The stuff Hacker News actually recommends.

Pens and paper

Lamy Safari vs Pilot Metropolitan

Hacker News owners lean toward the Lamy Safari.

Lamy SafariPilot Metropolitan
Owners with an opinion4932
Positive verdicts79% of 4872% of 29
Positive/negative since 202416/58/3
Happy after 3+ years53
Longest happy owner13 yrs10 yrs
Praised forvalue and ease of usevalue and ease of use
Criticized forreliability and comfortreliability and performance
Newest comment

Updated

What owners wrote about both

Lamy Safari: Likes itPilot Metropolitan: Doesn’t like it
Fountains pens are nice if you write by hand a lot. When I was taking humanities classes, I would get assigned 30 page of readings a week -- which meant a ton of summarizing and note taking. I started out using a ballpoint pen, but I would get tired after a few pages of writing. I decided to invest in a fountain pen, which allowed me to write with a lighter grip. It was a quality of life improvement. It made writing feel pleasurable (similar to how I feel when I see the PDF produced by a LaTeX file). I started with a $15 Japanese Pilot Metropolitan (not a good pen IMO, the fine nib was too scratchy for me) but eventually moved to a $30 Taiwanese TWSBI ECO and nowadays my go-to is a $30 German Lamy Safari. ($200 pens are a luxury; the sweet spot is ~$30; also Western pens and Asian pens are different in their nib sizing). Those of you who are using BiC pens -- you can do so much better. However, I will admit that gel pens come pretty close, so if you don't care for fountain pens, gel pens should be your go to.
Lamy Safari: Recommends itPilot Metropolitan: Doesn’t like it
> Pilot Metropolitan One thing I’d like to mention is the difference between Japanese Fine and European Fine, with Japanese being much finer. I found Metropolitan Fine to be scratchy while love Lamy Safari Fine. I’ll recommend Metropolitan Medium to most people who are starting with fountain pens, or a Lamy Safari Fine.
Lamy Safari: Likes itPilot Metropolitan: Doesn’t like it
Agreed, love the Lamy Safari. I got the Al Star to up-scale it a bit. And, then a gold-nib later. But, honestly, like the steel more! I also tried the Pilot Metropolitan, for some reason this awful pen is recommended as an alternative to the Lamy. Doesn't even compare, got rid of it fairly quickly. The ridge along the grip was very uncomfortable for me.
Lamy Safari: Doesn’t like itPilot Metropolitan: Likes it
In my view, Lamy Safari is way overrated. Don't get me wrong, it's far from bad, a pretty consistent pen for the price. But the ink dries fast-ish if you don't use it, and especially, the cartridges are proprietary so you're tied to the brand's cartridges and ink colors (there's a piston converter, but converters, meh). A Pilot Metropolitan is approximately the same price and at least in my view, it's better as it uses standard international cartridges. A TWSBI Eco is more expensive, but not by that much, and it's an absolute reliability monster.
Lamy Safari: Recommends itPilot Metropolitan: Neutral
Which size nib are you using? If it is Extra Fine (EF) or Fine (F), then it can be scratchy. Moreover, Japanese EF and F are generally smaller than other EF and F. I have a Lamy Safari F, which is super smooth and glides. My Pilot Metropolitan also has F, but not only is it thinner/smaller but it is not as smooth. I won't call it scratchy but it could be construed as such. Also, paper matters. Fountain pens generally prefer a smoother paper, especially one that doesn't absorb much ink. You will also need to see how you are holding the pen and the angle the nib strikes the paper. You may want to search online for some advises on that since that can make a world of difference. Edit: Almost forgot, the more you write the better a fountain pen gets since the nib adjusts to your writing habit. I had an old Waterman when I was in high-school, which I don't have anymore, and so far no pen has come close to it in smoothness.
Lamy Safari: Likes itPilot Metropolitan: Likes it
