The stuff Hacker News actually recommends.

Consoles and handhelds

Microsoft Xbox vs Nintendo Switch

Hacker News owners slightly favor the Nintendo Switch.

Microsoft XboxNintendo Switch
Owners with an opinion251304
Positive verdicts59% of 20961% of 240
Positive/negative since 202444/4163/42
Happy after 3+ years72
Longest happy owner21 yrs8 yrs
Praised forease of use and reliabilityease of use and performance
Criticized forsoftwarereliability and comfort
Newest comment

Updated

What owners wrote about both

Microsoft Xbox: Doesn’t like itNintendo Switch: Likes it
Same boat as you. It's wild that I can turn on the xbox, wait 20-30min for mandatory updates, then need to re-sign in or occasionally reset my wireless mac address due to some bug, then re-sign into my Xbox account even if I am fine playing offline but of course I forgot my password so now I'm on my phone doing 2FA to remember which email I used to reset the password. Then I will need to update the game I want to play (somehow FIFA 23 still requires updates?), then re-sign in to EA whose password of course I also forgot so now I'm on my phone resetting my password for EA. Now it's been 45minutes and I'm frustrated and realize I could have loaded up Steam or Switch and been playing this whole time. Not to mention that once the Xbox itself is working it will be running slower than the Nintendo Switch I own which is only about 2yr newer than it. just a bad system! I legit got my old PlayStation 2 back up and running so I wouldn't deal with this. (sorry been needing to vent all this lmao)
Microsoft Xbox: Doesn’t like itNintendo Switch: Likes it
An Xbox has sat in my living room since the first one came out way back when I worked at Microsoft. Many enjoyable hours of Halo, Rainbow Six and what have you. The most current hardware (Xbox X) I mainly use to play remasters of old games (currently, Mass Effect) and as a Blu-ray player. Latest Call of Duty? Soooo tired. Jack up the Game Pass sub price? It’s just not worth it anymore. Xbox spent a ton of money pushing game streaming. Right, because I do what I can to reduce latency, and now I’m going to stream the game? If I’m going to play casual games, I’ll do it from my phone. There are paper cuts that start to add up. Like if I hit A to play a game, now I have to hit A again on some intermediate screen to activate the Play button on that screen. WTF is that for? Further examples abound. Part of the problem is on my end, as I’m growing a bit tired of the game industry in general (gambling-lite, with some gameplay thrown in). But part of it is the floundering of the platform I’ve used for over two decades. I’ve got a Switch that I’ve had a lot of fun with, and I think when it comes new hardware time, it’ll probably be a Steam Deck.
Microsoft Xbox: Doesn’t like itNintendo Switch: Likes it
We have a switch and an XBox and after liking the 360 back in the day the newer XBoxes just make me want to tear my hair out. They sold us all on bigger and bigger hardware to get rid of load times and they ended up with the system with the worst load times going all the way back to the 70s. Sometimes it seems like it takes 10 minutes to start up and actually play a game, and then there the updates. My son got a Forza Horizon game for Xmas and it immediately said it needed to download 128GB from the internet before he could play it. With the way it worked out he didn't get to play it on Christmas day as it never finished downloading before we had to go leave to visit relatives. Just a horrific experience compared to Switch.
Microsoft Xbox: Doesn’t like itNintendo Switch: Likes it
The Switch is genuinely one of the last pieces of hardware I was really excited about, and I can't say that about much anymore. It's extremely well put together, I've repaired mine a number of times with no issues (honestly opening anything made in Japan is a joy, the engineering is so good) and the specs leave a lot to be desired, which is unfortunate, but at the same time, you wouldn't know it while using it. The XBox is such a curmudgeonly slow experience to use, everything in the menus takes forever to load, the dash jerks and lags, and it's just like... this machine can run Halo Infinite, why does it struggle so damn hard with just... boxes and jpegs? The Switch has a similar issue occasionally in the store application, but outside of that, settings are snappy, updates are practically instant, it turns on and off so quickly. It's what consoles are supposed to be. And honestly in this same vein, the PS5 is also bloody impressive, but that impressiveness came with an impressive price too. The Switch costing as little as it did and still holding it's own is so cool.
Microsoft Xbox: Likes itNintendo Switch: Doesn’t like it
> All mainstream console controllers experience more or less stick drift Yet my two xbox controllers that I've had for 5 years have not experienced this, and nor have my PS4 controller (4 years old at this point). I've had to replace the joycon twice. And the third one still has drift. I gave up and just use a Nintendo Switch Pro controller with it now.
