The stuff Hacker News actually recommends.

Laptops

Lenovo ThinkPad vs Sony VAIO

Hacker News owners slightly favor the Lenovo ThinkPad.

Lenovo ThinkPadSony VAIO
Owners with an opinion273263
Positive verdicts75% of 236675% of 53
Positive/negative since 2024686/27312/6
Happy after 3+ years2817
Longest happy owner25 yrs18 yrs
Praised forreliability and performanceportability and performance
Criticized forbatteryreliability and battery
Newest comment

Updated

What owners wrote about both

Lenovo ThinkPad: NeutralSony VAIO: Likes it
I have Lenovo W530 from around 2012 or so. It has Nvidia K1000M card, full of RAM, i7. I kept upgrading it over the years and used Windows. I have decided to get back to FreeBSD, I used it as desktop 2002-2009 or so. Downloaded 15.0, start install, wifi driver works perfectly, out of the box. Promising start, never seen before with FreeBSD. Installed. Next, lets go to setup, graphics and Wayland. And here we started again, same story, hundred magic params to add, nvidia drivers doesn't work properly, install older version, is incompatible with Wayland etc. Need to go back to Xorg, another set of problems. Ok, if I spent another 8 hours and asked for help in forums as it was 20+ years ago, I could have probably made it work. Until the next issue showed up. So I decide to drop it, download CachyOS. Start installer. It detects K1000M, installs old version of Nvidia drivers, KDE, sorts out all compatibility issues, everything just flies, flawlessly. As never before, not even Ubuntu or Fedora. CachyOS guys, thank you, you made an incredible work on getting it all to this state. Absolutely great. Now don't get me wrong, I love FreeBSD, used it as my main driver for years in early 2000s, started my career with it and it has sweet spot in my heart, forever. It's just that laptop support is not there, still terrible, as it was 20 years ago. PS last laptop I used it successfully on, was Sony Vaio VGN-FS550 from 2005!
Lenovo ThinkPad: Doesn’t like itSony VAIO: Likes it
Back in the day, I heard all sorts of great things about how durable Thinkpads were, I bought one with my hard earned money in ~2004 when doing contact web development work. It was my least reliable laptop I've ever had. My Vaio notebooks always lasted quite a bit longer. Eventually got a macbook and haven't gone back, but yeah, the one Thinkpad I owned was the least reliable computing device I've bought in the ~40 years of my lifetime.
Lenovo ThinkPad: Likes itSony VAIO: Doesn’t like it
I apologise for being ambiguous. « My dad had a laptop in the mid-90s that had a floppy drive, and I think a parallel port, too. » When I said "none of them did" I meant that no IBM Butterfly had these things, not that no 1990s laptop did. The 701C is a subnotebook and IBM left out everything it could. I do have a floppy drive, and it worked fine. For the rest, when I needed it, I used PCMCIA devices. « The Butterfly was meant to be used with a docking station, but I never managed to get my hands on one. I just enjoy looking at it and thinking what a great laptop it was in its day. I'd like very much to have one with a fold-out keyboard today. » Oh really? I've never seen a docking station for one. For the rest, yes, I totally agree. :-) An interesting take is the Sony Vaio P, which attacked the problem from another angle. It is basically the shape of the keyboard. So it's very shallow front-to-back but had an almost letter-box shaped screen. I have one. Sadly it's very underpowered, and has a terrible keyboard, poor pointing device, and the VGA-cum-Ethernet dongle I bought separately doesn't work. The form-factor has immense potential, but this is not a good version of it.
Switched from the Sony VAIO to the Lenovo ThinkPadLenovo ThinkPad: Likes it
my path was toshiba > 3 vaios > 2 thinkpads, sure premium laptops are pricey new but they last well, most of my laptops have managed at least 4 years of useful life, im hoping the x1 extreme will last me the next five years (notice i typed five as the five key died this morning) my only current questions are of the screen and cpu, i was thinking of getting the i7 model but there are 2 on offer the higher model is only 30 quid more, its slightly faster but im unsure if its a better bet to go with the lower tier one for thermal reasons then theres the screen, sure a 4k HDR screen could be nice but itll also hammer battery life compared to the fhd model and as capable as the gpu is its not likely to be pumping out games in 4k so the fhd is seeming like the better option for me. which machine did you go with? an X or a T?
Lenovo ThinkPad: Likes itSony VAIO: Likes it
I have Linux as primary OS since 4 laptops. No issue, especially now that all the devices are detected without any problems and works out of the box. My actual setup is a Thinkpad T430 running Debian Bookworm with XFCE as DE. What I have experienced in my 15 years of using Linux on laptops daily is that the life of a Linux laptop is really long and you don't need to replace it to fight obsolence. My old Sony Vaio lasts for more than 10 years, running Ubuntu and just replacing HDD to SSD.
Lenovo ThinkPad: Likes itSony VAIO: Likes it
ThinkPads back when were certainly good, sturdy machines, though I could never get along with the nipple. Another great older machine for me was the purple Sony Vaio - magnesium alloy, came with Win2K installed. I bought one, and then immediately bought another - the first I repurposed as a Linux server and I carried them both (easily) around for demoing this and that. My latest, which I think is going to be in the ThinkPad and Vaio class is my new Asus Zenbook - brilliant light chassis and great performance.
Lenovo ThinkPad: Likes itSony VAIO: Likes it
i think its the weight, size and durability of my x1 carbon, its old but has served me very well and is lugged everywhere with me, its been dropped, had beer, coffee and cola spilled on it but it still soldiers on! sadly though after some five years its time has come, while its still very much usable (im typing this on it now) several keys are dodgy and the casing has seen better days to name but a few issues. id been researching for some time to find something that could replace it but also had a discreet GPU, i eventually decided on the dell XPS as nothing much else seemed to fit the bill but just before i hit the button on it lenovo went and announced my dream laptop, the X1 extreme. i also once had a very nice sony vaio laptop with some unique features (before i became a fan of thinkpads vaios were my goto laptops) not only did it have a full socketed desktop P4 cpu but also the cpu fan was magnetic, you could just lift out the piece with the blades to clean the fins out