Hey! Welcome. Let me respectfully disagree with you with my stained fingers. I'm using fountain pens as my primary writing instrument for more than 15 years now. My familiarity with these marvelous things go back even longer than that. So, I believe I know a couple of things, probably not much as you, about them. First let me start with the polishing issue. Not all paper is same, and even smooth paper is very abrasive in its nature. You can actually slowly polish a fountain pen nib with a coarse brown bag. If you want to do it faster, you can use a micromesh (which I'm too coward to use). If you search Fountain Pen Network, there are tons of resources how to work with both. If I understood it correctly, you said that the nib is not made of an alloy that can resist wear and tear. Yes, that's true. Today's nibs are mostly steel or gold alloys. However tips of said nibs are different. If you want to watch how Lamy's nibs are made in house, you can watch [0]. The link I shared starts right at the nib production and finishing process. I'll politely counter your wager about nib polishing with another anecdote. My father gave all his fountain pens to me since he's not using them anymore. One of them is used everyday for years, and he uses his pens at a slight angle. The well used pen writes scratchy when I hold it like my other pens, but writes buttery smooth when I hold like him. Another pen also exhibits this but to a lesser degree. Interestingly, when my father tries my pens, the…
Lamy Safari: Likes itPilot Metropolitan: Likes it
As you know, almost all fountain pen nibs (sans some specialty ones) come with some tipping. This is a very hard alloy engineered to resist wear and tear. Some manufacturers have their own formulations and grinding characteristics, and some manufacturers use "default" versions supplied by the nib vendor. As the user writes, this tipping material starts to get polished. This can take from a couple of months (e.g. Lamy) to years (e.g. Pilot, Sailor). Since the user keeps the pen at a certain angle, the same area gets polished a lot. This makes the pen write smoother when held "correctly" (i.e. the way the user holds), reduces contact pressure (pen starts writing almost before touching the paper) and makes the pen a little wetter in some cases, making it more reliable and enjoyable to use. After some point you can write without ever thinking about the pen, because it never skips (even like gels, rollerballs and ballpoints), and becomes an extension of you. It's hard to precisely and accurately describe though. For example, I have an old Lamy Safari which writes slightly broader than its Medium designation because of this. I can understand whether my Pilot Metropolitan is happy with the ink or not from how it feels on paper. I have another Pilot which feels like glass on paper due to the same effect (it was already a smooth grind but it got even smoother over time). Another advantage of fountain pens is the writing characteristics is a constant. Since you don't change the nib wit
Lamy Safari: Likes itPilot Metropolitan: Likes it
I have multiple pens which are a decade old, incl. a Metropolitan and Safari, and write like day one despite being used frequently. I also have a couple ones older than 50. They also work. Clogged ones generally need a good flush with a fountain pen flush.
Lamy Safari: Recommends itPilot Metropolitan: Recommends it
Under $100 - A good old fashioned digital timer for $6. I set up the time and do something, like work, read, hobbies, etc. I don't get distracted by other things on phone. I don't have to keep the screen on and use apps like Forest or other pomodoro timers, and it saves battery. I waste way less time now getting distracted. So, it's like a pomodoro timer but my intervals are higher- 1 hr to 2 hr. - A basic smartwatch for $20 that tracks my sleep and physical activity. I get 8000 steps of walking everyday now, and are more aware of stress. I can now use stress reduction and avoidance techniques before I get stressed, with heart rate monitoring. It really changed my life. - Several entry level fountain pens in $20/$30 like Lamy Safari, Pilor Metropolitan, etc. You wouldn't believe how great the writing experience becomes when start using FPs. - A Ukulele at $30, and it is so much easier than guitar for the easier things. Now I can sing and play an instrument. I tried guitar, piano, flute, but they didn't stick. Under $1000 - At just over $100, a Kindle with background light for reading. I love paper books but Kindles are much more convenient. I read much more and in more situations.
Lamy Safari: Recommends itPilot Metropolitan: Recommends it
I have been using fountain pens exclusively for the last two years. I don't identify as an addict or a collector. I can tell you that they are not overhyped. Fountain pens are totally worth it. I never went too high with the price. I have multiple Pilot Metropolitans (M and F nibs), multiple Platinum Preppies, one Lamy Safari. I also have several Indian Parkers. I can very highly recommend Pilot Metropolitan, Lamy Safari, and Platinum Preppy. You can't go wrong with them. They are also cheap enough. With ink, just go with plain Lamy ink, or Platinum/Pilot inks. I also use Noodler's.
