The stuff Hacker News actually recommends.

VR and AR headsets

Meta Quest vs Oculus Rift

Hacker News owners slightly favor the Meta Quest.

Meta QuestOculus Rift
Owners with an opinion80687
Positive verdicts53% of 67244% of 68
Positive/negative since 2024169/1438/11
Happy after 3+ years22
Longest happy owner5 yrs10 yrs
Praised forperformance and ease of usecomfort and performance
Criticized forcomfort and displaydisplay and ease of use
Newest comment

Updated

What owners wrote about both

Meta Quest: Likes itOculus Rift: Doesn’t like it
I have both a Rift S and a Quest 3. The Quest 3's displays and optics blow the Rift out of the water! I've used it for coding using Immersed, and would be happy to use equivalent or slightly better (as the Steam Frame should be) for this purpose.
Meta Quest: Doesn’t like itOculus Rift: Likes it
> …I guess I’ve been an enthusiast since the Rift Kickstarter? The rift CV1 was really comfortable because there wasn't a whole lot in it. No processing, no battery, no cameras. It was pretty light. And the strap was not built down to a price and skimped on to upsell the elite straps. Even the much heavier quest 1 was way more comfortable than the quest 2 and 3. Way better standard strap. So good an elite one wasn't even needed.
Meta Quest: Doesn’t like itOculus Rift: Neutral
I had the original Oculus Rift (tethered to a PC), the Oculus Go, the Quest 2 (paid for by my former employer) and now the Quest 3 (employer discount, I work for Meta but on WhatsApp, not Quest), and it’s a huge improvement over the Quest Pro or Quest 2, which is why I got it. My main use case is watching the 360º spherical panoramas I take with my Ricoh Theta Z1 camera, and possibly some light gaming, although Call of Duty Above and Beyond’s dogged insistence on realistic weapons handling is more of a drag than fun. I’m still working on getting a WebXR-enabled photo gallery generator using Three.js to be able to share those immersive panoramas with friends & family.
Meta Quest: Doesn’t like itOculus Rift: Likes it
I had Rift, Quest 1, and Quest 2. The problem with these is 1. They’re really high friction to turn on so I don’t usually bother 2. The displays are too low rez so I don’t want to read text/do work or watch non-3D movies in them (though 3D ones are spectacular, but too hard to set up and no streaming service support means even more friction “acquiring” them), and 3. There aren’t enough AAA blockbuster narrative games (Half Life Alyx made my entire Rift purchase worth it, but nothing single handedly justified the Quest 2). The UI is also really annoying to navigate without controllers. Idk why they didn’t instantly adopt the Apple look-and-pinch model (even without eye tracking a crosshair with snapping would probably be fine).
Meta Quest: Doesn’t like itOculus Rift: Likes it
Q2 owner, decided not to upgrade to the Q3 because I want a mid range headset with a DisplayPort connection. As much as I appreciate wireless PCVR - I am excited for its future but it doesn't do it for me at this stage. People say that the latency and fidelity are indistinguishable from wired PCVR - that has not been my experience. I have a high end WiFi 6 router where the Q2 is the only device connected in line of sight of the router via 5ghz and my PC is connected via gigabit ethernet. I have also tweaked all the settings, purchased Virtual Desktop and done my best. It's _fine_ but certainly not delivering anywhere close to what the headset hardware can offer in terms of fidelity. The worst part is that, though better than wireless, even PCVR over the link cable is kinda rubbish. Previously to the Q2 I had an HP Reverb G2 and the visual quality was mind blowing - however the controller tracking and software was a disaster. Prior to that I had a Rift 2 and prior to that Lenovo Explorer. The Quest 2 feels about as good as the Rift 2 - though I think I preferred the Rift 2 because it had little-to-no setup and felt more responsive in games like BeatSaber. The reviews for the Q3 sing its praises but I have been here before. I have tried the Pico 4 and I know the Q3 is around that level of quality - however the lack of uncompressed, responsive PCVR keeps me away. If Meta released a Rift 3 - which was just a lighter/thinner Q3 without the battery/SoC - I'd be all over it. I'd lov…
Meta Quest: Likes itOculus Rift: Doesn’t like it
