The stuff Hacker News actually recommends.

Laptops

Lenovo ThinkPad vs System76

Hacker News owners lean toward the Lenovo ThinkPad.

Lenovo ThinkPadSystem76
Owners with an opinion2732312
Positive verdicts75% of 236669% of 280
Positive/negative since 2024686/27349/23
Happy after 3+ years28133
Longest happy owner25 yrs20 yrs
Praised forreliability and performancereliability and performance
Criticized forbatterybuild quality and battery
Newest comment

Updated

What owners wrote about both

Lenovo ThinkPad: Likes itSystem76: Doesn’t like it
(Lenovo) Thinkpads, specifically many of the X, T and P products, are best in class. All the Linux things just work at this point, and have for the last 5-10 years. Some products ship with Fedora or Ubuntu. Those lines have the highest end individual products with the best build quality, and user-serviceable/replaceable components. Other Lenovo laptops are either less good or much less good/absolute crap. I have several Framework laptops, to be supportive of alternative supply chains. They are great with Linux compatibility, all the things work, but in terms of build, they are much less mature from a long term maturity and tolerances perspective. The new 13 Pro is probably a pretty solid machine, though. I occasionally have to work on Dells or HPs for clients, and just don't like the keyboards or the fit/finish. I had a couple of earlier system 76 machines, they did not last and the keyboards also were not comparable to a Thinkpad.
Lenovo ThinkPad: Recommends itSystem76: Doesn’t like it
Starting at 1700 USD, vs 500$ for a Neo or a very capable Windows PC on sale. My personal favorite is a lightly used Thinkpad, you can get a nice Linux machine for under 400$. But it's still a lot of work for most people. If a Ubuntu update does something weird, what do you do with your 1700$ System 76 laptop ? With your Neo, you go to the Apple store and they'll sort it out.
Lenovo ThinkPad: Doesn’t like itSystem76: Neutral
ThinkPad keyboards have gotten worse. I have a closet full of older models where the keyboards aren’t crap. But it really is a shame there are no high quality laptops with Linux preinstalled as an option. Every time this comes up people suggest everything except the thing I’m looking for. System76 desktops aren’t bad, I used one daily for several years. They’re also in the same price or higher as the MacBook Pro I replaced it with.
Lenovo ThinkPad: Doesn’t like itSystem76: Likes it
Lenovo and quality aren't two words I associate together anymore. The IBM thinkpads were great, I have a pile of them in my storage. In fact I have both some Lenovo and IBM branded T60 and T4XX models. The IBM units have obviously more bulk to them, and the lids are stronger with more metal inside... I prioritize Coreboot and OpenEC over all else, Lenovo is known for security issues with their machines in the past and occasionally cripple features and even Linux boot support. Their track record is awful. If you're a tinkerer, why would you buy a ferrari you're not able or allowed to work on? The higher end premium System76 machines are of excellent quality. The Serval WS - which I ordered 2 weeks ago - is such an example.
Lenovo ThinkPad: Recommends itSystem76: Likes it
I see very disparate use cases for these laptops, so the competition is not really that fair. - Fastest CPU + GPU + battery life, x64 not needed, money no object: M1 MBP. - Reliable, serviceable, upgradeable, fashion-despising: T14 / T480 / T490. - Serviceable, upgradable, but sort of new kids on the block, and less fashion-oblivious: Star Labs Starfighter, Framework, System 76 Oryx Pro. - Sleek-looking at the expense of everything soldered and glued down: Thinkpad X1, MBP 2019. - Open-source loving, more things under user's control: System 76 Oryx Pro, Star Labs Starfighter, partly Framework. Star Labs Starfighter looks incredible BTW, thanks to bringing it to my attention. I sorely miss a trackpoint though. No idea about others. I'd like to like HP Dev One, but I don't trust HP to make reliable things any more :( I wonder why no model from the Dell Latitude line made it here; I thought some of them have good Linux support.
Lenovo ThinkPad: Recommends itSystem76: Likes it
I can recommend Lenovo Thinkpads as long as you're willing to live with the following restrictions: avoid any Nvidia hardware, and be willing to use a very recent kernel (Arch and friends, not Ubuntu and friends). Nvidia makes good hardware for 3D acceleration but their drivers are the absolute worst and their power consumption is unreasonable at idle. Cutting edge hardware from other manufacturers (i.e. Intel) may need a very new kernel, my laptop didn't have sound without messing with the config when I got it because Intel either forgot or failed to hit the deadline to get their drivers into the most recent stable kernel. The build quality of the Thinkpad laptops is just generally very good, especially for the price, better than some of their more expensive competition in my opinion. I disagree with their Fn-key position, but luckily the UEFI allows you to switch it around to a more sane position (where the ctrl key is on their layout). If you disagree and would like to try non-Lenovo laptops, any laptop that gets sold with Linux on it by default will save you a lot of working out config options. Just because the manufacturer threw Ubuntu on it doesn't mean that it'll work well (the same can be said of Windows, sadly) but the basic driver support is there. System76 laptops are the exception there, they generally work great with Linux but you pay for the privilege. I've personally also had a great experience running Linux on HP's ProBook line. As for the macOS requirement, y