Lamy Safari: Likes itPilot Metropolitan: Likes it
Budget fountain pens fill a niche of “spend a little more for something nice, but not so much I’ll worry about losing or wrecking it.” Fountain pens that work well without fuss, like Lamy Safari, or Pilot Metropolitan, really are nicer to use than ballpoint or gel pens, and the slight extra effort to using ink in cartridges or from a bottle adds familiarity and comfort to it. It’s not a pen, it’s your pen, and the longer you have it, the more attached you are to it. The more attached you are to it, the better the act of using it feels. It makes your world feel less disposable.
Lamy Safari: Recommends itPilot Metropolitan: Recommends it
This list is certainly not classic fountain pens. They are mostly machined pens made by small batch producers with generic nibs and two with somewhat "different" nibs I wouldn't normally suggest most people get. These are pretty good pens but not what I would get as a first pen. Here are the pens I would suggest you consider if you don't know a lot about fountain pens. If you are a fountain pen collector, I'm mostly ignoring a number of European brands who make great pens but have nib quality control from hell which are fine if you know fountain pens and how to adjust nibs etc but not if you are a beginner. Budget under 40 bucks: 1) Lamy Safari: The grip section is triangular to support the traditional writing grip. It's one of the choices middle schoolers are require to use in certain European countries. If you have a traditional grip and don't have huge hands you will likely like it. If you don't, stay away. Lamy sometimes has quality control issues on it's inexpensive nibs but not as many as other European brands in my experience. 2) Pilot Metropolitan: Pilot has a reputation of really good quality control on what are very high quality nibs. The 20 dollar Pilot Metropolitan is no exception. Amazing writing experience for the money. Probably the best steel nibs you can buy. Competitive with many pens that cost over 100 dollars. 3) TWSBI Eco: Piston filler pen so you don't need a cartridge or converter. The pen is a demonstrator so you can see how it works. Comes in lots of
Lamy Safari: Recommends itPilot Metropolitan: Recommends it
As a fountain pen enthusiast who uses fountain pens exclusively, this list surprises me. What does this author want to cover? Good looking expensive stuff? Just buy a Pilot Metropolitan or a Lamy Safari. Or even a Platinum Preppy. These pens are extremely cheap. And beyond these pens, if you notice any improvement in smoothness and comfort of writing, I would throw that in the margin of error. People have their reasons to buy more expensive pens. But if smoothness, comfort are your goal, then you can buy what I said. Metal-body Lamys and Pilots are also generational wealth. You can hand over one to your daughter after you write 40 years with it. My favorite fountain pen so far is: Pilot Custom 823. That's a bit expensive. But I used Metropolitan, Preppy, and Safari for close to a decade. And I had only these pens. Nothing else.
Lamy Safari: Likes itPilot Metropolitan: Likes it
Lately I've been using Vela Sciences lab notebooks for my general software engineering usage. A few years ago I started an experiment to see if inexpensive fountain pens with refillable ink would be both cheaper and have less waste. I got a Pilot Metropolitan and a Lamy Safari for around $20 each. I also bought a Pentel mechanical pencil with a plastic barrel (but everything else metal) for around $15 from an art store. So far, the experiment has been very successful and I'm still on the original bottle of ink and container of pencil leads. But the downside with the pens is that I need at least a minimum paper quality for the pens (the pencil works with anything, of course) to avoid ink bleeding/blotting. I've tried a few Moleskin notebooks and while the paper is of sufficient quality I don't really like the way they feel when writing (personal preference). The good news is that I can get a pretty good sense just by feeling the paper in person, and the notebooks don't necessarily have to be super expensive. But they're never cheap.
Lamy Safari: Recommends itPilot Metropolitan: Recommends it
