The stuff Hacker News actually recommends.

VR and AR headsets

Meta Quest vs Valve Index

Hacker News owners slightly favor the Meta Quest.

Meta QuestValve Index
Owners with an opinion806128
Positive verdicts53% of 67256% of 102
Positive/negative since 2024169/14324/13
Happy after 3+ years20
Longest happy owner5 yrs0.5 yrs
Praised forperformance and ease of useperformance and comfort
Criticized forcomfort and displayease of use and display
Newest comment

Updated

What owners wrote about both

Meta Quest: NeutralValve Index: Likes it
That's gonna be one expensive BeatSaber machine, but after having owned an Index (and really feeling how nice that headset was when I got my current Quest 2), there's no way I'm not gonna get one.
Meta Quest: Likes itValve Index: Doesn’t like it
I one the other hand bought one before Christmas and love it. I got a Valve Index when it first released and while a fun gimmick, I don't think I've used it more than 20 hours. I have yet to play Half Life Alyx. The Quest 3 on the other hand is so plug and play I put it on pretty much every evening after work, especially because I have grown to dislike sitting on my desk to play video games. This generation of Quest might be the first device to reach critical mass I reckon. A lot of naysayers are a bit like those that believed videogames to be a fad in the 1980s. Yeah, it's nascent technology, but it is improving at breakneck pace. Even Apple is in the space now.
Meta Quest: Likes itValve Index: Doesn’t like it
It’s way better than the Index resolution wise, and there is no screen door effect. Then again even the Quest 3 is better now since the Index is so ancient. There are two main issues with the visuals though: 1. Poor vertical FOV 2. Motion blurring whenever you move which is likely due to the OLED screens You can’t use this on Steam until we get Virtual desktop on the Vision Pro. Not sure how well it would work though since the blur is not great unless you mostly play sim games.
Meta Quest: Recommends itValve Index: Neutral
I was an early adopter of VR. Original Quest, followed by Htc Vive followed by Valve Index, followed by Quest 3. Spent almost as much hours gaming and using VR as I do my regular computer. I recently tried the Vision Pro at my friends house. Graphics are definitely a lot better. Hand tracking is better than Quest 3. Weight is definitely bulkier on out of all the headsets, but thats something that you get used to - when I first started gaming in VR, my neck was super sore, but after a while, you actually end up strengthening your neck and upper back, which ironically resulted in less headaches for me during the day. That being said, Vision pro is nothing revolutionary. You either have to be a massive Apple stan or never experienced VR to begin with to find it amazing. Its a better iteration of the current VR headsets for sure, but just like the rest, its missing the point. The biggest problem in itself is that everyone is trying to mix VR and AR into one, which is the wrong way to go. VR is way better with external tracking, because you can do things like full body tracking. In VR chat, Ive participated in a few events where people were teaching dance or martial arts, with trackers on hip, knees and legs, and it worked out quite well. Behind the back tracking is also useful for games. Of course the issue with VR is that the entry cost (including the space to play VR) is very high, so the community is VERY tiny. AR on the other hand needs to be a very lightweight, low profile…
Meta Quest: Likes itValve Index: Doesn’t like it
Yeah, the Quest's boundary setup process astounded me at how polished and user-friendly it is compared to the Vive and Index's room setup process. Anyone saying that the Quest's software is obviously terrible lives on a different planet than me. The Quest is so simple and works so well compared to other VR headsets+software I've used.
Meta Quest: Doesn’t like itValve Index: Likes it
I write applications to run on the quest and it's miserable. Simply getting your apk onto the device is the most unnecessarily difficult things I've ever seen. In order to unlock developer mode, you have to have a Facebook account with your phone number associate with a Facebook developer group for your company which requires additional verification to set up. Then you are required to install the oculus app on your phone and link it into your Facebook account. If you're lucky, this will work the second or third time you try it. Even then, sideloaded apps are hidden away in a separate menu. Oh, and you think you can just use your quest tethered while you work in Unity? Good fucking luck. It's remarkably unreliable and unstable. Usually I get a black screen until I restart my headset, my computer, SteamVR, unity or a combination thereof. It's been over a year and I still don't know what the right incantation is. If you want to try air-link, you don't get hand tracking. Intentionally. It's not a technical limitation. Beyond that, it's mostly-standard Android, which is also painful to develop for, but in new and exciting ways. Conversely, targeting Valve Index and an ultraleap tracker is as easy as it gets. If your application runs on the PC where you're developing it, you're already done. It's plug and play almost every time. There's no extra layers of bullshit to wade through, you just open unity and hit play and that's it . Well, unless you count all the ways that PC develo…
Meta Quest: Doesn’t like itValve Index: Likes it
As an owner of an HTC Vive and a Quest 2, I find the terrible specs of the Quest to be the biggest reason why it collects dust. The resolution is horrible, the cameras are horrible, and the apps it can run are crap. Exploring raytraced worlds on my 3090Ti in a high resolution Vive or Valve Index delivers a level of immersive experience that’s impossible to achieve on Quests hardware. The Quest 3 is still a bit of a potato but one day, quality and convenience will converge into a sweet spot that clicks for more people in a way that only enthusiasts get to experience nowadays. A portable Index would likely have the impact people tend to expect when they imagine futuristic VR.
