The stuff Hacker News actually recommends.

Pens and paper

Lamy Safari vs TWSBI Eco

Hacker News owners lean toward the TWSBI Eco.

Lamy SafariTWSBI Eco
Owners with an opinion4920
Positive verdicts79% of 4894% of 18
Positive/negative since 202416/57/0
Happy after 3+ years51
Longest happy owner13 yrs9 yrs
Praised forvalue and ease of useperformance and comfort
Criticized forreliability and comfortdesign and reliability
Newest comment

Updated

What owners wrote about both

Lamy Safari: Doesn’t like itTWSBI Eco: Likes it
Lamy Safari friends, I bought one, and it went unused for years because it was no fun to write with. The nib was scratchy, not feedback, scratchy, and no small tweak ever made it smooth. I was on the verge of buying a sheet of micro-mesh to fix it when I came to my senses, what the hell was I doing, like trying to fix a smokey candlewick for light. I thought to myself, it can't all be like this, and bought a TWSBI Eco. This was going to be my last fountain pen if it didn't work out. And, dear readers, it is amazing! It writes like butter, words cannot describe, I whip it out every chance I get to write with it. (The Lamy does OK with a very wet ink and cheap printer paper. I use it to doodle, so all is not lost.)
Lamy Safari: Doesn’t like itTWSBI Eco: Recommends it
A TWSBI Eco with a medium nib or maybe a Pilot Prera in fine would be a good start for anyone, both under $50. Maybe a Pilot Kakuno since they are under $20. Lamy Safari are often recommended, but have a forced grip pattern due to the shape of the barrel. Pilot Vanishing Point is going to be the best for retractable, but at just under $200-- it isn't super practical, although it will last a lifetime and Pilot will typically warranty them for free/cheap for the life of the pen. A Majohn A1 or A2 is close enough for 10% of the price if you want a retractable fountain pen.
Lamy Safari: Doesn’t like itTWSBI Eco: Neutral
Agree on the Lamy Safari drying out very quickly; I use it about once a week, and it is always dried out at first use. I know Montblanc can be overpriced, but it's the only pen I have that writes immediately without skipping after a time, even if I haven't used it in a month. My daily drivers are a Lamy 2000 with a TWSBI Eco in different color ink for highlighting/commenting; I also carry a Pilot 823 on me as a backup to the Lamy 2000 but I have never been able to get used to the vacuum mechanism.
Lamy Safari: NeutralTWSBI Eco: Likes it
Ten cheap yet great fountain pens from my experience: - Platinum Preppy/Prefounte/Plasir ($3-$20) - TWSBI ECO ($30-$50) - Pilot Metro/Cavalier ($20-$50) Cheap and OK pens (I found these better for drawing than writing): - Lamy Safari/Al-Star ($20-$50) - Kaweco Sport Classic ($20 -- ) 'Affordable' Gold Nib pens (These are necessarily 'better' but writing experience is different(softer feel) which some people prefer) - Pilot Elite 95S ($80-$100) - Pilot Decimo/Capless ($115-$160) All prices are from online stores available in US.
Lamy Safari: Doesn’t like itTWSBI Eco: Likes it
In my view, Lamy Safari is way overrated. Don't get me wrong, it's far from bad, a pretty consistent pen for the price. But the ink dries fast-ish if you don't use it, and especially, the cartridges are proprietary so you're tied to the brand's cartridges and ink colors (there's a piston converter, but converters, meh). A Pilot Metropolitan is approximately the same price and at least in my view, it's better as it uses standard international cartridges. A TWSBI Eco is more expensive, but not by that much, and it's an absolute reliability monster.
Lamy Safari: Doesn’t like itTWSBI Eco: Neutral
Sorry I don’t check comments often — here’s my go to pens: - pocket pen: Kaweco brass sport . It’s built like a tank, and develops a unique patina. - daily workhorse: Pilot VP . Great solid pen. The retractable nib is so darn convenient that it’s my go to for anything where I may be intermittently taking notes (e.g. meetings) - fancy pen for home: Pilot 823 . I got a quite good deal on it, as it’s more than I’m comfortable spending, but it’s one of the best writing pens out there and the vac filler is fun. But it doesn’t leave my desk. - recent pen: Moonman A1 . This is a “knockoff” of the Pilot VP, which had its patents expire. Quality is maybe 90% of the Pilot, but I paid <$25 shipped on AliExpress. Trying it out as a note taking pen since I’m a little over protective of my VP. I also have a TWSBI Eco and a Lamy Safari. I use the eco for basically callouts (circling/adding comments in red) when I review meeting notes. The Safari isn’t really for me… maybe the nib never meshed with my handwriting but I’ve always had issues; however, a lot of folks give it a ton of praise.
