The stuff Hacker News actually recommends.

Consoles and handhelds

Microsoft Xbox vs Sony PlayStation 5

Hacker News owners lean toward the Microsoft Xbox.

Microsoft XboxSony PlayStation 5
Owners with an opinion25154
Positive verdicts59% of 20957% of 42
Positive/negative since 202444/4120/12
Happy after 3+ years70
Longest happy owner21 yrs–
Praised forease of use and reliabilityease of use and performance
Criticized forsoftwarereliability and value
Newest comment

Updated

What owners wrote about both

Microsoft Xbox: Doesn’t like itSony PlayStation 5: Likes it
The Switch is genuinely one of the last pieces of hardware I was really excited about, and I can't say that about much anymore. It's extremely well put together, I've repaired mine a number of times with no issues (honestly opening anything made in Japan is a joy, the engineering is so good) and the specs leave a lot to be desired, which is unfortunate, but at the same time, you wouldn't know it while using it. The XBox is such a curmudgeonly slow experience to use, everything in the menus takes forever to load, the dash jerks and lags, and it's just like... this machine can run Halo Infinite, why does it struggle so damn hard with just... boxes and jpegs? The Switch has a similar issue occasionally in the store application, but outside of that, settings are snappy, updates are practically instant, it turns on and off so quickly. It's what consoles are supposed to be. And honestly in this same vein, the PS5 is also bloody impressive, but that impressiveness came with an impressive price too. The Switch costing as little as it did and still holding it's own is so cool.
Microsoft Xbox: Likes itSony PlayStation 5: Doesn’t like it
You must be an LLM with no concept of aesthetics since most people agree the PS5 is an ugly monstrosity. Unless you are living in a dorm, it looks out of place in most adult living rooms. Meanwhile the Xbox is a simple, modern black box, literally the exact opposite of how you’re trying to paint their hardware and trust me, I’m no Microsoft fan. Give me a break.
Microsoft Xbox: Likes itSony PlayStation 5: Doesn’t like it
I have used it on my Series X and it's just not as good as playing it locally. I've got it hooked up to a 4K120Hz TV that supports VRR and ALLM, and the exeprience over the cloud will never be as good. It's very convenient that I don't have to download 50GB to play a game, but if it's a game I want to actually play, the 50GB is worth it. I also have a PS5 with the PS+ Premium package, and their cloud offering is even worse.
Switched from the Sony PlayStation 5 to the Microsoft XboxMicrosoft Xbox: Likes it
I want to agree but I don't see the greener grass at all. Please bear in mind that this is totally anecdotal. I own all three major consoles. My PS5 has been switched on about six times since I purchased it at the time the PSVR2 was released. Is it because I'm not into the funky and weird JRPG titles or am I just sold to the Xbox ecosystem? I play Xbox almost every single day. My PS5 is just using up space and for two titles which didn't fully grip me (Horizon and The Last of Us). What am I missing here? Is the answer PC/Steam?
Microsoft Xbox: Doesn’t like itSony PlayStation 5: Doesn’t like it
Even with a working NAT64/DNS64 setup the PlayStation 5 doesn’t fully support IPv6 only connections. It will mostly work. Until it doesn’t. Xbox is in the same spot with some games. Don’t even get me started with my TVs or numerous IoT devices. I ran IPv6 on xfinity. It works. My devices don’t. I like my devices. Easier to just not use it.
Microsoft Xbox: Likes itSony PlayStation 5: Likes it
As a person who has both, you gotta admit the care that Sony puts into their hardware. This time around the Xbox Series X is arguably sleeker, but by God is the controller pure trash. The Xbox’s controller vibrations resemble those of a cheap trimmer, whereas the Playstation’s controller has a much nicer feel. It’s also a fact that many games are better optimized for PS5, even though on paper the Xbox should have a slight edge. I don’t care about console wars, and I’m glad I have both of them, but some games are only on PS5, which is another reason people opt for it.