that's just not true. [1] The PS4 and PS5 are nice and pain free. The Switch even more so, because the games will run right off the cartridge without needing updates. They have available updates, but the version shipped on the cartridge is 100% playable. [1] With the exception of the XBox because Microsoft can't get their shit together.
Microsoft Xbox: Likes itSony PlayStation PS4: Doesn’t like it
Getting a PS5 consists of signing up for Telegram alerts and waiting for stock alerts. Within 1-3 weeks you’ll snag one. In my opinion it makes sense to be patient for 3 weeks and get a PS5, which will surely be relevant for 5-7 more years. Keep in mind, PS4s are also difficult to find right now. They are still selling at the full $300 retail price if you can even find one, and used on eBay they are $250. Why pay $250 for a console that will stop getting new games this year or next year? Now granted, OP seems to be in a different country so maybe these circumstances are different for them but in the US certainly it does not make sense to buy a PS4, for the same price you can buy an Xbox Series S.
Microsoft Xbox: Doesn’t like itSony PlayStation PS4: Likes it
I liked the PS4 but even I feel like Sony didn't so much win the last generation so much as Microsoft lost it. Microsoft just never recovered from just how bad the XBox One launch was and Sony managed to win by pretty much doing nothing but releasing great exclusive titles. Sony right now seems to be fully into the hubris stage they were in when they made the PS3 and I feel like they are going to slowly lose market to XBox which has immerged from the disastrous XBox One humbled and with a greater desire to cater to their audience.
Microsoft Xbox: Likes itSony PlayStation PS4: Likes it
You are aware that old consoles still play games, right? My PS4 still plays all my PS4 games and lets me stream PS5 games to from my living room to my bedroom. My Xbox 360 still plays games just fine last time I checked (last June or so). Getting rid of old consoles doesn’t make sense unless you absolutely have to have the latest tech and also don’t have much storage space.
Microsoft Xbox: Likes itSony PlayStation PS4: Likes it
>Still, I imagine that if you don't do anything that can't be done on an $800-900 laptop, it might just be simpler to buy that and an Xbox. I always found it funny that PC gamers seem to think console gamers don't own a computer. We do, we've simply found that for the price of building a gaming PC, one can buy a decent laptop AND a console, and run them both without needing further upgrades for a decade . This has a huge bang for buck. I should know, I've done this twice with the x360 and PS4, paired with a mid range dell laptop. Both are flawless for their respective niche. I'm probably building a PC next year, but even I acknowledge that I'm going pretty far out into diminishing returns of enjoyment curve to do so.
Microsoft Xbox: Recommends itSony PlayStation PS4: Recommends it
Just don't ever give it the wifi password. Drive the TV from a PS4/PS4, xbox series X or home theatre PC. Use the youtube/netflix/amazon video/whatever client software on those platforms. I have a thousand times more confidence that microsoft or sony will keep their operating system patched and free from zero days than some random OS on a TV. And at least they're big enough that their telemetry and data collection practices are documented. Yes, it's true you can't get much use out of an xbox series x without an internet connection, but at least you know what you're getting yourself into in advance.
Microsoft Xbox: Doesn’t like itSony PlayStation PS4: Doesn’t like it
I'm not talking about the games themselves, I'm talking about the experience of using the console (I also thought Dread was a bit of a letdown, and don't get me started on the difference between 3D All Stars and the Crash/Spyro remaster). It's just that on the Switch, in almost all cases you just put the cartridge in the console you're in-game within seconds. For Xbone/PS4 (and I'm assuming this is worse on the new consoles), there's a whole arduous process to go through before you can play the game. As someone who no longer has the time/energy to pour into gaming like I used to, this hour long wait before playing a game just makes the whole experience not worth it.