Microsoft Xbox: Doesn’t like itNintendo Switch: Likes it
The funny thing is even as a consumer that understands all the confusing branding and power differences, I would still buy the cheaper system if it had compelling games to play compared to the PS5…it just doesn’t, and when it comes to first party titles everything Microsoft puts out is mid at best (Halo), or downright awful (Redfall). I also own a Nintendo Switch and I think I own more games on that than any other console I’ve owned in my entire life so raw power is t an issue for me. I want to want to buy an Xbox but the most important thing (games) just is t there. I may still buy one when Starfield comes out because it would be more expensive to build a gaming PC to play it (mac user), but I’m waiting to find out from reviews if it lives up to the (admittedly impressive from what they’ve shown) stuff they’ve shown off recently.
Microsoft Xbox: Doesn’t like itNintendo Switch: Likes it
I have an Xbox One and have had it since late 2015? I have been gaming since Atari (though the first I bought with my own money was Dreamcast) and even versus the Xbox 360 I'd say the Xbox One has been the console I'm least satisfied by. And Microsoft's strategy with the S/X nonsense and games now not working as well on some versions of the console versus others has put the stake in it for me. I'm going to be extremely reluctant to ever buy another one of their consoles. This generation has almost completely turned me off gaming. A lot of the other changes in gaming (gambling, loot boxes, monetization, abandoning single player gaming) have not helped either, but MS has definitely shot themselves in the foot hard as far as I'm concerned. My son has a Switch, it might not be as powerful, but Nintendo literally got everything right in the way MS got everything wrong. You can actually play the switch when you have 5 minutes to play. It doesn't do super long updates. The games always work. The games don't get slower when an update is applied, etc.. It has excellent single player games and excellent multiplayer in the same room games. A lot of their games have great deployability. My 360 broke twice (RROD, DVD drive failure) and my PS3 also broke, and yet I would still take either of those back over the Xbox One any day. My kid is 10 and the other thing is the game selection on Xbox is terrible for having games that adults and kids can actually play together. The %…
Microsoft Xbox: Likes itNintendo Switch: Doesn’t like it
I mean, isn't it kind of obvious that this design "flaw" was engineered on purpose in order to force people to buy more JoyCons? Every company does this sort of thing. On a side note, does anyone have any recommendations for a legitimate premium controller for PC that won't break? I've tried so many controllers and they all turn out to be cheap bullshit... the best I've been able to find is the official Xbox remote. But I'd gladly shell out big bucks for a high quality controller that won't break, like a mechanical keyboard but for gaming controllers.
Microsoft Xbox: Doesn’t like itNintendo Switch: Likes it
In a past interview, Phil mentioned "dabbing with a handheld prototype since forever", so they already have a head start The problem is their strategy with the cloud, i believe it is the wrong one since they are burning a lot of steps They should have done the nintendo way, since the beginning, and as 5G networks gets deployed, you supplement your library with cloud and various services, and then once it becomes mainstream you already have a huge userbase ready to transition fully to a simpler cloud only device Let's remember: https://twitter.com/xboxp3/status/463171463168524288?lang=en then 3 years later the switch was released and then 1 month later he doubled down on "i don't think we'll do a handheld" https://www.gamedeveloper.com/business/q-a-with-scorpio-risi... Then 4 years later the Steam Deck was announced (and that's when he mention the "we dabbled with handheld since forever", * i'm still trying to find that itw, hold on *) So in total, they had more than a decade (3 generations), to release multiple attempts for a handheld, they did nothing, and they are still the 3rd and last player in the console market And nintendo annihilates both Sony/Microsoft with their handheld, just 1gen, still beats 2 of their competitors gens Series S should have been a handheld, and Series X the digital only console, i think they agree but they don't have the balls to rectify, that's funny when you consider they also had the balls to release a phone with 2 screens lol
Microsoft Xbox: Doesn’t like itNintendo Switch: Likes it
I agree with the sentiment, but in my experience that's just not true. [1] The PS4 and PS5 are nice and pain free. The Switch even more so, because the games will run right off the cartridge without needing updates. They have available updates, but the version shipped on the cartridge is 100% playable. [1] With the exception of the XBox because Microsoft can't get their shit together.