> Other players did go against Meta/Oculus and their VR products were abysmal in comparison. Not really. The original HTC Vive outsold the original Rift by a lot and was a vastly superior headset (full 6DOF headset/controller vs front-facing/Xbox controller), while also costing about the same. It took Facebook quite a while, the release of Touch and a lot of patches to catch up. And on top of that they had to cut the price in half to stay relevant. Meanwhile PlaystationVR was outselling everything PCVR was doing combined by 5x. > Their products would still be crap or not even exist today The "not even exist today" might very well be true, the crap however not. Microsoft was the one pioneering 6DOF standalone and handtracking back in 2016. Google had one with the Lenovo Mirage a year before Facebook even entered that space. The issue is that they all left the market before the Quest was even out. They never tried to compete, they saw that VR wasn't selling and gave up prematurely. Which is a shame, as I really miss WMR, which was both substantially cheaper than a Quest2, as well as having really nice way to interact with 2D apps inside VR with WMR Portal. Meanwhile Pico4 just entered the market in Europe and happens to be a substantially improvement over Quest2 while also costing less. Quest2 still has a bit of an edge on the software side, but the gap is quite small when taking into account how much money Facebook spend. The strength of Facebook is simply endurance, they kept…
Meta Quest: Likes itOculus Rift: Doesn’t like it
I have tried it and it is a pretty cool experience. But I understand the rants, not a matter of age btw. Facebook is for old people for that matter and developing against any META hardware would have to take that into consideration. But the closed environments are just majorly repellant. I had an older headset (rift s) and suddenly needed to create a facebook account. Should have bought the more expensive Steam version. But I don't see how VR can really reach the masses. You need the extra funds and a decent system and 2D monitor is the more sensible investment. I will never buy an Occulus device again of course. There were management decisions anyone who really likes technology and wants to dabble with it will very likely and understandably hate with a burning passion. A passion sourced in the love for technology and the ability to share it. And they knew that people would dislike it, just hoped they would comply in switching to their Facebook platform. This is 100% on Facebook and to 0% on grumpy users. Not being grumpy is pretty naive in my opinion.
Meta Quest: Likes itOculus Rift: Neutral
I have used a Rift CV1, a Quest 1 and now a Quest 2. What I like about the Q2 is that it's cheap and offers wifi capability so I can sit on the couch far from the PC. More relaxing that way. Sometimes I use real controllers and I got a USB extender cable for that.
Meta Quest: Likes itOculus Rift: Doesn’t like it
Imho right now the immersion is "good enough"... but what I notice the most is the lack of light. So HDR or some evolution of that is what's most lacking in my opinion. Even with the crappy compression on YouTube, you can watch a scene where you are on the beach in VR. After all, isn't that the dream? Of course you can't feel the waves splashing on your feet, but you can definitely enjoy the feeling of being in that space. However, the lack of the bright deep blue sky is really noticeable. Likewise in games. I definitely preferred Skyrim VR on Quest via a cable over the RIFT because the blacks are much deeper (oled), but on the other end of the spectrum, the sky is always lacking in brightness. My hunch is this is going to be hard to solve... I mean most homes today don't even have any kind of lighting that remotely reproduces the outdoor lighting.. I doubt that the small screen inside the headset will be able to simulate a bright blue sky... I mean I don't think it's just a matter of "intensity". But who knows I am clueless, it could be that the pixel density is what prevents the screen from giving the "bright blue sky" depth of light.
Meta Quest: Likes itOculus Rift: Doesn’t like it
Rift S felt like an in-between step to partially satisfy PCVR users, and it was dropped disappointingly quickly. It's obvious that Facebook is moving towards standalone headsets now. Quest 2 is designed to hit a very low price point, and it certainly shows. But despite that, it's a very competent high-resolution, high-framerate (90, with experimental 120Hz support) VR headset; the only major drawbacks are low FOV, poor color quality on the display, and lack of uncompressed PCVR.
Meta Quest: Doesn’t like itOculus Rift: Doesn’t like it
