The stuff Hacker News actually recommends.

Laptops

Lenovo Legion vs Lenovo ThinkPad

Hacker News owners slightly favor the Lenovo ThinkPad.

Lenovo LegionLenovo ThinkPad
Owners with an opinion402732
Positive verdicts67% of 3375% of 2366
Positive/negative since 20249/9686/273
Happy after 3+ years1281
Longest happy owner3 yrs25 yrs
Praised forperformance and reliabilityreliability and performance
Criticized forportabilitybattery
Newest comment

Updated

What owners wrote about both

Lenovo Legion: NeutralLenovo ThinkPad: Likes it
W500 - 3 years, nothing x230 - replacement battery, screen died (easy replacement), handrest cracked, still usable T460p - 5 years of light use, nothing T470p - 3 years, nothing Legion Y520 - keyboard stopped working partly, bought a replacement and noticed it's basically impossible to replace, then bought a second one, this time a complete top case - replacement was a chore, but fine Overall: still a happy Lenovo customer
Lenovo Legion: Likes itLenovo ThinkPad: Doesn’t like it
Thinkpads have ACPI bugs that transfer to Windows too, it's amazing. I've been using Lenovo's Legion devices instead. They don't run this horribly bloated BIOS, they run the much less critically acclaimed Insyde BIOS, but guess what, it just works. I've not had an unexpected wake-crash in years (aside from nvidia drivers with the mux switch on, but just use amdgpu instead). Desktop grade processors, weight comparable to a T420. Definitely not a device to use on the go, but very capable if you just need to carry a computer to the office.
Switched from the Lenovo ThinkPad to the Lenovo LegionLenovo Legion: Recommends it
I actually switched from Thinkpads to a Legion 7 2021 and I'd recommend them over Thinkpads. It is by far the best Linux experience on a Laptop I've ever had. * upgradable RAM * two NVMe slots * actually good keyboard (that unfortunately is part of the case, but replacement parts are available) * the glass touchpad is better than my P14s with the X1C glass touchpad mod. * the panel and refresh rate is very good and there's no lottery. I don't know why Lenovo cuts corners on their business laptops, especially in the last two points. It's heavy, but I don't lug it around too often, and having a 140W (max power spec) 3070 is great. Just avoid placing them vertically on a stand, I had to replace the thermal assembly eventually.
Lenovo Legion: Likes itLenovo ThinkPad: Likes it
That does sound awful. I am longtime Firefox faithful. But I keep extension usage down to minimum- multi account container, ad block for YouTube, leechblock, clear url, zotero and fpl tools (fantasy football) right now. Tbh Firefox rarely bothers me nowadays with resource usage. I am confident I haven't had to restart Firefox since last November. My work laptop is a Lenovo P52 with 32GB of ram and win10. Home laptop is a Lenovo legion with 16GB of ram and win11. I had so many issues with performance in the past that I just trained myself to never keep resource-hogging stuff running in background that I am not actively using. I regularly have zoom and Firefox running while playing MMO games on home laptop. Firefox, SQL server etc. running in background while running multi-core data analysis on work laptop. I never had issues with Firefox, and if there's a memory crash I usually know what caused it. But it is down to hardcore discipline using the machines, and I understand it is not usual patterns for others.
Lenovo Legion: Likes itLenovo ThinkPad: Likes it
The Lenovo Laptops I have are Legion 7 2021 (5800H / 3070), X1 Extreme Gen 1 (8th gen / 1050ti) vs Dell XPS 15 (12700 / 3050ti) Both Lenovos are rock solid, not laggy or stuttery. But I had a Dell XPS 15 (2020) model from work, I gave it back because idling in Windows made the fans spin... I got a newer Dell XPS 15 (2022) for work (new job) and its great, but its stuttery and the fans spin under light loads. (the screen is amazing tho, i love the screen)
Lenovo Legion: Likes itLenovo ThinkPad: Likes it
> Lenovo also sells a bunch of cheapish plasticky laptops that look like some random noname chinese OEM manufactured and lenovo just put a sticker on... well, linux support there is a bit hit and miss. They look like that because they basically are . There's really two companies called Lenovo. One of them makes the ThinkPad T, X, P and one of the budget lines (L or E, always forget which, we don't use either). And the ThinkStations. The other makes the IdeaPads and the other ThinkPad budget line which lacks the great keyboard and Linux compatibility, it just looks a bit like a ThinkPad. And the Legion gaming stuff etc. They're really two different companies with different factories. We have a global contract with Lenovo and we can't even order the consumer laptops. We wanted to get some Legions because some of our dev teams prefer the Legion with RTX over the ThinkPad P which come with Quadros. But they simply can't sell them to us. I think RTX came to the ThinkPad P since anyway, not sure because I'm not involved anymore. It seems one company because as a consumer you can buy all of them from Lenovo.com but that's not even really Lenovo, it's a third party reseller called DigitalRiver.