Lenovo ThinkPad: Recommends itSystem76: Neutral
The larger P series from Lenovo are also excellent, have 4k screens, and run Fedora flawlessly. They also have next day onsite warranty support which actually works. The hardware is definitely not Apple level, but it's good, and for those of us for whom Apple software/ecosystem for various reasons are not a fit, the combination of Fedora and Thinkpad is something to be grateful for. As much as I support the motivation behind System76 and Framework- and I own products from both- the quality is not (yet) professional tier. Fedora + Thinkpad is.
Lenovo ThinkPad: Recommends itSystem76: Doesn’t like it
I own one but would probably not buy another unless they refresh their lineup. It works as advertized; it runs linux...that's about it. The HW is middle/low quality and I'm not sure the premium System76 charges is warranted. I also own a Thinkpad which is superior to anything System76 offers. Installing linux was trivial, and everything seems to work. System76 rebrands OEM laptops, but my understanding is that they may be working on an in-house laptop. If so, I would probably give it a look...but for now, I think Thinkpads are a better deal.
Lenovo ThinkPad: Likes itSystem76: Doesn’t like it
Last year I finally replaced my old Macbook Pro with a Thinkpad running Pop OS. I'm so pleased with the operating system and the hardware. I want to support System76, but I read some not so positive anecdotes about their laptop's build quality, so went with the Thinkpad. I also wanted/needed a centered keyboard layout without numberpad, which they don't offer. Their desktop models look nice, but feel like a luxury when I can get a custom-built PC and just install Linux on it. Anyway, Pop OS is wonderful. I actually installed it on the old MBP too, and gave it new life. In addition: the Nordic theme makes for a beautiful interface, it's like what macOS should have become. https://github.com/EliverLara/Nordic
Lenovo ThinkPad: Likes itSystem76: Neutral
I had one of their systems, a gazelle professional 4 if I recall right, it must've been around, oh say, 2013? And it was quite a nice machine, great linux compat, the 4-core i7 in it performed quite well and it let me load it up with RAM. It wasn't too heavy or anything and I liked the display. But the battery life. Good lord. 45 minutes, 55 if I messed and fussed with power settings and such. Basically gaming-laptop-tier "more like a UPS than a battery" battery performance. My next laptop was a thinkpad T440s and it had similarly good linux compat and it performed much better for battery life - I got an i5 in that one and saw 8ish hours of battery life, and it had a hot-swap feature where I could swap in a big-ass battery once I depleted the slim one and get an additional 20(!!) something hours of battery life on a single boot. Great for car trips and heavy all-day use like at conferences. But then superfish and I swore Lenovo had lost me for-ever. So my current laptop is an XPS13 and I get 8-10ish hours off one charge with it, and it is super thin and the only Linux issue I've had is needing a very new kernel when I bought it new a year and a half or so ago, new enough that Linux Mint didn't ship it OOTB and the live ISO couldn't get WiFi, so I installed Arch instead, where their latest install image did indeed have a sufficiently new kernel. So I'm a happy XPS user right now and I've found I like the 13" form factor. Would I be disappointed on battery performance if I went…
Lenovo ThinkPad: Likes itSystem76: Doesn’t like it
Current linux laptop landscape: Thinkpads (T): Decent keyboards, fwupd. Everything else is mediocre to poor. Dell Precision: About the same as thinkpads. S76, Starlabs: coreboot, upgradable. Mediocre screen, keyboard, trackpad, audio etc. Framework: Not enough to differentiate for the price premium. I have mostly given up on this. If macbooks get gpu linux drivers, I am willing to jump ship.
Lenovo ThinkPad: Likes itSystem76: Neutral
I also used to always run ThinkPads (and Precision workstations with pointing sticks). I these days run a System76 Lemur Pro with a USB thinkpad keyboard I stick on top. The built-in keyboard is good, but trackpads and I have never gotten along. They've come a long way. Another option that friend got was the Frame Work. I helped him assemble it, and it also is a great GNU/Linux machine. Everything just works.
Lenovo ThinkPad: Recommends itSystem76: Likes it