If you want to learn to write in a way that isn't painful, learn to use a fountain pen - a $20 Pilot Metropolitan, or a Lamy Safari for I believe about the same, will do more than well enough. Pencils and ballpoints, and to a lesser but real extent most rollerballs, require so much force to mark the paper that you can't help getting a cramp. Fountain pen ink is thinner and flows more easily, so all you have to do is steer the pen. This makes a very significant difference. Don't start with a gold-nibbed pen - both of those I named use steel. Gold admittedly feels nicer to use, but you need the transitional step to learn better habits; steel is much more forgiving of excess force, and you'll know on your own when you're ready for a more delicate and expressive nib. I used to hate to write longhand, too. I've been using fountain pens for about half a decade now. A few days ago I used one to work out a complex idea over eight A5 pages with no need to pause save occasionally for thought, and my wrist wasn't sore afterward. Here as elsewhere, choosing the proper tool makes all the difference.
Lamy Safari: Recommends itPilot Metropolitan: Recommends it
- a jacket made of pure leather, custom-made, from a local artisanal, spent ~$120 (quite expensive for India), wearing it for 8 years, and it keeps getting better , zero sign of wear and tear - several fountain pens, especially Pilot Metropolitan F, Lamy Safari M; also the Platinum Preppy is really great, did not expect much from such a cheap pen; contemplated buying better fountain pens now and then, but these are so great; I write exclusively with fountain pens now - physical books that I buy, I buy because they are worth keeping, others I just borrow from library, friends, or buy ebooks - mechanical keyboard, a chinese-made rip-off of a famous brand, but really great, and just as same as the original - leather notebooks (refillable), gets better with the passing of time, can refill them with notebooks from market - as for software, I pay for/use stuff that are open, and easy to migrate from, has good support, etc. vim, ObsidianMD, git, etc. come to mind I am a person who always looks for durable products. Because I like the ease and comfort that comes from using stuff that you are using for years. I look for durable products when I am in the market for anything .
Lamy Safari: Recommends itPilot Metropolitan: Recommends it
Start with either Lamy Safary [0] or Pilot Metropolitan [1]. If you like smooth, go with Medium nib, and if you like some feedback, go with Fine, as I said. Writing on decent paper (not always the expensive one) with a decent medium nib pen is something everyone needs to try at least once. [0]: https://www.amazon.com/Safari-Fountain-Charcoal-Medium-L17M/... [1]: https://www.amazon.com/Pilot-Metropolitan-Collection-Fountai...
Lamy Safari: Likes itPilot Metropolitan: Likes it
The award for utilitarian and timeless has to go to the Lamy 2000. The Safari is very good as a starter (though I'm partial to the Pilot Metropolitan or TWSBI Eco for starters). I don't have experience with the Kaweco Sport, though I hear only good things.
Lamy Safari: Recommends itPilot Metropolitan: Recommends it
If you're looking to try quills and haven't previously worked with anything other than modern instruments, it is very likely a wise idea to start with an inexpensive, steel-nibbed fountain pen, such as the Lamy Safari or Pilot Metropolitan, as an intermediate step. One of the things you learn as you become familiar with nibbed pens of any kind is that they can, and indeed must , be used with much less pressure than more modern types. The ink is much thinner than that of a ballpoint or rollerball, so less pressure is necessary for ink to flow into the paper; too, a nib is much more mechanically delicate, and using the same force you would with a ball pen will eventually damage it. (Or, if it's a gold nib, not so eventually .) This is why starter fountain pens have always had steel nibs. Originally, these tools were used to teach writing to children, who would of necessity abuse their pens somewhat in the process of learning how not to do that. These days in many countries schools instead teach writing with pencils, but that in itself tends to create the bad habit of using excess force that someone learning to use nibbed pens will still need to overcome. (I certainly did! My hand doesn't hurt when I write any more, too, which is really nice.) Just as fountain pen nibs are more delicate than ball pens, quill nibs are more delicate than even fountain pens. So if you haven't used a nib before, I would definitely advise first getting at least basic familiarity with a fountain…