The stuff Hacker News actually recommends.

VR and AR headsets

Meta Quest vs Microsoft HoloLens

Hacker News owners slightly favor the Meta Quest.

Meta QuestMicrosoft HoloLens
Owners with an opinion80632
Positive verdicts53% of 67232% of 28
Positive/negative since 2024169/1432/4
Happy after 3+ years20
Longest happy owner5 yrs–
Praised forperformance and ease of useperformance and ease of use
Criticized forcomfort and displaydisplay and comfort
Newest comment

Updated

What owners wrote about both

Meta Quest: Likes itMicrosoft HoloLens: Doesn’t like it
Why, is AR all of the sudden useful and highly-demanded when you can run native Mac apps, instead of streaming them or using the iPad/VisionOS versions? Doesn't seem to be the case. I've come around to an understanding that the Vision Pro would be DOA even with regular VR features like OpenXR/sideloading enabled for normies. For the high-end VR/simming market you can buy much better hardware at a lower price from Pimax, and the all-in-one philosophy of the Meta Quest and Steam Frame is much more appealing than Apple's tethered battery brick. If we're being honest with ourselves, it's the exact same cowpie as Hololens with the exact same cognitive dissonance that killed Windows MR. I'd be shocked if the next Vision product (if we get one) treats the Steam Frame as a legitimate competitor, it's just not in Apple's blood to fight those battles.
Meta Quest: Doesn’t like itMicrosoft HoloLens: Likes it
I have a home theater which is 5.1 which is great for movies [1] and some music [2]. There are 'virtual surround' systems based on [3] of which Airpods are the most famous. Most of those don't work for me except in the sense that I learn 'sounds like I have a cold' means 'the sound is supposed to be above me'. The exception is my Hololens where if I use the web browser to play music and turn around it really sounds like the music is coming from behind me. I have yet to be impressed by spatial audio on my Meta Quest 3. [1] Oddly the surround sound soundtracks that impress me the most are old VHS tapes encoded with Dolby Pro Logic [2] let's see... Close to the Edge by Yes, Supernature by Goldfrapp, Maximum-Minimum by Kraftwerk [3] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Head-related_transfer_function
Meta Quest: Doesn’t like itMicrosoft HoloLens: Neutral
The devices they tried are 1080p and not pushing enough pixels for reading text. Even the Quest 3 with much more per eye is not great if you want to do knowledge work in VR. The main issues is that text is blurry at the edges, so instead of glancing with your eyes, you have to turn your head. You're definitely going to want passthrough. Suggestion, if you have a VR setup already, is to try out Immersed(.com) that can connect any computer to multiple virtual monitors. If you like the idea, you'll want a 4k/eye device, which is still what we are all waiting on. They have their own Vison(.com) in the works, founders edition supposedly shipping later this year. (My understanding is that Immersed cannot unlock AVP enough to operate like all the other headsets, but I'm also not trying to spend that much again on a first edition (bought the HL2, which is the best experience for smart glasses still, FOV sucks tho))
Meta Quest: Likes itMicrosoft HoloLens: Recommends it
Hololens 2 has the best "smart glasses" experience imho, though it's a dead product at this point. Worth it if you can find a used one at a good price. MRTK is an awesome framework and there are some people keeping it alive last I saw Quest 3 is the cheapest and most accessible, but is a passthrough device Apple Vision Pro should probably be on the list, but I have no experience with it personally. Also a passthrough device This site is a good place to stay up to date with the hardware: https://vr-compare.com/ar The biggest holdup is FOV for AR / smart glasses. Passthrough is lame by comparison
Meta Quest: NeutralMicrosoft HoloLens: Doesn’t like it
I got a Hololens 1 that turned out to be a white elephant and I read a lot of stories about people buying VR headsets and abandoning them so when I got an MQ3 I was quite deliberate about getting a variety of games and apps and spending enough time with VR to succeed at it.
Meta Quest: Likes itMicrosoft HoloLens: Doesn’t like it
