The stuff Hacker News actually recommends.

Laptops

Lenovo ThinkPad vs Microsoft Surface

Hacker News owners lean toward the Lenovo ThinkPad.

Lenovo ThinkPadMicrosoft Surface
Owners with an opinion2732171
Positive verdicts75% of 236647% of 150
Positive/negative since 2024686/27329/37
Happy after 3+ years2814
Longest happy owner25 yrs10 yrs
Praised forreliability and performancereliability and performance
Criticized forbatteryease of use
Newest comment

Updated

What owners wrote about both

Lenovo ThinkPad: Likes itMicrosoft Surface: Doesn’t like it
How is the Mac CLI more convenient? There isn't even a package manager in the box, they ship loads of old outdated tools too. Plus there's the whole BSD/GNU convention thing you have to watch out for. I don't find my ThinkPad running Linux overheats, nor is it particularly heavy. And performance is comparable to the similarly priced MBP at the time. Camera sucks, but compared to my Surface so do the Macs...
Lenovo ThinkPad: NeutralMicrosoft Surface: Likes it
He doesn’t have nano texture, I can guarantee that. His screen probably has fingerprints and glare and all sorts of issues like visible pixels. I’ve owned a hell of a lot of laptops and MacBooks are the best, not because of Mac, but because of the build quality. The touchpad is perfect, the aluminum body is rugged, the screen is amazing, and the audio truly is sorcery thanks to Apple acquiring Beat’s audionet. The worst laptop for build quality were those HP Chromebooks. ThinkPad’s are mid tier but still made of plastic. Yoga foldable or a MS Surface is better. MSI or Razor if you don’t feel like ever touching your laptop (:fire:)
Lenovo ThinkPad: NeutralMicrosoft Surface: Doesn’t like it
I highly recommend against Microsoft Surface products. I bought them for my dev team and we saw 3 of the 10 or so devices fail and need to be replaced. The RMA experience in other countries may differ to Australia, but it meant my team were without a dev spec'd laptop in total of close to a month across the whole team. They had to use off the shelf laptops and use a VDI for computational taxing workloads while waiting for a replacement device. Throw in how ordinary the support process was with Microsoft, e.g., no phone contact number, only email, correspondance takes 1-2 days to start and the back and forth taking another few hours each way. We wasted a lot of time on these devices and the bullshit Microsoft support process. Devs are now split between Lenovo ThinkPads and MacBooks now depending on their wants and needs. I've never seen a failure record like what we had with the Surfaces as we have with any other hardware provider.
Lenovo ThinkPad: Likes itMicrosoft Surface: Likes it
Every once in awhile I will try a non-thinkpad laptop and I regret it every single time. There's always at least one thing that just doesn't work well. Trackpad being unpleasant, dropped keys when typing fast, can't wake up from sleep in a timely manner, or who knows what else. Thinkpads aren't quite like Macbooks but at least all of their components work... Actually the Microsoft Surface book/laptop line is really good in my opinion... It's just the Linux support is often (understandably) quite bad. Sometimes I psych myself into thinking I can stomach Windows for the "official, supported" laptop experience but it never lasts more than a few months before I cave and go back to Linux.
Lenovo ThinkPad: Likes itMicrosoft Surface: Likes it
On the PC side, Asus and IBM / Lenovo ( Thinkpad ), Microsoft Surface are the best there is AFAIK. I haven't touched Framework yet but given how many developers uses it I think most problem will get ironed out eventually.
Lenovo ThinkPad: Likes itMicrosoft Surface: Likes it
Connected Standby has worked on my devices for a decade. When I plug in my laptop to my dock in the office and it wakes up, it comes on pretty much instantly. Its already on the WiFi, which it joined when I walked in the building. My email has already synced. My chat has already synced before I even log in. It has been doing this just fine since Windows 8 came out across multiple Thinkpads, Surface tablets, and other devices. Even pre-Windows 8, sleep has generally worked perfectly fine for me. I'd have my computer on sleep between classes, open it up and pretty much instantly be right back in OneNote ready to take notes. Cheap Compaq laptops, expensive HP laptops, IBM Thinkpads, Lenovo Thinkpads, Surface tablets, no-name cheap Walmart laptops, all kinds of devices. In the last almost 20 years I've had less than a dozen instances of a hot bag running XP, Vista, 7, 8, 8.1, 10, now 11. I had issues with sleep on some desktops in the past, where it wouldn't want to stay in sleep. Every time it was some dumb app waking up the machine. Never due to some specific Windows issue, always something I installed.
Lenovo ThinkPad: Likes itMicrosoft Surface: Likes it
IDK, but Microsoft seems to be now what Google was a many many years ago: a company creating tech I like to use such as Bing, Edge, Windows Terminal, VSCode, etc. Their Surface hardware is nice too (even if I prefer thinkpads) Oh and they're also helping with the linux kernel. Why can't old people let go? Companies aren't people - they respond to market incentices. Yes, Microsoft did bad stuff in the 1990s, but now they're doing good stuff I like and TBH I'm way more afraid of google.
Lenovo ThinkPad: Doesn’t like itMicrosoft Surface: Doesn’t like it
Linux worked out of the box (Ubuntu LTS or Lubuntu) with: - Lenovo ThinkPad T41 - Lenovo ThinkPad X61s - LenovWo ThinkPad X220 - Lenovo ThinkPad X230 - Lenovo ThinkPad X1 - DELL Latitude E7762 - DELL Latitude E7480 - Apple iMac 27" Problems encountered: - The touchpad on the Lenovo ThinkPad 240 mad random jumps, not sure if this is a Linux issue since I never tried Windows (I usually wipe it right after unpacking). - Couldn't install any Linux flavour on the Microsoft Surface 3 laptop. It was painful to get rid of Windows and UEFI boot, and apparently a kernel patch is needed to go further (according to Microsoft support, who didn't provide said patch). Does anyone here have that patch BTW? Generally speaking it is getting harder and harder to install Linux, due to Microsofts efforts to make PCs "more secure" (which - oops - prevents the installation of competitors' OSes, how convenient).