Meta Quest: Likes itValve Index: Doesn’t like it
Hardly the last hope. So far the only successful headset is the Oculus Quest and it was made by Meta, not Apple. It had multiple new features: internal processor, inside-out tracking, camera passthrough, very low price. The Quest headsets have sold 20 million units. In terms of features, the Vision is basically an ultra expensive premium Quest, combined with a heavier software focus on AR and finger tracking instead of controllers. It is clear that Meta tries to conquer the market from the low price end, which seems to work, as there hasn't been an expensive headset (like the Valve Index) which sold anywhere as many units as the Quest. Now Apple doubles down on the high price end route. It will be interesting to see which price approach proves successful in the long run, or whether they both converge at some sort of compromise. I wouldn't say Apple's approach has an obvious advantage.
Meta Quest: Likes itValve Index: Doesn’t like it
Ok. But Index is made by Valve and you're using SteamVR. I've always had motion sickness issues with Valve. For whatever reason, Quest's rendering stack has always not made me motion sick. Even with Oculus Link which has what people consider "crazy" latencies, it's not which means that it's ASW and other last rendering corrections that are hiding better all the things that would cause motion sickness.
Meta Quest: Likes itValve Index: Doesn’t like it
I was tooling around with VR development when I tried developing directly from within the headset. Shockingly, the Quest 2 was streets ahead of the Index when it came to usability. It wasn't bad; it just wasn't something I would want to replace my current setup. I'm sure once the headsets hit a certain resolution, this will become much more common.
Meta Quest: Doesn’t like itValve Index: Likes it
It depends on how you want to argue. For me, refresh rate and FOV matter most . Low refresh headsets make me nauseated, and the Quest 1 can easily start to verge on that sickness after 30 minutes to an hour of playtime. The Index did a good job at mitigating that sickness feeling, and the FOV seems very desirable if people want to use these headsets as monitor replacements.
Meta Quest: Doesn’t like itValve Index: Recommends it
The previous quests are shoddily built - both in software and hardware. Very frustrating to try to do anything with it outside of using the default apps, which are frankly beta quality at best, and the ~3 fully fleshed out games. If you're going to invest over $1k, might as well get a valve index. I can't imagine this working out well for running custom enterprise software, which seems to be who they are targeting.
Meta Quest: Doesn’t like itValve Index: Likes it
Wow, no built-in speakers/headphones? Ignoring the sticker shock for a moment, for $1500 that seems like a big oversight. The ones on my Index are incredible quality and can't be heard by anyone near me even when the volume is pumped up, but they're selling these $50 Meta Quest Pro VR Earphones separately? Feels kind of like they're adding insult to injury. Separately, I still have a hard time with my friends Quest controllers compared to the Valve knuckles. Something about how the Valve controls grip your hands, instead of you actively gripping them, it's just so much more natural. I'm really surprised these new controllers don't have the same style of straps built-in.
Meta Quest: Doesn’t like itValve Index: Likes it
If you have the money, an index is the true experience. Quest gives me headaches and lenses have terrible godrays. You can't match eye spacing properly on quest, and it's software is junk. The UI hitches and causes nausea. Sometimes refuses to display menus or setup boundary properly and just sits there until I factory restore the headset. Secondary FB accounts can be banned for not being the "real person" btw.
Meta Quest: Likes itValve Index: Neutral
At typically more than 2x the cost. I've played Alyx on both, the Index is absolutely not a 2x better experience. I'm no fan of their corporate parent either, but the value proposition on Quest 2 for general purpose PC VR gaming (especially prior to this price increase) was remarkable given size of subsidy Meta were prepared to make on price.
Meta Quest: Doesn’t like itValve Index: Likes it
I bought two recently for my parents and they don’t use them. I tried to use them but there are no real VR games to play. All of the games are arcade-style mini games with 20 year-old graphics. They get boring after a couple minutes. Huge disappointment! Around 10 years ago I gave up on VR and decided to wait for the VR game market to grow. It was a huge bummer to learn that nothing has changed after all this time. I think it will take another decade or two for hardware power and costs to catch up to modern game engines. For me, the only VR experience worth experiencing right now is probably a $1000 Valve Index with Half-Life Alyx running on my $4000 PC.
Meta Quest: Doesn’t like itValve Index: Likes it
A lot of people have found motion sickness in VR is actually usually driven by refresh rate. They get sick because the screen doesn't update as fast as reality. If you have the chance to try a Valve Index, they have the ability (not default setting though) to go to 144hz, and you may experience way less sickness. The Quest and Quest2 can't go that high.
Meta Quest: Doesn’t like itValve Index: Likes it
You are ignoring that plenty of people, especially young people, already tolerate headsets enough to spend many hours wearing them. Making the headsets much much lighter, less hot, wireless, better optics, higher res, higher refresh rates, etc., will improve the experience massively. Look into what is already public: companies are exploring eye tracking, varifocal lenses (so your eyes are not always looking at the same focal plane), etc. You can even compare the Index versus the Quest 2 to see what a difference a better screen can make. People already deal with eye strain by staring at a bright screen from a fixed distance for most of their life. Neural link, sure, eventually. For now, if you don’t think ten years of progress won’t lead to hundreds of millions of devices sold, well, wait and see.