The stuff Hacker News actually recommends.

Consoles and handhelds

Microsoft Xbox vs Sony PlayStation

Hacker News owners slightly favor the Sony PlayStation.

Microsoft XboxSony PlayStation
Owners with an opinion251357
Positive verdicts59% of 20964% of 289
Positive/negative since 202444/4183/46
Happy after 3+ years72
Longest happy owner21 yrs10 yrs
Praised forease of use and reliabilityease of use and reliability
Criticized forsoftwaresoftware
Newest comment

Updated

What owners wrote about both

Microsoft Xbox: Doesn’t like itSony PlayStation: Likes it
Playstation and Nintendo are doing just fine in regards to mindshare, XBox less so, but it has nothing to do with DirectX NDA for it, rather mismanagement.
Microsoft Xbox: Doesn’t like itSony PlayStation: Likes it
Same boat as you. It's wild that I can turn on the xbox, wait 20-30min for mandatory updates, then need to re-sign in or occasionally reset my wireless mac address due to some bug, then re-sign into my Xbox account even if I am fine playing offline but of course I forgot my password so now I'm on my phone doing 2FA to remember which email I used to reset the password. Then I will need to update the game I want to play (somehow FIFA 23 still requires updates?), then re-sign in to EA whose password of course I also forgot so now I'm on my phone resetting my password for EA. Now it's been 45minutes and I'm frustrated and realize I could have loaded up Steam or Switch and been playing this whole time. Not to mention that once the Xbox itself is working it will be running slower than the Nintendo Switch I own which is only about 2yr newer than it. just a bad system! I legit got my old PlayStation 2 back up and running so I wouldn't deal with this. (sorry been needing to vent all this lmao)
Microsoft Xbox: Doesn’t like itSony PlayStation: Likes it
For this generation I switched to PlayStation, after many years of being an Xbox gamer. Microsoft can't make good products anymore. The Xbox One is nearly unusable. It would interrupt me nearly every single evening while I was trying to use it with updates that would take 20+ minutes, no option to defer to a later time (well, you _could_ defer to a later time, but you'd be forced to go offline until the update installed). Software constantly crashed, the list of problems goes on and on, and they got worse over time rather than better. So now I have the first PlayStation I've ever owned, and for the first time in a long time I actually like my game console.
Microsoft Xbox: Doesn’t like itSony PlayStation: Likes it
I never understood what the heck they were thinking. I've been an Xbox diehard since the early 2000s but bringing your exclusives to PlayStation just makes me genuinely consider switching to PlayStation. You are telling me I can now get all the games I want to play on PlayStation, or some of the games I want to play on Xbox? You're really making the case for me to switch. And the whole "This is an Xbox" marketing strategy, claiming a Firestick streaming Xbox is as good as an Xbox? Firstly it's dumb and no one is buying it. Secondly, if people did believe it, at best you're just canabalizing your market share. You're not going to build any sort of brand loyalty to a dime a dozen streaming platform.
Microsoft Xbox: Likes itSony PlayStation: Doesn’t like it
I want to agree but I don't see the greener grass at all. Please bear in mind that this is totally anecdotal. I own all three major consoles. My PS5 has been switched on about six times since I purchased it at the time the PSVR2 was released. Is it because I'm not into the funky and weird JRPG titles or am I just sold to the Xbox ecosystem? I play Xbox almost every single day. My PS5 is just using up space and for two titles which didn't fully grip me (Horizon and The Last of Us). What am I missing here? Is the answer PC/Steam?
Microsoft Xbox: NeutralSony PlayStation: Likes it
According to leaks with an excellent track recordWe are getting at least 1 more console, and possibly 2. The first (most likely) is a classic Xbox, the second is a handheld. After that, who knows? All I know is that I own both an Xbox Series X and a PS5. I use the PS5 more. I also own a PC, and it sees more than 1,000 times the usage of either. I bought the PS5 for exclusives, and Sony began changing that. However there are still alot of older PS4/PS5 titles that are fun to play, and some games are just better with a controller and a TV. That being said, I'm likely not going to purchase any other consoles.
Microsoft Xbox: Recommends itSony PlayStation: Likes it
I don’t see what the point is for consoles that aren’t PCs. Pair an XBOX ONE controller with a decent PC and install Steam and it is not the sweaty experience that PC gaming was in the 1990s, but a lean-back “just works” experience, you can play the same games with the same controller. Instead of waiting for the upgrade cycle you can get the latest hardware from AMD, Intel or even Apple. If you want to spend more and get a top flight graphics card you can get high frame rates at 4k. And it’s a PC, you can hook up a keyboard and a mouse and do all your PC stuff too so it better justifies the price. The PS5 has sold a respectable number of units but when I needed a mostly media box to sit next to a TV I got a used PS4 Pro because the PS5 was much more expensive, I have Steam on a few machines. There are only 15 exclusives for the PS 5, one is a remake of my favorite game from the early 2010s but that’s not worth it to me. Microsoft should come out with XBOX gaming PCs, whether it is own-brand like the Surface or are licensed through partners like ASUS and Dell.
Microsoft Xbox: Likes itSony PlayStation: Doesn’t like it
The reason I bought an Xbox is because of the PS4 I had before. It was quite bad and I have no idea why anyone would think it’s better. The game controller was average, laggy and had to be charged every 5 hours. The console was noisy and the UI was sluggish. Download speeds from the store were also weirdly slow. The whole experience was very meh. Then I bought an Xbox and was pleasantly surprised with the quality.