I had the oculus rift, sold it when they made me get a Facebook account (they might have backtracked on that). Bought a quest 2 thinking surely they have learned their lesson by now. Nope. Some of the decisions they made around ux are so insane I feel like ripping it off and throwing it across the room. I bet there are some properly talented people at meta, but someone senior is committed to making it suck. Wouldn't be surprised if it's zuck himself. So even though I'm passionate about it, I have no VR in my life because I can't afford another one
Meta Quest: Doesn’t like itOculus Rift: Doesn’t like it
I tried the first Oculus dev kit in 2013 and got instant motion sickness after a short session. Tried some fancy Quest headset more than a decade later, and same thing. It's crazy that after spending like $100 billion in the space they still haven't been able to remove the most fundamental barriers to entry.
Meta Quest: NeutralOculus Rift: Neutral
This isn't true. It's more that the Vision Pro deliberately prioritized certain things that Meta or Vive or Valve or Sony have not: geometrically stable pass through, wide library of popular 3D movies via AppleTV and Disney+, high resolution immersive environments, seamless keyboard/mouse/trackpad migration between PC and native apps, strong iOS/iPadOS ecosystem integration, high fps / low latency wireless ultra-wide virtual displays for the Mac, etc. In some ways it focuses on what the Oculus Go was trying to do but was underpowered to really do it. It's meant to replace other iOS devices for general productivity and entertainment, and to complement a Mac. It's not focused on VR gaming though it can do that. I have a Oculus Rift dev kit, Ovulus Go, Quest , Quest 2, Valve Index, PSVR2. The AVP is much better of an experience on almost every level but three: too much motion blur when moving your head (this isn't bad when watching high fps video), lack of controller support, not so great hand tracking (which the Quest had to do well due to lack of eye tracking). The controller support should be fixed with the Sony PSVR2 partnership. Motion blur and hand tracking I suspect will be software fixed as they evolve to prioritize active fitness with the AVP.
Meta Quest: Likes itOculus Rift: Likes it
Yes and no. In order to get and maintain the best possible clarity, key for text, I have to wear it higher on my face than is comfortable and tighten the strap more than I would prefer. If I could wear it a little lower or with different supports on my face I could easily spend a full day in it; as it is, I’ve yet to spend more than 4h with it on. I find the Meta Quest Pro and 3 more comfortable, but the CV1 was the most comfortable. Can’t imagine using those for productivity though; the 3 is _ok_ for text but not stellar, and the pass through mode there is a joke compared to the Vision Pro. Viture and NReal (XReal now, I guess?) AR glasses don’t compare at all. Vastly more comfortable (if your face isn’t too wide) but tiny FOV and lots of fiddling required to get sharp text, with unavoidable blur at the edges of the screen. …I guess I’ve been an enthusiast since the Rift Kickstarter?
Meta Quest: Doesn’t like itOculus Rift: Doesn’t like it
The best VR experience I've ever had was with the original PSVR, sat on a chair surrounded by cables with my wife and son playing with me. I bought Oculus Rift and then the Quest 2 and they were both used for 40 mins max and collect dust. For me, it is an incredibly isolating experience unless, like PS did, other people are playing with you in the room and you are taking turns.
Meta Quest: Doesn’t like itOculus Rift: Doesn’t like it
> no other hardware platform has paved a way to a sustainable consumer ecosystem, from end to end: low priced hardware Without Facebook we might have gotten a consumer version of the DK2 for $350, instead of the $600 CV1, and we might have spend two or three years doing VR with Xbox gamepad instead of having to spend an additional $200 on Touch controller. Hard to say if that would have succeeded, as early not-quite-6DOF VR certainly had issues, but low cost and accessible VR is what the whole VR hype from 2012 onward was build on. The two year delay and the $600 announcement destroyed that hype and reduced VR to a few hardcore fans. Going all exclusive with their store and not allowing other headsets in also fractured the already tiny market completely without need. Quest2 momentarily got the price back down (since then increased by $100), but it still struggles quite a lot in getting the excitement back, as there isn't anything interesting happening on the content side. We don't have movies in VR, games are still all low budget indie stuff and there isn't much in terms of events in VR either, even Meta themselves still struggles broadcasting their own conferences as a proper VR event.