I’ve had a series of art projects that were always asking to have their own virtual worlds. When I heard about Apple Vision Pro I got excited about being able to deploy this kind of application. My Mac Mini burned out and Ithought about replacing it with an M2 so I could use Apple’s proprietary dev tools but then I thought it would make more sense to get real MR/VR hardware. I got a Hololens 1 off Ebay which was not too expensive but the software availability is just about zero and I never really built a stack to develop for it. I am not a Facebook fan but I heard really good things about the MQ3 (costs 1/7 of the Apple vision) and I can say I am impressed. It supports ‘immersed’ and some other applications to put virtual screens in your space, I have used immersed a bit but I am still thinking of getting a fancy monitor for my workstation (can’t make up my mind if I want high refresh rate or a very wide color gamut) and putting the old monitor up in my media room/VR lab instead of using virtual screens. I have been developing virtual worlds using A-frame which is basically web development, the server reloads when I update the files so my workflow so far has been “edit on the computer, put on the headset to view” and it is slick because by the time I put the headset on the page has been reloaded. I have a bunch of GLTF models of Mars captured by the Pathfinder rover and processed by a PhD student, I’ve gotten one to view on the MQ3 but I think the rest are too big. I have…
Meta Quest: NeutralMicrosoft HoloLens: Likes it
I primarily bought my Q3 as a holdover to the Visor. I use the Immersed app and AR definitely is a great feature when using a virtual desktop setup, for drinking coffee and using a real keyboard. I secondarily bought it as a Q1 upgrade for entertainment. That being said, the AR features still don't hold a candle to the Hololens 2 experience. The hand and environment recognition are still behind, even after 3+ years, and passthrough will never compare to real view. There are tons of visual distortions in the Q3 passthrough to make it usable like the early videos people put out, but for desk work it's fine. Then main issue with Q3 for virtual screens is the uneven pixel density. Words are blurry if not at the center, where you would normally use your eyes to look IRL. This is not peripheral distance, but quick eye glance distance. My understanding is Visor is designing their displays and lenses so this is not an issue.
Meta Quest: Doesn’t like itMicrosoft HoloLens: Doesn’t like it
If the displays and sensors on the device are as good as they say they are, I'd buy it. Watch a movie, play a game, workout, code, dance, be fully immersed. Like have multiple screens around my garage walls in 3D where I can walk up to them. I tried NReal AR glasses, Roku, Quest, Holo lens. They didn't feel right. If Apple vision pro could really take me to another world, be immersed for multiple hours, $4000 (including tax) is worth the experience.
Meta Quest: Doesn’t like itMicrosoft HoloLens: Doesn’t like it
HoloLens had same price point and this price point is where consumer products go to die. I think they are currently looking for early adopters and may be built up volume in 2-3 years (a la iPhone). HoloLens hade strategy which didn't work because utility of AR was far less than utility of mobile computer in your pocket. It looks to me the whole bet here is that VR's killer app would be virtual meetings and it will fix this critical issue. Unfortunately, doing meetings requires two people to have this device and that would be tremendous barrier for adoption. Is no one at Meta thinking of these stuff and learn from history?
Meta Quest: Likes itMicrosoft HoloLens: Likes it
Can you explain what you mean? The Quest2 is easily the best stand alone headset and the hololens has the best world sensing. How can you say it's generally crappy? I consider it industry leading unless you get some niche devices that push up the spec sheet but are generally uninteresting.
Meta Quest: Likes itMicrosoft HoloLens: Likes it
> I think of Windows Mixed Reality, for instance, which never got AR headsets What about Hololens? Hololens 2 is currently the industry leader for enterprise AR and is used for use cases like high-end manufacturing. They're reportedly shipping 70k - 100k units per year. > There's a perception that AR has failed, that VR has failed I don't think that this is a widespread perception. Many people, including analysts like Ben Thompson at Stratechery, just see that it's early days for both technologies, especially AR. I also think that the popularity of the Oculus Quest could be seen as a sign of success for VR. For example, it appears that Oculus sold more headsets in 2021 than Microsoft did Xboxs.