Lamy Safari: Likes itTWSBI Eco: Likes it
Fountains pens are nice if you write by hand a lot. When I was taking humanities classes, I would get assigned 30 page of readings a week -- which meant a ton of summarizing and note taking. I started out using a ballpoint pen, but I would get tired after a few pages of writing. I decided to invest in a fountain pen, which allowed me to write with a lighter grip. It was a quality of life improvement. It made writing feel pleasurable (similar to how I feel when I see the PDF produced by a LaTeX file). I started with a $15 Japanese Pilot Metropolitan (not a good pen IMO, the fine nib was too scratchy for me) but eventually moved to a $30 Taiwanese TWSBI ECO and nowadays my go-to is a $30 German Lamy Safari. ($200 pens are a luxury; the sweet spot is ~$30; also Western pens and Asian pens are different in their nib sizing). Those of you who are using BiC pens -- you can do so much better. However, I will admit that gel pens come pretty close, so if you don't care for fountain pens, gel pens should be your go to.
Lamy Safari: Recommends itTWSBI Eco: Recommends it
This list is certainly not classic fountain pens. They are mostly machined pens made by small batch producers with generic nibs and two with somewhat "different" nibs I wouldn't normally suggest most people get. These are pretty good pens but not what I would get as a first pen. Here are the pens I would suggest you consider if you don't know a lot about fountain pens. If you are a fountain pen collector, I'm mostly ignoring a number of European brands who make great pens but have nib quality control from hell which are fine if you know fountain pens and how to adjust nibs etc but not if you are a beginner. Budget under 40 bucks: 1) Lamy Safari: The grip section is triangular to support the traditional writing grip. It's one of the choices middle schoolers are require to use in certain European countries. If you have a traditional grip and don't have huge hands you will likely like it. If you don't, stay away. Lamy sometimes has quality control issues on it's inexpensive nibs but not as many as other European brands in my experience. 2) Pilot Metropolitan: Pilot has a reputation of really good quality control on what are very high quality nibs. The 20 dollar Pilot Metropolitan is no exception. Amazing writing experience for the money. Probably the best steel nibs you can buy. Competitive with many pens that cost over 100 dollars. 3) TWSBI Eco: Piston filler pen so you don't need a cartridge or converter. The pen is a demonstrator so you can see how it works. Comes in lots of
Lamy Safari: Likes itTWSBI Eco: Likes it
IMO posts like this contribute to the impression of _all_ fountain pens being "expensive, fancy things". I have a Lamy Safari that has lasted 12 years (and counting) I have a TWSBI Eco that has lasted 9 years (ditto) You have a LOT of options with pens and ink that are high-quality and long-lasting. Of course, there are _better_ ones out there, but it's important to share how easy it is to get started.
Lamy Safari: Likes itTWSBI Eco: Likes it
I have two Lamy Safaris (fine, extra fine) and they're good pens. I think the barrels are ABS plastic - very durable, good if you're going to toss the pen in a backpack or aren't too careful about how you carry it around, easy to clean. The converter was saving me roughly 5 - 10 times over the cost of ink cartridges. The drawbacks: The grip seemed a little slippery, even though it's sculptured. The extra fine nib produced a line that was a little wider than I wanted. The converter doesn't hold much ink. I switched to the TWSBI Eco extra fine. The line is tight and precise (good for subscripts with subscripts), the pen is easy to grip, the piston fill gives roughly 3 times the ink capacity as the Lamy converters, and the clear barrel allows you to see how much ink is left. The TWSBI is roughly the same price as the Safari. I do much more writing since I started using fountain pens, and it's changed my work habits. I think better when writing than when typing (maybe) - but in any event, it's fun to write with good instruments. Reading physical books and writing with pen and paper are good ways for me to resist the urge to stare at a screen. (I get my pens from JetPens. I noticed a while ago complaints on Amazon about some of the Lamys possibly being counterfeits - no way to confirm, don't know if it's still an issue.)
Lamy Safari: Likes itTWSBI Eco: Likes it
The award for utilitarian and timeless has to go to the Lamy 2000. The Safari is very good as a starter (though I'm partial to the Pilot Metropolitan or TWSBI Eco for starters). I don't have experience with the Kaweco Sport, though I hear only good things.