I completely believe you've experienced these. TL;DR: Linux, like all other systems, mostly has issues with hardware. For a proper experience, get a system that's known good under Linux (and you need to use a non-ideological distribution like Ubuntu which will ship proprietary drivers). Linux-focused or business models of major manufacturers are your best bet. 1) sounds like a hardware issue or hardware compatibility issue. Unfortunately, while Linux does come with great and extensive hardware support out-of-the-box, you'd still benefit from choosing hardware that works well with Linux. Thinkpad T series (I usually use X1 Carbon, but as the highest end ultraportable it can introduce some Windows-specific firmware issues that they only resolve in a few months after release — they did that with Gen6 when they switched to new always-on-standby, but they introduced a BIOS option for Linux ~6 months later) is usually the best bet out of big manufacturers, and Linux-focused ones like System76 are a good choice too. So if you want to try out Linux next time, get Linux hardware that will work well with it first (or be ready to debug issues like the ones you mention). These sort of issues happen even more on Windows if you clean install it on a wide variety of hardware (MacOS can't even be installed on your non-Apple system, I am guessing, so I'd say that it's even worse :). The benefit Windows has is that it comes pre-installed on those systems. I've seen 2) frequently ~5 years…
Lenovo ThinkPad: Recommends itSystem76: Doesn’t like it
Be sure to check support forums, subreddits, yt review videos before buying a laptop. I wanted to buy a system76 laptop but after reading the subreddit there seem to be many people having problems especially with the build quality, things are just breaking after one or two years. For now I'd just use a Thinkpad. Linux works great on it and if there are any problems it's easy to find help online. The framework laptop has no official linux support yet. They have a forum where people share their experiences running linux on it and discuss problems.
Lenovo ThinkPad: Recommends itSystem76: Doesn’t like it
Hi! Been running Linux on laptops for years (over a decade). Everything from XPS to Thinkpad and System76. My first recommendation is to check the Linux distro wiki and see what hardware is officially supported. Ubuntu, RHEL / Fedora, and the major distros have lists and tell you what is officially supported; even sometimes down the the piece of hardware (i.e. Thinkpad fingerprint reader) and precise serial numbers. If you're not going to look at the distros wiki or you're not sure what distro you're going to run, the general rule of thumb is the older the hardware the better chance it is of being supported. Now, my personal opinions: I've owned two Thinkpads (x270 & x220), had a dell XPS 13 from work ~4 years ago, and my wife currently owns a System76 Lemur Pro (I have a Thelio Desktop). I've run Ubuntu and RHEL flavored distros on all these. Personally, the Thinkpads blow the Dells and System76 in terms of quality out of the water, and I'd argue they do with hardware support as well (if you're running RHEL / Fedora). The System76 works great with Ubuntu since the drivers and firmware are open (and POP!OS), but I'm not impressed with the quality of the product. Keyboard is low quality, as well as finish (footpads ungluing, finish on keys / track pad coming off, etc.). Dell makes a nice computer, but when I had my XPS 13 there were some major issues with HiDPI (I'm sure it's fixed now). I also didn't like the keyboard and the charging port was finicky. Gonna be honest, you're
Lenovo ThinkPad: Recommends itSystem76: Likes it
Check out the Thinkpad A series, a replica of the X & T but with Ryzen CPUs -> More Cores Also Dell has decent Latitude and Precision lines System76 is pulling up some great work, I would not recommend the GalagoPro just yet as the battery life won't be great, but the Oryx Pro and Gazelle looks great
Lenovo ThinkPad: Likes itSystem76: Doesn’t like it
I have a Dell XPS 13 and a Dell Precision 5520 [1], both 2017 models. It feels like the XPS gets around 8 hours of battery life and the Precision gets around 4.5 (even with the discrete GPU turned off). I got the high-res screen option on both, I hear that going with the low-res option boosts battery life. I bought the Precision with very good specs, which may help explain why it gets worse performance than seems to be advertised. Its screen is also brighter than the XPS 13's. The reason I got the Precision is that the XPS 13 was too small and slow and I didn't feel productive on it. I find that small screens really hamper my productivity, and having a smaller palm rest beneath the keyboard also makes typing more difficult. System 76 laptops have very poor ergonomics and battery life, but great internals at a decent price. I bought a Gazelle Pro from them 6 years ago and it was basically unusable as a mobile computer; it got 1 hour of battery life out of the box and that declined to about 5 minutes after a year or so of wear (I'm not joking, it was bad). The keyboard was also terrible. I ended up using it as a portable desktop. That said, it was as powerful, if not more, than the XPS 13 that I bought 6 years later, and it cost slightly less too. ThinkPads are also really nice. They have great keyboards and good battery life (generally coming with swappable batteries). I bought one about 8 years ago and it was probably the best personal laptop I've owned. The reason I went Del