Microsoft Xbox: Doesn’t like itSony PlayStation: Likes it
I've never managed to find a Wii-connector-to-USB adapter that wouldn't inexplicably die within six months, but the 1st-party SNES Classic controllers are basically perfect clones of the original. Ditto the NES versions they have. Wii Pro Controllers are also great and have a similar feel & quality, but with modern ergonomics (no rumble, though, so not great for e.g. Playstation games, and IIRC the triggers aren't analog, which is limiting) You can connect Wiimotes to PCs over Bluetooth and use any of those Wii-connector controllers through them, which would make them wireless and solve the finding-a-reliable-adapter problem, but I've never managed to make that kind of set-up sufficiently stable. Always having to screw with re-pairing and such. In the end, my go-to for BT emulation controllers is usually a PS3/4/5 controller. I haven't tried the XBone but I found the d-pad on the XB and XB360 controllers unusably inaccurate, and the face buttons weirdly slow when trying to play old-school Nintendo-hard games. Playstation controller d-pads are much better, and the face buttons feel quicker to switch between, for whatever reason.
Microsoft Xbox: Likes itSony PlayStation: Neutral
I had an xecuter mod on the first Xbox and a 2TB hard drive, you could do so many many things with Xbox Media Center on the very first Xbox - FTP your games over. TBH the Xbox 360 console was like a refresh of XBMC. One of the greatest things about the 360 out of the box was it played popular video codecs directly from USB storage - unmodded! Unheard of at the time. I had an early model PSX console in high school and bought the plug and play mod chip online in 2000 or so. Rented a lot of games and bought a lot of verbatim blue bottoms Later a USB plus 1 wire mod chip for the PS2 that let me play backups and homebrew
Microsoft Xbox: Likes itSony PlayStation: Doesn’t like it
Microsoft is much better about backwards compatibility and preservation than Sony, too. I have a library of Xbox and Xbox 360 discs I can just put in my Xbox Series X and still play, often with improvements. I can even still buy many titles from those generations digitally and play them on my Series X. Meanwhile, Sony's missing many landmark titles from two generations, and your only option for playing PS3 games on a PS5 is streaming.
Microsoft Xbox: Likes itSony PlayStation: Doesn’t like it
A bit off topic, but I recently bought my first Xbox (series x) after owning every generation of PlayStation since launch. There were 3 reasons I opted for the Xbox: availability, aesthetics of the device itself (in my opinion the new PS5 is hideous), and most importantly Xbox Game Pass. I am amazed at the number of high quality games on there for a relatively small monthly fee. Buying one new game at full price is the equivalent of around 6 months of game pass. So for the same price I can either have 2 new games a year, or have access to hundreds of games. Subscription services like that make piracy completely redundant. Game pass is spotify for games, and I haven't bought or pirated music since I started using spotify
Microsoft Xbox: Doesn’t like itSony PlayStation: Likes it
AFAIK you cannot even use an Xbox for the 1st time without connecting it to the internet. PS on the contrary you can pop a game and it runs offline. But it seems they have been working on removing these constrains which are truly crucial for preservation in the future.
Microsoft Xbox: Doesn’t like itSony PlayStation: Likes it
Remember that at launch it was $100 cheaper and more powerful. Multi-plats on PS4 outperformed Xbox One almost always. Usually the PS4 version was 1080p native, Xbox One 900p. Plus storage could be easily upgraded with a screwdriver. And you got the exclusives too. All of the Xbox One's benefits mainly came later when they added backwards compatibility, 4K Blu-ray support, Game Pass etc.
Microsoft Xbox: Likes itSony PlayStation: Doesn’t like it
I stuck to XB1 for backwards compatibility and Gears of War, but on the other hand I failed to see an obvious advantage to the PS4. What's the "killer app" of the PS4? Apart from exclusives, both seem similar. Both seem to be considerably worse as a media box compared to the good old 360 with it's magnificent built-in DLNA compatibility and CD-ripping.
Microsoft Xbox: Doesn’t like itSony PlayStation: Likes it
PS4 is a gaming device with similar hardware, the "killer app" is going to be a game. It seemed to me that Sony invested a lot more than Microsoft in making games during the PS4 era. Microsoft seemed to think Gears of War and Halo were "good enough" while Sony was producing a lot more exclusives. Microsoft must have realized they were getting slaughtered due to lack of games since they started buying gaming studios towards the end of this era.
Microsoft Xbox: Doesn’t like itSony PlayStation: Likes it
I agree with the sentiment, but in my experience that's just not true. [1] The PS4 and PS5 are nice and pain free. The Switch even more so, because the games will run right off the cartridge without needing updates. They have available updates, but the version shipped on the cartridge is 100% playable. [1] With the exception of the XBox because Microsoft can't get their shit together.
Microsoft Xbox: Likes itSony PlayStation: Doesn’t like it
I have a PS5, but bought a Series S recently and since then the PS5 is gathering dust. Not because it's some superior console(it isn't) but because GamePass is just such a fantastic offering, and Sony's PS Plus Premium is just a joke in comparison. And the fact that nearly all games sync saves with their PC versions is just a cherry on top. I can play something on my gaming PC then move over to the living room and continue seamlessly - it's great. Can't do that with 99% of games on the PS5.