Microsoft Xbox: Doesn’t like itNintendo Switch: Likes it
I'm not talking about the games themselves, I'm talking about the experience of using the console (I also thought Dread was a bit of a letdown, and don't get me started on the difference between 3D All Stars and the Crash/Spyro remaster). It's just that on the Switch, in almost all cases you just put the cartridge in the console you're in-game within seconds. For Xbone/PS4 (and I'm assuming this is worse on the new consoles), there's a whole arduous process to go through before you can play the game. As someone who no longer has the time/energy to pour into gaming like I used to, this hour long wait before playing a game just makes the whole experience not worth it.
Switched from the Microsoft Xbox to the Nintendo SwitchNintendo Switch: Likes it
I am so glad i jumped out of the Xbox ecosystem back when I did. I was such a loyal fan, but the Xbox One made me go from an avid gamer to a casual gamer. I thought I was done with gaming until I picked up a Nintendo Switch back in 2018 and I rediscovered the joy. I gave Xbox one more chance with the Series X and that was the final nail in the coffin. I only play on Switch 2 and Steam OS nowadays.
Microsoft Xbox: Doesn’t like itNintendo Switch: Doesn’t like it
And no jailbreaking required. I just wish I could hold one to see if my hands fit. My awkward hands where DS, Switch, PS and Xbox controllers all give me cramps after around ten minutes of play time. N64 not so. It's why I've always been a PC gamer.
Microsoft Xbox: Likes itNintendo Switch: Likes it
I dunno, I own everything Apple, except for gaming. I have two of their best XBOX and I'm loving the game pass and their "game streaming" actually works. In my mind, you can't get better value than XBOX for console games. My kids have the switch, with all the mario titles, they're super cool too. But in terms of winning, XBOX has the best value proposition + powerhouse.
Microsoft Xbox: Doesn’t like itNintendo Switch: Doesn’t like it
Homebrew development has been a thing for as long as video game consoles have been around. I don't think it'd be reasonable to require Sony/Nintendo/Microsoft to provide the development toolchains/SDKs/software they've developed for free. However, it would be good if they were required to allow third-party software installations with software written using third party toolchains (like the homebrew ones). Consoles like the PS5/Xbox really aren't all that different from PCs nowadays, even from the software library side. Most games are cross-platform, and even Sony has been bringing their exclusives to PC. So really, a PS5/Xbox/Switch is just a gaming PC with arbitrary anti-consumer, anti-competitive restrictions. Even if these restrictions actually subsidize the price of the hardware, it's still harmful to consumers since they end up spending a lot more money on software over the lifetime of the console. Plus, that hardware is extremely locked down, so it's not like consumers are really benefiting from those supposed subsidies. They're just paying slightly less up front for a machine designed to take a lot of money from them.
Microsoft Xbox: Likes itNintendo Switch: Likes it
Considering that consoles like Xbox Series S, Nintendo Switch are available for less than $300 and provide a much better gaming experience, it was quite inevitable. This does even more damage to the Google's reputation. I would never recommend or use GCP for example, now. Lastly google already has a gaming platform i.e. Android, and I would have loved to see some more innovation in that space instead.
Microsoft Xbox: Doesn’t like itNintendo Switch: Doesn’t like it
Some surprising companies have not completely figured out the correct way to use CEC either. - Apple: When you start an Airplay stream on your phone directed at an Apple TV, the Apple TV doesn't send a switch input command. - Nintendo: The Nintendo Switch switch input command when waking from sleep is unreliable at best. - Microsoft: Surprisingly the worst offender. The only switch input command it ever sends is when it wakes from user-induced sleep. If you let the console go to sleep on its own, and wake up the controller and press the big Xbox button, it never sends a CEC command.
Microsoft Xbox: Likes itNintendo Switch: Likes it
Oddly enough, my experience was the opposite. After enjoying the Switch for 3+ years (purchased late 2018), the same price point bought me an XBOX Series S earlier this year (Series X were/(are?) hard to find and this was an impromptu purchase. Not entirely happy about that tradeoff). Suffice to say, been having a blast catching up with old favorites and new games. The backward compatibility enhancements (higher FPS and upres'ing) really put into perspective just how little gaming has progressed generationally, which makes these games that much more enjoyable. The Switch is an amazing device (own two - one modded and one non). While the availability of games increases daily, its performance will always remain the weak point. That^ and its horrible controllers. The XBX controller is sublime.